Tony's first rating list (2007)

Tony Thomas · Post by **Tony Thomas** » Sat Dec 01, 2007 8:54 am

I dont know how to weed out the weaker version of the same engine, so I did the ranking and weeding manually. So I expect the list to have errors, please point them out to me. If anyone know of an easy way to weed out the list for double entries (two versions of the same engine) please let me know. The directions that Igor gave are way too complicated for me to understand unless it comes with step by step directions. These are the versions that are strongest at my settings, there is a list of about 40 engines that are still in the que, since I have a CPU over heating problem, I wont be able to test them until I buy a new computer.

Code: Select all

    Program                          Elo    +   -   Games   Score   Av.Op.  Draws

  1 HiarcsX50UCI                   : 2883   48  47   201    72.4 %   2716   17.4 %
  2 Shredder11UCI                  : 2877   54  53   144    71.2 %   2720   22.9 %
  3 Rybka v1.0 Beta.w32            : 2860   44  43   214    69.6 %   2715   23.4 %
  4 Fruit 2.3                      : 2859   50  49   160    69.4 %   2717   25.0 %
  5 TogaII 1.2 beta 2a KS/EHP      : 2855   43  42   210    69.0 %   2716   26.7 %
  6 Ktulu 8.0                      : 2802   44  43   208    61.8 %   2719   19.7 %
  7 ChessTiger2007UCI              : 2797   41  40   360    86.9 %   2468   18.9 %
  8 Naum 2.2                       : 2787   46  46   160    59.7 %   2719   29.4 
  9 AlaricWB707                    : 2756   52  52   132    54.9 %   2722   25.0 %
 10 Spike 1.2 Turin                : 2755   41  41   209    55.3 %   2718   24.4 %
 11 Smarthink 1.00                 : 2740   41  41   208    52.9 %   2720   26.0 %
 12 Glaurung 2 Epsilon/4           : 2740   58  58   108    53.7 %   2714   24.1 %
 13 Delfi 5.2                      : 2719   51  51   152    49.3 %   2723   17.1 %
 14 DeepSjeng27                    : 2713   47  47   156    49.0 %   2719   26.3 %
 15 Scorpio 2.0                    : 2712   55  55   132    48.5 %   2723   15.2 %
 16 Gandalf 6.01                   : 2710   43  43   200    48.8 %   2718   22.5 %
 17 List 5.12                      : 2709   53  53   118    49.2 %   2715   28.8 %
 18 Zappa_mexico fix               : 2692   55  55   128    45.3 %   2724   18.8 %
 19 Pharaon 3.5.1                  : 2689   41  41   208    45.4 %   2721   24.5 %
 20 WildCat 7.0                    : 2675   45  45   200    43.8 %   2719   14.5 %
 21 Prodeo 1.2                     : 2674   41  41   200    43.5 %   2719   28.0 %
 22 Ruffian 1.0.5                  : 2674   45  45   200    43.5 %   2719   15.0 %
 23 CM10th D2Alos                  : 2670   42  42   200    43.0 %   2719   25.0 %
 24 SlowChess Blitz WV 2.1         : 2669   41  42   208    42.5 %   2721   24.5 %
 25 Thinker 4.7a                   : 2658   43  43   199    41.2 %   2720   24.1 %
 26 Crafty 21.6 JA                 : 2655   37  37   264    51.7 %   2643   20.8 %
 27 Frenzee  2.0                   : 2631   53  52   176    74.1 %   2448   16.5 %
 28 Movei00_8_438                  : 2629   49  50   152    36.5 %   2725   24.3 %
 29 Booot 4.13.0                   : 2625   50  50   144    59.0 %   2562   25.0 %
 30 Aristarch 4.50                 : 2625   44  45   199    36.7 %   2720   20.1 %
