With this one I'm for the first time able to show statistically relevant positive difference in using MCTS- mode, at least for a certain suite of positions with a certain setting and hardware- TC. With the suite of 256 positions, I already pasted now and then, at Talkchess latest here
, I had 2 more runs with 6 threads (5 concurrencies) of the 16x3,5GHz- CPU, MultiPV=4, 30"/pos., compared MCTS true with 1 thread out of the 6 to MCTS false:
Code: Select all
ShashChess 39 6t-1MCTS-MuPV4 ShashChess 39 6t-MuPV4
HTC114,1 00:00:00 HTC114,1 00:00:00
HTC114,2 00:00:00 HTC114,2 00:00:00
HTC114,3 00:00:06 HTC114,3 00:00:01
HTC114,4 00:00:30 HTC114,4 00:00:30
HTC114,5 00:00:04 HTC114,5 00:00:20
HTC114,6 00:00:00 HTC114,6 00:00:00
HTC114,7 00:00:01 HTC114,7 00:00:03
HTC114,8 00:00:03 HTC114,8 00:00:01
HTC114,9 00:00:00 HTC114,9 00:00:24
HTC114,1 00:00:00 HTC114,1 00:00:00
HTC114,1 00:00:07 HTC114,1 00:00:16
HTC114,1 00:00:30 HTC114,1 00:00:30
HTC114,1 00:00:30 HTC114,1 00:00:30
HTC114,1 00:00:03 HTC114,1 00:00:03
HTC114,1 00:00:28 HTC114,1 00:00:25
HTC114,1 00:00:00 HTC114,1 00:00:00
HTC114,1 00:00:00 HTC114,1 00:00:00
HTC114,1 00:00:04 HTC114,1 00:00:03
HTC114,1 00:00:30 HTC114,1 00:00:30
HTC114,2 00:00:00 HTC114,2 00:00:00
HTC114,2 00:00:27 HTC114,2 00:00:14
HTC114,2 00:00:03 HTC114,2 00:00:04
HTC114,2 00:00:01 HTC114,2 00:00:03
HTC114,2 00:00:00 HTC114,2 00:00:00
HTC114,2 00:00:00 HTC114,2 00:00:00
HTC114,2 00:00:03 HTC114,2 00:00:01
HTC114,2 00:00:01 HTC114,2 00:00:30
HTC114,2 00:00:02 HTC114,2 00:00:07
HTC114,2 00:00:30 HTC114,2 00:00:30
HTC114,3 00:00:26 HTC114,3 00:00:30
HTC114,3 00:00:00 HTC114,3 00:00:01
HTC114,3 00:00:00 HTC114,3 00:00:00
HTC114,3 00:00:00 HTC114,3 00:00:01
HTC114,3 00:00:00 HTC114,3 00:00:00
HTC114,3 00:00:01 HTC114,3 00:00:00
HTC114,3 00:00:00 HTC114,3 00:00:00
HTC114,3 00:00:30 HTC114,3 00:00:30
HTC114,3 00:00:30 HTC114,3 00:00:30
HTC114,3 00:00:09 HTC114,3 00:00:10
HTC114,4 00:00:00 HTC114,4 00:00:00
HTC114,4 00:00:30 HTC114,4 00:00:30
HTC114,4 00:00:01 HTC114,4 00:00:01
HTC114,4 00:00:03 HTC114,4 00:00:02
HTC114,4 00:00:26 HTC114,4 00:00:09
HTC114,4 00:00:30 HTC114,4 00:00:30
HTC114,4 00:00:00 HTC114,4 00:00:00
HTC114,4 00:00:00 HTC114,4 00:00:12
HTC114,4 00:00:30 HTC114,4 00:00:30
HTC114,4 00:00:30 HTC114,4 00:00:30
HTC114,5 00:00:30 HTC114,5 00:00:30
HTC114,5 00:00:30 HTC114,5 00:00:30
HTC114,5 00:00:01 HTC114,5 00:00:00
