What engine can evaluate this draw ending correctly w/o TB?

Discussion of anything and everything relating to chess playing software and machines.

Moderator: Ras

pichy
Posts: 2564
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 3:04 am

What engine can evaluate this draw ending correctly w/o TB?

Post by pichy »

How many Engines can evaluate this position as a draw without using tablebase, some top engines including Komodo evaluate this position as better for White, but all that Black has to do is remain on the 5th rank by moving the Rook back and forward between g5 to e5 and there is nothing that White can do to penetrate Black fortress :roll:
[d]8/3Q1pk1/5p2/4r3/5K2/8/8/8 w - - 0 1
FEN: 8/3Q1pk1/5p2/4r3/5K2/8/8/8 w - - 0 1

Komodo-10-32-ja:
fen = 8/3Q1pk1/5p2/4r3/5K2/8/8/ w - -
1 00:00 83 0 +1.44 Qd7g4+ Kg7h6
2 00:00 465 29.807 +1.50 Qd7d3 Re5e8
3 00:00 1.399 89.678 +1.47 Qd7d4 Re5e1 Kf4f5
4 00:00 3.468 111.152 +1.47 Qd7d4 Re5e2 Kf4f3 Re2e1
5 00:00 5.128 164.356 +1.46 Qd7d4 Re5e2 Qd4d3 Re2f2+ Kf4g3 Rf2a2
5 00:00 7.520 241.022 +1.46 Qd7d4 Re5e2 Qd4d3 Re2f2+ Kf4g3 Rf2a2
6 00:00 15.429 329.675 +1.43 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4d3 Rg5g1 Qd3e3 Rg1f1+ Kf4g3
6 00:00 16.567 353.991 +1.44 Qd7g4+ Re5g5 Qg4f3 Rg5g1 Qf3e3 Rg1f1+ Kf4g3 Rf1d1
6 00:00 17.277 369.161 +1.44 Qd7g4+ Re5g5 Qg4f3 Rg5g1 Qf3e3 Rg1f1+ Kf4g3 Rf1d1
7 00:00 24.957 399.946 +1.44 Qd7g4+ Re5g5 Qg4f3 Rg5g1 Qf3f2 Rg1g5 Qf2e3 Rg5h5 Qe3f3 Rh5h4+ Kf4f5
7 00:00 32.855 526.515 +1.47 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4d3 Rg5g1 Qd3e2 Rg1g5 Qe2b2 Rg5g1
7 00:00 34.036 545.441 +1.47 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4d3 Rg5g1 Qd3e2 Rg1g5 Qe2b2 Rg5g1
8 00:00 41.834 536.326 +1.46 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3e3 Rg5e5 Qe3g3+ Re5g5
8 00:00 43.000 551.274 +1.46 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3e3 Rg5e5 Qe3g3+ Re5g5
9 00:00 51.123 655.414 +1.43 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4c3 Re5d5 Qc3c6 Rd5d4+ Kf4f5
9 00:00 53.626 687.503 +1.43 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4c3 Re5d5 Qc3c6 Rd5d4+ Kf4f5
10 00:00 71.982 769.028 +1.45 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4c3 Re5d5 Qc3c6 Rd5g5 Qc6f3 Rg5c5 Qf3g4+ Kg7h6
10 00:00 74.865 799.829 +1.45 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4c3 Re5d5 Qc3c6 Rd5g5 Qc6f3 Rg5c5 Qf3g4+ Kg7h6
11 00:00 87.681 468.380 +1.45 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4c3 Re5h5 Qc3c6 Rh5h4+ Kf4f5 Rh4h5+ Kf5g4 Kg7g6
11 00:00 90.178 444.663 +1.45 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4c3 Re5h5 Qc3c6 Rh5h4+ Kf4f5 Rh4h5+ Kf5g4 Kg7g6
12 00:00 123.425 527.454 +1.42 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5g1 Qd3e4 Rg1f1+ Kf4g3 Rf1g1+ Kg3f2 Rg1c1
12 00:00 126.818 508.082 +1.42 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5g1 Qd3e4 Rg1f1+ Kf4g3 Rf1g1+ Kg3f2 Rg1c1
13 00:00 146.990 554.257 +1.42 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5c5 Qd3g3+ Rc5g5 Qg3f3 Rg5e5 Qf3c6 Re5g5 Qc6b6 Rg5h5 Qb6g1+ Rh5g5
13 00:00 151.626 571.738 +1.42 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5c5 Qd3g3+ Rc5g5 Qg3f3 Rg5e5 Qf3c6 Re5g5 Qc6b6 Rg5h5 Qb6g1+ Rh5g5
14 00:00 207.665 605.083 +1.40 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5c5 Qd3g3+ Rc5g5 Qg3c3 Rg5g2 Qc3e3 Rg2g5 Qe3f2 Kg7h6 Qf2e3
14 00:00 213.094 593.905 +1.40 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5c5 Qd3g3+ Rc5g5 Qg3c3 Rg5g2 Qc3e3 Rg2g5 Qe3f2 Kg7h6 Qf2e3
15 00:00 284.561 651.464 +1.43 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5c5 Qd3g3+ Rc5g5 Qg3c3 Rg5g2 Qc3e3 Rg2g5 Qe3f2 Kg7h6 Qf2d2 Kh6g7 Qd2e3 Kg7h6 Qe3e4
15 00:00 291.156 666.563 +1.43 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5c5 Qd3g3+ Rc5g5 Qg3c3 Rg5g2 Qc3e3 Rg2g5 Qe3f2 Kg7h6 Qf2d2 Kh6g7 Qd2e3 Kg7h6 Qe3e4
