CCRL rating lists updated (11th June 2010)

[Graham Banks]

The latest CCRL Rating Lists and Statistics are available for viewing from the following links:
http://computerchess.org.uk/ccrl/4040.live/ (40/40)
http://www.computerchess.org.uk/ccrl/404.live/ (40/4)
http://www.computerchess.org.uk/ccrl/404FRC/ (FRC 40/4)

Please note that the three lists are updated separately to each other.
The links given in each update report will give you the currently up to date lists.

The links to the various rating lists can be found just beneath the default Best Versions list (as in this screenshot). Specific 32-bit rating lists are denoted as such to the right of the default list in each category. The default lists contain the 64-bit engines.



Our 40 moves in 40 minutes repeating and 40 moves in 4 minutes repeating are both adjusted to the AMD64 X2 4600+ (2.4GHz).

Currently active testers are Graham Banks, Ray Banks, Shaun Brewer, Adam Hair, Aser Huerga, Kirill Kryukov, Dom Leste, Denis Mendoza, Cody Rowland, Wassim Saeed, Joshua Shriver, Charles Smith, Gabor Szots and Martin Thoresen.

[Norm Pollock]

Hi Graham,

In doing my current work on a new utility tool, I came across some old CCRL games from 2008 that must have used a really buggy GUI, or whatever. I wonder if it is possible to know what was at fault for the insane book evaluations of +355.34.

-Norm

Code: Select all

[Event "CCRL 40/40"]
[Site "CCRL"]
[Date "2008.01.27"]
[Round "110.1.314"]
[White "Deuterium 06.08.25.04"]
[Black "Cheese 1.1b"]
[Result "1-0"]
[ECO "B46"]
[Opening "Sicilian"]
[Variation "Taimanov variation"]
[PlyCount "137"]
[WhiteElo "2332"]
[BlackElo "2403"]