HTC114,5 00:00:00 HTC114,5 00:00:00
HTC114,5 00:00:00 HTC114,5 00:00:00
HTC114,5 00:00:00 HTC114,5 00:00:00
HTC114,5 00:00:00 HTC114,5 00:00:00
HTC114,5 00:00:30 HTC114,5 00:00:30
HTC114,5 00:00:00 HTC114,5 00:00:00
HTC114,5 00:00:30 HTC114,5 00:00:30
HTC114,6 00:00:30 HTC114,6 00:00:30
HTC114,6 00:00:30 HTC114,6 00:00:30
HTC114,6 00:00:00 HTC114,6 00:00:00
HTC114,6 00:00:27 HTC114,6 00:00:30
HTC114,6 00:00:30 HTC114,6 00:00:30
HTC114,6 00:00:28 HTC114,6 00:00:30
HTC114,6 00:00:01 HTC114,6 00:00:00
HTC114,6 00:00:01 HTC114,6 00:00:05
HTC114,6 00:00:00 HTC114,6 00:00:02
HTC114,6 00:00:30 HTC114,6 00:00:30
HTC114,7 00:00:08 HTC114,7 00:00:10
HTC114,7 00:00:30 HTC114,7 00:00:30
HTC114,7 00:00:11 HTC114,7 00:00:19
HTC114,7 00:00:30 HTC114,7 00:00:30
HTC114,7 00:00:02 HTC114,7 00:00:02
HTC114,7 00:00:30 HTC114,7 00:00:25
HTC114,7 00:00:30 HTC114,7 00:00:30
HTC114,7 00:00:00 HTC114,7 00:00:00
HTC114,7 00:00:00 HTC114,7 00:00:00
HTC114,7 00:00:00 HTC114,7 00:00:00
HTC114,8 00:00:01 HTC114,8 00:00:01
HTC114,8 00:00:00 HTC114,8 00:00:00
HTC114,8 00:00:17 HTC114,8 00:00:30
HTC114,8 00:00:00 HTC114,8 00:00:00
HTC114,8 00:00:00 HTC114,8 00:00:00
HTC114,8 00:00:10 HTC114,8 00:00:03
HTC114,8 00:00:00 HTC114,8 00:00:00
HTC114,8 00:00:00 HTC114,8 00:00:11
HTC114,8 00:00:02 HTC114,8 00:00:09
HTC114,8 00:00:00 HTC114,8 00:00:02
HTC114,9 00:00:00 HTC114,9 00:00:00
HTC114,9 00:00:00 HTC114,9 00:00:00
HTC114,9 00:00:00 HTC114,9 00:00:00
HTC114,9 00:00:00 HTC114,9 00:00:01
HTC114,9 00:00:30 HTC114,9 00:00:30
HTC114,9 00:00:06 HTC114,9 00:00:06
HTC114,9 00:00:00 HTC114,9 00:00:00
HTC114,9 00:00:00 HTC114,9 00:00:00
HTC114,9 00:00:00 HTC114,9 00:00:01
HTC114,9 00:00:02 HTC114,9 00:00:01
HTC114,1 00:00:30 HTC114,1 00:00:30
HTC114,1 00:00:30 HTC114,1 00:00:30
HTC114,1 00:00:00 HTC114,1 00:00:00
HTC114,1 00:00:26 HTC114,1 00:00:19
HTC114,1 00:00:00 HTC114,1 00:00:00
HTC114,1 00:00:00 HTC114,1 00:00:00
HTC114,1 00:00:00 HTC114,1 00:00:00
HTC114,1 00:00:00 HTC114,1 00:00:00
HTC114,1 00:00:00 HTC114,1 00:00:01
ENET-2025 002 00:00:06 ENET-2025 002 00:00:11
ENET-2025 015 00:00:00 ENET-2025 015 00:00:00
ENET-2025 021 00:00:00 ENET-2025 021 00:00:00
ENET-2025 022 00:00:02 ENET-2025 022 00:00:02
ENET-2025 037 00:00:00 ENET-2025 037 00:00:00
ENET-2025 043 00:00:06 ENET-2025 043 00:00:00
ENET-2025 045_AlphaZero vs St,4 00:00:00 ENET-2025 045_AlphaZero vs St,4 00:00:01
ENET-2025 046_Ollinegame best,4 00:00:10 ENET-2025 046_Ollinegame best,4 00:00:11