16 00:00 451.915 762.337 +1.39 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5c5 Qd3g3+ Rc5g5 Qg3e3 Kg7g6 Qe3e4+ Kg6h6 Qe4b1 Kh6g7 Qb1b2 Kg7g6 Qb2c2+ Kg6g7 Qc2c6
16 00:01 531.246 791.957 +1.39 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5c5 Qd3g3+ Rc5g5 Qg3e3 Kg7g6 Qe3e4+ Kg6h6 Qe4b1 Kh6g7 Qb1b2 Kg7g6 Qb2c2+ Kg6g7 Qc2c6
17 00:01 668.506 840.250 +1.40 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5c5 Qd3g3+ Rc5g5 Qg3e3 Kg7g6 Qe3e4+ Kg6g7 Kf4f3 Rg5g1 Qe4d4 Rg1g5 Qd4c3 Rg5f5+ Kf3e3 Rf5d5
17 00:01 676.850 850.738 +1.40 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5c5 Qd3g3+ Rc5g5 Qg3e3 Kg7g6 Qe3e4+ Kg6g7 Kf4f3 Rg5g1 Qe4d4 Rg1g5 Qd4c3 Rg5f5+ Kf3e3 Rf5d5
18 00:01 811.702 881.898 +1.39 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5c5 Qd3g3+ Rc5g5 Qg3e3 Kg7g6 Qe3e4+ Kg6g7 Qe4c6 Kg7g6 Qc6c2+ Kg6g7 Qc2c3 Kg7g6 Qc3c8 Kg6g7 Qc8c2 Rg5g1 Qc2c3 Rg1f1+ Kf4e3
18 00:01 826.483 882.992 +1.39 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5c5 Qd3g3+ Rc5g5 Qg3e3 Kg7g6 Qe3e4+ Kg6g7 Qe4c6 Kg7g6 Qc6c2+ Kg6g7 Qc2c3 Kg7g6 Qc3c8 Kg6g7 Qc8c2 Rg5g1 Qc2c3 Rg1f1+ Kf4e3
19 00:01 958.537 903.596 +1.39 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5c5 Qd3g3+ Rc5g5 Qg3e3 Rg5e5 Qe3f3 Re5g5 Qf3c3 Kg7g6 Qc3c8 Kg6g7 Qc8c2 Rg5g1 Qc2c3 Rg1f1+ Kf4g3 Rf1f5 Kg3h4 Rf5e5 Qc3g3+ Re5g5
19 00:01 1.001.109 916.764 +1.39 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5c5 Qd3g3+ Rc5g5 Qg3e3 Rg5e5 Qe3f3 Re5g5 Qf3c3 Kg7g6 Qc3c8 Kg6g7 Qc8c2 Rg5g1 Qc2c3 Rg1f1+ Kf4g3 Rf1f5 Kg3h4 Rf5e5 Qc3g3+ Re5g5
20 00:02 1.549.095 964.084 +1.40 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5c5 Qd3g3+ Rc5g5 Qg3e3 Rg5e5 Qe3f3 Re5g5 Qf3c3 Kg7g6 Qc3c8 Kg6g7 Qc8c2 Rg5g1 Qc2c3 Rg1f1+ Kf4e3 Rf1d1 Ke3f3 Rd1f1+ Kf3e2 Rf1b1 Qc3d4 Rb1c1
20 00:02 1.566.841 965.752 +1.40 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5c5 Qd3g3+ Rc5g5 Qg3e3 Rg5e5 Qe3f3 Re5g5 Qf3c3 Kg7g6 Qc3c8 Kg6g7 Qc8c2 Rg5g1 Qc2c3 Rg1f1+ Kf4e3 Rf1d1 Ke3f3 Rd1f1+ Kf3e2 Rf1b1 Qc3d4 Rb1c1
21 00:02 1.976.485 989.824 +1.39 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5h5 Qd3g3+ Rh5g5 Qg3e3 Rg5e5 Qe3g1+ Re5g5 Qg1b6 Kg7g6 Qb6b1+ Kg6g7 Qb1h1 Rg5e5 Qh1g2+ Re5g5 Qg2f3 Rg5e5 Qf3g4+ Re5g5 Qg4h3 Rg5e5 Qh3d7 Re5g5 Qd7c6
21 00:02 2.007.092 997.360 +1.39 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5h5 Qd3g3+ Rh5g5 Qg3e3 Rg5e5 Qe3g1+ Re5g5 Qg1b6 Kg7g6 Qb6b1+ Kg6g7 Qb1h1 Rg5e5 Qh1g2+ Re5g5 Qg2f3 Rg5e5 Qf3g4+ Re5g5 Qg4h3 Rg5e5 Qh3d7 Re5g5 Qd7c6
22 00:03 3.363.656 1.021.888 +1.39 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5h5 Qd3g3+ Rh5g5 Qg3e3 Rg5e5 Qe3f3 Re5g5 Qf3c6 Rg5h5 Qc6c3 Rh5h4+ Kf4g3 Rh4h5 Qc3d3 Rh5e5 Qd3d4 Kg7g6 Kg3f3 Re5f5+ Kf3e2 Rf5a5 Qd4g4+ Kg6h6 Qg4f4+ Kh6g6 Qf4g4+ Ra5g5
22 00:03 3.451.590 1.024.330 +1.39 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5h5 Qd3g3+ Rh5g5 Qg3e3 Rg5e5 Qe3f3 Re5g5 Qf3c6 Rg5h5 Qc6c3 Rh5h4+ Kf4g3 Rh4h5 Qc3d3 Rh5e5 Qd3d4 Kg7g6 Kg3f3 Re5f5+ Kf3e2 Rf5a5 Qd4g4+ Kg6h6 Qg4f4+ Kh6g6 Qf4g4+ Ra5g5
23 00:04 3.953.129 986.012 +1.39 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5h5 Qd3f3 Rh5g5 Qf3e3 Kg7g6 Qe3e4+ Kg6h6 Qe4c6 Kh6g7 Qc6f3 Kg7g6 Qf3b7 Rg5f5+ Kf4e3 Kg6g7 Qb7b6 Rf5e5+ Ke3f4 Re5g5 Qb6c6 Kg7g6 Qc6c2+ Kg6h6 Qc2c8 Kh6g7 Qc8c3
23 00:04 3.992.367 984.309 +1.39 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5h5 Qd3f3 Rh5g5 Qf3e3 Kg7g6 Qe3e4+ Kg6h6 Qe4c6 Kh6g7 Qc6f3 Kg7g6 Qf3b7 Rg5f5+ Kf4e3 Kg6g7 Qb7b6 Rf5e5+ Ke3f4 Re5g5 Qb6c6 Kg7g6 Qc6c2+ Kg6h6 Qc2c8 Kh6g7 Qc8c3
24 00:04 4.569.625 1.006.612 +1.39 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5h5 Qd3f3 Rh5g5 Qf3e3 Kg7g6 Qe3e4+ Kg6g7 Qe4f3 Rg5e5 Qf3g2+ Re5g5 Qg2c6 Rg5e5 Qc6c3 Re5h5 Qc3g3+ Rh5g5 Qg3h4 Rg5g2 Qh4h5 Rg2g1 Qh5d5 Rg1f1+ Kf4g4 Rf1e1 Qd5d3 Re1e5 Qd3d4