1. e4 {+355.34/0 0s} c5 {+355.34/0 0s} 2. Nf3 {+355.34/0 0s} Nc6 {+355.34/0 0s}
3. d4 {+355.34/0 0s} cxd4 {+355.34/0 0s} 4. Nxd4 {+355.34/0 0s} e6 {+355.34/0
0s} 5. Nc3 {+355.34/0 0s} a6 {+355.34/0 0s} 6. Be2 {+355.34/0 0s} d6 {+355.34/0
0s} 7. Be3 {+355.34/0 0s} Nf6 {+355.34/0 0s} 8. O-O {+355.34/0 0s} Be7
{+355.34/0 0s} 9. f4 {+355.34/0 0s} O-O {+355.34/0 0s} 10. a4 {+355.34/0 0s}
Qc7 {+355.34/0 0s} 11. Kh1 {+355.34/0 0s} Re8 {+355.34/0 0s} 12. Bf3 {+355.34/0
0s} Rb8 {+355.34/0 0s} 13. Rc1 {+0.27/10 208s} Na5 {-0.16/14 83s} 14. Rb1
{(Bf2) +0.19/12 253s} Nc4 {(Bd7) -0.36/14 73s} 15. Bc1 {(Qd3) +0.19/12 74s} Rd8
{(Bd7) -0.28/12 119s} 16. Qe2 {(Ra1) +0.24/10 97s} Bd7 {(Na3) -0.22/13 97s} 17.
Qd3 {(Rd1) +0.13/10 76s} Rdc8 {-0.28/13 120s} 18. Rd1 {(b3) +0.20/11 95s} b5
{(Na5) -0.25/13 120s} 19. axb5 {+0.54/13 150s} axb5 {-0.14/14 81s} 20. b3
{+0.62/13 98s} Na5 {(Ne3) -0.07/14 121s} 21. Ncxb5 {(Ndxb5) +1.03/14 197s} Bxb5
{+0.48/15 90s} 22. Nxb5 {+0.98/10 2s} Qxc2 {+0.46/15 80s} 23. Nxd6 {+0.95/14
149s} Qxd3 {+0.44/14 125s} 24. Rxd3 {+0.94/10 2s} Bxd6 {+0.35/14 125s} 25. Rxd6
{+1.03/9 1s} h6 {(Nxb3) +0.45/14 117s} 26. Be3 {(e5) +0.92/14 358s} Nc4
{+0.57/15 126s} 27. Rd3 {+1.02/14 143s} Nxe3 {+0.46/16 113s} 28. Rxe3 {+1.04/9
1s} Rb5 {(Rc2) +0.43/15 127s} 29. Ra1 {(Rd3) +1.08/12 100s} e5 {(Rc2) +0.39/15
127s} 30. g3 {(fxe5) +1.20/12 101s} Rcb8 {(Rc2) +0.05/15 127s} 31. fxe5
{+1.24/13 102s} Rxe5 {+0.12/14 127s} 32. Kg2 {(Kg1) +1.29/11 103s} Nh7 {(Rc8)
+0.09/13 127s} 33. h4 {(Rd1) +1.54/11 105s} Nf6 {+0.12/14 127s} 34. Ra7
{+1.34/11 106s} Rc8 {(g5) +0.20/15 127s} 35. Ra4 {(Rd3) +1.39/11 114s} Rb8
{(Rc2+) +0.23/14 98s} 36. Rd3 {(Kh3) +1.56/11 115s} Ree8 {(g5) +0.28/14 100s}
