Updated: "Dark Basement Ratings List" LOL

[Erik Roggenburg]

I haven't been testing much, but here's my updated list. I only have 180 games with Naum 3 2T, but I'll get to around 1,000 games.

Code: Select all

7 Naum 3 2T                 : 2770  180 (+ 52,= 80,- 48), 51.1 %

Deep Shredder 11 UCI 2T       :  60 (+ 21,= 19,- 20), 50.8 %
Zappa Mexico 2T               :  60 (+ 25,= 24,- 11), 61.7 %
Rybka 2.3.2a mp 32-bit 2T     :  60 (+  6,= 37,- 17), 40.8 %

Code: Select all

    Program                          Elo    +   -   Games   Score   Av.Op.  Draws

  1 Rybka 2.3.2a mp 32-bit 2T      : 2833   18  18   890    70.4 %   2683   38.8 %
  2 Rybka 2.3.1 mp 32-bit 2T       : 2819   13  13  2230    72.8 %   2648   29.8 %
  3 Rybka 2.3.2a 32-bit            : 2813   18  18   975    70.9 %   2658   37.9 %
  4 Rybka 2.2 mp 32-bit 2T         : 2811   15  15  1580    72.7 %   2642   30.4 %
  5 Rybka 2.3 LK mp 32-bit 2T      : 2806   18  18  1140    73.1 %   2633   28.8 %
  6 Rybka 2.3 mp 32-bit 2T         : 2806   18  18  1140    73.0 %   2633   30.4 %
  7 Naum 3 2T                      : 2770   38  38   180    51.1 %   2763   44.4 %
  8 Deep Shredder 11 UCI 2T        : 2732   16  16  1275    61.3 %   2653   30.3 %
  9 Fritz 11                       : 2728   16  16  1215    61.5 %   2647   37.4 %
 10 Zappa Mexico 2T                : 2724   15  15  1280    60.1 %   2653   36.7 %
 11 HIARCS 11.1 MP UCI 2T          : 2723   11  11  2355    60.0 %   2653   36.5 %
 12 Deep Fritz 10 2T               : 2720   11  11  2465    58.8 %   2658   31.2 %
 13 Loop 13.5.32 2T                : 2718   11  11  2270    60.1 %   2648   37.1 %
 14 LoopMP 12.32 2T                : 2699   13  13  1680    56.9 %   2650   36.5 %
 15 Naum 2.2 2T                    : 2698   16  16  1160    57.0 %   2649   39.7 %
 16 HIARCS 11 MP UCI 2T            : 2691   14  14  1480    58.1 %   2635   37.2 %
 17 Deep Shredder 10 UCI 2T        : 2668   12  12  2190    52.0 %   2655   30.7 %
 18 Naum 2.1 MP 2T                 : 2660   12  12  1980    49.8 %   2662   39.1 %
 19 HIARCS 11 UCI                  : 2652   14  14  1545    52.5 %   2635   35.7 %
 20 Fruit 2.3.1                    : 2648   16  16  1245    50.3 %   2646   35.2 %
 21 Toga II 1.3x4                  : 2638   17  17  1080    49.8 %   2640   36.4 %
 22 Toga II 1.2.1a                 : 2638   12  12  2185    47.5 %   2655   34.6 %
 23 Deep Junior 10.1 2T            : 2634   11  11  2465    46.3 %   2660   30.3 %
 24 Spike 1.2 Turin                : 2629   11  11  2335    45.9 %   2657   36.5 %
 25 Bright-0.2c 2T                 : 2626   25  25   500    47.5 %   2643   33.8 %
 26 Hiarcs X54 UCI                 : 2624   16  16  1140    51.2 %   2616   35.7 %
 27 Toga II 3.1.2SE                : 2623   35  35   250    46.2 %   2650   34.8 %
 28 Hiarcs X50 UCI                 : 2623   16  16  1140    51.0 %   2616   36.7 %
 29 Deep Sjeng 2.7 2T              : 2620   16  16  1165    45.2 %   2654   33.4 %
 30 Fritz 9                        : 2617   15  15  1465    48.4 %   2628   29.7 %
 31 Fruit 2.2.1                    : 2613   12  12  2160    43.7 %   2657   33.4 %
 32 Glaurung 2.0.1 2T              : 2609   16  16  1220    41.8 %   2666   36.1 %
 33 Shredder 7.04 2T               : 2604   25  25   525    45.5 %   2635   29.0 %
 34 Glaurung 1.2 SMP 2T            : 2581   12  12  2305    39.6 %   2655   29.1 %
 35 Fritz 8 Bilbao                 : 2569   25  25   560    38.8 %   2649   26.8 %
 36 Scorpio 2.0 2T                 : 2568   17  17  1105    38.0 %   2653   31.3 %
 37 Chess Tiger 2007.1 UCI         : 2559   12  12  2405    36.2 %   2657   33.1 %
 38 Alaric 707                     : 2553   24  24   575    35.5 %   2657   29.9 %
 39 Naum 2.0                       : 2544   16  16  1200    38.9 %   2622   36.2 %
 40 Scorpio 1.91 2T                : 2539   13  13  1920    32.1 %   2669   31.8 %
 41 Deep Pharaon 3.5.1 2T          : 2521   12  12  2355    31.7 %   2654   29.6 %
 42 Chess Tiger 15.0               : 2521   16  17  1165    35.9 %   2622   34.2 %
 43 Scorpio 1.8 2T                 : 2498   16  16  1380    31.1 %   2637   30.0 %
 44 Deep Frenzee 3.0 2T            : 2494   13  13  2345    28.3 %   2655   24.8 %

