FCT1: Basic Tourney, final results ...

elcabesa · Post by **elcabesa** » Sun Jun 15, 2014 7:24 pm

I'm adding some missing knowledge. but I have just found the problem with game 8593

vajolet think that position fen 8/8/5b2/8/7p/1k6/6K1/8 w - - 0 49 is lost but evalutation is 0... I have to understood why search told me this is lost.

Frank Quisinsky · Post by **Frank Quisinsky** » Mon Jun 23, 2014 2:07 am

Hi there,

here are the final results of Crafty 24.0 SSE42 x64.

Round Robin:
http://www.amateurschach.de/ftptrigger/ ... 2-x64.html

Code: Select all

    Programs                       Score       1-0  =  0-1          EloS  Baye  Ordo  +   -  Draws  MoveØ won<50 lost<50
 01. Stockfish 26.03.14 SSE42 x64  813.5/1000  653 321  26  81.3%   3061  3041  3089  19 19  32.1%   80     25      0
 02. Komodo TCECr x64              782.5/1000  615 335  50  78.2%   3029  3014  3055  19 18  33.5%   86     23      1
 03. GullChess 2.8 Beta BMI2 x64   720.0/1000  521 398  81  72.0%   2974  2965  2995  17 17  39.8%   90     10      3
 04. Fire 3.0 AVX x64              694.5/1000  495 399 106  69.5%   2953  2947  2972  17 17  39.9%   88      7      3
 05. Chiron 2.0 x64                583.0/1000  379 408 213  58.3%   2873  2870  2882  17 17  40.8%   85      9      5
 06. Hannibal 1.4b x64             573.5/1000  355 437 208  57.4%   2866  2864  2875  16 16  43.7%   91      9      5
 07. Protector 1.5.0 JA x64        538.5/1000  310 457 233  53.8%   2843  2841  2848  16 16  45.7%   88      8      5
 08. Senpai 1.0 SSE42 x64          521.5/1000  308 427 265  52.1%   2832  2831  2835  16 16  42.7%   88      4     10
 09. Hiarcs 14 WCSC w32            506.0/1000  276 460 264  50.6%   2821  2820  2824  16 16  46.0%   88     12      9
 10. Shredder 12 x64               473.5/1000  269 409 322  47.3%   2800  2800  2800  17 17  40.9%   88      9     12
 11. Texel 1.03 x64                464.0/1000  255 418 327  46.4%   2794  2792  2793  16 16  41.8%   90      7      6
 12. Spike 1.4 Leiden w32          449.0/1000  243 412 345  44.9%   2784  2783  2781  17 17  41.2%   88      6     10
 13. Junior 13.8.04 Yokohama x64   445.5/1000  238 415 347  44.5%   2781  2782  2779  16 17  41.5%   84     10      5
 14. Spark 1.0 x64                 422.5/1000  220 405 375  42.2%   2766  2767  2761  17 17  40.5%   88     18      0
 15. Quazar 0.4 x64                419.5/1000  209 421 370  41.9%   2764  2764  2759  16 16  42.1%  100      2      6
 16. Zappa Mexico II x64           403.5/1000  194 419 387  40.4%   2753  2754  2747  16 17  41.9%   90      7     10
 17. Gaviota 1.0 AVX x64           377.0/1000  188 378 434  37.7%   2734  2735  2727  17 17  37.8%   86      4     23
 18. Vajolet2 1.28 POP x64         371.5/1000  174 395 431  37.1%   2730  2733  2722  17 17  39.5%   88      2     12
 19. SmarThink 1.50 SSE3 x64       348.0/1000  170 356 474  34.8%   2714  2715  2704  18 18  35.6%   85      5     16
 20. Nirvanachess 1.6 x64          324.0/1000  145 358 497  32.4%   2696  2700  2684  18 18  35.8%   87      6     17
 21. Crafty 24.0 SSE42 x64         269.0/1000  105 328 567  26.9%   2652  2659  2637  18 19  32.8%   84      0     25

Ratings: Move number 20-59

Code: Select all

 FCT1 (Frank's Continuous Tourney 1), games with move number 020-059
 Elostat 1.3,   EloØ = 2.820, Category = 23
 
     Programs                         Elo   +   - Games Score Av.Op. Draws   Won Draw Lost
 01. Stockfish 26.03.14 SSE42 x64   : 2995  36 33  176  75.3%  2802  49.4%    89   87    0
 02. Komodo TCECr x64               : 2983  41 38  144  73.6%  2805  48.6%    71   70    3
 03. Fire 3.0 AVX x64               : 2906  35 34  144  61.1%  2827  62.5%    43   90   11
 04. Chiron 2.0 x64                 : 2900  34 33  164  62.8%  2809  58.5%    55   96   13
 05. GullChess 2.8 Beta BMI2 x64    : 2890  36 34  133  61.7%  2808  63.2%    40   84    9
 06. Spark 1.0 x64                  : 2872  33 32  141  58.9%  2810  66.7%    36   94   11
 07. Protector 1.5.0 JA x64         : 2853  30 30  167  55.1%  2817  67.1%    36  112   19
 08. Junior 13.8.04 Yokohama x64    : 2850  34 34  161  56.8%  2802  60.2%    43   97   21
 09. Hannibal 1.4b x64              : 2833  39 39  123  50.0%  2833  61.0%    24   75   24
 10. Texel 1.03 x64                 : 2830  37 37  145  52.1%  2815  57.2%    34   83   28
 11. Hiarcs 14 WCSC w32             : 2810  34 35  167  47.9%  2825  57.5%    32   96   39
 12. Spike 1.4 Leiden w32           : 2802  31 32  133  48.5%  2812  71.4%    17   95   21
 13. Shredder 12 x64                : 2792  37 38  149  45.0%  2827  55.0%    26   82   41
 14. Senpai 1.0 SSE42 x64           : 2789  34 35  136  45.2%  2822  65.4%    17   89   30
 15. Quazar 0.4 x64                 : 2788  41 42   94  43.1%  2836  64.9%    10   61   23
 16. Zappa Mexico II x64            : 2771  36 37  136  43.0%  2820  61.0%    17   83   36
 17. Nirvanachess 1.6 x64           : 2754  36 37  159  39.6%  2827  54.1%    20   86   53
 18. Vajolet2 1.28 POP x64          : 2716  38 39  140  34.3%  2829  54.3%    10   76   54
 19. Gaviota 1.0 AVX x64            : 2715  39 40  152  34.5%  2826  49.3%    15   75   62
 20. SmarThink 1.50 SSE3 x64        : 2714  39 40  170  34.7%  2824  43.5%    22   74   74
 21. Crafty 24.0 SSE42 x64          : 2650  38 41  168  24.7%  2844  43.5%     5   73   90

