Discussion of computer chess matches and engine tournaments.
Moderator: Ras
Vinvin
Posts: 5298Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 9:40 amFull name: Vincent Lejeune
Post by Vinvin Sun Aug 16, 2009 4:09 pm
After round 9 :
Code: Select all
Name R1 R2 R3 R4 R5 R6 R7 R8 R9 R10 Score
1 Rybka (2813) +w11 +b7 =w2 +b6 +w4 +b3 +w8 =b10 +w9 b5 8.0
2 Sjeng (2720) +b22 +w9 =b1 +w8 =w3 =b4 +w7 +b11 +w10 b6 7.5
3 StockfishACCA (2800) Wb23 +w18 +b5 =w4 =b2 -w1 +b9 =w6 =b8 w7 6.0
4 Hiarcs8x (2789) +w20 +b14 +w10 =b3 -b1 =w2 =b6 =w8 +b12 w9 6.0
5 Pandix (2050) +b16 +w13 -w3 -b10 =b9 +w18 =b12 =b7 +w14 w1 5.5
6 IkarusX (2839) =b13 =w16 +b18 -w1 =b12 +w15 =w4 =b3 =w7 w2 5.0
7 crafty (2688) +b19 -w1 +b20 +w9 +w10 -b8 -b2 =w5 =b6 b3 5.0
8 spark02 (2700) +w21 -b10 +w12 -b2 +w14 +w7 -b1 =b4 =w3 b13 5.0
9 ChessThinkerX (2872) +w12 -b2 +w14 -b7 =w5 +b10 -w3 +b13 -b1 b4 4.5
10 TwistedLogicCCT(2829) +b15 +w8 -b4 +w5 -b7 -w9 +b14 =w1 -b2 w12 4.5
11 Deuterium2009 (2455) -b1 =w15 =b16 =w13 +b21 =w12 +b18 -w2 =b17 w14 4.5
12 dshawul (2600) -b9 +w19 -b8 +w20 =w6 =b11 =w5 +b15 -w4 b10 4.5
13 LearningLemming(2585) =w6 -b5 =w15 =b11 -b18 +w16 +b19 -w9 +b20 w8 4.5
14 thebaron (2552) Wb17 -w4 -b9 +w21 -b8 +w19 -w10 +w16 -b5 b11 4.0
15 Telepath (2506) -w10 =b11 =b13 =w16 +b20 -b6 =w17 -w12 +b19 w21 4.0
16 DIEP (2602) -w5 =b6 =w11 =b15 =w19 -b13 +w21 -b14 +b22 w17 4.0
17 Buzz (2829) Lw14 +b22 +w20 =b15 +b21 =w11 b16 4.0
18 HfC (2000) bye -b3 -w6 =b19 +w13 -b5 -w11 -w20 +b21 w22 3.5
19 zct (2230) -w7 -b12 +b21 =w18 =b16 -b14 -w13 +w22 -w15 b20 3.0
20 JokerX (2345) -b4 +w21 -w7 -b12 -w15 -b17 =w22 +b18 -w13 w19 2.5
21 microMaX (2266) -b8 -b20 -w19 -b14 -w11 +w22 -b16 -w17 -w18 b15 1.0
22 NoonianChess (2281) -w2 -w17 -b21 =b20 -b19 -w16 b18 0.5
23 Tornado-C (2445) Lw3 ----- ----- ----- ----- ----- ----- ----- ----- ----- 0.0
Vinvin
Posts: 5298Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 9:40 amFull name: Vincent Lejeune
Post by Vinvin Sun Aug 16, 2009 5:36 pm
After round 10 :
Code: Select all
Name R1 R2 R3 R4 R5 R6 R7 R8 R9 R10 R11 Score #g
1 Rybka +w8 +b11 =w2 +b10 +w4 +b3 +w6 =b13 +w9 =b5 w7 8.5 10
2 Sjeng +b22 +w9 =b1 +w6 =w3 =b4 +w11 +b8 +w13 +b10 w5 8.5 10
3 StockfishACCA Wb23 +w19 +b5 =w4 =b2 -w1 +b9 =w10 =b6 +w11 b8 7.0 9
4 Hiarcs8x +w20 +b17 +w13 =b3 -b1 =w2 =b10 =w6 +b7 =w9 b11 6.5 10
5 Pandix +b15 +w14 -w3 -b13 =b9 +w19 =b7 =b11 +w17 =w1 b2 6.0 10
6 spark02 +w21 -b13 +w7 -b2 +w17 +w11 -b1 =b4 =w3 +b14 w10 6.0 10