ENET-2025 047_Mittelspiel_Re4,4 00:00:03 ENET-2025 047_Mittelspiel_Re4,4 00:00:04
ENET-2025 048_Onlinegame Stoc,4 00:00:00 ENET-2025 048_Onlinegame Stoc,4 00:00:00
ENET-2025 049_Onlinegame Best,4 00:00:30 ENET-2025 049_Onlinegame Best,4 00:00:30
ENET-2025 050_Onlinegame_Bxf5 00:00:00 ENET-2025 050_Onlinegame_Bxf5 00:00:00
ENET-2025 051_Lc0 vs Stockfis,O 00:00:10 ENET-2025 051_Lc0 vs Stockfis,O 00:00:03
ENET-2025 052_Onlinegame Best,5 00:00:06 ENET-2025 052_Onlinegame Best,5 00:00:30
ENET-2025 053_Onlinegame_g4!,5 00:00:02 ENET-2025 053_Onlinegame_g4!,5 00:00:03
ENET-2025 054_Online Engine g,5 00:00:27 ENET-2025 054_Online Engine g,5 00:00:20
ENET-2025 055_Online engine g,5 00:00:00 ENET-2025 055_Online engine g,5 00:00:01
ENET-2025 056_Dorsz,S 00:00:00 ENET-2025 056_Dorsz,S 00:00:00
ENET-2025 057_Taktik,V 00:00:01 ENET-2025 057_Taktik,V 00:00:02
ENET-2025 059_Turmopfer_Rxf3!,5 00:00:30 ENET-2025 059_Turmopfer_Rxf3!,5 00:00:30
ENET-2025 061_Königsangriff_h,6 00:00:14 ENET-2025 061_Königsangriff_h,6 00:00:29
ENET-2025 068_Mittelspiel_Re8,6 00:00:21 ENET-2025 068_Mittelspiel_Re8,6 00:00:15
ENET-2025 069_Damenausfall_Qh,6 00:00:13 ENET-2025 069_Damenausfall_Qh,6 00:00:30
ENET-2025 070_Königsangriff_Q,7 00:00:00 ENET-2025 070_Königsangriff_Q,7 00:00:00
ENET-2025 071_Angriff_Ra3!,7 00:00:30 ENET-2025 071_Angriff_Ra3!,7 00:00:12
ENET-2025 072_Spieloeffnung_h,7 00:00:00 ENET-2025 072_Spieloeffnung_h,7 00:00:00
ENET-2025 073_Mittelspiel Ent,7 00:00:00 ENET-2025 073_Mittelspiel Ent,7 00:00:03
ENET-2025 074_Mittellspiel_Rf,7 00:00:05 ENET-2025 074_Mittellspiel_Rf,7 00:00:07
ENET-2025 075_Bestmove_Rad1! ,7 00:00:01 ENET-2025 075_Bestmove_Rad1! ,7 00:00:03
ENET-2025 076_Stockfish vs Ko,B 00:00:24 ENET-2025 076_Stockfish vs Ko,B 00:00:05
ENET-2025 077_Entlastung_Nd5,7 00:00:30 ENET-2025 077_Entlastung_Nd5,7 00:00:30
ENET-2025 078_Blockade_b4! On,7 00:00:30 ENET-2025 078_Blockade_b4! On,7 00:00:30
ENET-2025 079_Beste Verteidig,7 00:00:30 ENET-2025 079_Beste Verteidig,7 00:00:30
ENET-2025 080_Mittelspiel_Bb4,8 00:00:21 ENET-2025 080_Mittelspiel_Bb4,8 00:00:10
ENET-2025 081_Taktik_Nxd5! On,8 00:00:08 ENET-2025 081_Taktik_Nxd5! On,8 00:00:06
ENET-2025 082_Mittelspiel_Ba7,8 00:00:22 ENET-2025 082_Mittelspiel_Ba7,8 00:00:27
ENET-2025 083_b4? 00:00:30 ENET-2025 083_b4? 00:00:30
M. Garcia - P. Krug,S 00:00:05 M. Garcia - P. Krug,S 00:00:16
