Spike 1.4 vs Critter vs R3 vs Shredder vs Bright

Discussion of computer chess matches and engine tournaments.

Moderator: Ras

frcha
Posts: 221
Joined: Thu Jan 28, 2010 5:47 pm

Spike 1.4 vs Critter vs R3 vs Shredder vs Bright

Post by frcha »

Win32 Xp On Arena 128Hash tc=+4s

Seems like critter slightly weaker than R3 which is slightly weaker than spike which is weaker than critter ....go figure!

But the old # 1 is no longer #1 without R4, Ippo stockfish in the tournament !!

First match:

using official nunn 20 positions.

Code: Select all

1: Critter_0.90_32bit 98.5/160 
2: Spike1.4           95.5/160 
3: Rybka 3_(cont 0)   93.5/160 
4: Shredder12         74.5/160 
5: Bright-0.5c        38.0/160 


-----------------Bright-0.5c-----------------
Bright-0.5c - Critter_0.90_32bit      : 6.0/40 1-29-10 (0===0000001000000==0000=00=00000=000=00=)  15%  -301
Bright-0.5c - Rybka 3_(cont 0)        : 10.5/40 4-23-13 (=01=10=000==0=00000==100=000==0=10=00000)  26%  -182
Bright-0.5c - Shredder12              : 13.0/40 6-20-14 (110=00=====000==0=101=0=0000=0100==00001)  33%  -123
Bright-0.5c - Spike1.4                : 8.5/40 3-26-11 (00000000=00100=00==00100010===0=0==0000=)  21%  -230
-----------------Critter_0.90_32bit-----------------
Critter_0.90_32bit - Bright-0.5c      : 34.0/40 29-1-10 (1===1111110111111==1111=11=11111=111=11=)  85%  +301
Critter_0.90_32bit - Rybka 3_(cont 0) : 19.0/40 8-10-22 (=0=1==0=0==1===0=0==010=11==1===1=00==01)  48%   -14
Critter_0.90_32bit - Shredder12       : 24.5/40 15-6-19 (=11=1====1=1==11====0110=1=10=01101==10=)  61%   +78
Critter_0.90_32bit - Spike1.4         : 21.0/40 13-11-16 (=00==1====1100=100000101=1=1==111=1=10==)  53%   +21
-----------------Rybka 3_(cont 0)-----------------
Rybka 3_(cont 0) - Bright-0.5c        : 29.5/40 23-4-13 (=10=01=111==1=11111==011=111==1=01=11111)  74%  +182
Rybka 3_(cont 0) - Critter_0.90_32bit : 21.0/40 10-8-22 (=1=0==1=1==0===1=1==101=00==0===0=11==10)  53%   +21
Rybka 3_(cont 0) - Shredder12         : 24.0/40 14-6-20 (==1==0====11==10==1==010111====11=011=01)  60%   +70
Rybka 3_(cont 0) - Spike1.4           : 19.0/40 10-12-18 (1=1=1=1==010===00=0==01==10==001=010=1=0)  48%   -14
-----------------Shredder12-----------------
Shredder12 - Bright-0.5c              : 27.0/40 20-6-14 (001=11=====111==1=010=1=1111=1011==11110)  68%  +131
Shredder12 - Critter_0.90_32bit       : 15.5/40 6-15-19 (=00=0====0=0==00====1001=0=01=10010==01=)  39%   -78
Shredder12 - Rybka 3_(cont 0)         : 16.0/40 6-14-20 (==0==1====00==01==0==101000====00=100=10)  40%   -70
Shredder12 - Spike1.4                 : 16.0/40 8-16-16 (10==10=01=10=000=0==1=10=00010====00==01)  40%   -70
-----------------Spike1.4-----------------
Spike1.4 - Bright-0.5c                : 31.5/40 26-3-11 (11111111=11011=11==11011101===1=1==1111=)  79%  +230
Spike1.4 - Critter_0.90_32bit         : 19.0/40 11-13-16 (=11==0====0011=011111010=0=0==000=0=01==)  48%   -14
Spike1.4 - Rybka 3_(cont 0)           : 21.0/40 12-10-18 (0=0=0=0==101===11=1==10==01==110=101=0=1)  53%   +21
Spike1.4 - Shredder12                 : 24.0/40 16-8-16 (01==01=10=01=111=1==0=01=11101====11==10)  60%   +70


Critter vs R3 vs Spike +4s Silver suite positions.

Code: Select all






1: Critter_0.90_32bit 107.5/200 
2: Rybka 3_(cont 0)   97.5/200  
3: Spike1.4           95.0/200  


Critter_0.90_32bit - Rybka 3_(cont 0) : 49.5/100 22-23-55 (===101=0=1=11==1=00=1==0==110=00==01000====1=10==00=1===01===0==1===010=====0==11==1==1==0==0==1=0=1)  50%    ±0
Critter_0.90_32bit - Spike1.4         : 58.0/100 37-21-42 (=11==011====001==0110=0=1=1===10101010=0==10===0==10=11=11001=1=1011111=1==0=1=0=01=1=1==11=0=1==11=)  58%   +56
-----------------Rybka 3_(cont 0)-----------------
Rybka 3_(cont 0) - Critter_0.90_32bit : 50.5/100 23-22-55 (===010=1=0=00==0=11=0==1==001=11==10111====0=01==11=0===10===1==0===101=====1==00==0==0==1==1==0=1=0)  51%    +7
Rybka 3_(cont 0) - Spike1.4           : 47.0/100 27-33-40 (==100100=1===001110==1===1==01=1=1==11==000000=1===1010==0001==0=1110===1=1=01100===01==000==0101000)  47%   -21
-----------------Spike1.4-----------------
Spike1.4 - Critter_0.90_32bit         : 42.0/100 21-37-42 (=00==100====110==1001=1=0=0===01010101=1==01===1==01=00=00110=0=0100000=0==1=0=1=10=0=0==00=1=0==00=)  42%   -56
Spike1.4 - Rybka 3_(cont 0)           : 53.0/100 33-27-40 (==011011=0===110001==0===0==10=0=0==00==111111=0===0101==1110==1=0001===0=0=10011===10==111==1010111)  53%   +21


:) :P