7 dshawul -b9 +w18 -b6 +w20 =w10 =b8 =w5 +b12 -w4 +b13 b1 5.5 10
8 Deuterium2009 -b1 =w12 =b15 =w14 +b21 =w7 +b19 -w2 =b16 +w17 w3 5.5 10
9 ChessThinkerX +w7 -b2 +w17 -b11 =w5 +b13 -w3 +b14 -b1 =b4 w12 5.0 10
10 IkarusX =b14 =w15 +b19 -w1 =b7 +w12 =w4 =b3 =w11 -w2 b6 5.0 10
11 crafty +b18 -w1 +b20 +w9 +w13 -b6 -b2 =w5 =b10 -b3 w4 5.0 10
12 Telepath -w13 =b8 =b14 =w15 +b20 -b10 =w16 -w7 +b18 +w21 b9 5.0 10
13 TwistedLogicCCT +b12 +w6 -b4 +w5 -b11 -w9 +b17 =w1 -b2 -w7 b22 4.5 10
14 LearningLemming =w10 -b5 =w12 =b8 -b19 +w15 +b18 -w9 +b20 -w6 b21 4.5 10
15 DIEP -w5 =b10 =w8 =b12 =w18 -b14 +w21 -b17 +b22 =w16 w19 4.5 10
16 Buzz Lw17 +b22 +w20 =b12 +b21 =w8 =b15 w18 4.5 6
17 thebaron Wb16 -w4 -b9 +w21 -b6 +w18 -w13 +w15 -b5 -b8 w20 4.0 9
18 zct -w11 -b7 +b21 =w19 =b15 -b17 -w14 +w22 -w12 +b20 b16 4.0 10
19 HfC bye -b3 -w10 =b18 +w14 -b5 -w8 -w20 +b21 =w22 b15 4.0 10
20 JokerX -b4 +w21 -w11 -b7 -w12 -b16 =w22 +b19 -w14 -w18 b17 2.5 10
21 microMaX -b6 -b20 -w18 -b17 -w8 +w22 -b15 -w16 -w19 -b12 w14 1.0 10
22 NoonianChess -w2 -w16 -b21 =b20 -b18 -w15 =b19 w13 1.0 7
23 Tornado-C Lw3 ----- ----- ----- ----- ----- ----- ----- ----- ----- ----- 0.0 0
Vinvin
Posts: 5298Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 9:40 amFull name: Vincent Lejeune
Post by Vinvin Sun Aug 16, 2009 6:22 pm
After round 11 :
Code: Select all
Name R1 R2 R3 R4 R5 R6 R7 R8 R9 R10 R11 R12 Score
1 Rybka +w11 +b14 =w2 +b8 +w4 +b3 +w5 =b10 +w6 =b7 +w9 b12 9.5
2 Sjeng +b22 +w6 =b1 +w5 =w3 =b4 +w14 +b11 +w10 +b8 +w7 b9 9.5
3 StockfishACCA Wb23 +w19 +b7 =w4 =b2 -w1 +b6 =w8 =b5 +w14 +b11 w13 8.0
4 Hiarcs8x +w20 +b18 +w10 =b3 -b1 =w2 =b8 =w5 +b9 =w6 +b14 w7 7.5
5 spark02 +w21 -b10 +w9 -b2 +w18 +w14 -b1 =b4 =w3 +b12 =w8 b6 6.5
6 ChessThinkerX +w9 -b2 +w18 -b14 =w7 +b10 -w3 +b12 -b1 =b4 +w15 w5 6.0
7 Pandix +b13 +w12 -w3 -b10 =b6 +w19 =b9 =b14 +w18 =w1 -b2 b4 6.0
8 IkarusX =b12 =w13 +b19 -w1 =b9 +w15 =w4 =b3 =w14 -w2 =b5 b17 5.5
9 dshawul -b6 +w17 -b5 +w20 =w8 =b11 =w7 +b15 -w4 +b10 -b1 w2 5.5
10 TwistedLogicCCT+b15 +w5 -b4 +w7 -b14 -w6 +b18 =w1 -b2 -w9 +b22 w20 5.5
11 Deuterium2009 -b1 =w15 =b13 =w12 +b21 =w9 +b19 -w2 =b16 +w18 -w3 b22 5.5
12 LearningLemming=w8 -b7 =w15 =b11 -b19 +w13 +b17 -w6 +b20 -w5 +b21 w1 5.5
13 DIEP -w7 =b8 =w11 =b15 =w17 -b12 +w21 -b18 +b22 =w16 +w19 b3 5.5
14 crafty +b17 -w1 +b20 +w6 +w10 -b5 -b2 =w7 =b8 -b3 -w4 w21 5.0
15 Telepath -w10 =b11 =b12 =w13 +b20 -b8 =w16 -w9 +b17 +w21 -b6 w18 5.0