24 00:05 4.794.805 1.017.744 +1.39 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5h5 Qd3f3 Rh5g5 Qf3e3 Kg7g6 Qe3e4+ Kg6g7 Qe4f3 Rg5e5 Qf3g2+ Re5g5 Qg2c6 Rg5e5 Qc6c3 Re5h5 Qc3g3+ Rh5g5 Qg3h4 Rg5g2 Qh4h5 Rg2g1 Qh5d5 Rg1f1+ Kf4g4 Rf1e1 Qd5d3 Re1e5 Qd3d4
25 00:08 8.388.364 1.054.342 +1.39 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5h5 Qd3f3 Rh5g5 Qf3e3 Kg7g6 Qe3e4+ Kg6g7 Qe4f3 Kg7g6 Qf3b7 Rg5f5+ Kf4e3 Kg6g7 Qb7b6 Rf5e5+ Ke3f4 Re5g5 Qb6c6 Rg5h5 Qc6c3 Rh5h4+ Kf4g3 Rh4h5 Qc3c2 Rh5e5 Kg3g4 Re5d5 Kg4f4 Rd5g5 Qc2c3
25 00:09 9.939.346 1.054.861 +1.39 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5h5 Qd3f3 Rh5g5 Qf3e3 Kg7g6 Qe3e4+ Kg6g7 Qe4f3 Kg7g6 Qf3b7 Rg5f5+ Kf4e3 Kg6g7 Qb7b6 Rf5e5+ Ke3f4 Re5g5 Qb6c6 Rg5h5 Qc6c3 Rh5h4+ Kf4g3 Rh4h5 Qc3c2 Rh5e5 Kg3g4 Re5d5 Kg4f4 Rd5g5 Qc2c3
26 00:23 24.345.891 1.058.772 +1.39 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5h5 Qd3f3 Rh5e5 Qf3g2+ Re5g5 Qg2c6 Rg5h5 Qc6c3 Rh5h4+ Kf4f5 Rh4h5+ Kf5g4 Rh5g5+ Kg4f4 Rg5h5 Qc3g3+ Rh5g5 Qg3h3 Rg5e5 Qh3g4+ Re5g5 Qg4h4 Rg5g2 Qh4h5 Rg2g5 Qh5e2 Rg5e5 Qe2f2 Kg7g6 Qf2g2+ Kg6h6 Qg2f3
26 00:23 24.513.110 1.060.290 +1.39 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5h5 Qd3f3 Rh5e5 Qf3g2+ Re5g5 Qg2c6 Rg5h5 Qc6c3 Rh5h4+ Kf4f5 Rh4h5+ Kf5g4 Rh5g5+ Kg4f4 Rg5h5 Qc3g3+ Rh5g5 Qg3h3 Rg5e5 Qh3g4+ Re5g5 Qg4h4 Rg5g2 Qh4h5 Rg2g5 Qh5e2 Rg5e5 Qe2f2 Kg7g6 Qf2g2+ Kg6h6 Qg2f3
27 00:26 27.928.873 1.074.615 +1.40 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5h5 Qd3f3 Rh5e5 Qf3g2+ Re5g5 Qg2c6 Rg5e5 Qc6c3 Re5h5 Qc3g3+ Rh5g5 Qg3h3 Rg5e5 Qh3g4+ Re5g5 Qg4h4 Rg5g2 Qh4h3 Rg2g5 Kf4e4 Kg7g6 Qh3h8 Rg5e5+ Ke4f4 Re5f5+ Kf4g3 Rf5g5+ Kg3f2 Kg6f5 Qh8f8 Rg5g4 Qf8c8+ Kf5f4 Qc8c7+ Kf4e4 Qc7xf7
27 00:26 28.034.863 1.074.822 +1.40 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5h5 Qd3f3 Rh5e5 Qf3g2+ Re5g5 Qg2c6 Rg5e5 Qc6c3 Re5h5 Qc3g3+ Rh5g5 Qg3h3 Rg5e5 Qh3g4+ Re5g5 Qg4h4 Rg5g2 Qh4h3 Rg2g5 Kf4e4 Kg7g6 Qh3h8 Rg5e5+ Ke4f4 Re5f5+ Kf4g3 Rf5g5+ Kg3f2 Kg6f5 Qh8f8 Rg5g4 Qf8c8+ Kf5f4 Qc8c7+ Kf4e4 Qc7xf7
28 00:29 31.884.076 1.076.842 +1.40 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5h5 Qd3f3 Rh5g5 Qf3c6 Rg5h5 Qc6c7 Rh5h4+ Kf4g3 Rh4h5 Qc7c2 Rh5g5+ Kg3f4 Kg7h6 Qc2c7 Kh6g7 Qc7c8 Rg5e5 Qc8c2 Re5g5 Qc2c3 Kg7g6 Qc3c6 Rg5f5+ Kf4e4 Rf5e5+ Ke4d3 Re5e6 Qc6g2+ Kg6f5 Qg2g8 Re6e7 Qg8c8+ Kf5g5 Qc8c5+ Re7e5 Qc5f8 Kg5g6 Qf8g8+ Kg6f5 Qg8xf7
28 00:30 32.067.907 1.077.939 +1.40 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5h5 Qd3f3 Rh5g5 Qf3c6 Rg5h5 Qc6c7 Rh5h4+ Kf4g3 Rh4h5 Qc7c2 Rh5g5+ Kg3f4 Kg7h6 Qc2c7 Kh6g7 Qc7c8 Rg5e5 Qc8c2 Re5g5 Qc2c3 Kg7g6 Qc3c6 Rg5f5+ Kf4e4 Rf5e5+ Ke4d3 Re5e6 Qc6g2+ Kg6f5 Qg2g8 Re6e7 Qg8c8+ Kf5g5 Qc8c5+ Re7e5 Qc5f8 Kg5g6 Qf8g8+ Kg6f5 Qg8xf7
29 00:36 38.754.386 1.084.825 +1.40 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5c5 Qd3f3 Rc5c4+ Kf4f5 Rc4c5+ Kf5e4 Rc5g5 Ke4f4 Kg7g6 Qf3e4+ Kg6g7 Qe4c6 Rg5h5 Qc6c7 Rh5h4+ Kf4g3 Rh4h5 Qc7c2 Rh5g5+ Kg3f4 Rg5g1 Qc2f2 Rg1g5 Qf2e3 Kg7g6 Qe3c3 Rg5f5+ Kf4e3 Rf5e5+ Ke3d4 Kg6g5 Qc3c1+ Kg5f5 Qc1c2+ Kf5g5 Qc2b3 Re5e6 Qb3g3+ Kg5f5 Qg3h3+ Kf5g5
29 00:36 38.890.777 1.085.798 +1.40 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5c5 Qd3f3 Rc5c4+ Kf4f5 Rc4c5+ Kf5e4 Rc5g5 Ke4f4 Kg7g6 Qf3e4+ Kg6g7 Qe4c6 Rg5h5 Qc6c7 Rh5h4+ Kf4g3 Rh4h5 Qc7c2 Rh5g5+ Kg3f4 Rg5g1 Qc2f2 Rg1g5 Qf2e3 Kg7g6 Qe3c3 Rg5f5+ Kf4e3 Rf5e5+ Ke3d4 Kg6g5 Qc3c1+ Kg5f5 Qc1c2+ Kf5g5 Qc2b3 Re5e6 Qb3g3+ Kg5f5 Qg3h3+ Kf5g5
30 00:42 46.496.527 1.104.722 +1.39 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5c5 Qd3f3 Rc5c4+ Kf4f5 Rc4c5+ Kf5e4 Rc5g5 Ke4f4 Kg7g6 Qf3e4+ Kg6g7 Qe4c6 Rg5h5 Qc6f3 Rh5c5 Qf3f2 Rc5g5 Qf2e3 Kg7g6 Qe3b6 Rg5f5+ Kf4e3 Rf5e5+ Ke3d2 Kg6g7 Qb6d4 Re5h5 Kd2c3 Rh5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5a5 Qe4f4 Kg7g6 Kc3b4 Ra5g5 Qf4e4+ Kg6h6 Qe4c6 Rg5g4+ Kb4c5 Kh6g6