37. g4 {(Rad4) +1.70/12 96s} Nh7 {(g5) +0.00/15 141s} 38. Rc4 {(Be2) +1.85/12
124s} Nf8 {(g5) +0.00/17 141s} 39. Kg3 {(h5) +1.58/13 128s} Re5 {(Ng6) +0.00/15
103s} 40. Bd1 {(Rdc3) +1.81/12 138s} Re7 {+0.00/14 89s} 41. Rdc3 {(Rd5)
+1.75/11 77s} Rd8 {+0.11/14 83s} 42. Be2 {(Bc2) +1.71/13 116s} Ree8 {(Ne6)
+0.15/14 83s} 43. b4 {(Ra4) +1.88/12 76s} Rb8 {(Nd7) +0.11/13 53s} 44. Rb3
{(Rf3) +1.89/12 115s} Rbd8 {(Ne6) +0.00/13 84s} 45. b5 {(Rbc3) +2.03/12 75s}
Ne6 {+0.48/13 61s} 46. Rd3 {(Bf3) +1.99/13 76s} Ra8 {(g5) +0.40/13 85s} 47. Rd5
{(b6) +2.05/11 76s} Ra1 {(Ra3+) +0.33/13 85s} 48. Rc6 {(b6) +2.05/11 76s} Ra3+
{+0.38/12 81s} 49. Bd3 {+2.06/13 76s} Rb8 {(Rd8) +0.43/13 85s} 50. Kf3 {(g5)
+2.07/12 76s} Rb3 {(Kf8) +0.49/12 85s} 51. Rc1 {(Ke3) +2.10/12 114s} Re8
{(R8xb5) +0.28/12 85s} 52. Ke3 {(Kg3) +2.11/12 75s} Rb8 {(g5) +0.52/13 85s} 53.
Rc2 {(Rc6) +2.07/12 113s} Nf8 {(g5) +0.58/13 85s} 54. Rc7 {(Rc6) +2.33/13 170s}
Ne6 {+0.50/13 85s} 55. Rcd7 {(Rc6) +2.26/12 106s} Ra3 {(Rc8) +0.53/12 85s} 56.
R7d6 {+2.22/12 139s} Rb3 {(Ra2) +0.46/13 66s} 57. Rc6 {(Rf5) +2.05/12 117s} g6
{(g5) +0.48/12 86s} 58. Rc2 {(Kd2) +2.22/11 97s} Ra8 {(Ra3) +0.47/12 86s} 59.
Rd7 {+2.28/11 64s} Nf8 {(Kg7) +0.85/13 85s} 60. Rd6 {+2.24/12 64s} Ne6
{+0.92/12 86s} 61. Kd2 {(h5) +2.33/11 64s} Nf4 {(Kg7) +1.06/12 59s} 62. Bc4
{+2.46/12 128s} Rg3 {(Rh3) +1.39/12 87s} 63. Rd7 {(b6) +2.90/11 91s} Rg2+
{(Rxg4) +2.19/12 69s} 64. Kc1 {+2.91/12 89s} Rxg4 {(Rg1+) +2.82/12 58s} 65. b6
{+4.17/12 67s} Kh8 {(Rb8) +3.22/11 90s} 66. b7 {+4.03/11 57s} Rb8 {+3.80/12
90s} 67. Rc7 {(Ba6) +4.47/11 58s} Rg1+ {+6.92/12 90s} 68. Kb2 {+6.46/14 145s}
Rxb7+ {+7.03/13 90s} 69. Rxb7 {+7.08/10 1s} 1-0