16 Buzz Lw18 +b22 +w20 =b15 +b21 =w11 =b13 =w17 b19 5.0
17 zct -w14 -b9 +b21 =w19 =b13 -b18 -w12 +w22 -w15 +b20 =b16 w8 4.5
18 thebaron Wb16 -w4 -b6 +w21 -b5 +w17 -w10 +w13 -b7 -b11 -w20 b15 4.0
19 HfC bye -b3 -w8 =b17 +w12 -b7 -w11 -w20 +b21 =w22 -b13 w16 4.0
20 JokerX -b4 +w21 -w14 -b9 -w15 -b16 =w22 +b19 -w12 -w17 +b18 b10 3.5
21 microMaX -b5 -b20 -w17 -b18 -w11 +w22 -b13 -w16 -w19 -b15 -w12 b14 1.0
22 NoonianChess -w2 -w16 -b21 =b20 -b17 -w13 =b19 -w10 w11 1.0
23 Tornado-C Lw3 ----- ----- ----- ----- ----- ----- ----- ----- ----- ----- ----- 0.0
Vinvin
Posts: 5298Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 9:40 amFull name: Vincent Lejeune
Post by Vinvin Sun Aug 16, 2009 7:32 pm
After 12th and final round :
Code: Select all
Name R1 R2 R3 R4 R5 R6 R7 R8 R9 R10 R11 R12 Score
1 Rybka +w9 +b12 =w2 +b7 +w4 +b3 +w5 =b8 +w6 =b10 +w11 +b14 10.5
2 Sjeng +b22 +w6 =b1 +w5 =w3 =b4 +w12 +b9 +w8 +b7 +w10 =b11 10.0
3 StockfishACCA Wb23 +w19 +b10 =w4 =b2 -w1 +b6 =w7 =b5 +w12 +b9 +w15 9.0
4 Hiarcs8x +w20 +b16 +w8 =b3 -b1 =w2 =b7 =w5 +b11 =w6 +b12 +w10 8.5
5 spark02 +w21 -b8 +w11 -b2 +w16 +w12 -b1 =b4 =w3 +b14 =w7 =b6 7.0
6 ChessThinkerX +w11 -b2 +w16 -b12 =w10 +b8 -w3 +b14 -b1 =b4 +w17 =w5 6.5
7 IkarusX =b14 =w15 +b19 -w1 =b11 +w17 =w4 =b3 =w12 -w2 =b5 +b18 6.5
8 TwistedLogicCCT+b17 +w5 -b4 +w10 -b12 -w6 +b16 =w1 -b2 -w11 +b22 +w20 6.5
9 Deuterium2009 -b1 =w17 =b15 =w14 +b21 =w11 +b19 -w2 =b13 +w16 -w3 +b22 6.5
10 Pandix +b15 +w14 -w3 -b8 =b6 +w19 =b11 =b12 +w16 =w1 -b2 -b4 6.0
11 dshawul -b6 +w18 -b5 +w20 =w7 =b9 =w10 +b17 -w4 +b8 -b1 =w2 6.0
12 crafty +b18 -w1 +b20 +w6 +w8 -b5 -b2 =w10 =b7 -b3 -w4 +w21 6.0
13 Buzz Lw16 +b22 +w20 =b17 +b21 =w9 =b15 =w18 +b19 6.0
14 LearningLemming=w7 -b10 =w17 =b9 -b19 +w15 +b18 -w6 +b20 -w5 +b21 -w1 5.5
15 DIEP -w10 =b7 =w9 =b17 =w18 -b14 +w21 -b16 +b22 =w13 +w19 -b3 5.5
16 thebaron Wb13 -w4 -b6 +w21 -b5 +w18 -w8 +w15 -b10 -b9 -w20 +b17 5.0
17 Telepath -w8 =b9 =b14 =w15 +b20 -b7 =w13 -w11 +b18 +w21 -b6 -w16 5.0
18 zct -w12 -b11 +b21 =w19 =b15 -b16 -w14 +w22 -w17 +b20 =b13 -w7 4.5
19 HfC bye -b3 -w7 =b18 +w14 -b10 -w9 -w20 +b21 =w22 -b15 -w13 4.0
20 JokerX -b4 +w21 -w12 -b11 -w17 -b13 =w22 +b19 -w14 -w18 +b16 -b8 3.5
21 microMaX -b5 -b20 -w18 -b16 -w9 +w22 -b15 -w13 -w19 -b17 -w14 -b12 1.0
22 NoonianChess -w2 -w13 -b21 =b20 -b18 -w15 =b19 -w8 -w9 1.0
23 Tornado-C Lw3 ----- ----- ----- ----- ----- ----- ----- ----- ----- ----- ----- 0.0 Congratulations to the Rybka team !!
