Thanks, Louis. I understand, now. And I absolutely agree with Joerg.zullil wrote:I think Joerg was quite clear about what happened. You can look here to see the work that Joerg has done on Zander. One can assume that the various "extensions" were added by Marco Zerbinati.Rodolfo Leoni wrote: Both you and Marco Zerbinati should clear what's happening. Everything is quite confusing.
Stockfish version with hash saving capability
Moderators: hgm, Rebel, chrisw
-
- Posts: 545
- Joined: Tue Jun 06, 2017 4:49 pm
- Location: Italy
Re: Stockfish version with hash saving capability
F.S.I. Chess Teacher
-
- Posts: 545
- Joined: Tue Jun 06, 2017 4:49 pm
- Location: Italy
Re: Stockfish version with hash saving capability
As it's clear that "Zander version" was unauthorized, it's my opinion moderators should delete the post, until Joerg and Marco come to an agreement (if possible). As for the current situation, I think that release, under "Zander" name and with Joerg mentioned as author, should be considered illegal.
It's not easy for me, as I consider the PH and savehash features a step forward to a better user friendly engine, but
a) it's matter of respect
b) it's matter of rules.
In case an agreement couldn't be reached, I'd suggest Marco Zerbinati to start his new branch.
Only my two cents, anyway.
It's not easy for me, as I consider the PH and savehash features a step forward to a better user friendly engine, but
a) it's matter of respect
b) it's matter of rules.
In case an agreement couldn't be reached, I'd suggest Marco Zerbinati to start his new branch.
Only my two cents, anyway.
F.S.I. Chess Teacher
-
- Posts: 122
- Joined: Mon Aug 18, 2014 7:12 pm
- Location: Trento (Italy)
Re: Stockfish version with hash saving capability
Hi JoergJoerg Oster wrote:It seems there is some misunderstanding here.Rodolfo Leoni wrote:SF Zander maybe?Joerg Oster wrote: Huh? Where?
I'm not responsible for what other people do.
In fact, Marco Z. published SF Zander without dropping any message or asking if that's ok with me.
Which he must not do as far as I know, of course.
Nevertheless, I'm not very happy about it ...
What is the problem?
I just released a compilation with additional options
I do not think I've violated any rule
I think it's the case to ask permission for an open source code available to everyone
Already in the past your complained for no justified reason No one had taken credit for your job because you were rightly quoted as Author.
You should be happy .. I praised your work did not criticize it.
My original post:
Sf-Zander 080817
Branch Zander extended (Zander is Great work of by Jörg Oster)
Add:
- support "Polyglot Book management"
- support "Cerebellum Book Library"
- Large pages
- Save/Load Hash File "Daniel Jose Original Code"
-
- Posts: 545
- Joined: Tue Jun 06, 2017 4:49 pm
- Location: Italy
Re: Stockfish version with hash saving capability
I'm a third part here, then I could only add more confusion. I think you should suspend the release until both of you reach an agreement. Many appreciates your good will in doing things, but it's unfair to write "by Joerg Oster" when you made it.Zerbinati wrote:Hi JoergJoerg Oster wrote:It seems there is some misunderstanding here.Rodolfo Leoni wrote:SF Zander maybe?Joerg Oster wrote: Huh? Where?
I'm not responsible for what other people do.
In fact, Marco Z. published SF Zander without dropping any message or asking if that's ok with me.
Which he must not do as far as I know, of course.
Nevertheless, I'm not very happy about it ...
What is the problem?
I just released a compilation with additional options
I do not think I've violated any rule
I think it's the case to ask permission for an open source code available to everyone
Already in the past your complained for no justified reason No one had taken credit for your job because you were rightly quoted as Author.
You should be happy .. I praised your work did not criticize it.
My original post:
Sf-Zander 080817
Branch Zander extended (Zander is Great work of by Jörg Oster)
Add:
- support "Polyglot Book management"
- support "Cerebellum Book Library"
- Large pages
- Save/Load Hash File "Daniel Jose Original Code"
E dai Marcoo!
F.S.I. Chess Teacher
-
- Posts: 122
- Joined: Mon Aug 18, 2014 7:12 pm
- Location: Trento (Italy)
Re: Stockfish version with hash saving capability
Unfair?? "Write" by Joerg Oster "Rodolfo Leoni wrote:I'm a third part here, then I could only add more confusion. I think you should suspend the release until both of you reach an agreement. Many appreciates your good will in doing things, but it's unfair to write "by Joerg Oster" when you made it.Zerbinati wrote:Hi JoergJoerg Oster wrote:It seems there is some misunderstanding here.Rodolfo Leoni wrote:SF Zander maybe?Joerg Oster wrote: Huh? Where?
I'm not responsible for what other people do.
In fact, Marco Z. published SF Zander without dropping any message or asking if that's ok with me.
Which he must not do as far as I know, of course.
Nevertheless, I'm not very happy about it ...