[Event "CCRL 40/40"]
[Site "CCRL"]
[Date "2008.01.28"]
[Round "110.1.315"]
[White "Joker 1.1.14"]
[Black "Latista (Sinobyl) 1.5"]
[Result "0-1"]
[ECO "C53"]
[Opening "Giuoco Piano"]
[PlyCount "84"]
[WhiteElo "2404"]
[BlackElo "2299"]

1. e4 {+355.34/0 0s} e5 {+355.34/0 0s} 2. Nf3 {+355.34/0 0s} Nc6 {+355.34/0 0s}
3. Bc4 {+355.34/0 0s} Bc5 {+355.34/0 0s} 4. c3 {+355.34/0 0s} Nf6 {+355.34/0
0s} 5. d3 {+355.34/0 0s} d6 {+355.34/0 0s} 6. O-O {+355.34/0 0s} O-O {+355.34/0
0s} 7. Bb3 {+355.34/0 0s} a6 {+355.34/0 0s} 8. Nbd2 {+355.34/0 0s} Ba7
{+355.34/0 0s} 9. h3 {+355.34/0 0s} Be6 {+355.34/0 0s} 10. Re1 {+355.34/0 0s}
h6 {+355.34/0 0s} 11. Nf1 {+355.34/0 0s} Re8 {+355.34/0 0s} 12. Be3 {+355.34/0
0s} Bxe3 {+355.34/0 0s} 13. Nxe3 {+0.04/15 233s} Qd7 {(a5) +0.12/14 116s} 14.
Qc2 {+0.02/14 213s} Ne7 {(Rad8) +0.12/13 116s} 15. Bxe6 {(a4) +0.02/13 118s}
Qxe6 {+0.07/13 116s} 16. b3 {(Rad1) +0.02/13 151s} Ng6 {+0.04/13 116s} 17. h4
{(Nf5) +0.00/13 184s} Nf4 {(b5) -0.23/12 116s} 18. Rad1 {(a4) -0.02/13 177s}
Ng4 {(c5) -0.25/12 116s} 19. Nf5 {-0.06/14 61s} Qg6 {-0.30/13 116s} 20. Ng3
{(g3) -0.18/15 170s} Nf6 {-0.52/14 116s} 21. Nh2 {-0.25/15 170s} N6h5 {-0.60/16
116s} 22. Re3 {-0.34/15 116s} d5 {-0.62/15 116s} 23. Nhf1 {(exd5) -0.24/14
108s} Rad8 {-0.78/14 116s} 24. Rd2 {(exd5) -0.30/14 123s} Nf6 {(dxe4) -0.69/13
116s} 25. Qd1 {-0.32/14 142s} dxe4 {(c5) -1.13/15 116s} 26. dxe4 {-0.36/16 93s}
Rxd2 {-1.17/15 116s} 27. Qxd2 {(Nxd2) -0.36/15 64s} Qg4 {-1.26/14 116s} 28. c4
{(Re1) -0.45/15 126s} b6 {(Qxh4) -1.18/14 116s} 29. c5 {-0.39/13 67s} Qxh4
{-1.10/14 116s} 30. Nf5 {(cxb6) -0.36/13 45s} Qh5 {-1.22/14 116s} 31. N1g3
{-0.34/13 45s} Qg5 {-1.32/14 116s} 32. cxb6 {-0.77/13 53s} cxb6 {-1.38/14 116s}
33. Qc2 {(Qd6) -0.95/14 123s} h5 {-1.19/12 116s} 34. Nd6 {-2.52/14 107s} Rf8
{-2.36/13 116s} 35. Rc3 {-3.04/15 96s} h4 {-3.26/14 116s} 36. Ndf5 {(Rc8)
-3.66/15 92s} g6 {-3.72/14 116s} 37. Nxh4 {-3.83/14 57s} Qxh4 {-3.88/13 29s}
38. Rc8 {-4.19/14 62s} Qg4 {-4.30/15 108s} 39. Rxf8+ {-4.55/15 43s} Kxf8
{-4.38/14 41s} 40. Qd2 {-4.74/15 30s} Nxe4 {-4.64/14 71s} 41. Qb4+ {-5.43/16
70s} Nc5 {-4.70/14 86s} 42. Qxb6 {-5.54/16 63s} Qd1+ {-4.88/13 86s} 0-1

