Rating for Rybka 3

Discussion of computer chess matches and engine tournaments.

Moderator: Ras

IWB
Posts: 1539
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 2:02 pm

Rating for Rybka 3

Post by IWB »

Hello all,

first of all: I think I am not a suspect of beeing a big supporter of Rybka :)

Conditions:

1 THREAD
PONDER ON
50 STARTING POSITION, changing colors (NO BOOK!)
6 min + 3 sec (average ~16 min per game)
256 MB Hash
4 pc Tbs and Sbases / 64 MB cache (after a few acesses they are completly in Memory)

where ever possible I used the 64bit versions of a program!

Individual statistics:

1 Rybka 3 1T : 2845 1000 (+692,=263,- 45), 82.3 %

Deep Shredder 10 x64 1T : 100 (+ 80,= 17,- 3), 88.5 %
Spike 1.2 Turin : 100 (+ 85,= 15,- 0), 92.5 %
Fruit 05/11/03 : 100 (+ 75,= 23,- 2), 86.5 %
Rybka 2.3.2a mp 1T : 100 (+ 44,= 46,- 10), 67.0 %
Naum 3.1 1T : 100 (+ 65,= 31,- 4), 80.5 %
HIARCS 12 MP 1T : 100 (+ 72,= 23,- 5), 83.5 %
Toga II 1.4 beta5c BB : 100 (+ 66,= 30,- 4), 81.0 %
Zappa Mexico II x64 1T : 100 (+ 65,= 30,- 5), 80.0 %
DSjeng 3.0 x64 1T : 100 (+ 75,= 20,- 5), 85.0 %
Deep Shredder 11 x64 1T : 100 (+ 65,= 28,- 7), 79.0 %

and this is my little rating list for R3 after 1000 games. Just plain available engines, no betas mentioned:

Program Elo + - Games Score Av.Op. Draws

1 Rybka 3 1T : 2845 21 21 1000 82.3 % 2578 26.3 %
2 Rybka 2.3.2a mp 1T : 2722 8 8 4700 69.1 % 2582 36.6 %
3 Rybka 1.2f : 2672 7 7 7000 65.5 % 2561 33.2 %
4 Zappa Mexico II x64 1T : 2624 11 11 2400 53.2 % 2602 39.9 %
5 Deep Shredder 11 x64 1T : 2600 11 11 2600 53.8 % 2574 35.5 %
6 Strelka 2.0 B x64 : 2599 16 16 1000 52.8 % 2580 43.5 %
7 Rybka 1.0 Beta x64 : 2594 11 11 2300 53.5 % 2570 36.7 %
8 Naum 3.1 1T : 2593 9 9 3700 49.5 % 2596 38.7 %
9 Zappa Mexico X64 Final : 2592 9 9 3600 53.2 % 2570 40.4 %
10 HIARCS 12 MP 1T : 2580 12 12 2000 45.1 % 2613 38.1 %
11 Toga II 1.4 beta5c BB : 2577 12 12 2000 46.5 % 2601 40.4 %
12 DSjeng 3.0 x64 1T : 2565 14 14 1500 42.5 % 2618 33.4 %
13 Naum 2.2 : 2544 10 10 2700 43.5 % 2589 42.9 %
14 Rybka 1.0 Beta 32-bit : 2542 8 8 4400 50.1 % 2541 33.2 %
15 HIARCS 11.2 : 2536 7 7 6600 45.5 % 2568 36.3 %
16 Fruit 05/11/03 : 2533 8 8 4500 41.9 % 2590 39.0 %
17 Fruit 2.3 : 2532 22 22 600 51.9 % 2518 39.2 %
18 DS 10 Balmung : 2531 10 10 2600 49.9 % 2531 42.5 %
19 LoopMP 12.32 : 2525 9 9 3800 49.3 % 2530 34.8 %
20 Loop 13.5 : 2524 8 8 4700 43.4 % 2570 37.0 %
21 Toga II 1.2.1a : 2520 7 7 6600 46.6 % 2543 35.2 %
22 ListMP 11.64b : 2517 12 12 2200 44.0 % 2559 35.9 %
23 Deep Shredder 10 x64 1T : 2511 7 7 6000 43.1 % 2559 37.2 %
24 HIARCS 11 MP 1T : 2506 19 19 800 44.9 % 2542 36.4 %
25 Naum 2.1 NoLearn : 2505 9 9 3700 44.6 % 2543 36.4 %
26 Toga II 1.3x4 : 2498 19 19 800 44.6 % 2536 38.9 %
27 Hiarcs X54 64bit UCI NORM : 2497 22 22 600 43.9 % 2539 36.5 %
28 Spike 1.2 Turin : 2480 7 7 7000 38.4 % 2562 35.4 %
29 DS 9.02 1T : 2467 16 16 1400 37.9 % 2553 29.1 %
30 Deep Sjeng 2.7 : 2455 13 13 2000 31.2 % 2593 33.1 %
31 Glaurung 2-epsilon/5 : 2446 16 16 1300 34.8 % 2555 30.9 %
32 Deep Sjeng 2.5 : 2387 20 20 900 29.9 % 2534 30.6 %

I had to delete same engines as the full list contains betas!

Have fun with this fishy monster!

Bye
Ingo
User avatar
George Tsavdaris
Posts: 1627
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 12:35 pm

Re: Rating for Rybka 3

Post by George Tsavdaris »

IWB wrote: 1 THREAD
PONDER ON
I guess it was a Dual or Quad or Octal computer right?
Since if it was a single CPU then ponder on makes no sense.
Individual statistics:

1 Rybka 3 1T : 2845 1000 (+692,=263,- 45), 82.3 %
This +692 -45 is beyond any imagination!!

I wonder in how many months the other programs will manage to catch up with Rybka 3?
Except in analysis, i'm also interested in engine-engine games/tournaments also and this situation is not the most exciting thing obviously. I want a stronger and closer competition as having a Rybka winning all the time is not the most exciting thing.


Can you email me the games of Rybka 3?
My email is:
gts77avdar@gmail.com (remove 77)
After his son's birth they've asked him:
"Is it a boy or girl?"
YES! He replied.....
IWB
Posts: 1539
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 2:02 pm

Re: Rating for Rybka 3

Post by IWB »

George Tsavdaris wrote:I guess it was a Dual or Quad or Octal computer right?
Since if it was a single CPU then ponder on makes no sense.
8way@2.3 Ghz
Can you email me the games of Rybka 3?
No sorry, I will keep the opening positions with me!

Bye
INgo[/quote]
User avatar
M ANSARI
Posts: 3734
Joined: Thu Mar 16, 2006 7:10 pm

Re: Rating for Rybka 3

Post by M ANSARI »

I think the only engines that can give Rybka 3 some tough moments are ... Rybka 3 Human ... and Rybka 3 Dynamic. These 2 other versions have totally (and I mean totally) different evaluations ... and in many positions there is a difference of more than .5 centipawns on the same position. I have been doing such tourneys and the games are really a joy to watch.
ArmyBridge

Re: Rating for Rybka 3

Post by ArmyBridge »

M ANSARI wrote:I think the only engines that can give Rybka 3 some tough moments are ... Rybka 3 Human ... and Rybka 3 Dynamic. These 2 other versions have totally (and I mean totally) different evaluations ... and in many positions there is a difference of more than .5 centipawns on the same position. I have been doing such tourneys and the games are really a joy to watch.
Hi Ansari
Would you share your games? I would like to see this matchs.
Regards 8-)
swami
Posts: 6664
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 4:21 am

Re: Rating for Rybka 3

Post by swami »

Rybka 3 is obviously around 3300...