[Tony Thomas]

Cant you turn the light on?

[Erik Roggenburg]

I'm saving energy to make up for the electricity my dual PCs suck down.

[Erik Roggenburg]

Code: Select all

7 Naum 3 2T                 : 2770  240 (+ 77,= 99,- 64), 52.7 %

Deep Fritz 10 2T              :  60 (+ 25,= 19,- 16), 57.5 %
Deep Shredder 11 UCI 2T       :  60 (+ 21,= 19,- 20), 50.8 %
Zappa Mexico 2T               :  60 (+ 25,= 24,- 11), 61.7 %
Rybka 2.3.2a mp 32-bit 2T     :  60 (+  6,= 37,- 17), 40.8 %

So far, about 72 Elo stronger than Naum 2.2.

[Yarget]

Great to see Erik that you have started testing Naum 3. I know it's early days in your tests but I think the that the final difference between Naum 2.2 and the new version will be close to your current stand (72 ELO).

Regards
Per

[Erik Roggenburg]

Great to see Erik that you have started testing Naum 3. I know it's early days in your tests but I think the that the final difference between Naum 2.2 and the new version will be close to your current stand (72 ELO).

Regards
Per

I think you are right, Per. Naum has already played against some of the top engines on my PC, and I think he'll be hard pressed to pick up many more Elo against some of the weaker competition unless he absolutely rocks them.

[Erik Roggenburg]

75 Elo... more or less.

Code: Select all

7 Naum 3 2T                 : 2772  420 (+140,=180,-100), 54.8 %

Deep Fritz 10 2T              :  60 (+ 25,= 19,- 16), 57.5 %
HIARCS 11.1 MP UCI 2T         :  60 (+ 22,= 21,- 17), 54.2 %
Loop 13.5.32 2T               :  60 (+ 25,= 24,- 11), 61.7 %
Deep Shredder 11 UCI 2T       :  60 (+ 21,= 19,- 20), 50.8 %
Zappa Mexico 2T               :  60 (+ 25,= 24,- 11), 61.7 %
Fritz 11                      :  60 (+ 16,= 36,-  8), 56.7 %
Rybka 2.3.2a mp 32-bit 2T     :  60 (+  6,= 37,- 17), 40.8 %