[Event "CCRL 40/40"]
[Site "CCRL"]
[Date "2008.01.28"]
[Round "110.1.316"]
[White "Parrot 07.07.22"]
[Black "GarboChess 0.21"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[ECO "B35"]
[Opening "Sicilian"]
[Variation "accelerated fianchetto, modern variation with Bc4"]
[PlyCount "191"]
[WhiteElo "2249"]
[BlackElo "2317"]

1. e4 {+355.34/0 0s} c5 {+355.34/0 0s} 2. Nc3 {+355.34/0 0s} Nc6 {+355.34/0 0s}
3. Nf3 {+355.34/0 0s} g6 {+355.34/0 0s} 4. d4 {+355.34/0 0s} cxd4 {+355.34/0
0s} 5. Nxd4 {+355.34/0 0s} Bg7 {+355.34/0 0s} 6. Be3 {+355.34/0 0s} Nf6
{+355.34/0 0s} 7. Bc4 {+355.34/0 0s} O-O {+355.34/0 0s} 8. Bb3 {+355.34/0 0s}
d6 {+355.34/0 0s} 9. f3 {+355.34/0 0s} Bd7 {+355.34/0 0s} 10. Qd2 {+355.34/0
0s} Nxd4 {+355.34/0 0s} 11. Bxd4 {+355.34/0 0s} b5 {+355.34/0 0s} 12. a4
{+355.34/0 0s} bxa4 {+0.18/12 81s} 13. Bxa4 {(Nxa4) +0.45/15 99s} a5 {(Ne8)
+0.26/12 79s} 14. O-O {(b3) +0.55/14 113s} Rb8 {(Nh5) +0.30/12 77s} 15. b3
{+0.57/13 62s} Be6 {(e5) +0.39/12 75s} 16. Bb5 {(Rfd1) +0.69/12 47s} Nh5
{+0.32/12 73s} 17. Ra4 {(Rf2) +0.60/13 76s} Bxd4+ {+0.17/12 71s} 18. Rxd4
{(Qxd4) +0.38/14 140s} Qb6 {(Qc7) -0.03/13 70s} 19. Rf2 {(Kh1) +0.34/13 50s}
Rfc8 {(Nf6) -0.08/13 68s} 20. Ba4 {(Bf1) +0.33/14 55s} Nf4 {(Nf6) -0.12/12 66s}
21. Nd5 {(Nb5) +0.32/15 82s} Bxd5 {(Nxd5) -0.12/14 64s} 22. exd5 {+0.61/15 46s}
g5 {-0.06/13 63s} 23. c4 {+0.62/14 49s} Rb7 {(h6) +0.00/13 61s} 24. h4
{+0.62/14 50s} f6 {+0.21/14 60s} 25. Kf1 {(hxg5) +0.63/14 74s} Qb4 {(Rf8)
+0.19/14 58s} 26. Qxb4 {+0.96/14 37s} axb4 {+0.17/16 57s} 27. g3 {+0.84/12 23s}
Nh5 {+0.17/14 55s} 28. Rg2 {(Ke1) +0.79/13 54s} Ra7 {(Kf7) +0.17/14 54s} 29.
Kf2 {+0.72/13 54s} Rf8 {(Kf7) +0.21/16 53s} 30. Rh2 {+0.78/15 117s} Ng7
{+0.19/16 51s} 31. hxg5 {+0.81/15 62s} fxg5 {+0.18/16 50s} 32. g4 {+0.83/15
97s} Rf6 {(Ne8) +0.18/15 49s} 33. Ke3 {(Rh1) +0.86/13 79s} h6 {(e5) +0.16/14
48s} 34. Rd1 {(Rh1) +0.81/13 66s} e5 {(e6) +0.72/13 46s} 35. c5 {+1.17/14 66s}
Rc7 {(dxc5) +1.05/15 45s} 36. c6 {(cxd6) +1.74/15 150s} Ne8 {(Rcf7) +0.80/13
44s} 37. Bb5 {+1.75/15 89s} Ra7 {(Rcf7) +0.78/14 43s} 38. Rc2 {+1.84/13 51s}
Nc7 {+0.54/13 42s} 39. Bc4 {+1.42/14 66s} Rf8 {(Kf8) +0.62/15 41s} 40. Rdd2
{+1.45/15 367s} Rfa8 {(Kg7) +0.58/16 40s} 41. Rf2 {(Rh2) +1.76/12 30s} Kg7
{(Ne8) +0.52/17 120s} 42. Rcd2 {+1.45/14 43s} Ra3 {(Rf8) +0.53/17 117s} 43. Rf1
{(Rh2) +1.42/13 29s} Rf8 {+0.33/15 114s} 44. Rb1 {(Kf2) +1.33/12 20s} Na8