 31 Colossus2007d                  : 2622   52  51   136    58.5 %   2562   24.3 %
 32 BugChess2_V1_5_2               : 2614   31  31   395    52.7 %   2595   18.2 %
 33 SOS 5.1                        : 2601   44  45   199    33.4 %   2721   22.6 %
 34 Trace 1.37a                    : 2599   44  45   199    33.2 %   2721   22.1 %
 35 Chiron v0.8.1b10.3             : 2598   45  45   183    55.7 %   2558   21.9 %
 36 Pseudo07c                      : 2595   45  45   188    55.6 %   2556   20.7 %
 37 Jonny 2.83                     : 2593   47  48   181    32.3 %   2721   21.5 %
 38 AnMon 5.60                     : 2590   45  44   195    55.1 %   2554   17.9 %
 39 Pepit 1.59                     : 2585   43  43   195    54.4 %   2555   22.6 %
 40 E.T.Chess 18.10.05             : 2576   44  44   195    53.1 %   2555   19.0 %
 41 Hamsters 0.5                   : 2570   59  58   114    64.5 %   2467   21.9 %
 42 Baron 1.8.1                    : 2565   52  52   141    50.7 %   2560   19.1 %
 43 Zarkov 4.89                    : 2564   43  43   195    51.3 %   2555   22.6 %
 44 Ufim 8.02                      : 2564   43  43   195    51.3 %   2555   21.5 %
 45 Amyan 1.597                    : 2562   31  31   374    58.2 %   2505   25.4 %
 46 Tao 5.6 Blitz Specialist       : 2560   43  43   197    50.8 %   2554   21.3 %
 47 Alfil8.04SIMD                  : 2553   65  63   112    76.3 %   2350   22.3 %
 48 Sloppy-0.1.1 JA                : 2550   52  52   130    48.1 %   2564   25.4 %
 49 Yace.099.56                    : 2545   44  44   195    48.5 %   2555   21.0 %
 50 Green Light Chess 3.01.2.2     : 2536   42  42   199    47.5 %   2554   23.6 %
 51 Bright 0.1                     : 2527   34  33   391    67.9 %   2397   15.6 %
 52 Arasan 9.3                     : 2515   49  48   176    59.1 %   2451   13.6 %
 53 Petir 3.99d                    : 2514   41  41   201    44.3 %   2553   27.9 %
 54 KnightDreamer 3.2              : 2505   46  45   176    57.7 %   2451   23.3 %
 55 Francesca MAD 0.13             : 2505   20  20   985    57.7 %   2451   19.4 %
 56 RomiChessNG2                   : 2490   31  31   420    55.5 %   2452   16.2 %
 57 Nejmet_307                     : 2490   44  45   195    40.5 %   2557   19.5 %
 58 Twisted logic 20070915         : 2487   61  60   105    52.4 %   2470   19.0 %
 59 Comet_B68                      : 2481   44  44   199    39.4 %   2555   20.6 %
 60 Gromit_30                      : 2475   47  47   176    53.4 %   2452   17.0 %
 61 King Of Kings 2.56             : 2470   46  46   176    52.6 %   2452   21.0 %
 62 Typhoon 1.00 rev 281           : 2460   36  36   305    61.8 %   2376   18.0 %
 63 Gosu 0.16                      : 2459   48  48   170    50.6 %   2455   17.6 %
 64 Hermann 2.0                    : 2455   65  64   112    64.3 %   2353    8.9 %
 65 Quark 2.35                     : 2455   45  46   195    35.6 %   2557   20.0 %
 66 Leila_053h                     : 2454   44  44   173    50.0 %   2454   27.2 %
 67 Patzer 3.80                    : 2453   45  46   199    35.7 %   2556   18.1 %
 68 Danasah 2.85                   : 2446   19  19   951    51.5 %   2436   22.8 %
 69 Phalanx Reborn                 : 2436   20  20   956    47.8 %   2452   15.2 %
 70 The Crazy Bishop 0052          : 2435   45  45   176    47.4 %   2453   25.6 %