30 00:43 47.488.827 1.108.576 +1.39 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5c5 Qd3f3 Rc5c4+ Kf4f5 Rc4c5+ Kf5e4 Rc5g5 Ke4f4 Kg7g6 Qf3e4+ Kg6g7 Qe4c6 Rg5h5 Qc6f3 Rh5c5 Qf3f2 Rc5g5 Qf2e3 Kg7g6 Qe3b6 Rg5f5+ Kf4e3 Rf5e5+ Ke3d2 Kg6g7 Qb6d4 Re5h5 Kd2c3 Rh5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5a5 Qe4f4 Kg7g6 Kc3b4 Ra5g5 Qf4e4+ Kg6h6 Qe4c6 Rg5g4+ Kb4c5 Kh6g6
31 01:18 84.559.375 1.085.177 +1.39 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5c5 Qd3f3 Rc5c4+ Kf4f5 Rc4c5+ Kf5e4 Rc5g5 Ke4f4 Kg7g6 Qf3e4+ Kg6g7 Qe4c6 Rg5e5 Qc6g2+ Re5g5 Qg2b2 Kg7g6 Qb2b1+ Kg6g7 Qb1b6 Rg5e5 Qb6g1+ Re5g5 Qg1f2 Kg7g6 Qf2c2+ Kg6g7 Qc2c7 Rg5h5 Qc7c8 Rh5h4+ Kf4f3 Rh4h5 Qc8g4+ Rh5g5 Qg4f4 Rg5h5 Qf4d4 Rh5f5+ Kf3g3 Rf5g5+ Kg3f4
31 01:18 84.703.695 1.085.725 +1.39 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5c5 Qd3f3 Rc5c4+ Kf4f5 Rc4c5+ Kf5e4 Rc5g5 Ke4f4 Kg7g6 Qf3e4+ Kg6g7 Qe4c6 Rg5e5 Qc6g2+ Re5g5 Qg2b2 Kg7g6 Qb2b1+ Kg6g7 Qb1b6 Rg5e5 Qb6g1+ Re5g5 Qg1f2 Kg7g6 Qf2c2+ Kg6g7 Qc2c7 Rg5h5 Qc7c8 Rh5h4+ Kf4f3 Rh4h5 Qc8g4+ Rh5g5 Qg4f4 Rg5h5 Qf4d4 Rh5f5+ Kf3g3 Rf5g5+ Kg3f4
32 01:24 92.856.180 1.098.211 +1.40 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5c5 Kf4e4 Rc5g5 Qd3f3 Rg5g1 Ke4f4 Rg1g5 Qf3c6 Rg5e5 Qc6g2+ Re5g5 Qg2c2 Rg5e5 Qc2c6 Re5g5 Qc6c3 Rg5e5 Qc3g3+ Re5g5 Qg3h3 Rg5e5 Qh3g4+ Re5g5 Qg4f3 Rg5e5 Qf3c3 Re5g5 Qc3c7 Rg5h5 Qc7c8 Rh5h4+ Kf4f3 Rh4h5 Qc8g4+ Rh5g5 Qg4d4 Kg7g6 Qd4d3+ Kg6g7 Qd3c3 Kg7g6
32 01:25 93.178.967 1.098.785 +1.40 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5c5 Kf4e4 Rc5g5 Qd3f3 Rg5g1 Ke4f4 Rg1g5 Qf3c6 Rg5e5 Qc6g2+ Re5g5 Qg2c2 Rg5e5 Qc2c6 Re5g5 Qc6c3 Rg5e5 Qc3g3+ Re5g5 Qg3h3 Rg5e5 Qh3g4+ Re5g5 Qg4f3 Rg5e5 Qf3c3 Re5g5 Qc3c7 Rg5h5 Qc7c8 Rh5h4+ Kf4f3 Rh4h5 Qc8g4+ Rh5g5 Qg4d4 Kg7g6 Qd4d3+ Kg6g7 Qd3c3 Kg7g6
33 02:00 133.473.599 1.111.970 +1.39 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5c5 Kf4e4 Rc5g5 Qd3f3 Rg5g1 Ke4f4 Rg1g5 Qf3c6 Rg5h5 Qc6c3 Rh5e5 Qc3c2 Re5g5 Qc2e2 Kg7g6 Qe2e4+ Kg6h6 Qe4c4 Kh6g7 Qc4c8 Rg5b5 Qc8g4+ Rb5g5 Qg4f3 Kg7g6 Qf3c3 Rg5f5+ Kf4e3 Rf5e5+ Ke3d4 Kg6g7 Qc3c6 Kg7g6 Qc6g2+ Kg6h7 Qg2g4 Re5g5 Qg4f3 Kh7g7 Qf3f4 Rg5h5 Qf4g4+ Rh5g5 Qg4f3 Rg5e5 Qf3d3 Kg7h6 Qd3d2+ Kh6g7
33 02:09 144.713.454 1.118.668 +1.39 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Qd3d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d6 Re5g5 Qd6d3 Rg5c5 Kf4e4 Rc5g5 Qd3f3 Rg5g1 Ke4f4 Rg1g5 Qf3c6 Rg5h5 Qc6c3 Rh5e5 Qc3c2 Re5g5 Qc2e2 Kg7g6 Qe2e4+ Kg6h6 Qe4c4 Kh6g7 Qc4c8 Rg5b5 Qc8g4+ Rb5g5 Qg4f3 Kg7g6 Qf3c3 Rg5f5+ Kf4e3 Rf5e5+ Ke3d4 Kg6g7 Qc3c6 Kg7g6 Qc6g2+ Kg6h7 Qg2g4 Re5g5 Qg4f3 Kh7g7 Qf3f4 Rg5h5 Qf4g4+ Rh5g5 Qg4f3 Rg5e5 Qf3d3 Kg7h6 Qd3d2+ Kh6g7
34 03:44 249.748.793 1.112.164 +1.40 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Kf4e4 Rg5g4+ Ke4d5 Rg4g5+ Kd5c4 Rg5g4+ Kc4c3 Rg4g5 Qd3e4 Rg5c5+ Kc3d4 Rc5g5 Qe4f3 Rg5e5 Qf3d3 Re5g5 Qd3h3 Rg5g1 Qh3h4 Rg1g5 Qh4f4 Rg5e5 Qf4g4+ Re5g5 Qg4e4 Rg5g1 Kd4d3 Rg1g5 Qe4f3 Kg7g6 Qf3f4 Rg5g1 Kd3c4 f6f5 Qf4d6+ f7f6 Qd6b8 Rg1g4+ Kc4d3 Kg6g5 Qb8g8+ Kg5h6 Qg8f7 Rg4g6 Qf7d7 Rg6g3+ Kd3c4 Kh6g6 Qd7e8+ Kg6g7 Qe8d7+ Kg7g6
34 03:45 249.890.389 1.112.331 +1.40 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Kf4e4 Rg5g4+ Ke4d5 Rg4g5+ Kd5c4 Rg5g4+ Kc4c3 Rg4g5 Qd3e4 Rg5c5+ Kc3d4 Rc5g5 Qe4f3 Rg5e5 Qf3d3 Re5g5 Qd3h3 Rg5g1 Qh3h4 Rg1g5 Qh4f4 Rg5e5 Qf4g4+ Re5g5 Qg4e4 Rg5g1 Kd4d3 Rg1g5 Qe4f3 Kg7g6 Qf3f4 Rg5g1 Kd3c4 f6f5 Qf4d6+ f7f6 Qd6b8 Rg1g4+ Kc4d3 Kg6g5 Qb8g8+ Kg5h6 Qg8f7 Rg4g6 Qf7d7 Rg6g3+ Kd3c4 Kh6g6 Qd7e8+ Kg6g7 Qe8d7+ Kg7g6
35 04:07 275.941.939 1.115.158 +1.40 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Kf4e4 Rg5e5+ Ke4d4 Re5g5 Qd3e4 Rg5e5 Qe4c6 Kg7g6 Qc6f3 Re5g5 Qf3e4+ Kg6g7 Qe4c6 Rg5g4+ Kd4d5 Rg4g5+ Kd5d6 Rg5e5 Qc6g2+ Re5g5 Qg2h2 Rg5g4 Qh2c2 Rg4g3 Qc2c4 Rg3g5 Qc4c3 Rg5e5 Qc3d4 Kg7g6 Qd4d3+ Kg6h6 Qd3g3 Re5g5 Qg3h4+ Kh6g7 Qh4d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d2 Re5e6+ Kd6d5 Re6e5+ Kd5d4 Re5g5 Qd2f4 Kg7g6 Kd4c3 Rg5c5+ Kc3d3 Rc5a5 Qf4e4+ Kg6g5 Kd3d2 Ra5a6 Qe4g2+ Kg5h4