{+0.32/15 111s} 45. Bf1 {(Kf2) +1.13/13 26s} Nb6 {+0.29/15 108s} 46. Rd3
{+0.89/14 55s} Ra5 {+0.28/15 106s} 47. Rbd1 {+0.68/15 58s} Rf4 {+0.26/14 103s}
48. Be2 {(Bh3) +0.67/14 16s} Rc5 {+0.00/16 100s} 49. Kf2 {(R1d2) +0.45/14 34s}
Rf8 {(Rf7) +0.00/16 98s} 50. R1d2 {+0.24/14 41s} Ra8 {(Rc3) +0.00/17 95s} 51.
Ke3 {+0.28/15 52s} Ra7 {(Rc3) +0.00/16 93s} 52. Bd1 {+0.07/15 50s} Rc7 {(Ra8)
+0.00/17 91s} 53. Bc2 {+0.30/17 109s} Ra7 {+0.00/16 88s} 54. Ke4 {+0.24/16 59s}
Rf7 {+0.00/16 86s} 55. Bb1 {(Bd1) +0.18/14 27s} Rc1 {(Rf4+) +0.00/15 84s} 56.
Rd1 {+0.06/17 104s} Rf4+ {+0.00/15 82s} 57. Ke3 {+0.01/1 0s} Rc5 {+0.00/15 80s}
58. R1d2 {+0.02/15 54s} Kf8 {(Kf7) +0.00/15 78s} 59. Rc2 {(Bc2) +0.02/14 72s}
Rxd5 {+0.00/14 76s} 60. Rc1 {(Ra2) +0.00/14 57s} Ke7 {(Rxd3+) -0.52/14 74s} 61.
Rdd1 {(c7) -0.19/15 138s} Rxd1 {-0.47/14 72s} 62. Rxd1 {-0.44/18 129s} Rf6
{-0.98/15 70s} 63. Bf5 {-0.54/17 147s} Kd8 {-0.98/16 69s} 64. Ke4 {(Be4)
-0.61/16 81s} Kc7 {-1.26/16 67s} 65. Rc1 {-0.95/17 61s} d5+ {(Rf8) -1.09/16
65s} 66. Kxe5 {-0.18/17 246s} Rxc6 {-1.26/16 64s} 67. Rc2 {(Re1) -0.58/16 43s}
Rxc2 {-1.38/17 62s} 68. Bxc2 {-0.64/16 104s} Kc6 {-1.33/18 60s} 69. Bf5
{-0.60/16 61s} Na8 {(Kc5) -1.32/18 59s} 70. Bg6 {(Be6) -0.31/16 75s} Kc5 {(Nc7)
-1.33/18 58s} 71. Bh7 {(Bb1) -0.41/17 91s} Nb6 {-1.34/18 56s} 72. Bf5 {-0.33/16
39s} d4 {-1.43/17 55s} 73. Bd3 {(Be4) -0.89/15 68s} Nd5 {-1.57/17 53s} 74. Bc4
{(Bh7) -0.80/16 74s} Nc3 {-1.52/18 52s} 75. f4 {-0.88/16 31s} gxf4 {-1.47/18
51s} 76. Kxf4 {-0.80/16 119s} Nb1 {-1.44/18 49s} 77. Bf7 {(Bg8) -0.80/16 89s}
Nd2 {-1.42/18 48s} 78. Be6 {-0.81/15 71s} Kd6 {-1.40/18 47s} 79. Bg8 {(Bf7)
-0.80/16 228s} Kc6 {-1.40/18 46s} 80. Bf7 {-0.79/15 46s} Kb7 {(Kb6) -1.32/17
45s} 81. Ke5 {-0.75/13 34s} Nf3+ {-1.28/18 125s} 82. Kf4 {(Kd6) -0.41/13 32s}
Ng5 {-1.34/19 121s} 83. Bc4 {-0.55/14 20s} Kb6 {(Kc6) -1.26/18 118s} 84. Kf5
{(Ke5) -0.54/14 33s} Nh3 {-1.22/19 115s} 85. Ke4 {-0.75/14 35s} Kc5 {-1.26/18
113s} 86. Kf3 {-0.67/14 36s} Ng5+ {-1.18/18 110s} 87. Kf4 {-0.60/15 98s} Kd6
{(Nh7) -1.24/18 107s} 88. Kf5 {-0.58/15 68s} Nh3 {(Nf3) -1.32/19 104s} 89. Ke4
{-0.64/15 45s} Nf2+ {-1.33/19 102s} 90. Kxd4 {(Kf3) -0.70/15 66s} Nxg4
{-1.44/20 99s} 91. Bf7 {(Ke4) -0.64/15 41s} Nf6 {(Ne5) -1.63/20 97s} 92. Kc4
{(Bg6) -0.52/16 83s} h5 {(Ne4) -1.61/20 94s} 93. Bxh5 {+0.00/16 91s} Nxh5
{-1.30/25 92s} 94. Kxb4 {+0.00/1 0s} Kd5 {+0.00/1 0s} 95. Ka5 {+0.00/1 0s} Kc6
{+0.00/1 0s} 96. Ka6 {+0.00/1 0s} 1/2-1/2

