Houdini 4, Stockfish-DD, Komodo-TCEC: EGTBs on and off

Discussion of computer chess matches and engine tournaments.

Moderator: Ras

User avatar
RJN
Posts: 303
Joined: Fri Jun 21, 2013 5:18 am
Location: Orion Spiral Arm

Re: Houdini 4, Stockfish-DD, Komodo-TCEC: EGTBs on and off

Post by RJN »

2520 games

PGN link:

https://www.sugarsync.com/pf/D0094094_75971673_880566

Code: Select all

2520 games

1/10/2014 1:02:08 AM :

    Program                          Elo    +   -   Games   Score   Av.Op.  Draws

  1 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy :       25   19  19   504    54.0 %     -3   61.1 %
  2 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota :      21   18  18   504    53.4 %     -2   63.9 %
  3 Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota :      15   19  19   504    52.4 %     -2   61.1 %
  4 Stockfish_DD_64_modern    :       12   19  19   504    51.9 %     -1   59.7 %
  5 Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921 :    11   19  19   504    51.8 %     -1   61.5 %
  6 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None   :        9   18  18   504    51.5 %     -1   63.3 %
  7 Komodo-TCEC-64bit         :       -6   20  20   504    49.1 %      1   56.2 %
  8 Komodo6-64bit             :      -10   20  20   504    48.4 %      1   57.9 %
  9 Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota :      -34   18  18   504    44.6 %      4   63.1 %
 10 Houdini_3_Pro-None        :      -44   19  19   504    43.0 %      5   59.7 %


Individual statistics:

1 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy:    25  504 (+118,=308,- 78), 54.0 %

Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota:      56 (+ 16,= 37,-  3), 61.6 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None       :      56 (+ 10,= 42,-  4), 55.4 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None  :      56 (+  6,= 42,-  8), 48.2 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern   :      56 (+ 15,= 27,- 14), 50.9 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921:   56 (+ 17,= 28,- 11), 55.4 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota:     56 (+  9,= 39,-  8), 50.9 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit        :      56 (+ 17,= 30,-  9), 57.1 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota:     56 (+ 14,= 30,- 12), 51.8 %
Komodo6-64bit            :      56 (+ 14,= 33,-  9), 54.5 %

2 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota:   21  504 (+108,=322,- 74), 53.4 %

Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota:      56 (+ 11,= 44,-  1), 58.9 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy:      56 (+  8,= 39,-  9), 49.1 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None       :      56 (+ 15,= 41,-  0), 63.4 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None  :      56 (+ 10,= 40,-  6), 53.6 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern   :      56 (+ 12,= 29,- 15), 47.3 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921:   56 (+ 11,= 38,-  7), 53.6 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit        :      56 (+ 18,= 31,-  7), 59.8 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota:     56 (+ 11,= 31,- 14), 47.3 %
Komodo6-64bit            :      56 (+ 12,= 29,- 15), 47.3 %

3 Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota:   15  504 (+110,=308,- 86), 52.4 %

Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota:      56 (+ 17,= 31,-  8), 58.0 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy:      56 (+ 12,= 30,- 14), 48.2 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None       :      56 (+ 18,= 31,-  7), 59.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None  :      56 (+ 10,= 40,-  6), 53.6 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern   :      56 (+  7,= 45,-  4), 52.7 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921:   56 (+  4,= 46,-  6), 48.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota:     56 (+ 14,= 31,- 11), 52.7 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit        :      56 (+ 16,= 28,- 12), 53.6 %
Komodo6-64bit            :      56 (+ 12,= 26,- 18), 44.6 %

4 Stockfish_DD_64_modern:       12  504 (+111,=301,- 92), 51.9 %

Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota:      56 (+ 17,= 29,- 10), 56.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy:      56 (+ 14,= 27,- 15), 49.1 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None       :      56 (+ 18,= 29,-  9), 58.0 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None  :      56 (+ 11,= 36,-  9), 51.8 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921:   56 (+  4,= 45,-  7), 47.3 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota:     56 (+ 15,= 29,- 12), 52.7 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit        :      56 (+ 13,= 31,- 12), 50.9 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota:     56 (+  4,= 45,-  7), 47.3 %
Komodo6-64bit            :      56 (+ 15,= 30,- 11), 53.6 %

5 Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 11  504 (+106,=310,- 88), 51.8 %

Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota:      56 (+ 15,= 35,-  6), 58.0 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy:      56 (+ 11,= 28,- 17), 44.6 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None       :      56 (+ 15,= 28,- 13), 51.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None  :      56 (+ 18,= 24,- 14), 53.6 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern   :      56 (+  7,= 45,-  4), 52.7 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota:     56 (+  7,= 38,- 11), 46.4 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit        :      56 (+ 14,= 30,- 12), 51.8 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota:     56 (+  6,= 46,-  4), 51.8 %
Komodo6-64bit            :      56 (+ 13,= 36,-  7), 55.4 %

6 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None:       9  504 (+100,=319,- 85), 51.5 %

Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota:      56 (+ 17,= 33,-  6), 59.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy:      56 (+  8,= 42,-  6), 51.8 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None       :      56 (+ 10,= 39,-  7), 52.7 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern   :      56 (+  9,= 36,- 11), 48.2 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921:   56 (+ 14,= 24,- 18), 46.4 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota:     56 (+  6,= 40,- 10), 46.4 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit        :      56 (+ 14,= 30,- 12), 51.8 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota:     56 (+  6,= 40,- 10), 46.4 %
Komodo6-64bit            :      56 (+ 16,= 35,-  5), 59.8 %

7 Komodo-TCEC-64bit    :        -6  504 (+106,=283,-115), 49.1 %

Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota:      56 (+  9,= 40,-  7), 51.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy:      56 (+  9,= 30,- 17), 42.9 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None       :      56 (+ 18,= 24,- 14), 53.6 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None  :      56 (+ 12,= 30,- 14), 48.2 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern   :      56 (+ 12,= 31,- 13), 49.1 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921:   56 (+ 12,= 30,- 14), 48.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota:     56 (+  7,= 31,- 18), 40.2 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota:     56 (+ 12,= 28,- 16), 46.4 %
Komodo6-64bit            :      56 (+ 15,= 39,-  2), 61.6 %

8 Komodo6-64bit        :       -10  504 (+ 98,=292,-114), 48.4 %

Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota:      56 (+ 14,= 33,-  9), 54.5 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy:      56 (+  9,= 33,- 14), 45.5 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None       :      56 (+ 17,= 31,-  8), 58.0 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None  :      56 (+  5,= 35,- 16), 40.2 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern   :      56 (+ 11,= 30,- 15), 46.4 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921:   56 (+  7,= 36,- 13), 44.6 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota:     56 (+ 15,= 29,- 12), 52.7 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit        :      56 (+  2,= 39,- 15), 38.4 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota:     56 (+ 18,= 26,- 12), 55.4 %

9 Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota:   -34  504 (+ 66,=318,-120), 44.6 %

Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy:      56 (+  3,= 37,- 16), 38.4 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None       :      56 (+ 16,= 36,-  4), 60.7 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None  :      56 (+  6,= 33,- 17), 40.2 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern   :      56 (+ 10,= 29,- 17), 43.8 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921:   56 (+  6,= 35,- 15), 42.0 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota:     56 (+  1,= 44,- 11), 41.1 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit        :      56 (+  7,= 40,-  9), 48.2 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota:     56 (+  8,= 31,- 17), 42.0 %
Komodo6-64bit            :      56 (+  9,= 33,- 14), 45.5 %

10 Houdini_3_Pro-None   :      -44  504 (+ 66,=301,-137), 43.0 %

Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota:      56 (+  4,= 36,- 16), 39.3 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy:      56 (+  4,= 42,- 10), 44.6 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None  :      56 (+  7,= 39,- 10), 47.3 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern   :      56 (+  9,= 29,- 18), 42.0 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921:   56 (+ 13,= 28,- 15), 48.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota:     56 (+  0,= 41,- 15), 36.6 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit        :      56 (+ 14,= 24,- 18), 46.4 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota:     56 (+  7,= 31,- 18), 40.2 %
Komodo6-64bit            :      56 (+  8,= 31,- 17), 42.0 %
Top
User avatar
Ozymandias
Posts: 1537
Joined: Sun Oct 25, 2009 2:30 am

Re: Houdini 4, Stockfish-DD, Komodo-TCEC: EGTBs on and off

Post by Ozymandias »

Ratings are getting compressed, but the trend continues.
Top
User avatar
RJN
Posts: 303
Joined: Fri Jun 21, 2013 5:18 am
Location: Orion Spiral Arm

Re: Houdini 4, Stockfish-DD, Komodo-TCEC: EGTBs on and off

Post by RJN »

2880 games

PGN link:

https://www.sugarsync.com/pf/D0094094_75971673_807509

Code: Select all

2880 games

1/15/2014 11:27:08 PM :

    Program                          Elo    +   -   Games   Score   Av.Op.  Draws

  1 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy :       28   17  17   576    54.4 %     -3   62.3 %
  2 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota :      23   17  17   576    53.6 %     -3   64.2 %
  3 Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota :      15   18  18   576    52.3 %     -2   60.2 %
  4 Stockfish_DD_64_modern    :       11   18  18   576    51.7 %     -1   60.4 %
  5 Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921 :    10   18  18   576    51.6 %     -1   60.9 %
  6 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None   :        3   17  17   576    50.4 %     -0   63.7 %
  7 Komodo-TCEC-64bit         :       -9   19  19   576    48.6 %      1   56.6 %
  8 Komodo6-64bit             :      -11   18  18   576    48.2 %      1   58.2 %
  9 Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota :      -33   17  17   576    44.8 %      4   63.9 %
 10 Houdini_3_Pro-None        :      -37   18  18   576    44.2 %      4   61.3 %
Top

Return to “Computer Chess Club: Tournaments and Matches”