 71 Gaia 3.5                       : 2430   33  33   360    55.7 %   2390   18.1 %
 72 Abrok_5_0 wb                   : 2427   46  46   177    46.3 %   2453   21.5 %
 73 Arion 1.7                      : 2422   31  31   363    54.7 %   2389   26.2 %
 74 Bruja_19                       : 2416   33  33   364    53.8 %   2389   17.6 %
 75 Delphil 1.6c                   : 2411   19  19   974    47.2 %   2430   22.1 %
 76 Horizon_4_3_173                : 2400   26  26   600    43.2 %   2447   15.5 %
 77 Queen 3.09                     : 2397   42  42   209    45.9 %   2426   22.0 %
 78 Postmodernist 1016             : 2394   46  46   175    41.4 %   2454   22.3 %
 79 Ayito 0.2.994                  : 2386   38  38   306    63.4 %   2290   10.5 %
 80 Diablo_04_dc.ex                : 2380   42  42   220    58.2 %   2322   18.2 %
 81 Chezzz-1.0.3                   : 2378   48  49   175    39.1 %   2454   15.4 %
 82 Djinn 0.925x                   : 2377   20  20   947    46.0 %   2405   17.8 %
 83 Muse0899b                      : 2370   46  46   185    55.4 %   2332   16.8 %
 84 Matacz 1.0.2                   : 2367   42  43   202    40.6 %   2433   23.8 %
 85 Xpdnt_060829                   : 2366   45  45   186    54.8 %   2332   19.4 %
 86 Now 0.1w                       : 2364   55  55   135    55.9 %   2323   14.1 %
 87 Resp_0_1_9                     : 2363   39  39   245    54.9 %   2329   22.4 %
 88 Dragon 4.6                     : 2359   49  49   176    36.6 %   2454   15.3 %
 89 Snitch 1.6.2                   : 2357   50  51   173    36.1 %   2456   13.3 %
 90 NanoSzachy 2.7                 : 2357   24  24   720    38.1 %   2441   15.4 
 91 Zeus 1.28                      : 2347   22  22   799    40.9 %   2411   17.5 %
 92 Eeyore 1.48                    : 2340   46  46   185    51.1 %   2332   16.8 %
 93 Capture R01                    : 2338   46  46   185    51.4 %   2329   15.1 %
 94 AICE 0.99.2                    : 2333   45  45   188    50.3 %   2331   17.6 %
 95 Amateur282                     : 2322   45  46   194    34.5 %   2433   19.6 %
 96 Popochin 2.9                   : 2317   73  72    73    63.7 %   2219   23.3 %
 97 EXchess 5.01                   : 2301   45  45   185    45.4 %   2333   20.5 %
 98 Tytan 8.84                     : 2300   45  45   186    45.2 %   2333   19.4 %
 99 ThorsHammer 2.28               : 2299   46  46   185    45.1 %   2333   17.8 %
100 Aice 0.98                      : 2296   57  57   123    59.3 %   2230   17.9 %
101 GreKo 5.2                      : 2285   24  24   770    28.5 %   2445   16.8 %
102 Homer 2.0                      : 2278   80  78    70    58.6 %   2217   11.4 %
103 Latista 1.5                    : 2272   36  36   274    47.1 %   2293   23.4 %
104 Anechka 0.08                   : 2262   45  46   187    39.8 %   2334   19.8 %
105 Knightx192                     : 2262   47  48   185    39.7 %   2334   14.6 %
106 Scidlet 3.6                    : 2258   44  45   185    39.2 %   2334   24.3 %
107 CyberPagno                     : 2246   69  69    89    55.6 %   2207   12.4 %
108 Natwarlal                      : 2245   69  69    85    53.5 %   2221   15.3 %
109 Dorky                          : 2240   67  67    88    54.0 %   2212   17.0 %
110 Gnuchess4TM                    : 2239   56  55   122    51.2 %   2230   20.5 %