 Games         : 1551
 White Perf.   : 56.1%
 Black Perf.   : 43.9%
 White Wins    :  426 Games (27.5%)
 Black Wins    :  236 Games (15.2%)
 Draws         :  889 Games (57.3%)

 ECO A00-A99   :  287 Games (18.5%)
 ECO B00-B99   :  349 Games (22.5%)
 ECO C00-C99   :  304 Games (19.6%)
 ECO D00-D99   :  366 Games (23.6%)
 ECO E00-E99   :  245 Games (15.8%)

Ratings: Move number 60-99

Code: Select all

 FCT1 (Frank's Continuous Tourney 1), games with move number  060-099
 Elostat 1.3,   EloØ = 2.820, Category = 23
 
     Programs                         Elo   +   - Games Score Av.Op. Draws   Won Draw Lost
 01. Stockfish 26.03.14 SSE42 x64   : 3132  32 32  644  88.0%  2785  17.1%   512  110   22
 02. Komodo TCECr x64               : 3080  29 29  638  84.2%  2790  20.1%   473  128   37
 03. GullChess 2.8 Beta BMI2 x64    : 3032  29 28  594  80.5%  2786  22.2%   412  132   50
 04. Fire 3.0 AVX x64               : 2989  27 26  601  76.3%  2786  24.5%   385  147   69
 05. Chiron 2.0 x64                 : 2879  25 25  599  60.8%  2803  24.7%   290  148  161
 06. Hannibal 1.4b x64              : 2870  24 24  579  59.6%  2802  28.0%   264  162  153
 07. Protector 1.5.0 JA x64         : 2846  25 25  548  54.3%  2816  27.9%   221  153  174
 08. Senpai 1.0 SSE42 x64           : 2841  24 24  588  54.3%  2811  27.7%   238  163  187
 09. Hiarcs 14 WCSC w32             : 2821  24 24  559  51.2%  2813  29.3%   204  164  191
 10. Shredder 12 x64                : 2785  24 24  588  45.2%  2818  25.3%   191  149  248
 11. Texel 1.03 x64                 : 2778  25 25  569  44.3%  2818  22.1%   189  126  254
 12. Spike 1.4 Leiden w32           : 2767  24 24  612  42.1%  2822  25.3%   180  155  277
 13. Junior 13.8.04 Yokohama x64    : 2753  24 24  593  40.6%  2818  26.6%   162  158  273
 14. Quazar 0.4 x64                 : 2750  27 27  531  39.5%  2825  17.9%   162   95  274
 15. Spark 1.0 x64                  : 2744  25 25  589  38.2%  2828  24.4%   153  144  292
 16. Zappa Mexico II x64            : 2726  25 25  575  36.3%  2823  25.4%   136  146  293
 17. Gaviota 1.0 AVX x64            : 2709  26 26  581  33.5%  2828  21.2%   133  123  325
 18. Vajolet2 1.28 POP x64          : 2707  26 26  574  33.8%  2824  23.7%   126  136  312
 19. SmarThink 1.50 SSE3 x64        : 2682  26 26  605  30.3%  2827  20.7%   121  125  359
 20. Nirvanachess 1.6 x64           : 2661  27 27  599  27.9%  2826  20.0%   107  120  372
 21. Crafty 24.0 SSE42 x64          : 2612  28 29  606  22.3%  2829  18.2%    80  110  416

 Games         : 6186
 White Perf.   : 56.9%
 Black Perf.   : 43.1%
 White Wins    : 2794 Games (45.2%)
 Black Wins    : 1945 Games (31.4%)
 Draws         : 1447 Games (23.4%)

 ECO A00-A99   : 1173 Games (19.0%)
 ECO B00-B99   : 1398 Games (22.6%)
 ECO C00-C99   : 1243 Games (20.1%)
 ECO D00-D99   : 1394 Games (22.5%)
 ECO E00-E99   :  978 Games (15.8%)

Ratings: Move number 100-300

Code: Select all

 FCT1 (Frank's Continuous Tourney 1), games with move number 100-299
 Elostat 1.3,   EloØ = 2.820, Category = 23
 