35 04:07 276.123.530 1.115.400 +1.40 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Kf4e4 Rg5e5+ Ke4d4 Re5g5 Qd3e4 Rg5e5 Qe4c6 Kg7g6 Qc6f3 Re5g5 Qf3e4+ Kg6g7 Qe4c6 Rg5g4+ Kd4d5 Rg4g5+ Kd5d6 Rg5e5 Qc6g2+ Re5g5 Qg2h2 Rg5g4 Qh2c2 Rg4g3 Qc2c4 Rg3g5 Qc4c3 Rg5e5 Qc3d4 Kg7g6 Qd4d3+ Kg6h6 Qd3g3 Re5g5 Qg3h4+ Kh6g7 Qh4d4 Rg5e5 Qd4d2 Re5e6+ Kd6d5 Re6e5+ Kd5d4 Re5g5 Qd2f4 Kg7g6 Kd4c3 Rg5c5+ Kc3d3 Rc5a5 Qf4e4+ Kg6g5 Kd3d2 Ra5a6 Qe4g2+ Kg5h4
36 04:40 313.638.070 1.120.746 +1.40 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Kf4e4 Rg5e5+ Ke4d4 Re5g5 Qd3e4 Rg5e5 Qe4c6 Kg7g6 Qc6f3 Re5g5 Qf3e4+ Kg6g7 Qe4c6 Rg5g4+ Kd4d5 Rg4g5+ Kd5d6 Rg5e5 Qc6g2+ Re5g5 Qg2h2 Rg5g4 Qh2c2 Rg4g3 Qc2c4 Rg3g5 Qc4c3 Rg5e5 Qc3d4 Kg7g6 Qd4d3+ Kg6h6 Qd3g3 Re5g5 Qg3h4+ Kh6g7 Qh4c4 Rg5e5 Qc4g4+ Re5g5 Qg4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4f3 Re5e6+ Kd6c5 Re6e5+ Kc5d4 Kg7g6 Qf3g4+ Re5g5 Qg4f4 Rg5g1 Qf4e4+ Kg6h6 Kd4c3 Kh6g7 Qe4f4
36 04:42 315.803.008 1.121.294 +1.40 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Kf4e4 Rg5e5+ Ke4d4 Re5g5 Qd3e4 Rg5e5 Qe4c6 Kg7g6 Qc6f3 Re5g5 Qf3e4+ Kg6g7 Qe4c6 Rg5g4+ Kd4d5 Rg4g5+ Kd5d6 Rg5e5 Qc6g2+ Re5g5 Qg2h2 Rg5g4 Qh2c2 Rg4g3 Qc2c4 Rg3g5 Qc4c3 Rg5e5 Qc3d4 Kg7g6 Qd4d3+ Kg6h6 Qd3g3 Re5g5 Qg3h4+ Kh6g7 Qh4c4 Rg5e5 Qc4g4+ Re5g5 Qg4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4f3 Re5e6+ Kd6c5 Re6e5+ Kc5d4 Kg7g6 Qf3g4+ Re5g5 Qg4f4 Rg5g1 Qf4e4+ Kg6h6 Kd4c3 Kh6g7 Qe4f4
37 05:32 370.975.979 1.117.084 +1.40 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Kf4e4 Rg5e5+ Ke4d4 Re5g5 Qd3e4 Rg5e5 Qe4c6 Kg7g6 Qc6f3 Re5g5 Qf3e4+ Kg6g7 Qe4c6 Rg5g4+ Kd4d5 Rg4g5+ Kd5d6 Rg5e5 Qc6g2+ Re5g5 Qg2h2 Rg5g4 Qh2c2 Rg4g3 Qc2c4 Rg3g5 Qc4c3 Rg5e5 Qc3d4 Kg7g6 Qd4d3+ Kg6h6 Qd3g3 Re5g5 Qg3h4+ Kh6g7 Qh4c4 Rg5e5 Qc4g4+ Re5g5 Qg4f3 Rg5e5 Qf3g3+ Kg7f8 Qg3g4 Re5e6+ Kd6d5 Re6e5+ Kd5d4 f6f5 Qg4f3 Re5e4+ Kd4c3 Re4e5 Qf3f4 f7f6 Qf4b4+
37 05:34 373.167.858 1.117.177 +1.40 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Kf4e4 Rg5e5+ Ke4d4 Re5g5 Qd3e4 Rg5e5 Qe4c6 Kg7g6 Qc6f3 Re5g5 Qf3e4+ Kg6g7 Qe4c6 Rg5g4+ Kd4d5 Rg4g5+ Kd5d6 Rg5e5 Qc6g2+ Re5g5 Qg2h2 Rg5g4 Qh2c2 Rg4g3 Qc2c4 Rg3g5 Qc4c3 Rg5e5 Qc3d4 Kg7g6 Qd4d3+ Kg6h6 Qd3g3 Re5g5 Qg3h4+ Kh6g7 Qh4c4 Rg5e5 Qc4g4+ Re5g5 Qg4f3 Rg5e5 Qf3g3+ Kg7f8 Qg3g4 Re5e6+ Kd6d5 Re6e5+ Kd5d4 f6f5 Qg4f3 Re5e4+ Kd4c3 Re4e5 Qf3f4 f7f6 Qf4b4+
38 07:47 519.717.580 1.111.878 +1.40 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Kf4e4 Rg5e5+ Ke4d4 Re5g5 Qd3e4 Rg5e5 Qe4c6 Kg7g6 Qc6f3 Re5g5 Qf3e4+ Kg6g7 Qe4c6 Rg5g4+ Kd4d5 Rg4g5+ Kd5d6 Rg5e5 Qc6g2+ Re5g5 Qg2h2 Rg5g4 Qh2c2 Rg4g3 Qc2c4 Rg3g5 Qc4c3 Rg5e5 Qc3d4 Kg7g6 Qd4d3+ Kg6h6 Qd3g3 Re5g5 Qg3h4+ Kh6g7 Qh4c4 Rg5e5 Qc4c3 Re5e6+ Kd6c5 Re6e5+ Kc5b4 Kg7g6 Qc3c6 Kg6g7 Qc6g2+ Re5g5 Qg2f3 Kg7g6 Qf3e4+ Kg6h6 Kb4c4 Kh6g7 Kc4c3 Rg5g3+ Kc3d4
38 07:58 531.050.847 1.110.297 +1.40 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Kf4e4 Rg5e5+ Ke4d4 Re5g5 Qd3e4 Rg5e5 Qe4c6 Kg7g6 Qc6f3 Re5g5 Qf3e4+ Kg6g7 Qe4c6 Rg5g4+ Kd4d5 Rg4g5+ Kd5d6 Rg5e5 Qc6g2+ Re5g5 Qg2h2 Rg5g4 Qh2c2 Rg4g3 Qc2c4 Rg3g5 Qc4c3 Rg5e5 Qc3d4 Kg7g6 Qd4d3+ Kg6h6 Qd3g3 Re5g5 Qg3h4+ Kh6g7 Qh4c4 Rg5e5 Qc4c3 Re5e6+ Kd6c5 Re6e5+ Kc5b4 Kg7g6 Qc3c6 Kg6g7 Qc6g2+ Re5g5 Qg2f3 Kg7g6 Qf3e4+ Kg6h6 Kb4c4 Kh6g7 Kc4c3 Rg5g3+ Kc3d4
39 12:50 752.160.500 976.738 +1.40 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Kf4e4 Rg5e5+ Ke4d4 Re5g5 Qd3e4 Rg5e5 Qe4c6 Kg7g6 Qc6f3 Re5g5 Qf3e4+ Kg6g7 Qe4c6 Rg5g4+ Kd4d5 Rg4g5+ Kd5d6 Rg5e5 Qc6g2+ Re5g5 Qg2h2 Rg5g4 Qh2c2 Rg4g3 Qc2c4 Rg3g5 Qc4c3 Rg5e5 Qc3d4 Kg7g6 Qd4d3+ Kg6h6 Qd3g3 Re5g5 Qg3h4+ Kh6g7 Qh4c4 Rg5e5 Qc4c3 Re5e6+ Kd6c5 Re6e5+ Kc5b4 Kg7g6 Qc3c6 Kg6g7 Qc6g2+ Kg7f8 Kb4c3 Re5g5 Qg2e4 Kf8g7 Kc3b4 Rg5g6 Qe4d4 Rg6g5 Qd4c4