What is the problem?
I just released a compilation with additional options
I do not think I've violated any rule
I think it's the case to ask permission for an open source code available to everyone
Already in the past your complained for no justified reason No one had taken credit for your job because you were rightly quoted as Author.
You should be happy .. I praised your work did not criticize it.
My original post:
Sf-Zander 080817
Branch Zander extended (Zander is Great work of by Jörg Oster)
Add:
- support "Polyglot Book management"
- support "Cerebellum Book Library"
- Large pages
- Save/Load Hash File "Daniel Jose Original Code"
E dai Marcoo!
Joerg Oster is author the Zander branch
I mentioned this for fairness and respect for him
Complaints would have to arise if I had failed to do so
No irregularities here..
https://github.com/Zerbinati/Zander-extended
-
- Posts: 545
- Joined: Tue Jun 06, 2017 4:49 pm
- Location: Italy
Re: Stockfish version with hash saving capability
I think it's a great work. Most of all, about Daniel's code addition and Cerebellum. But if Joerg doesn't agree it's not a Zander version by Joerg Oster. It'd be wise to clear the situation with him, privately. Hopefully, he'll agree with the upgrade. If not, let me repeat it's not Zander.Zerbinati wrote: Unfair?? "Write" by Joerg Oster "
Joerg Oster is author the Zander branch
I mentioned this for fairness and respect for him
Complaints would have to arise if I had failed to do so
No irregularities here..
https://github.com/Zerbinati/Zander-extended
F.S.I. Chess Teacher
-
- Posts: 122
- Joined: Mon Aug 18, 2014 7:12 pm
- Location: Trento (Italy)
Re: Stockfish version with hash saving capability
Zander version by Joerg Oster was quoted semplicemente as the source usedRodolfo Leoni wrote:I think it's a great work. Most of all, about Daniel's code addition and Cerebellum. But if Joerg doesn't agree it's not a Zander version by Joerg Oster. It'd be wise to clear the situation with him, privately. Hopefully, he'll agree with the upgrade. If not, let me repeat it's not Zander.Zerbinati wrote: Unfair?? "Write" by Joerg Oster "
Joerg Oster is author the Zander branch
I mentioned this for fairness and respect for him
Complaints would have to arise if I had failed to do so
No irregularities here..
https://github.com/Zerbinati/Zander-extended
as the starting point
-
- Posts: 545
- Joined: Tue Jun 06, 2017 4:49 pm
- Location: Italy
Re: Stockfish version with hash saving capability
OK. Then, it's MarcFish (or SuperFish, SpiderFish, or whatever you want), aZerbinati wrote:Zander version by Joerg Oster was quoted semplicemente as the source usedRodolfo Leoni wrote:I think it's a great work. Most of all, about Daniel's code addition and Cerebellum. But if Joerg doesn't agree it's not a Zander version by Joerg Oster. It'd be wise to clear the situation with him, privately. Hopefully, he'll agree with the upgrade. If not, let me repeat it's not Zander.Zerbinati wrote: Unfair?? "Write" by Joerg Oster "
Joerg Oster is author the Zander branch
I mentioned this for fairness and respect for him
Complaints would have to arise if I had failed to do so
No irregularities here..
https://github.com/Zerbinati/Zander-extended
as the starting point
SF Zander fork by Marco Zerbinati.
It seems a bit more precise.
F.S.I. Chess Teacher
-
- Posts: 122
- Joined: Mon Aug 18, 2014 7:12 pm
- Location: Trento (Italy)
Re: Stockfish version with hash saving capability
You are right RodolfoRodolfo Leoni wrote:OK. Then, it's MarcFish (or SuperFish, SpiderFish, or whatever you want), aZerbinati wrote:Zander version by Joerg Oster was quoted semplicemente as the source usedRodolfo Leoni wrote:I think it's a great work. Most of all, about Daniel's code addition and Cerebellum. But if Joerg doesn't agree it's not a Zander version by Joerg Oster. It'd be wise to clear the situation with him, privately. Hopefully, he'll agree with the upgrade. If not, let me repeat it's not Zander.Zerbinati wrote: Unfair?? "Write" by Joerg Oster "
Joerg Oster is author the Zander branch
I mentioned this for fairness and respect for him
Complaints would have to arise if I had failed to do so
No irregularities here..
https://github.com/Zerbinati/Zander-extended
as the starting point
SF Zander fork by Marco Zerbinati.
It seems a bit more precise.
However I decided to delete repository
-
- Posts: 545
- Joined: Tue Jun 06, 2017 4:49 pm
- Location: Italy
Re: Stockfish version with hash saving capability
I don't need to be right, Marco. I only wish both you and Joerg come to an agreement about:Zerbinati wrote: You are right Rodolfo
However I decided to delete repository
a) including your changes, or
b) making your own SF fork.
In both cases, what you're doing is greatly interesting.
F.S.I. Chess Teacher