[CCB] Division 1, Edition 8

[Ovyron]

This is fair I think.

But overly complicated and unnecessary in my opinion.

If we had a democratic system, I'd vote for bringing back the "Pick 4th, 5th and 6th" engines, and just swap them with the first places. I liked that.

[swami]

This is fair I think.

But overly complicated and unnecessary in my opinion.

If we had a democratic system, I'd vote for bringing back the "Pick 4th, 5th and 6th" engines, and just swap them with the first places. I liked that.

But I think this system is only fair for lower order engines. Overall it's fair way to calculate the scores. I think I will just enforce this system.

[pedrox]

Wildcat
Delfi
Alaric

[beachknight]

Alaric,
WildCat,
Pharaon.

HT

[swami]

Tournament Finished:

Code: Select all

 Engine              Score     Ry   Fr   Gl   To   Na   Fr   Sp   Br   Wi   Al   De   Bo   Ru   Sl   Ph   Li    S-B
01: Rybka v1.0 Beta.w32 43.0/60 ···· =010 1111 1001 101= 0100 =0=0 =111 1101 1111 01=1 110= =111 1111 1111 1111  1197.2
02: Fruit-051103        41.0/60 =101 ···· ==1= 1111 ==1= 111= 0==1 ===0 0=01 0101 =1=1 1111 1101 =111 1101 ===1  1188.2
03: Glaurung Beta       38.0/60 0000 ==0= ···· 01== 1011 1=01 1=11 1=01 101= ==11 0111 1=10 1==1 0=11 011= 1111  1056.0
04: TogaII142JD-1cpu    37.5/60 0110 0000 10== ···· 1110 11=1 0001 0110 11=1 110= 1=01 =01= =111 1101 =111 11=1  1041.0
05: Naum 2.0            35.0/60 010= ==0= 0100 0001 ···· 01== =11= 1=01 =1=1 =11= 1111 1111 1100 0011 0==1 =110  979.25
06: Frenzee Feb08       33.0/60 1011 000= 0=10 00=0 10== ···· 0=10 1001 =110 1111 1001 01== 1==0 1111 1101 ==1=  929.25
07: Spike1.2            32.5/60 =1=1 1==0 0=00 1110 =00= 1=01 ···· 010= 0=0= 1=01 =1=0 1=1= 1==1 110= =110 =101  948.25
08: Bright-0.3a         31.5/60 =000 ===1 0=10 1001 0=10 0110 101= ···· 1=10 0001 11== 10== 1=1= 1111 =0=1 0=01  899.50
09: WildCat_8           27.5/60 0010 1=10 010= 00=0 =0=0 =001 1=1= 0=01 ···· 10=0 0101 1011 =0=1 10=0 ==01 11==  791.50
10: Alaric707           27.5/60 0000 1010 ==00 001= =00= 0000 0=10 1110 01=1 ···· 1=== ===1 ==11 =010 =110 ==11  756.25
11: Delfi 5.2           23.5/60 10=0 =0=0 1000 0=10 0000 0110 =0=1 00== 1010 0=== ···· 10== 1==0 1=== 1==0 0=01  679.25
12: Booot414            23.0/60 001= 0000 0=01 =10= 0000 10== 0=0= 01== 0100 ===0 01== ···· 1=00 =01= 1=10 0=11  657.50
13: Ruffian_105         22.5/60 =000 0010 0==0 =000 0011 0==1 0==0 0=0= =1=0 ==00 0==1 0=11 ···· 1100 1101 00==  635.25
14: SlowChess Blitz     22.5/60 0000 =000 1=00 0010 1100 0000 001= 0000 01=1 =101 0=== =10= 0011 ···· =11= =1==  613.00
15: Pharaon 3.5         21.0/60 0000 0010 100= =000 1==0 0010 =001 =1=0 ==10 =001 0==1 0=01 0010 =00= ···· 1=10  606.75
16: List512             21.0/60 0000 ===0 0000 00=0 =001 ==0= =010 1=10 00== ==00 1=10 1=00 11== =0== 0=01 ····  590.75

480 games played / Tournament is finished
Name of the tournament: Division 1 Edition 8
Site/ Country: ADMIN, United States
Level: Blitz 1/1
Hardware: Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.60GHz 2650 MHz with 248 MB Memory
Operating system: Microsoft Windows XP Professional Service Pack 2 (Build 2600)
PGN-File: D:\Arena 1.99\Tournaments\Division 1 Edition 8.pgn
Website: 
E-Mail Address:

[swami]

Revised list: Engine and EPC points for calculation.

1. Rybka 21
2. Fruit 22.5
3. Glaurung 23
4. Toga 27.5
5. Naum 31.5
6. Frenzee 33
7. Spike 37.5
8. Bright 43
9. Wildcat 41
10.Alaric 38
11. Delfi 35
12. Booot 32.5
13. Ruffian 27.5
14. Slowchess 23.5
15. Pharaon 22.5
16. List 21

[Jim Ablett]

My bottom 3 guess was spot on

Jim.

[swami]

Engine Prediction Contest:


Graham:
33,38,35
106

Pedro:
41,35,38
114

Jim:
21,23.5,22.5
67

Tony:
35,41,22.5
98.5

Pavel:
41,22.5,35
98.5

Ulysses:
27.5,22.5,32.5
82.5

George:
[pause]

Evgenii:
[pause]

Harun:
38,41,22.5
101.5

Sergio:
23,23.5,35
81.5

Pedro 114
Graham 106
Harun 101.5
Pavel 98.5
Tony 98.5
Ulysses 82.5
Sergio 81.5
Jim 67

Cg to Pedro.

I found this system to be fair, just swapping the points of the engines in question with the first 3 places don't seem to give the accurate results. A bit flawed I think, as the edition progresses, I learn something new.

Regards.

[beachknight]

My congrats to Pedro too.

Unshared third place, plus above Tony.
No other thing could make me more happier.

Best,

[Ovyron]

Congrats Pedro!

Also, this is my last participation on Division 1.