[Event "CCRL 40/40"]
[Site "CCRL"]
[Date "2008.01.28"]
[Round "110.1.317"]
[White "NagaSkaki 4.00"]
[Black "Buzz 0.08 32-bit"]
[Result "0-1"]
[ECO "B90"]
[Opening "Sicilian"]
[Variation "Najdorf, Byrne (English) attack"]
[PlyCount "72"]
[WhiteElo "2252"]
[BlackElo "2294"]

1. e4 {+355.34/0 0s} c5 {+355.34/0 0s} 2. Nf3 {+355.34/0 0s} d6 {+355.34/0 0s}
3. d4 {+355.34/0 0s} cxd4 {+355.34/0 0s} 4. Nxd4 {+355.34/0 0s} Nf6 {+355.34/0
0s} 5. Nc3 {+355.34/0 0s} a6 {+355.34/0 0s} 6. Be3 {+355.34/0 0s} e6 {+355.34/0
0s} 7. Be2 {+355.34/0 0s} Nc6 {+355.34/0 0s} 8. f4 {+355.34/0 0s} Bd7 {+0.12/11
93s} 9. Qd2 {(Nxc6) +0.45/11 149s} e5 {(Be7) +0.04/11 93s} 10. Nxc6 {+0.59/11
125s} Bxc6 {+0.06/11 93s} 11. Bf3 {+0.62/11 57s} b5 {(Be7) +0.06/11 93s} 12.
O-O-O {(Rd1) +0.94/11 58s} b4 {(Be7) +0.04/11 93s} 13. fxe5 {+0.88/11 17s} dxe5
{+0.06/12 93s} 14. Qxd8+ {(Qe2) +0.93/12 33s} Rxd8 {+0.01/1 0s} 15. Rxd8+
{+1.01/14 58s} Kxd8 {+0.15/14 96s} 16. Nd5 {(Rd1+) +0.62/14 80s} Bxd5 {(Nxd5)
+0.12/14 96s} 17. exd5 {+0.57/14 57s} Kc7 {(e4) +0.13/13 96s} 18. Rd1 {(Rf1)
+0.87/13 63s} Bd6 {(Be7) +0.05/13 96s} 19. g3 {(Be2) +0.78/13 100s} h5 {(Be7)
+0.08/12 96s} 20. Bg5 {(Be2) +0.45/14 90s} Ng4 {+0.03/14 96s} 21. Rd2 {+0.41/14
38s} f6 {+0.01/14 96s} 22. Bxg4 {+0.19/16 47s} hxg4 {+0.06/15 96s} 23. Be3
{+0.02/16 32s} Rc8 {(f5) +0.08/15 96s} 24. c4 {(c3) +0.10/15 96s} bxc3
{+0.00/15 96s} 25. Rc2 {+0.05/15 103s} f5 {(Rd8) -0.07/14 96s} 26. bxc3
{-0.71/16 348s} f4 {-0.19/14 96s} 27. gxf4 {-0.95/15 59s} exf4 {-0.38/14 96s}
28. Bg1 {-1.15/16 271s} f3 {-0.61/14 96s} 29. c4 {(Kd2) -1.15/14 53s} Rb8
{(Bf4+) -1.31/13 96s} 30. Be3 {-1.31/14 54s} Re8 {-1.31/12 96s} 31. Kd2 {(Bd4)
-2.08/14 309s} Bxh2 {-1.81/12 96s} 32. Kd3 {(Rc3) -2.58/13 44s} g3 {-3.22/11
96s} 33. Rb2 {(Rc1) -2.87/13 45s} g2 {-4.12/11 96s} 34. Bb6+ {-4.75/14 148s}
Kc8 {-5.29/12 96s} 35. a4 {(d6) -5.25/13 41s} Re1 {-7.80/12 96s} 36. Bf2
{-6.79/15 123s} g1=Q {-8.92/13 95s} 0-1

[Graham Banks]

Hi Graham,

In doing my current work on a new utility tool, I came across some old CCRL games from 2008 that must have used a really buggy GUI, or whatever. I wonder if it is possible to know what was at fault for the insane book evaluations of +355.34.

-Norm

Hi Norm,

can't recall which GUI (and which version of it) used to report book moves in this manner, but it certainly looks strange, I agree.

Cheers,
Graham.