     Programs                         Elo   +   - Games Score Av.Op. Draws   Won Draw Lost
 01. Stockfish 26.03.14 SSE42 x64   : 2927  28 26  180  63.3%  2832  68.9%    52  124    4
 01. Komodo TCECr x64               : 2927  28 26  218  64.0%  2827  62.8%    71  137   10
 03. GullChess 2.8 Beta BMI2 x64    : 2892  24 23  273  58.6%  2832  66.7%    69  182   22
 04. Fire 3.0 AVX x64               : 2883  26 25  255  58.0%  2827  63.5%    67  162   26
 05. Hannibal 1.4b x64              : 2862  23 22  298  56.0%  2820  67.1%    67  200   31
 06. Shredder 12 x64                : 2840  24 24  263  53.6%  2815  67.7%    52  178   33
 07. Protector 1.5.0 JA x64         : 2831  23 23  285  52.3%  2815  67.4%    53  192   40
 08. Senpai 1.0 SSE42 x64           : 2825  25 25  276  50.9%  2819  63.4%    53  175   48
 08. Hiarcs 14 WCSC w32             : 2825  21 21  274  51.1%  2818  73.0%    40  200   34
 10. Chiron 2.0 x64                 : 2819  25 25  237  48.9%  2826  69.2%    34  164   39
 11. Spike 1.4 Leiden w32           : 2815  26 26  255  49.8%  2816  63.5%    46  162   47
 12. Gaviota 1.0 AVX x64            : 2803  24 24  267  48.7%  2813  67.4%    40  180   47
 13. Texel 1.03 x64                 : 2802  21 21  286  47.7%  2818  73.1%    32  209   45
 14. Junior 13.8.04 Yokohama x64    : 2798  26 26  246  45.9%  2826  65.0%    33  160   53
 15. Zappa Mexico II x64            : 2797  23 24  289  47.1%  2817  65.7%    41  190   58
 16. SmarThink 1.50 SSE3 x64        : 2795  25 25  225  46.9%  2817  69.8%    27  157   41
 17. Vajolet2 1.28 POP x64          : 2786  24 24  286  45.3%  2819  64.0%    38  183   65
 18. Quazar 0.4 x64                 : 2784  19 19  375  45.2%  2818  70.7%    37  265   73
 19. Spark 1.0 x64                  : 2764  25 26  270  42.4%  2817  61.9%    31  167   72
 20. Crafty 24.0 SSE42 x64          : 2749  26 27  226  40.9%  2812  64.2%    20  145   61
 21. Nirvanachess 1.6 x64           : 2741  26 27  242  38.8%  2819  62.8%    18  152   72

 Games         : 2763
 White Perf.   : 51.5%
 Black Perf.   : 48.5%
 White Wins    :  503 Games (18.2%)
 Black Wins    :  418 Games (15.1%)
 Draws         : 1842 Games (66.7%)

 ECO A00-A99   :  510 Games (18.5%)
 ECO B00-B99   :  616 Games (22.3%)
 ECO C00-C99   :  558 Games (20.2%)
 ECO D00-D99   :  638 Games (23.1%)
 ECO E00-E99   :  441 Games (16.0%)

Games with GUI comments and more Information can be found under:

Frank's Chess Page
http://www.amateurschach.de

Best
Frank

Frank Quisinsky · Post by **Frank Quisinsky** » Mon Jun 23, 2014 2:10 am

Hi there,

the next engine is Deuterium 14.2.33.276 x64.

Round Robin can be found on my webpage.
Deuterium have to beat Crafty for the qualify !!

Frank's Chess Page
http://www.amateurschach.de

Best
Frank

Ferdy · Post by **Ferdy** » Tue Jul 01, 2014 3:18 am

Frank Quisinsky wrote:Hi there,

the next engine is Deuterium 14.2.33.276 x64.

Round Robin can be found on my webpage.
Deuterium have to beat Crafty for the qualify !!

Frank's Chess Page
http://www.amateurschach.de

Best
Frank

Thanks Frank, looking forward to see your game phase rating stats and game downloads.

Code: Select all

Deuterium 14.2.33.276 x64 - Stockfish 26.03.14 SSE42 x64 (3061)		5.0	-	45.0		10.00%		Perf=2680
Deuterium 14.2.33.276 x64 - Komodo TCECr x64 (3029)                  8.0	-	42.0		16.00%		Perf=2741
Deuterium 14.2.33.276 x64 - GullChess 2.8 Beta BMI2 x64 (2974)	    9.5	-	40.5		19.00%		Perf=2723
Deuterium 14.2.33.276 x64 - Fire 3.0 AVX x64 (2953)		           12.0	-	38.0		24.00%		Perf=2753
Deuterium 14.2.33.276 x64 - Chiron 2.0 x64 (2873)		             11.5	-	38.5		23.00%		Perf=2664
Deuterium 14.2.33.276 x64 - Hannibal 1.4b x64 (2866)		          15.0	-	35.0		30.00%		Perf=2719
Deuterium 14.2.33.276 x64 - Protector 1.5.0 JA x64 (2843)		     12.0	-	38.0		24.00%		Perf=2643
Deuterium 14.2.33.276 x64 - Senpai 1.0 SSE42 x64 (2832) 		      19.5	-	30.5		39.00%		Perf=2755
Deuterium 14.2.33.276 x64 - Hiarcs 14 WCSC w32 (2821) 		        18.5	-	31.5		37.00%		Perf=2729
Deuterium 14.2.33.276 x64 - Shredder 12 x64 (2800)		            21.0	-	29.0		42.00%		Perf=2744
Deuterium 14.2.33.276 x64 - Texel 1.03 x64 (2794)		             19.0	-	31.0		38.00%		Perf=2709
Deuterium 14.2.33.276 x64 - Spike 1.4 Leiden w32 (2784) 		      21.0	-	29.0		42.00%		Perf=2728
Deuterium 14.2.33.276 x64 - Junior 13.8.04 Yokohama x64 (2781)		19.0	-	31.0		38.00%		Perf=2696
Deuterium 14.2.33.276 x64 - Spark 1.0 x64 (2766)	 	             18.0	-	32.0		36.00%		Perf=2667
Deuterium 14.2.33.276 x64 - Quazar 0.4 x64 (2764)		             21.5	-	28.5		43.00%		Perf=2716
Deuterium 14.2.33.276 x64 - Zappa Mexico II x64 (2753) 		       22.5	-	27.5		45.00%		Perf=2719
Deuterium 14.2.33.276 x64 - Gaviota 1.0 AVX x64 (2734)   	 	    27.0	-	23.0		54.00%		Perf=2761
Deuterium 14.2.33.276 x64 - Vajolet2 1.28 POP x64 (2730)  		    27.0	-	23.0		54.00%		Perf=2757
Deuterium 14.2.33.276 x64 - SmarThink 1.50 SSE3 x64 (2714)    		27.0	-	23.0		54.00%		Perf=2741
Deuterium 14.2.33.276 x64 - Nirvanachess 1.6 x64 (2696) 	  	    29.5	-	20.5		59.00%		Perf=2759
Deuterium 14.2.33.276 x64 - Crafty 24.0 SSE42 x64 (2652) 	 	    32.0	-	18.0		64.00%		Perf=2751
                                                                   395.5	-  654.5	   37.67%		Perf=2733

Frank Quisinsky · Post by **Frank Quisinsky** » Tue Jul 01, 2014 7:10 am

Hi Ferdinand,

I will working on the updates in the next hours.
Yesterday in the late evening I am looking football and feel asleep over it. What I do only are to start the update tourney.