Spock
Post by Spock Sun Aug 16, 2009 8:02 pm
Yes - and congratulations to Tord and the Stockfish
Tord Romstad
Posts: 1808Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 9:19 pmLocation: Oslo, Norway
Post by Tord Romstad Sun Aug 16, 2009 11:01 pm
Spock wrote: Yes - and congratulations to Tord and the Stockfish
Don't forget Sjeng, who played a very strong tournament, and Buzz, the only engine apart from Rybka and Sjeng which didn't lose a single game.
I had a brief look at Stockfish's games tonight, and it is clear that its third place was entirely undeserved. It got a free point in the first round (it seems that the opponent didn't show up), and somehow managed to get 1.5/2 from technically lost positions out of the book against Pandix and Spark. Sjeng, Hiarcs, Thinker, Crafty and Diep didn't play anywhere close to their best against Stockfish.
Stockfish was also helped by a massive hardware advantage compared to most of the participants, which surely explains some of its luck.
Andres Valverde
Posts: 582Joined: Sun Feb 18, 2007 11:07 pmLocation: Almeria. SPAINFull name: Andres Valverde Toresano
Post by Andres Valverde Sun Aug 16, 2009 11:31 pm
Tord Romstad wrote: Spock wrote: Yes - and congratulations to Tord and the Stockfish
Don't forget Sjeng, who played a very strong tournament, and Buzz, the only engine apart from Rybka and Sjeng which didn't lose a single game.
Thx Tord, but Dirty (not Buzz, account name) lost the first 4 games because the operator had "technical" problems.
Saludos, Andres
Christopher Conkie
Posts: 6074Joined: Sat Apr 01, 2006 9:34 pmLocation: Scotland
Post by Christopher Conkie Sun Aug 16, 2009 11:38 pm
Andres Valverde wrote: the operator had "technical" problems.
Anything to
help ........
mcostalba
Posts: 2684Joined: Sat Jun 14, 2008 9:17 pm
Post by mcostalba Sun Aug 16, 2009 11:49 pm
Tord Romstad wrote:
Stockfish was also helped by a massive hardware advantage compared to most of the participants, which surely explains some of its luck.
Well I would say hardware of Stockfish was dwarfed by that of the next competitors:
Rybka: Intel Cluster 52 CPU
Deep Sjeng: Cluster
Stockfish: Intel Q6600 (4 cpu)
HIARCS: Intel 8 Core Skulltrail
spark02: Mac Pro Dual Xeon 8 cpus
So I would think SF hardware, although very nice powerful in absolute value (I would dream to have a Q6600 Quad
) it was way smaller then the others, I mean the others of the leading group.
Tord Romstad
Posts: 1808Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 9:19 pmLocation: Oslo, Norway
Post by Tord Romstad Mon Aug 17, 2009 12:17 am
mcostalba wrote: Tord Romstad wrote:
Stockfish was also helped by a massive hardware advantage compared to most of the participants, which surely explains some of its luck.
Well I would say hardware of Stockfish was dwarfed by that of the next competitors:
Rybka: Intel Cluster 52 CPU
Deep Sjeng: Cluster
Actually, Sjeng didn't play on a cluster, even though it was supposed to. I'm not sure what happened.
Stockfish: Intel Q6600 (4 cpu)
HIARCS: Intel 8 Core Skulltrail
spark02: Mac Pro Dual Xeon 8 cpus
So I would think SF hardware, although very nice powerful in absolute value (I would dream to have a Q6600 Quad
) it was way smaller then the others, I mean the others of the leading group.
Sure, there were a few participants with even faster hardware, but Stockfish's hardware was much faster than most of the field.
) it was way smaller then the others, I mean the others of the leading group.