Zepler,E 00:00:30 Zepler,E 00:00:30
Formela,M 00:00:11 Formela,M 00:00:23
Stoofvlees_SF_TCEC 2019,2 00:00:00 Stoofvlees_SF_TCEC 2019,2 00:00:00
Lasker,E 00:00:10 Lasker,E 00:00:09
Los,A 00:00:05 Los,A 00:00:04
PurePower_Exxon_Chessbase onl,2 00:00:01 PurePower_Exxon_Chessbase onl,2 00:00:02
Bauer,R 00:00:00 Bauer,R 00:00:00
Mihai Neghina_Desperation_Whi,3 00:00:00 Mihai Neghina_Desperation_Whi,3 00:00:01
Tauber,H 00:00:30 Tauber,H 00:00:18
Bondarenko+Gorgiev,S 00:00:30 Bondarenko+Gorgiev,S 00:00:30
ACT3,? 00:00:25 ACT3,? 00:00:30
ACT3,? 00:00:30 ACT3,? 00:00:30
ACT3,? 00:00:30 ACT3,? 00:00:30
ACT3,? 00:00:00 ACT3,? 00:00:00
ACT3,? 00:00:30 ACT3,? 00:00:30
ACT3,? 00:00:30 ACT3,? 00:00:30
ACT3,? 00:00:18 ACT3,? 00:00:30
Neghina,M 00:00:25 Neghina,M 00:00:26
Matous,D 00:00:30 Matous,D 00:00:30
Neghina,M 00:00:30 Neghina,M 00:00:16
Sikorsky,H 00:00:30 Sikorsky,H 00:00:30
Krug,P 00:00:30 Krug,P 00:00:30
TCEC,S 00:00:15 TCEC,S 00:00:30
TCEC,S 00:00:30 TCEC,S 00:00:30
Sikorsky,H 00:00:03 Sikorsky,H 00:00:05
Zemljanski,Y 00:00:03 Zemljanski,Y 00:00:02
Study,? 00:00:00 Study,? 00:00:00
Study?,? 00:00:04 Study?,? 00:00:30
Study?,? 00:00:30 Study?,? 00:00:30
Semenikov+,D 00:00:30 Semenikov+,D 00:00:06
Petrov,M 00:00:19 Petrov,M 00:00:13
Study,? 00:00:30 Study,? 00:00:30
Study,? 00:00:29 Study,? 00:00:30
ERET 015_Endspiel D&B vs T&L&,5 00:00:01 ERET 015_Endspiel D&B vs T&L&,5 00:00:03
ERET 032_Zugzwang_Fahrni 1922,5 00:00:30 ERET 032_Zugzwang_Fahrni 1922,5 00:00:30
ERET 037_Zugzwang_Garcia 2000,6 00:00:00 ERET 037_Zugzwang_Garcia 2000,6 00:00:00
ERET 050_Koenigsangriff_Hanse,B 00:00:04 ERET 050_Koenigsangriff_Hanse,B 00:00:10
ERET 093_Endspiel T&S&B vs T&,6 00:00:30 ERET 093_Endspiel T&S&B vs T&,6 00:00:30
Fortress,S 00:00:30 Fortress,S 00:00:30
ACT4,N 00:00:08 ACT4,N 00:00:03
Cyclic,Z 00:00:30 Cyclic,Z 00:00:30
Blass,U 00:00:00 Blass,U 00:00:00
Campioli,M 00:00:00 Campioli,M 00:00:00
Krug,P 00:00:00 Krug,P 00:00:00
KrugP,G 00:00:16 KrugP,G 00:00:12
Kos,V 00:00:30 Kos,V 00:00:30
Sokka,H 00:00:00 Sokka,H 00:00:00
Sehwers,J 00:00:00 Sehwers,J 00:00:01
Zinar,M 00:00:30 Zinar,M 00:00:30
Nestorescu,V 00:00:01 Nestorescu,V 00:00:06
Timman,J 00:00:30 Timman,J 00:00:30
Unknown,A 00:00:00 Unknown,A 00:00:00
Ivanov,V 00:00:00 Ivanov,V 00:00:00
Bernhardt,G 00:00:07 Bernhardt,G 00:00:11
Unknows,A 00:00:07 Unknows,A 00:00:05
Naef,W 00:00:01 Naef,W 00:00:01
#7,? 00:00:30 #7,? 00:00:20