111 Uragano_3D 0.87                : 2223   67  67    88    51.7 %   2211   17.0 %
112 Sage 2.2a                      : 2220   64  64    89    51.7 %   2208   22.5 %
113 AliChess 4.06                  : 2206   60  59   118    60.2 %   2134   15.3 %
114 Adam 3.0                       : 2204   62  62   109    50.0 %   2204   11.9 %
115 Atlas220uci                    : 2198   62  62   108    49.1 %   2205   13.0 %
116 Neurosis 2.2                   : 2197   69  70    81    46.3 %   2223   18.5 %
117 Tornado 1.0 mainz              : 2192   48  49   186    30.4 %   2336   16.7 %
118 Wing 2.0a                      : 2184   66  66    89    45.5 %   2215   19.1 %
119 Fortress                       : 2179   68  69    85    44.1 %   2220   17.6 %
120 Lime 6.3                       : 2173   25  26   928    20.4 %   2410    9.6 %
121 Deuterium 06.06.23.04          : 2172   67  68    88    43.8 %   2215   17.0 %
122 Gaviota                        : 2166   66  67    89    43.8 %   2209   18.0 %
123 BlackBishop 0.9.7i             : 2164   67  68    88    42.6 %   2216   17.0 %
124 NagaSkaki 4.0 orig             : 2156   65  66    88    41.5 %   2216   21.6 %
125 Alarm0931                      : 2150   63  63   109    42.7 %   2201   10.1 %
126 Butcher 1.57                   : 2139   57  59   171    24.9 %   2331    7.6 %
127 Monarch 1.7                    : 2134   71  72    87    37.9 %   2220   11.5 %
128 Ant 2006F                      : 2110   51  52   206    22.8 %   2322   12.6 %
129 LittleThought-0.95             : 2080   69  71    89    32.0 %   2211   16.9 %
130 Buzz 0.05                      : 2071   79  82    77    28.6 %   2230   13.0 %
131 Woodpecker                     : 2060   86  90    68    27.2 %   2231   10.3 %
132 Eveann 1.60                    : 2059   83  79    81    79.0 %   1829   17.3 %
133 Bearded_06_29                  : 2058   90  85    85    78.2 %   1836    5.9 %
134 RDchess 3.23                   : 2052   95  89    78    78.8 %   1824    6.4 %
135 Alarm 0.93.1                   : 2025   92  87    70    75.0 %   1834   10.0 %
136 Matheus 2.3                    : 1995   77  74    86    71.5 %   1835   12.8 %
137 King' s Out 0.2.42             : 1974   81  78    81    69.1 %   1834    7.4 %
138 Bestia 0.90                    : 1969   74  72    84    67.3 %   1844   15.5 %
139 Matant 5.01                    : 1962   73  72    82    67.7 %   1833   18.3 %
140 Jan Willem 1.13                : 1945   78  76    78    66.7 %   1825   12.8 %
141 Prophet 2.0 Epsilon            : 1938   76  74    85    64.1 %   1837    8.2 %
142 Gullydeckel 2.15. pI10         : 1937   77  75    84    63.1 %   1844    4.8 %
143 Atak 4.99 Linka                : 1935   60  60   117    48.7 %   1944   12.0 %
144 BibiChess 0.5                  : 1932   74  73    83    63.9 %   1833   12.0 %
145 Clueless 1.3b                  : 1928   78  76    77    64.3 %   1826   11.7 %
146 BigLion 2.23w                  : 1924   71  69    94    64.4 %   1821    9.6 %
147 Laurifer 1.0                   : 1921   77  75    78    63.5 %   1825   11.5 %
148 BBChess 0.99b                  : 1920   75  74    82    62.2 %   1834    9.8 %
149 IACH 0.56E                     : 1919   72  71    84    61.9 %   1834   14.3 %
150 Ssechess 2.05DC                : 1918   77  76    78    62.8 %   1827   10.3 %
