Fringe- Special Engine and Book Tests

[Cengiz-Baba]

Rank Name Elo +/- Games Score Draw
1 Raid v3.3 DuaL+(hcanfree-24) 12 11 120 51.7% 96.7%
2 Raid v3.3 DuaL+(OPTİMUS) 6 11 120 50.8% 96.7%
3 Raid v3.3 DuaL+(etabeta) 6 16 120 50.8% 93.3%
4 Raid v3.3 DuaL+(selfish2) 0 18 120 50.0% 91.7%
5 Raid v3.3 DuaL+(book) -23 21 120 46.7% 88.3%

pgn: https://pixeldrain.com/u/BubcAaMc

[lucametehau]

What is this shit? SF clones battle?

[Jouni]

Hint: If You play equal engines 1000 games is minimum for one match. Better 10 000 or 60 000.

[Cengiz-Baba]

Time:1+1
Threads:1 CPU
Hash:64
Book: without book only engine

Code: Select all

Rank Name                           Elo     +/-   Games   Score    Draw 
   1 KillFish 130324_avx2            9      10     120   51.2%   97.5% 
   2 stockfish_24031109_x64          9      10     120   51.2%   97.5% 
   3 corchess_x64_avx2               9      10     120   51.2%   97.5% 
   4 StockfishMZ 20240222 avx2       6      11     120   50.8%   96.7% 
   5 SF-PB-120324_x64_AVX2           6      11     120   50.8%   96.7% 
   6 TacticaL Gear 2_avx2            0       0     120   50.0%  100.0% 
   7 Cool Iris 12.10-D3072_avx2    -38      20     120   44.6%   89.2% 

PGN: https://pixeldrain.com/u/Ga9MVqNq

[Cengiz-Baba]

First test:
Test book: Balsa270423
Time:1+1
Threads:1
Hash:64

Code: Select all

Rank Name                          Elo     +/-   Games   Score    Draw 
   1 Light 26.3                     14      11     180   51.9%   95.0% 
   2 SF-PB-220324                   10      10     180   51.4%   96.1% 
   3 JigSaw v5.1                    10       8     180   51.4%   97.2% 
   4 stockfish_24032617              6       8     180   50.8%   97.2% 
   5 Big-SF 220324                   6      11     180   50.8%   95.0% 
   6 HypnoS 240324                   4       9     180   50.6%   96.7% 
   7 INCOGNITO 8                     2       7     180   50.3%   98.3% 
   8 TacticaL Gear 3.1               0       9     180   50.0%   96.7% 
   9 corchess220324                 -2      11     180   49.7%   95.0% 
  10 dragon-3.3                    -49      19     180   43.1%   85.0%
  

1. pgn: https://pixeldrain.com/u/9pvmYAEM


Second test:
Test book: UHO2024
Time:1+1
Threads:1
Hash:64

Code: Select all

Rank Name                          Elo     +/-   Games   Score    Draw 
   1 Big-SF 220324                  35      38     180   55.0%   45.6% 
   2 SF-PB-220324                   29      35     180   54.2%   52.8% 
   3 HypnoS 240324                  21      37     180   53.1%   47.2% 
   4 Light 26.3                     15      36     180   52.2%   51.1% 
   5 TacticaL Gear 3.1              15      35     180   52.2%   52.2% 
   6 stockfish_24032617             14      35     180   51.9%   51.7% 
   7 corchess220324                 14      35     180   51.9%   51.7% 
   8 INCOGNITO 8                    -2      37     180   49.7%   47.2% 
   9 JigSaw v5.1                    -6      38     180   49.2%   45.0% 
  10 dragon-3.3                   -143      34     180   30.6%   52.2%
  

2. pgn: https://pixeldrain.com/u/cE441CCJ


Dear friends

Here are two tournaments with the same engine but different books. With the UHO opening book, we ensured fewer draws, while the Balsa opening book was evaluated by offering higher draws.

Conclusion:

I think we need more games to evaluate the results of the tournament where no parameters changed. As my dear friend Sedat said, we cannot see a similarity in the results.

Best regards,
Fringe.