But in the next hours I will create all the updates.
At the moment the donwload file is online, you can download ...

Best
Frank

Ferdy · Post by **Ferdy** » Tue Jul 01, 2014 8:02 am

Frank wrote:Unfortunately, we don't have a tool for make it better.
Better isnt to calculate with move numbers, better is to calculate with pieces on the board!

I tried to make a research on this and found out that pgn-extract is a possible tool that can do it.
Here is what I did, downloaded the fct1-10500.pgn, then search the rook+pawn vs rook+pawn ending. The criteria is find this type of ending where it occurs for at least 30 moves in every game in that pgn file, 1 rook per side and number of pawns on both sides is at least 1. Here is the ordo table.
[1]

Code: Select all

   # PLAYER                          : RATING  ERROR   POINTS  PLAYED    (%)
   1 Stockfish 26.03.14 SSE42 x64    : 3032.6   76.0     65.5      87   75.3%
   2 Komodo TCECr x64                : 2980.0   81.2     53.5      76   70.4%
   3 Protector 1.5.0 JA x64          : 2880.2   76.5     51.5      92   56.0%
   4 Chiron 2.0 x64                  : 2864.3   91.8     36.0      69   52.2%
   5 Senpai 1.0 SSE42 x64            : 2859.6   69.2     43.0      80   53.8%
   6 Hiarcs 14 WCSC w32              : 2858.6   76.9     38.0      71   53.5%
   7 GullChess 2.8 Beta BMI2 x64     : 2852.4   75.5     31.0      64   48.4%
   8 Fire 3.0 AVX x64                : 2849.2   83.8     32.5      65   50.0%
   9 Spike 1.4 Leiden w32            : 2842.6   78.0     47.5      92   51.6%
  10 Zappa Mexico II x64             : 2833.5   75.1     43.5      90   48.3%
  11 Texel 1.03 x64                  : 2833.0   69.7     49.5      97   51.0%
  12 SmarThink 1.50 SSE3 x64         : 2826.6   75.8     33.0      67   49.3%
  13 Spark 1.0 x64                   : 2825.8   75.0     46.0      95   48.4%
  14 Hannibal 1.4b x64               : 2819.9   76.5     41.0      91   45.1%
  15 Junior 13.8.04 Yokohama x64     : 2804.7   82.4     30.0      69   43.5%
  16 Shredder 12 x64                 : 2800.0   ----     33.5      75   44.7%
  17 Vajolet2 1.28 POP x64           : 2798.7   77.1     34.0      76   44.7%
  18 Quazar 0.4 x64                  : 2791.4   79.9     38.0      86   44.2%
  19 Gaviota 1.0 AVX x64             : 2765.8   78.9     27.0      68   39.7%
  20 Crafty 24.0 SSE42 x64           : 2738.4   84.9     24.0      67   35.8%
  21 Nirvanachess 1.6 x64            : 2726.1   92.2     24.0      67   35.8%

[2]
Another table for pure pawn ending, also occured in the game for at least 30 moves.

Code: Select all

   # PLAYER                          : RATING  ERROR   POINTS  PLAYED    (%)
   1 Komodo TCECr x64                : 3129.4  329.3     14.5      17   85.3%
   2 Stockfish 26.03.14 SSE42 x64    : 3103.4  312.3      7.5      10   75.0%
   3 GullChess 2.8 Beta BMI2 x64     : 2969.7  279.7     15.0      24   62.5%
   4 Chiron 2.0 x64                  : 2961.7  296.5      5.5       9   61.1%
   5 Nirvanachess 1.6 x64            : 2929.9  273.6      5.5      10   55.0%
   6 Spike 1.4 Leiden w32            : 2917.3  315.5      6.5      10   65.0%
   7 Junior 13.8.04 Yokohama x64     : 2910.7  308.2      6.0      11   54.5%
   8 Fire 3.0 AVX x64                : 2906.5  279.6      6.0      10   60.0%
   9 Quazar 0.4 x64                  : 2874.3  320.8      4.0       8   50.0%
  10 Senpai 1.0 SSE42 x64            : 2857.8  261.9      4.0      10   40.0%
  11 Hiarcs 14 WCSC w32              : 2849.4  285.9     10.0      19   52.6%
  12 Zappa Mexico II x64             : 2837.7  257.8      9.0      20   45.0%
  13 Protector 1.5.0 JA x64          : 2831.5  279.3      7.0      17   41.2%
  14 SmarThink 1.50 SSE3 x64         : 2829.2  259.6      6.5      14   46.4%
  15 Gaviota 1.0 AVX x64             : 2825.2  276.0      8.5      21   40.5%
  16 Spark 1.0 x64                   : 2820.9  275.8      7.5      18   41.7%
  17 Shredder 12 x64                 : 2800.0   ----      2.5       6   41.7%
  18 Vajolet2 1.28 POP x64           : 2799.5  268.9      6.5      17   38.2%
  19 Hannibal 1.4b x64               : 2794.3  392.3      2.0       4   50.0%
  20 Texel 1.03 x64                  : 2750.1  264.7      6.5      21   31.0%
  21 Crafty 24.0 SSE42 x64           : 2664.1  309.6      2.5      10   25.0%

[3]
And the imbalance of rook and pawns vs 1 bishop and 1 knight and pawns this also occured for at least 30 moves in a game.