151 Alf 1.06                       : 1914   73  72    83    60.2 %   1842   12.0 %
152 Gerbil 02                      : 1912   74  72    80    62.5 %   1823   15.0 %
153 ChessAlex 1.4 r 3              : 1902   81  79    70    59.3 %   1837   10.0 %
154 FireFly 2.13                   : 1894   73  72    78    59.6 %   1827   16.7 %
155 Smash 1.03                     : 1891   69  68    83    57.8 %   1836   19.3 %
156 Gibbon 2.01b                   : 1889   75  74    73    56.2 %   1846   16.4 %
157 Feuerstein 0.4.5 beta 1        : 1872   74  73    73    55.5 %   1834   17.8 %
158 Warrior 1.0.3                  : 1869   76  76    71    55.6 %   1829   15.5 %
159 Mustang 3.0                    : 1863   75  75    70    55.0 %   1828   18.6 %
160 Marvin 1.3.0                   : 1848   73  73    79    53.2 %   1826   12.7 %
161 FreeChess 2.16e                : 1832   72  72    77    50.6 %   1827   15.6 %
162 Enigma 1.1.4                   : 1805   75  75    77    46.8 %   1828   10.4 %
163 Alex 1.78                      : 1805   70  71    86    45.3 %   1837   11.6 %
164 Rival 1.14                     : 1800   82  83    70    46.4 %   1824    1.4 %
165 Eagle 0.7.5                    : 1791   79  80    71    44.4 %   1830    7.0 %
166 Amundsen 0.55                  : 1769   74  75    78    41.7 %   1827   11.5 %
167 Adamant 1.7                    : 1764   76  77    77    40.9 %   1828    9.1 %
168 J.S.BAM 0.52                   : 1755   74  75    78    39.7 %   1827   12.8 %
169 Kanguruh 1.92                  : 1745   80  83    71    36.6 %   1841    8.5 %
170 Tscp 1.81                      : 1742   72  74    84    35.1 %   1849   13.1 %
171 AjedrezTactico_273b            : 1719   76  78    72    34.0 %   1834   18.1 %
172 Milady 2.1                     : 1686   79  83    77    30.5 %   1829    9.1 %
173 Damas7c                        : 1686   81  84    77    30.5 %   1829    6.5 %
174 Hoichess-0.7.0                 : 1681   78  81    79    29.7 %   1830   11.4 %
175 Elf 1.30                       : 1672   80  83    78    28.8 %   1828    9.0 %
176 Beaches 2.2                    : 1660   82  86    74    27.0 %   1833   10.8 %
177 Surprise 4.2.8                 : 1654   83  88    79    26.6 %   1831    5.1 %
178 Hokus-Pokus 0.6.3              : 1644   82  86    78    25.6 %   1829   10.3 %
179 Chess-Rikus 1.466              : 1639   81  85    80    25.0 %   1830   10.0 %
180 Roce 0.0350                    : 1638   77  79    78    25.0 %   1829   19.2 %
181 TJchess 0.49                   : 1637   84  89    75    24.0 %   1837   10.7 %
182 Roque 1.1                      : 1621   84  89    78    23.1 %   1830   10.3 %
183 Mizar 3.0                      : 1618   87  93    77    22.7 %   1830    6.5 %
184 Cilian 4.14se                  : 1617   78  82    82    22.0 %   1838   17.1 %
185 Eden 0.0.11                    : 1567   96 105    80    17.5 %   1836    2.5 %
186 Nero 6.1                       : 1510  100 108    80    13.8 %   1829    7.5 %
187 Dimitri 1.32 beta 4            : 1499  114 129    71    12.7 %   1834    2.8 %
188 MiniChessAI 1.19               : 1404  133 156    77     7.8 %   1833    2.6 %
189 Marquis 0.1.5                  : 1351  146 117    77     5.8 %   1834    3.9 %
190 Chad's Chess 0.15              : 1249  229   3    64     3.1 %   1845    0.0 %