39 12:55 756.496.625 976.471 +1.40 Qd7d4 Re5g5 Qd4e4 Rg5e5 Qe4d3 Re5g5 Kf4e4 Rg5e5+ Ke4d4 Re5g5 Qd3e4 Rg5e5 Qe4c6 Kg7g6 Qc6f3 Re5g5 Qf3e4+ Kg6g7 Qe4c6 Rg5g4+ Kd4d5 Rg4g5+ Kd5d6 Rg5e5 Qc6g2+ Re5g5 Qg2h2 Rg5g4 Qh2c2 Rg4g3 Qc2c4 Rg3g5 Qc4c3 Rg5e5 Qc3d4 Kg7g6 Qd4d3+ Kg6h6 Qd3g3 Re5g5 Qg3h4+ Kh6g7 Qh4c4 Rg5e5 Qc4c3 Re5e6+ Kd6c5 Re6e5+ Kc5b4 Kg7g6 Qc3c6 Kg6g7 Qc6g2+ Kg7f8 Kb4c3 Re5g5 Qg2e4 Kf8g7 Kc3b4 Rg5g6 Qe4d4 Rg6g5 Qd4c4

Crafty-23.4-win32:
12 00:00 202.114 1.443.671 +4.33 1. Qg4+ Rg5 2. Qf3 Re5 3. Qh3 Ra5 4. Qc3 Re5 5. Qg3+ Rg5 6. Qh2 Re5 7. Qg1+ Kh7 8. Qd4
13 00:00 286.757 1.593.094 +4.32 1. Qg4+ Rg5 2. Qf3 Re5 3. Qh3 Ra5 4. Qc3 Re5 5. Qg3+ Rg5 6. Qh2 Re5 7. Qg1+ Kh7 8. Qd4 Kg6
13 00:00 296.570 1.647.611 +4.32 1. Qg4+ Rg5 2. Qf3 Re5 3. Qh3 Ra5 4. Qc3 Re5 5. Qg3+ Rg5 6. Qh2 Re5 7. Qg1+ Kh7 8. Qd4 Kg6
14 00:00 343.203 1.716.015 +4.33 1. Qg4+ Rg5 2. Qf3 Re5 3. Qh3 Ra5 4. Qc3 Re5 5. Qg3+ Rg5 6. Qh2 Re5 7. Qg1+ Rg5 8. Qf2 Re5 9. Qd4
14 00:00 366.305 1.665.022 +4.33 1. Qg4+ Rg5 2. Qf3 Re5 3. Qh3 Ra5 4. Qc3 Re5 5. Qg3+ Rg5 6. Qh2 Re5 7. Qg1+ Rg5 8. Qf2 Re5 9. Qd4
15 00:00 450.155 1.731.365 +4.35 1. Qg4+ Rg5 2. Qf3 Re5 3. Qh3 Ra5 4. Qc3 Re5 5. Qg3+ Rg5 6. Qe3 Re5 7. Qb3 Kg6 8. Qg3+ Kh7 9. Qg4 Rc5 10. Qh3+ Kg6 11. Qg3+ Kh5 12. Qg4+ Kh6
15 00:00 470.103 1.808.088 +4.35 1. Qg4+ Rg5 2. Qf3 Re5 3. Qh3 Ra5 4. Qc3 Re5 5. Qg3+ Rg5 6. Qe3 Re5 7. Qb3 Kg6 8. Qg3+ Kh7 9. Qg4 Rc5 10. Qh3+ Kg6 11. Qg3+ Kh5 12. Qg4+ Kh6
16 00:00 557.731 1.799.132 +4.35 1. Qg4+ Rg5 2. Qf3 Re5 3. Qh3 Ra5 4. Qc3 Re5 5. Qg3+ Rg5 6. Qe3 Re5 7. Qb3 Kg6 8. Qg3+ Kh7 9. Qg4 Rc5 10. Qh3+ Kg6 11. Qg3+ Kh5 12. Qg4+ Kh6
16 00:00 562.843 1.815.622 +4.35 1. Qg4+ Rg5 2. Qf3 Re5 3. Qh3 Ra5 4. Qc3 Re5 5. Qg3+ Rg5 6. Qe3 Re5 7. Qb3 Kg6 8. Qg3+ Kh7 9. Qg4 Rc5 10. Qh3+ Kg6 11. Qg3+ Kh5 12. Qg4+ Kh6
17 00:00 692.882 1.872.654 +4.35 1. Qg4+ Rg5 2. Qf3 Re5 3. Qh3 Ra5 4. Qc3 Re5 5. Qg3+ Rg5 6. Qe3 Re5 7. Qb3 Kg6 8. Qg3+ Kh7 9. Qg4 Rc5 10. Qh3+ Kg6 11. Qg3+ Kh5 12. Qg4+ Kh6
17 00:00 707.257 1.911.505 +4.35 1. Qg4+ Rg5 2. Qf3 Re5 3. Qh3 Ra5 4. Qc3 Re5 5. Qg3+ Rg5 6. Qe3 Re5 7. Qb3 Kg6 8. Qg3+ Kh7 9. Qg4 Rc5 10. Qh3+ Kg6 11. Qg3+ Kh5 12. Qg4+ Kh6
18 00:00 1.495.952 1.824.331 +4.33 1. Qg4+ Rg5 2. Qf3 Re5 3. Qh3 Ra5 4. Qc3 Re5 5. Qg3+ Rg5 6. Qe3 Re5 7. Qb3 Kg6 8. Qd3+ Kh6 9. Qh3+ Kg7 10. Qg2+ Rg5 11. Qf2 Re5 12. Qd4
18 00:00 1.539.446 1.832.673 +4.33 1. Qg4+ Rg5 2. Qf3 Re5 3. Qh3 Ra5 4. Qc3 Re5 5. Qg3+ Rg5 6. Qe3 Re5 7. Qb3 Kg6 8. Qd3+ Kh6 9. Qh3+ Kg7 10. Qg2+ Rg5 11. Qf2 Re5 12. Qd4
19 00:04 8.343.459 1.913.637 +4.37 1. Qg4+ Rg5 2. Qh4 Rg2 3. Qh5 Rg1 4. Qf3 Kf8 5. Qd5 Kg7 6. Qd3 Rg2 7. Qf3 Rg1 8. Qf2 Rg5 9. Qh2 Re5 10. Qd2 Kg6 11. Qg2+ Kh7 12. Qg4 Rc5 13. Qh3+ Kg6 14. Qd3+ Kh6
19 00:04 8.353.325 1.915.900 +4.37 1. Qg4+ Rg5 2. Qh4 Rg2 3. Qh5 Rg1 4. Qf3 Kf8 5. Qd5 Kg7 6. Qd3 Rg2 7. Qf3 Rg1 8. Qf2 Rg5 9. Qh2 Re5 10. Qd2 Kg6 11. Qg2+ Kh7 12. Qg4 Rc5 13. Qh3+ Kg6 14. Qd3+ Kh6
20 00:07 13.735.713 1.970.690 +4.35 1. Qg4+ Rg5 2. Qh4 Rg2 3. Qh3 Rg1 4. Qe3 Rg5 5. Qe2 Re5 6. Qf3 Kh7 7. Qg3 Rg5 8. Qd3+ Kg7 9. Qd2 Re5 10. Qd7 Kg6 11. Qh3 Rc5 12. Qg4+ Kh6
20 00:15 30.789.525 2.052.635 +4.35 1. Qg4+ Rg5 2. Qh4 Rg2 3. Qh3 Rg1 4. Qe3 Rg5 5. Qe2 Re5 6. Qf3 Kh7 7. Qg3 Rg5 8. Qd3+ Kg7 9. Qd2 Re5 10. Qd7 Kg6 11. Qh3 Rc5 12. Qg4+ Kh6
21 00:16 32.614.107 2.038.381 +4.36 1. Qg4+ Rg5 2. Qh4 Rg2 3. Qh3 Rg1 4. Qe3 Rg5 5. Qe2 Re5 6. Qf3 Kh7 7. Qg3 Rg5 8. Qh2+ Kg7 9. Qf2 Re5 10. Qd4 Kh7 11. Qd1 Kg6 12. Qd3+ Kh6 13. Qg3 Kh7 14. Qg4 Rc5 15. Qd1 Re5 16. Qb1+ Kh6 17. Qd3 Rg5 18. Qf3 Rc5 19. Qa8 Kh7 20. Qf3
21 00:16 32.635.917 2.039.744 +4.36 1. Qg4+ Rg5 2. Qh4 Rg2 3. Qh3 Rg1 4. Qe3 Rg5 5. Qe2 Re5 6. Qf3 Kh7 7. Qg3 Rg5 8. Qh2+ Kg7 9. Qf2 Re5 10. Qd4 Kh7 11. Qd1 Kg6 12. Qd3+ Kh6 13. Qg3 Kh7 14. Qg4 Rc5 15. Qd1 Re5 16. Qb1+ Kh6 17. Qd3 Rg5 18. Qf3 Rc5 19. Qa8 Kh7 20. Qf3