#9,? 00:00:30 #9,? 00:00:30
SilhanJ,Z 00:00:00 SilhanJ,Z 00:00:01
Hiarcs,? 00:00:00 Hiarcs,? 00:00:00
Hiarcs,? 00:00:01 Hiarcs,? 00:00:03
Derived,f 00:00:22 Derived,f 00:00:06
Midgame,? 00:00:02 Midgame,? 00:00:02
TTT2.053_?_TTT2,9 00:00:30 TTT2.053_?_TTT2,9 00:00:30
TTT2.073_?_TTT2,9 00:00:10 TTT2.073_?_TTT2,9 00:00:06
RoxlauM,G 00:00:30 RoxlauM,G 00:00:30
Smyslov,V 00:00:30 Smyslov,V 00:00:30
Smyslov,V 00:00:30 Smyslov,V 00:00:30
JostenG_?_?,9 00:00:00 JostenG_?_?,9 00:00:00
Study,? 00:00:30 Study,? 00:00:30
Wotawa,A 00:00:30 Wotawa,A 00:00:30
Study,? 00:00:03 Study,? 00:00:06
Bethge,F 00:00:02 Bethge,F 00:00:05
Blathy,O 00:00:30 Blathy,O 00:00:30
Cortlever,N 00:00:30 Cortlever,N 00:00:30
Korolkov,V 00:00:30 Korolkov,V 00:00:30
Fortress,? 00:00:30 Fortress,? 00:00:30
Unknown,A 00:00:30 Unknown,A 00:00:30
Kraemer,A 00:00:30 Kraemer,A 00:00:30
Sivkov,N 00:00:30 Sivkov,N 00:00:30
Timman=J_Glarean,N 00:00:03 Timman=J_Glarean,N 00:00:04
Boudy Bueno,J 00:00:18 Boudy Bueno,J 00:00:24
Lc0-dev_Stockfish_ECO MegaMat 00:00:01 Lc0-dev_Stockfish_ECO MegaMat 00:00:01
Bazlo,Y 00:00:30 Bazlo,Y 00:00:30
TCEC,r 00:00:00 TCEC,r 00:00:00
TCEC,r 00:00:30 TCEC,r 00:00:30
Gleichmann,M 00:00:30 Gleichmann,M 00:00:30
Yarmonov,I 00:00:30 Yarmonov,I 00:00:30
Eman_SugaR_Glarean,1 00:00:01 Eman_SugaR_Glarean,1 00:00:30
Hobacle's,V 00:00:30 Hobacle's,V 00:00:30
Krug,P 00:00:30 Krug,P 00:00:30
Gniazdowski,M 00:00:26 Gniazdowski,M 00:00:08
Illescas,M 00:00:30 Illescas,M 00:00:30
Heinz,J 00:00:21 Heinz,J 00:00:30
Josten,G 00:00:30 Josten,G 00:00:30
Timman,J 00:00:24 Timman,J 00:00:13
Gelly,M 00:00:11 Gelly,M 00:00:24
Krug,P 00:00:30 Krug,P 00:00:30
Popov,G 00:00:07 Popov,G 00:00:05
Hiarcs_Buch_512,1 00:00:30 Hiarcs_Buch_512,1 00:00:30
AM,H 00:00:04 AM,H 00:00:02
Source?_#13_mulitple,1 00:00:30 Source?_#13_mulitple,1 00:00:30
Neghina,N 00:00:08 Neghina,N 00:00:30
Svidler,P 00:00:00 Svidler,P 00:00:00
Source?_?_?,1 00:00:21 Source?_?_?,1 00:00:30
Efremov,A 00:00:05 Efremov,A 00:00:09
Hard,P 00:00:01 Hard,P 00:00:06
Source?_Corbit,D 00:00:01 Source?_Corbit,D 00:00:00
Timman,J 00:00:30 Timman,J 00:00:30
Zinar,M 00:00:30 Zinar,M 00:00:30
Total time : 00:58:00 Total time : 01:00:54
Total solved: 176 Total solved: 165
These two runs differ in 11/256 solutions (end of table), considering the time -indices too,
that makes a difference of 14 ElotStatTS (Frank Schubert)- Elo at an error bar of 3, regards