Code: Select all

   # PLAYER                          : RATING  ERROR   POINTS  PLAYED    (%)
   1 Senpai 1.0 SSE42 x64            : 3140.4  342.3      3.5       4   87.5%
   2 Stockfish 26.03.14 SSE42 x64    : 3008.8  349.0      6.0       8   75.0%
   3 Fire 3.0 AVX x64                : 2978.9  364.2      8.0      10   80.0%
   4 Protector 1.5.0 JA x64        > : 2973.8  368.0      1.0       1  100.0%
   5 Komodo TCECr x64                : 2948.5  408.8      3.5       5   70.0%
   6 GullChess 2.8 Beta BMI2 x64     : 2925.3  302.3      8.0      12   66.7%
   7 Texel 1.03 x64                  : 2868.5  354.5      4.0       7   57.1%
   8 Junior 13.8.04 Yokohama x64     : 2856.7  320.1      5.0       7   71.4%
   9 Hiarcs 14 WCSC w32              : 2807.8  291.0      6.0      10   60.0%
  10 Shredder 12 x64                 : 2800.0   ----      4.0       7   57.1%
  11 Spike 1.4 Leiden w32            : 2796.9  302.9      8.0      14   57.1%
  12 Hannibal 1.4b x64               : 2779.0  378.1      4.0       7   57.1%
  13 Chiron 2.0 x64                  : 2771.8  291.8      5.0      13   38.5%
  14 Quazar 0.4 x64                  : 2739.5  310.6      4.5       9   50.0%
  15 Zappa Mexico II x64             : 2699.0  413.9      2.5       6   41.7%
  16 Nirvanachess 1.6 x64            : 2683.5  332.4      4.5      11   40.9%
  17 Spark 1.0 x64                   : 2668.4  276.2      6.0      12   50.0%
  18 SmarThink 1.50 SSE3 x64         : 2632.4  364.1      3.5       8   43.8%
  19 Vajolet2 1.28 POP x64           : 2598.0  318.6      3.0      12   25.0%
  20 Gaviota 1.0 AVX x64             : 2511.8  354.7      1.5       8   18.8%
  21 Crafty 24.0 SSE42 x64           : 2460.9  328.1      3.5      19   18.4%

Frank if you are interested, I will a prepare the batch files to extract this info, or perhaps I will just post here, since this is not really complicated when using pgn-extract.

Frank Quisinsky · Post by **Frank Quisinsky** » Tue Jul 01, 2014 10:35 am

Hi Ferdinand,

all sites updated on my webpage.
I wrote a bit to Deuterium in my News (030).

The Philippine Cobra

Best
Frank

Frank Quisinsky · Post by **Frank Quisinsky** » Tue Jul 01, 2014 10:46 am

Hi Ferdinand,

yes, such batch files are interesting for each one!!
I can add it in my download selection if you like.
Could you send the files per mail. My mail address you can find under "Impressum" on my webpage.

That is what I try a long time.

To give my visitors more information to ratings. Ratings alone is very boring, we can see nothing. Most time I wrote about ideas I have in German language in CSS Forum.

We don't have a good statistic GUI for PGN files. Means the tools by Norm Pollock I used are great but we can more do with a nice graphical interface and a good sorted eng-eng database without resign=on.

Endgame stats are not easy to create. I create different stats for myself too but such stats need a lot of time.

I am most interesting in stats to fast won / lost games. I like engines with can play fast tactical games. Spark won 22 games and lost 0 up to move 50. Same in SWCR1 and SWCR2. Perfect for analyzes after the opening book moves in my opinion. But the endgame from Spark is very bad (wrote this for an example).

Thanks for Deuterium!!

A very very nice engine developement and I hope you can improved your engine in tactics. Have a look in the database! Deuterium saw tactical combination by the others very late.

Best
Frank

Frank Quisinsky · Post by **Frank Quisinsky** » Tue Jul 01, 2014 11:43 am

Hi there,

here are the final results of Deuterium 14.2.33.276 x64.
Deuterium won the qualify !!

Code: Select all

     Programs                      Score       1-0  =  0-1         EloS  Baye  Ordo  +   -  Draws  MoveØ won<50 lost<50
 18. Deuterium 14.2.33.276 x64     395.5/1050  176 439 435  37.7%  2731  2734  2723  16 16  41.8%   83      3      33     Qualified
 19. Vajolet2 1.28 POP x64         394.5/1050  185 419 446  37.6%  2730  2732  2722  16 16  39.9%   88      2      12     Qualified
 21. Nirvanachess 1.6 x64          344.5/1050  153 383 514  32.8%  2695  2700  2684  17 17  36.5%   86      6      17     Qualified
 22. Crafty 24.0 SSE42 x64         287.0/1050  112 350 588  27.3%  2652  2659  2637  18 18  33.3%   84      1      26     out of tourney

Round Robin:
http://www.amateurschach.de/ftptrigger/ ... 6-x64.html

More information (games, new random book v. 7.4) can be found on my webpage:

Frank's Chess Page
http://www.amateurschach.de

Best
Frank

Code: Select all

     Programs                      Score       1-0  =  0-1          EloS  Baye  Ordo  +   -  Draws  MoveØ won<50 lost<50
 01. Stockfish 26.03.14 SSE42 x64  858.5/1050  693 331  26  81.8%   3063  3043  3090  19 19  31.5%   80     28       0
 02. Komodo TCECr x64              824.5/1050  651 347  52  78.5%   3029  3015  3054  18 18  33.0%   85     25       1
 03. GullChess 2.8 Beta BMI2 x64   760.5/1050  554 413  83  72.4%   2975  2966  2995  17 17  39.3%   89     13       3
 04. Fire 3.0 AVX x64              732.5/1050  522 421 107  69.8%   2953  2946  2971  17 17  40.1%   88      9       3
 05. Chiron 2.0 x64                621.5/1050  409 425 216  59.2%   2876  2873  2885  16 16  40.5%   85     16       6
 06. Hannibal 1.4b x64             608.5/1050  380 457 213  58.0%   2868  2864  2875  16 16  43.5%   91     10       5
 07. Protector 1.5.0 JA x64        576.5/1050  338 477 235  54.9%   2847  2845  2852  16 16  45.4%   88     10       5
 08. Senpai 1.0 SSE42 x64          552.0/1050  326 452 272  52.6%   2831  2830  2835  16 16  43.0%   88      5      10
 09. Hiarcs 14 WCSC w32            537.5/1050  296 483 271  51.2%   2822  2821  2824  15 15  46.0%   88     13       9
 10. Shredder 12 x64               502.5/1050  284 437 329  47.9%   2800  2800  2800  16 16  41.6%   88     10      12
 11. Texel 1.03 x64                495.0/1050  275 440 335  47.1%   2795  2794  2794  16 16  41.9%   90     10       6
 12. Spike 1.4 Leiden w32          478.0/1050  261 434 355  45.5%   2785  2784  2782  16 16  41.3%   88      6      10
 13. Junior 13.8.04 Yokohama x64   476.5/1050  257 439 354  45.4%   2784  2784  2781  16 16  41.8%   84     10       5
 14. Spark 1.0 x64                 454.5/1050  242 425 383  43.3%   2770  2770  2765  16 16  40.5%   88     22       0
 15. Quazar 0.4 x64                448.0/1050  228 440 382  42.7%   2765  2765  2761  16 16  41.9%  100      2       7
 16. Zappa Mexico II x64           431.0/1050  206 450 394  41.0%   2754  2755  2749  16 16  42.9%   90      8      10
 17. Gaviota 1.0 AVX x64           400.0/1050  202 396 452  38.1%   2734  2735  2726  17 17  37.7%   86      4      23
 18. Deuterium 14.2.33.276 x64     395.5/1050  176 439 435  37.7%   2731  2734  2723  16 16  41.8%   83      3      33
 19. Vajolet2 1.28 POP x64         394.5/1050  185 419 446  37.6%   2730  2732  2722  16 16  39.9%   88      2      12
 20. SmarThink 1.50 SSE3 x64       371.0/1050  183 376 491  35.3%   2819  2715  2704  17 17  35.8%   85      6      16
 21. Nirvanachess 1.6 x64          344.5/1050  153 383 514  32.8%   2695  2700  2684  17 17  36.5%   86      6      17
 22. Crafty 24.0 SSE42 x64         287.0/1050  112 350 588  27.3%   2652  2659  2637  18 18  33.3%   84      1      26)

---

Code: Select all

FCT1 (Frank's Continuous Tourney 1), games with move number 020-059
 Elostat 1.3,   EloØ = 2.817, Category = 23

     Programs                         Elo   +   - Games Score Av.Op. Draws   Won Draw Lost
 01. Stockfish 26.03.14 SSE42 x64   : 2999  36 33  188  76.1%  2799  47.9%    98   90    0
 02. Komodo TCECr x64               : 2985  40 37  153  74.2%  2802  47.7%    77   73    3
 03. Chiron 2.0 x64                 : 2906  34 33  177  64.1%  2805  55.9%    64   99   14
 04. Fire 3.0 AVX x64               : 2905  34 32  153  61.4%  2824  62.7%    46   96   11
 05. GullChess 2.8 Beta BMI2 x64    : 2896  36 34  141  62.8%  2805  61.7%    45   87    9
 06. Spark 1.0 x64                  : 2880  33 32  154  60.7%  2804  64.3%    44   99   11
 07. Protector 1.5.0 JA x64         : 2856  30 29  176  56.0%  2814  66.5%    40  117   19
 08. Junior 13.8.04 Yokohama x64    : 2843  32 32  173  56.4%  2799  61.8%    44  107   22
 09. Hannibal 1.4b x64              : 2840  38 38  132  51.9%  2827  59.8%    29   79   24
 10. Texel 1.03 x64                 : 2837  36 36  161  54.0%  2809  55.9%    42   90   29
 11. Hiarcs 14 WCSC w32             : 2813  33 33  177  48.9%  2821  58.2%    35  103   39
 12. Spike 1.4 Leiden w32           : 2804  31 31  146  49.7%  2807  70.5%    21  103   22
 13. Shredder 12 x64                : 2794  36 36  156  45.5%  2825  56.4%    27   88   41
 14. Senpai 1.0 SSE42 x64           : 2790  33 34  149  46.3%  2816  64.4%    21   96   32
 15. Quazar 0.4 x64                 : 2779  39 40  101  42.6%  2831  65.3%    10   66   25
 16. Zappa Mexico II x64            : 2775  35 36  145  44.1%  2816  60.7%    20   88   37
 17. Nirvanachess 1.6 x64           : 2754  35 35  168  40.2%  2824  55.4%    21   93   54
 18. Deuterium 14.2.33.276 x64      : 2729  32 33  211  36.0%  2828  52.1%    21  110   80
 19. Vajolet2 1.28 POP x64          : 2722  36 37  147  35.4%  2826  55.8%    11   82   54
 20. Gaviota 1.0 AVX x64            : 2716  38 38  160  35.0%  2823  50.0%    16   80   64
 21. SmarThink 1.50 SSE3 x64        : 2714  39 39  180  35.0%  2821  42.2%    25   76   79
 22. Crafty 24.0 SSE42 x64          : 2650  38 40  176  25.0%  2840  43.2%     6   76   94

 Games         : 1762
 White Perf.   : 56.2%
 Black Perf.   : 43.8%
 White Wins    :  490 Games (27.8%)
 Black Wins    :  273 Games (15.5%)
 Draws         :  999 Games (55.7%)