22 00:17 35.035.839 2.060.931 +4.36 1. Qg4+ Rg5 2. Qh4 Rg2 3. Qh3 Rg1 4. Qe3 Rg5 5. Qe2 Re5 6. Qf3 Kh7 7. Qg3 Rg5 8. Qh2+ Kg7 9. Qf2 Re5 10. Qd4 Kh7 11. Qd1 Kg6 12. Qd3+ Kh6 13. Qg3 Kh7 14. Qg4 Rc5 15. Qd1 Re5 16. Qb1+ Kh6 17. Qd3 Rg5 18. Qf3 Rc5 19. Qa8 Kh7 20. Qf3
22 00:17 35.080.763 2.063.574 +4.36 1. Qg4+ Rg5 2. Qh4 Rg2 3. Qh3 Rg1 4. Qe3 Rg5 5. Qe2 Re5 6. Qf3 Kh7 7. Qg3 Rg5 8. Qh2+ Kg7 9. Qf2 Re5 10. Qd4 Kh7 11. Qd1 Kg6 12. Qd3+ Kh6 13. Qg3 Kh7 14. Qg4 Rc5 15. Qd1 Re5 16. Qb1+ Kh6 17. Qd3 Rg5 18. Qf3 Rc5 19. Qa8 Kh7 20. Qf3
23 00:25 49.428.930 1.977.157 +4.36 1. Qg4+ Rg5 2. Qh4 Rg2 3. Qh3 Rg1 4. Qe3 Rg5 5. Qe2 Re5 6. Qf3 Kh7 7. Qg3 Rg5 8. Qh2+ Kg7 9. Qf2 Re5 10. Qd4 Kh7 11. Qd1 Kg6 12. Qd3+ Kh6 13. Qg3 Kh7 14. Qg4 Rc5 15. Qd1 Re5 16. Qb1+ Kh6 17. Qd3 Rg5 18. Qf3 Rc5 19. Qa8 Kh7 20. Qf3
23 00:27 54.202.408 2.007.496 +4.36 1. Qg4+ Rg5 2. Qh4 Rg2 3. Qh3 Rg1 4. Qe3 Rg5 5. Qe2 Re5 6. Qf3 Kh7 7. Qg3 Rg5 8. Qh2+ Kg7 9. Qf2 Re5 10. Qd4 Kh7 11. Qd1 Kg6 12. Qd3+ Kh6 13. Qg3 Kh7 14. Qg4 Rc5 15. Qd1 Re5 16. Qb1+ Kh6 17. Qd3 Rg5 18. Qf3 Rc5 19. Qa8 Kh7 20. Qf3
24 00:53 105.353.743 1.987.806 +4.36 1. Qg4+ Rg5 2. Qh4 Rg2 3. Qh3 Rg1 4. Qe3 Rg5 5. Qe2 Re5 6. Qf3 Kh7 7. Qg3 Rg5 8. Qh2+ Kg7 9. Qf2 Re5 10. Qd4 Kh7 11. Qd1 Kg6 12. Qd3+ Kh6 13. Qg3 Kh7 14. Qg4 Rc5 15. Qd1 Re5 16. Qb1+ Kh6 17. Qd3 Rg5 18. Qf3 Rc5 19. Qa8 Kh7 20. Qf3
24 00:53 105.431.416 1.989.272 +4.36 1. Qg4+ Rg5 2. Qh4 Rg2 3. Qh3 Rg1 4. Qe3 Rg5 5. Qe2 Re5 6. Qf3 Kh7 7. Qg3 Rg5 8. Qh2+ Kg7 9. Qf2 Re5 10. Qd4 Kh7 11. Qd1 Kg6 12. Qd3+ Kh6 13. Qg3 Kh7 14. Qg4 Rc5 15. Qd1 Re5 16. Qb1+ Kh6 17. Qd3 Rg5 18. Qf3 Rc5 19. Qa8 Kh7 20. Qf3
25 01:09 136.958.517 1.984.906 +4.37 1. Qg4+ Rg5 2. Qh4 Rg2 3. Qh5 Rg5 4. Qf3 Re5 5. Qg3+ Rg5 6. Qh2 Rc5 7. Qg2+ Rg5 8. Qa8 Rg1 9. Qf3 Rg5 10. Qf1 Ra5 11. Qg1+ Rg5 12. Qd4 Rg2 13. Qd7 Ra2 14. Qg4+ Kf8 15. Kg3 Ra1 16. Kh3 Rh1+ 17. Kg2 Rb1 18. Qf5 Rb2+ 19. Kf3 Rb3+ 20. Ke2 Kg7 21. Qg4+ Kh6 22. Qg8 Rb2+ 23. Kd3 Rb7 24. Ke4 Rc7 25. Kf5
25 01:09 137.059.272 1.986.366 +4.37 1. Qg4+ Rg5 2. Qh4 Rg2 3. Qh5 Rg5 4. Qf3 Re5 5. Qg3+ Rg5 6. Qh2 Rc5 7. Qg2+ Rg5 8. Qa8 Rg1 9. Qf3 Rg5 10. Qf1 Ra5 11. Qg1+ Rg5 12. Qd4 Rg2 13. Qd7 Ra2 14. Qg4+ Kf8 15. Kg3 Ra1 16. Kh3 Rh1+ 17. Kg2 Rb1 18. Qf5 Rb2+ 19. Kf3 Rb3+ 20. Ke2 Kg7 21. Qg4+ Kh6 22. Qg8 Rb2+ 23. Kd3 Rb7 24. Ke4 Rc7 25. Kf5
26 04:16 500.862.607 1.964.167 +4.37 1. Qg4+ Rg5 2. Qh4 Rg2 3. Qh5 Rg5 4. Qf3 Re5 5. Qg3+ Rg5 6. Qh2 Rc5 7. Qg2+ Rg5 8. Qa8 Rg1 9. Qf3 Rg5 10. Qf1 Ra5 11. Qg1+ Rg5 12. Qd4 Rg2 13. Qd7 Ra2 14. Qg4+ Kf8 15. Kg3 Ra1 16. Kh3 Rh1+ 17. Kg2 Rb1 18. Qf5 Rb2+ 19. Kf3 Rb3+ 20. Ke2 Kg7 21. Qg4+ Kh6 22. Qg8 Rb2+ 23. Kd3 Rb7 24. Ke4 Rc7 25. Kf5
26 05:22 628.669.592 1.952.390 +4.37 1. Qg4+ Rg5 2. Qh4 Rg2 3. Qh5 Rg5 4. Qf3 Re5 5. Qg3+ Rg5 6. Qh2 Rc5 7. Qg2+ Rg5 8. Qa8 Rg1 9. Qf3 Rg5 10. Qf1 Ra5 11. Qg1+ Rg5 12. Qd4 Rg2 13. Qd7 Ra2 14. Qg4+ Kf8 15. Kg3 Ra1 16. Kh3 Rh1+ 17. Kg2 Rb1 18. Qf5 Rb2+ 19. Kf3 Rb3+ 20. Ke2 Kg7 21. Qg4+ Kh6 22. Qg8 Rb2+ 23. Kd3 Rb7 24. Ke4 Rc7 25. Kf5
27 05:54 692.393.092 1.955.912 +4.38 1. Qg4+ Rg5 2. Qh4 Rg2 3. Qh5 Rg5 4. Qf3 Re5 5. Qg3+ Rg5 6. Qh2 Rc5 7. Qg2+ Rg5 8. Qb7 Re5 9. Qb6 Rh5 10. Qg1+ Rg5 11. Qf1 Ra5 12. Qg1+ Rg5 13. Qd4 Rg2 14. Qd7 Rg1 15. Qd4 Rf1+ 16. Kg3 Rf5 17. Kg4 Rg5+ 18. Kf4 Rg2 19. Qe4 Rb2 20. Qe1 Rg2 21. Qf1 Rg5 22. Qf2 Re5 23. Qg2+ Kh7 24. Qg3 Rc5 25. Qd3+ Kg7 26. Qd4 Re5 27. Qc3 Kg6 28. Qc2+ Kh6 29. Qf2 Rh5 30. Qe3
27 06:01 705.069.693 1.953.101 +4.38 1. Qg4+ Rg5 2. Qh4 Rg2 3. Qh5 Rg5 4. Qf3 Re5 5. Qg3+ Rg5 6. Qh2 Rc5 7. Qg2+ Rg5 8. Qb7 Re5 9. Qb6 Rh5 10. Qg1+ Rg5 11. Qf1 Ra5 12. Qg1+ Rg5 13. Qd4 Rg2 14. Qd7 Rg1 15. Qd4 Rf1+ 16. Kg3 Rf5 17. Kg4 Rg5+ 18. Kf4 Rg2 19. Qe4 Rb2 20. Qe1 Rg2 21. Qf1 Rg5 22. Qf2 Re5 23. Qg2+ Kh7 24. Qg3 Rc5 25. Qd3+ Kg7 26. Qd4 Re5 27. Qc3 Kg6 28. Qc2+ Kh6 29. Qf2 Rh5 30. Qe3