Code: Select all

15 Naum 2.2 2T               : 2697  1160 (+431,=461,-268), 57.0 %

Glaurung 1.2 SMP 2T           :  60 (+ 33,= 17,- 10), 69.2 %
Spike 1.2 Turin               :  60 (+ 25,= 30,-  5), 66.7 %
Deep Shredder 10 UCI 2T       :  60 (+ 28,= 17,- 15), 60.8 %
Fruit 2.2.1                   :  60 (+ 21,= 24,- 15), 55.0 %
Toga II 1.2.1a                :  60 (+ 15,= 33,- 12), 52.5 %
Deep Fritz 10 2T              :  60 (+ 22,= 20,- 18), 53.3 %
Deep Pharaon 3.5.1 2T         :  60 (+ 36,= 21,-  3), 77.5 %
Deep Frenzee 3.0 2T           :  60 (+ 34,= 20,-  6), 73.3 %
Chess Tiger 2007.1 UCI        :  60 (+ 30,= 24,-  6), 70.0 %
Deep Junior 10.1 2T           :  60 (+ 25,= 23,- 12), 60.8 %
Naum 2.1 MP 2T                :  60 (+ 19,= 31,- 10), 57.5 %
Scorpio 1.91 2T               :  60 (+ 26,= 23,- 11), 62.5 %
HIARCS 11.1 MP UCI 2T         :  60 (+ 15,= 27,- 18), 47.5 %
Rybka 2.3.1 mp 32-bit 2T      :  60 (+  9,= 28,- 23), 38.3 %
Loop 13.5.32 2T               :  60 (+ 18,= 27,- 15), 52.5 %
Glaurung 2.0.1 2T             :  60 (+ 27,= 21,- 12), 62.5 %
Fritz 8 Bilbao                :  30 (+ 10,=  8,- 12), 46.7 %
Rybka 2.3.2a 32-bit           :  60 (+  9,= 24,- 27), 35.0 %
Rybka 2.3.2a mp 32-bit 2T     :  60 (+  7,= 23,- 30), 30.8 %
Alaric 707                    :  25 (+ 11,= 11,-  3), 66.0 %
Bright-0.2c 2T                :  25 (+ 11,=  9,-  5), 62.0 %

[Erik Roggenburg]

Code: Select all

7 Naum 3 2T                 : 2767  480 (+164,=207,-109), 55.7 %

Deep Fritz 10 2T              :  60 (+ 25,= 19,- 16), 57.5 %
HIARCS 11.1 MP UCI 2T         :  60 (+ 22,= 21,- 17), 54.2 %
Loop 13.5.32 2T               :  60 (+ 25,= 24,- 11), 61.7 %
Deep Shredder 11 UCI 2T       :  60 (+ 21,= 19,- 20), 50.8 %
Zappa Mexico 2T               :  60 (+ 25,= 24,- 11), 61.7 %
Fruit 2.3.1                   :  60 (+ 24,= 27,-  9), 62.5 %
Fritz 11                      :  60 (+ 16,= 36,-  8), 56.7 %
Rybka 2.3.2a mp 32-bit 2T     :  60 (+  6,= 37,- 17), 40.8 %

[Erik Roggenburg]

Code: Select all

7 Naum 3 2T                 : 2766  540 (+196,=227,-117), 57.3 %

Deep Fritz 10 2T              :  60 (+ 25,= 19,- 16), 57.5 %
HIARCS 11.1 MP UCI 2T         :  60 (+ 22,= 21,- 17), 54.2 %
Loop 13.5.32 2T               :  60 (+ 25,= 24,- 11), 61.7 %
Deep Shredder 11 UCI 2T       :  60 (+ 21,= 19,- 20), 50.8 %
Zappa Mexico 2T               :  60 (+ 25,= 24,- 11), 61.7 %
Fruit 2.3.1                   :  60 (+ 24,= 27,-  9), 62.5 %
Deep Sjeng 2.7 2T             :  60 (+ 32,= 20,-  8), 70.0 %
Fritz 11                      :  60 (+ 16,= 36,-  8), 56.7 %
Rybka 2.3.2a mp 32-bit 2T     :  60 (+  6,= 37,- 17), 40.8 %

[Tony Thomas]

You should test Thinker as well if you have time..