 ECO A00-A99   :  326 Games (18.5%)
 ECO B00-B99   :  394 Games (22.4%)
 ECO C00-C99   :  355 Games (20.1%)
 ECO D00-D99   :  404 Games (22.9%)
 ECO E00-E99   :  283 Games (16.1%)

---

Code: Select all

 FCT1 (Frank's Continuous Tourney 1), games with move number  060-099
 Elostat 1.3,   EloØ = 2.817, Category = 23

     Programs                         Elo   +   - Games Score Av.Op. Draws   Won Draw Lost
 01. Stockfish 26.03.14 SSE42 x64   : 3134  32 31  676  88.3%  2783  16.9%   540  114   22
 02. Komodo TCECr x64               : 3079  29 28  670  84.3%  2788  19.9%   498  133   39
 03. GullChess 2.8 Beta BMI2 x64    : 3034  28 28  627  80.9%  2784  22.0%   438  138   51
 04. Fire 3.0 AVX x64               : 2991  26 26  627  76.6%  2785  24.7%   403  155   69
 05. Chiron 2.0 x64                 : 2882  24 24  626  61.4%  2801  25.1%   306  157  163
 06. Hannibal 1.4b x64              : 2871  24 24  610  60.2%  2799  28.2%   281  172  157
 07. Protector 1.5.0 JA x64         : 2853  24 24  575  55.8%  2813  27.5%   242  158  175
 08. Senpai 1.0 SSE42 x64           : 2843  23 23  612  54.9%  2809  28.1%   250  172  190
 09. Hiarcs 14 WCSC w32             : 2822  24 24  587  51.8%  2810  29.0%   219  170  198
 10. Shredder 12 x64                : 2787  24 24  620  46.0%  2814  26.3%   204  163  253
 11. Texel 1.03 x64                 : 2779  25 25  595  44.9%  2815  22.9%   199  136  260
 12. Spike 1.4 Leiden w32           : 2769  23 23  637  42.8%  2819  25.9%   190  165  282
 13. Junior 13.8.04 Yokohama x64    : 2758  24 24  620  41.9%  2815  26.6%   177  165  278
 14. Quazar 0.4 x64                 : 2755  26 27  559  40.7%  2821  18.1%   177  101  281
 15. Spark 1.0 x64                  : 2748  24 24  616  39.2%  2824  24.5%   166  151  299
 16. Zappa Mexico II x64            : 2729  24 24  601  37.2%  2820  26.8%   143  161  297
 17. Deuterium 14.2.33.276 x64      : 2713  23 24  613  35.9%  2813  30.3%   127  186  300
 18. Gaviota 1.0 AVX x64            : 2709  25 25  616  34.1%  2823  21.4%   144  132  340
 19. Vajolet2 1.28 POP x64          : 2707  25 25  610  34.4%  2819  24.6%   135  150  325
 20. SmarThink 1.50 SSE3 x64        : 2685  25 26  633  31.0%  2823  21.3%   129  135  369
 21. Nirvanachess 1.6 x64           : 2661  26 26  633  28.5%  2821  21.0%   114  133  386
 22. Crafty 24.0 SSE42 x64          : 2612  28 28  635  22.6%  2826  18.7%    84  119  432

 Games         : 6799
 White Perf.   : 56.6%
 Black Perf.   : 43.4%
 White Wins    : 3030 Games (44.6%)
 Black Wins    : 2136 Games (31.4%)
 Draws         : 1633 Games (24.0%)

 ECO A00-A99   : 1290 Games (19.0%)
 ECO B00-B99   : 1517 Games (22.3%)
 ECO C00-C99   : 1376 Games (20.2%)
 ECO D00-D99   : 1521 Games (22.4%)
 ECO E00-E99   : 1095 Games (16.1%)

---

Code: Select all

FCT1 (Frank's Continuous Tourney 1), games with move number 100-299
 Elostat 1.3,   EloØ = 2.817, Category = 23
 
     Programs                         Elo   +   - Games Score Av.Op. Draws   Won Draw Lost
 01. Komodo TCECr x64               : 2927  28 26  227  64.5%  2823  62.1%    76  141   10
 01. Stockfish 26.03.14 SSE42 x64   : 2927  28 25  186  63.7%  2829  68.3%    55  127    4
 03. GullChess 2.8 Beta BMI2 x64    : 2889  23 23  282  58.5%  2829  66.7%    71  188   23
 04. Fire 3.0 AVX x64               : 2882  25 25  270  58.5%  2823  63.0%    73  170   27
 05. Hannibal 1.4b x64              : 2860  22 22  308  56.2%  2817  66.9%    70  206   32
 06. Shredder 12 x64                : 2835  23 23  274  53.3%  2812  67.9%    53  186   35
 07. Protector 1.5.0 JA x64         : 2830  23 22  299  52.5%  2812  67.6%    56  202   41
 08. Hiarcs 14 WCSC w32             : 2824  21 21  286  51.4%  2815  73.4%    42  210   34
 09. Chiron 2.0 x64                 : 2822  24 24  247  50.0%  2822  68.4%    39  169   39
 09. Senpai 1.0 SSE42 x64           : 2822  24 24  289  50.9%  2816  63.7%    55  184   50
 11. Spike 1.4 Leiden w32           : 2812  26 26  267  49.8%  2813  62.2%    50  166   51
 12. Gaviota 1.0 AVX x64            : 2802  24 24  274  48.9%  2810  67.2%    42  184   48
 13. Texel 1.03 x64                 : 2801  21 21  294  48.0%  2816  72.8%    34  214   46
 14. Junior 13.8.04 Yokohama x64    : 2798  25 25  257  46.5%  2822  65.0%    36  167   54
 15. Zappa Mexico II x64            : 2794  23 23  304  47.2%  2814  66.1%    43  201   60
 16. SmarThink 1.50 SSE3 x64        : 2793  24 25  237  47.0%  2813  69.6%    29  165   43
 17. Vajolet2 1.28 POP x64          : 2784  24 24  293  45.2%  2817  63.8%    39  187   67
 18. Quazar 0.4 x64                 : 2783  19 19  390  45.5%  2815  70.0%    41  273   76
 19. Deuterium 14.2.33.276 x64      : 2777  27 28  226  44.0%  2819  63.3%    28  143   55
 20. Spark 1.0 x64                  : 2763  25 25  280  42.7%  2815  62.5%    32  175   73
 21. Crafty 24.0 SSE42 x64          : 2750  26 26  239  41.6%  2809  64.9%    22  155   62
 22. Nirvanachess 1.6 x64           : 2737  25 26  249  38.8%  2817  63.1%    18  157   74