Sedat Canbaz · Post by **Sedat Canbaz** » Sat Dec 01, 2007 9:50 am

Hello Tony,

Thanks for your efforts...

Can you inform me please about the conditions :
-Hardware
Time control
...

Best,
Sedat

Tony Thomas · Post by **Tony Thomas** » Sun Dec 02, 2007 7:07 am

Sedat, my time control is not compareable to yours. Same goes for the computer. I have a celeron 2800Mhz, and I play 1m+1sec games only. Own book, ponder off, learning on. If you would like to know anything else please let me know. Romi is currently ranked 56th.

Graham Banks · Post by **Graham Banks** » Sun Dec 02, 2007 8:29 am

Tony Thomas wrote:Sedat, my time control is not compareable to yours. Same goes for the computer. I have a celeron 2800Mhz, and I play 1m+1sec games only. Own book, ponder off, learning on. If you would like to know anything else please let me know. Romi is currently ranked 56th.

I wouldn't worry about hardware comparisons. The most important thing is that you enjoy the hobby.

Tony Thomas · Post by **Tony Thomas** » Sun Dec 02, 2007 8:39 am

Graham Banks wrote:
Tony Thomas wrote:Sedat, my time control is not compareable to yours. Same goes for the computer. I have a celeron 2800Mhz, and I play 1m+1sec games only. Own book, ponder off, learning on. If you would like to know anything else please let me know. Romi is currently ranked 56th.
I wouldn't worry about hardware comparisons. The most important thing is that you enjoy the hobby.

Thanks Graham, Chess is very addictive. I am thinking about getting a core 2 Duo, I am just not sure when.

Chris Tatham · Post by **Chris Tatham** » Sun Dec 02, 2007 10:37 pm

Impressive list Tony, and thanks for posting this - in producing this list do you run any specific tournaments?

Best wishes

Chris

... now just waiting for Wael's list!

Tony Thomas · Post by **Tony Thomas** » Mon Dec 03, 2007 7:07 am

I used games from 7 different tournaments to compile the rating list. I did not use some of the minor tournaments that I have run (about 10) with another 5000 games. I currently have only 6 active tournaments. They are 4th division 2007, 3rd division 2007, Xiaolin show down (2nd division), Fight for the light (1st div), and Manipulator Prince (premier division), and Romi's Sparring Partners (Romi plays fourteen 30 game matches against different opponents). I somehow lost the arena tournament file for 5th division bullet, so I can no longer add anymore engines to that tournament. If someone can give me help on recreating the AT file to add more games to the current .pgn, I will continue testing weak engines. Otherwise, I will start a new one once I buy a new computer, or after I fix the CPU overheating problem.

CRoberson · Post by **CRoberson** » Mon Dec 03, 2007 5:49 pm

Getting rid of duplicates could speed things up a little.

In a quick scan of the list, I see two copies of the same version
of Alarm. One labeled Alarn0931 and the other Alarm 0.93.1.
They are ranked at 125 and 135 respectively.

Tony Thomas · Post by **Tony Thomas** » Mon Dec 03, 2007 6:35 pm

CRoberson wrote:Getting rid of duplicates could speed things up a little.

In a quick scan of the list, I see two copies of the same version
of Alarm. One labeled Alarn0931 and the other Alarm 0.93.1.
They are ranked at 125 and 135 respectively.

Charles, what did you use to scan the list? I had asked the question twice, and the answers werent easy enough for me to understand. I guess I missed Alarm, I should have known, When I promoted it to the higher division I tried to use proper naming, so I had to change the engines name everytime I ran a tournament for those divisions. Since the entry at rank 125 has more games, it stays.

Matthias Gemuh · Post by **Matthias Gemuh** » Mon Dec 03, 2007 6:52 pm

Well done, Tony !
I always like such tournaments that include engines of all strengths.
Only the elo calculation program sucks quite a bit: the elo gradient is too steep, underrating weak engines.

Best,
Matthias.

Tony's first rating list (2007)

Tony's first rating list (2007)

Re: Tony's first rating list (2007)

Re: Tony's first rating list (2007)

Re: Tony's first rating list (2007)

Re: Tony's first rating list (2007)

Re: Tony's first rating list (2007)

Re: Tony's first rating list (2007)

Re: Tony's first rating list (2007)

Re: Tony's first rating list (2007)

Re: Tony's first rating list (2007)