 Games         : 2989
 White Perf.   : 51.5%
 Black Perf.   : 48.5%
 White Wins    :  548 Games (18.3%)
 Black Wins    :  456 Games (15.3%)
 Draws         : 1985 Games (66.4%)

 ECO A00-A99   :  545 Games (18.2%)
 ECO B00-B99   :  670 Games (22.4%)
 ECO C00-C99   :  607 Games (20.3%)
 ECO D00-D99   :  682 Games (22.8%)
 ECO E00-E99   :  485 Games (16.2%)

Ferdy · Post by **Ferdy** » Tue Jul 01, 2014 1:28 pm

Frank Quisinsky wrote:Hi Ferdinand,

yes, such batch files are interesting for each one!!
I can add it in my download selection if you like.
Could you send the files per mail. My mail address you can find under "Impressum" on my webpage.

That is what I try a long time.

To give my visitors more information to ratings. Ratings alone is very boring, we can see nothing. Most time I wrote about ideas I have in German language in CSS Forum.

We don't have a good statistic GUI for PGN files. Means the tools by Norm Pollock I used are great but we can more do with a nice graphical interface and a good sorted eng-eng database without resign=on.

Endgame stats are not easy to create. I create different stats for myself too but such stats need a lot of time.

I am most interesting in stats to fast won / lost games. I like engines with can play fast tactical games. Spark won 22 games and lost 0 up to move 50. Same in SWCR1 and SWCR2. Perfect for analyzes after the opening book moves in my opinion. But the endgame from Spark is very bad (wrote this for an example).

Thanks for Deuterium!!

A very very nice engine developement and I hope you can improved your engine in tactics. Have a look in the database! Deuterium saw tactical combination by the others very late.

Best
Frank

I sent the files using your contact form in your web page.
I also notice these weaknesses of Deuterium, I will look more closely on these games. The stat below that I call power games rating table showed Deuterium's place

.

Here is a sample stat where one side has at least 1 queen + 1 rook and 1 minor, material persist for up to 30 moves, games are completed within 50 moves. Nice attacking games.

Code: Select all

   # PLAYER                          : RATING  ERROR   POINTS  PLAYED    (%)
   1 Komodo TCECr x64                : 3007.7  119.0     28.5      37   77.0%
   2 Stockfish 26.03.14 SSE42 x64    : 2992.5  110.7     42.5      57   74.6%
   3 Spark 1.0 x64                   : 2939.0  106.0     34.0      49   69.4%
   4 Hannibal 1.4b x64               : 2903.2  118.9     21.0      35   60.0%
   5 Fire 3.0 AVX x64                : 2899.0  105.3     18.5      31   59.7%
   6 GullChess 2.8 Beta BMI2 x64     : 2893.7  115.4     21.5      35   61.4%
   7 Chiron 2.0 x64                  : 2884.6  101.2     24.5      40   61.3%
   8 Junior 13.8.04 Yokohama x64     : 2859.7  102.7     28.0      48   58.3%
   9 Protector 1.5.0 JA x64          : 2849.4   98.8     27.0      47   57.4%
  10 Hiarcs 14 WCSC w32              : 2846.5   95.6     27.0      51   52.9%
  11 Texel 1.03 x64                  : 2834.1  101.1     28.0      51   54.9%
  12 Shredder 12 x64                 : 2800.0   ----     23.5      48   49.0%
  13 Spike 1.4 Leiden w32            : 2784.3  110.8     19.0      43   44.2%
  14 Zappa Mexico II x64             : 2771.5   98.5     24.0      52   46.2%
  15 Nirvanachess 1.6 x64            : 2767.1   93.6     19.5      50   39.0%
  16 Quazar 0.4 x64                  : 2755.7  122.6     11.0      28   39.3%
  17 Vajolet2 1.28 POP x64           : 2753.1  113.3     17.0      43   39.5%
  18 Senpai 1.0 SSE42 x64            : 2736.7  101.3     15.0      37   40.5%
  19 SmarThink 1.50 SSE3 x64         : 2724.8  108.3     18.0      48   37.5%
  20 Gaviota 1.0 AVX x64             : 2716.1   93.9     17.5      54   32.4%
  21 Deuterium 14.2.33.276 x64       : 2687.0   96.9     18.5      62   29.8%
  22 Crafty 24.0 SSE42 x64           : 2651.8  114.6     12.5      46   27.2%

FCT1: Basic Tourney, final results ...

Re: FCT1: Vajolet2, Gaviota, Spark ... good examples!

Re: FCT1: Crafty 24.0 SSE42 x64 ... final = 2652 Elo

Re: FCT1: Deuterium 14.2.33.276 x64 still running!

Re: FCT1: Deuterium 14.2.33.276 x64 still running!

Re: FCT1: Deuterium 14.2.33.276 x64 still running!

Re: FCT1: Vajolet2, Gaviota, Spark ... good examples!

Re: FCT1: The Philippine Cobra ...

Re: FCT1: Vajolet2, Gaviota, Spark ... good examples!

Re: FCT1: Deuterium 14.2.33.276 ... final = 2.731 Elo

Re: FCT1: Vajolet2, Gaviota, Spark ... good examples!