28 07:49 914.854.787 1.954.817 +4.38 1. Qg4+ Rg5 2. Qh4 Rg2 3. Qh3 Rg1 4. Qe3 Rg5 5. Qe8 Re5 6. Qd7 Kg6 7. Qg4+ Rg5 8. Qc8 Kg7 9. Qc2 Re5 10. Qd3 Ra5 11. Qe4 Ra2 12. Qe1 Rg2 13. Qf1 Rg5 14. Qf2 Re5 15. Qg2+ Kh7 16. Qg3 Rc5 17. Qd3+ Kg7 18. Qd4 Re5 19. Qc3 Kg6 20. Qc2+ Kh6 21. Qf2 Rh5 22. Qe3
28 07:49 915.025.497 1.951.013 +4.38 1. Qg4+ Rg5 2. Qh4 Rg2 3. Qh3 Rg1 4. Qe3 Rg5 5. Qe8 Re5 6. Qd7 Kg6 7. Qg4+ Rg5 8. Qc8 Kg7 9. Qc2 Re5 10. Qd3 Ra5 11. Qe4 Ra2 12. Qe1 Rg2 13. Qf1 Rg5 14. Qf2 Re5 15. Qg2+ Kh7 16. Qg3 Rc5 17. Qd3+ Kg7 18. Qd4 Re5 19. Qc3 Kg6 20. Qc2+ Kh6 21. Qf2 Rh5 22. Qe3
29 11:25 1.181.089.769 2.050.503 +4.38 1. Qg4+ Rg5 2. Qh4 Rg2 3. Qh3 Rg1 4. Qe3 Rg5 5. Qe8 Re5 6. Qd7 Kg6 7. Qg4+ Rg5 8. Qc8 Kg7 9. Qc2 Re5 10. Qd3 Ra5 11. Qe4 Ra2 12. Qd5 Rb2 13. Qd7 Ra2 14. Qd4 Rg2 15. Qd7 Rg1 16. Qd4 Rf1+ 17. Kg3 Rf5 18. Kg4 Rg5+ 19. Kf4 Rg2 20. Qe4 Rb2 21. Qe1 Rg2 22. Qf1 Rg5 23. Qf2 Re5 24. Qg2+ Kh7 25. Qg3 Rc5 26. Qd3+ Kg7 27. Qd4 Re5 28. Qc3 Kg6 29. Qc2+ Kh6 30. Qf2 Rh5 31. Qe3
29 11:25 1.181.716.072 2.051.590 +4.38 1. Qg4+ Rg5 2. Qh4 Rg2 3. Qh3 Rg1 4. Qe3 Rg5 5. Qe8 Re5 6. Qd7 Kg6 7. Qg4+ Rg5 8. Qc8 Kg7 9. Qc2 Re5 10. Qd3 Ra5 11. Qe4 Ra2 12. Qd5 Rb2 13. Qd7 Ra2 14. Qd4 Rg2 15. Qd7 Rg1 16. Qd4 Rf1+ 17. Kg3 Rf5 18. Kg4 Rg5+ 19. Kf4 Rg2 20. Qe4 Rb2 21. Qe1 Rg2 22. Qf1 Rg5 23. Qf2 Re5 24. Qg2+ Kh7 25. Qg3 Rc5 26. Qd3+ Kg7 27. Qd4 Re5 28. Qc3 Kg6 29. Qc2+ Kh6 30. Qf2 Rh5 31. Qe3
pichy
Posts: 2564
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 3:04 am

Re: What engine can evaluate this draw ending correctly w/o

Post by pichy »

I am starting to see why Houdini is the best engine :wink:


FEN: 8/3Q1pk1/5p2/4r3/5K2/8/8/8 w - - 0 1

Houdini_15_w32:
4/10 00:00 342 0 +0.03 Qd7d8 Re5e6 Kf4f5 Re6e5+ Kf5g4 Re5e6 Qd8d4 Re6e5 Kg4h4 Re5g5 Qd4b6 Rg5g6 Qb6b8 Rg6h6+ Kh4g4 Rh6g6+ Kg4f5 Rg6g5+ Kf5e4 Rg5g6 Qb8a8 f6f5+ Ke4xf5 Rg6e6 Qa8a1+ Kg7g8 Qa1c3 Re6g6 Qc3c8+ Kg8g7 Qc8d8 Rg6e6 Qd8d4+ Kg7g8 Qd4h4 Kg8g7 Qh4d8 Re6g6 Qd8d4+ Kg7g8 Qd4h4 Kg8g7 Qh4d8 Rg6e6
5/44 00:00 482 0 +0.03 Qd7d8 Re5e6 Kf4f5 Re6e5+ Kf5g4 Re5e6 Qd8d4 Re6e5 Kg4h4 Re5g5 Qd4b6 Rg5g6 Qb6b8 Rg6h6+ Kh4g4 Rh6g6+ Kg4f5 Rg6g5+ Kf5e4 Rg5g6 Qb8a8 f6f5+ Ke4xf5 Rg6e6 Qa8a1+ Kg7g8 Qa1c3 Re6g6 Qc3c8+ Kg8g7 Qc8d8 Rg6e6 Qd8d4+ Kg7g8 Qd4h4 Kg8g7 Qh4d8 Re6g6 Qd8d4+ Kg7g8 Qd4h4 Kg8g7 Qh4d8 Rg6e6
6/44 00:00 657 0 +0.03 Qd7d8 Re5e6 Kf4f5 Re6e5+ Kf5g4 Re5g5+ Kg4h4 Rg5g6 Qd8c8 Rg6h6+ Kh4g3 Rh6g6+ Kg3f4 f6f5 Qc8c3+ Kg7g8 Kf4xf5 Rg6e6 Qc3c5 Re6g6 Qc5c8+ Kg8g7 Qc8d8 Rg6e6 Qd8d4+ Kg7g8 Qd4h4 Kg8g7 Qh4d8 Re6g6 Qd8d4+ Kg7g8 Qd4h4 Kg8g7 Qh4d8 Rg6e6
7/44 00:00 852 0 +0.03 Qd7d8 Re5e6 Kf4f5 Re6e5+ Kf5g4 Re5g5+ Kg4h4 Rg5g6 Qd8c8 Rg6h6+ Kh4g3 Rh6g6+ Kg3f4 f6f5 Qc8c3+ Kg7g8 Kf4xf5 Rg6e6 Qc3c5 Re6g6 Qc5c8+ Kg8g7 Qc8d8 Rg6e6 Qd8d4+ Kg7g8 Qd4h4 Kg8g7 Qh4d8 Re6g6 Qd8d4+ Kg7g8 Qd4h4 Kg8g7 Qh4d8 Rg6e6
8/44 00:00 1.286 0 +0.03 Qd7d8 Re5e6 Kf4f5 Re6e5+ Kf5g4 Re5e6 Kg4f4 f6f5 Kf4xf5 Re6g6 Qd8d4+ Kg7g8 Qd4h4 Kg8g7 Qh4d8 Rg6e6 Qd8d4+ Kg7g8 Qd4h4 Kg8g7 Qh4d8 Re6g6
9/44 00:00 1.685 0 +0.03 Qd7d8 Re5e6 Kf4f5 Re6e5+ Kf5g4 Re5e6 Qd8d4 Kg7g8 Kg4f5 Kg8g7 Qd4g4+ Kg7f8 Qg4h3 Kf8g7 Qh3g2+ Kg7f8 Qg2a8+ Kf8g7 Qa8b8 Re6e5+ Kf5g4 Re5e6 Kg4f4 f6f5 Qb8b2+ Kg7g8 Qb2g2+ Kg8f8 Qg2a8+ Kf8g7 Qa8a1+ Kg7g8 Kf4xf5 Re6g6 Qa1c3 Rg6e6 Qc3c5 Re6g6 Qc5c8+ Kg8g7 Qc8d8 Rg6e6
10/44 00:00 2.282 0 +0.03 Qd7d8 Re5e6 Kf4f5 Re6e5+ Kf5g4 Re5e6 Qd8d4 Kg7g8 Kg4f5 Kg8g7 Qd4g4+ Kg7f8 Qg4b4+ Kf8g8
11/44 00:00 2.830 0 +0.03 Qd7d8 Re5e6 Kf4f5 Re6e5+ Kf5g4 Re5e6 Qd8d4 Kg7g8 Kg4f5 Kg8g7 Qd4g4+ Kg7f8 Qg4h3 Kf8g7 Qh3g2+ Kg7f8 Qg2a8+ Kf8g7 Qa8b8 Re6e5+ Kf5g4 Re5e6 Kg4f4 f6f5 Qb8b2+ Kg7g8 Qb2g2+ Kg8f8 Qg2a8+ Kf8g7 Qa8a1+ Kg7g8 Kf4xf5 Re6g6 Qa1c3 Rg6e6 Qc3c5 Re6g6 Qc5c8+ Kg8g7 Qc8d8 Rg6e6
12/44 00:00 3.697 0 +0.03 Qd7d8 Re5e6 Kf4f5 Re6e5+ Kf5g4 Re5e6 Qd8d4 Kg7g8 Kg4f5 Kg8g7 Qd4g4+ Kg7f8 Qg4h3 Kf8g7 Qh3g2+ Kg7f8 Qg2a8+ Kf8g7 Qa8b8 Re6e5+ Kf5g4 Re5e6 Kg4f4 f6f5 Qb8b2+ Kg7g8 Qb2g2+ Kg8f8 Qg2a8+ Kf8g7 Qa8a1+ Kg7g8 Kf4xf5 Re6g6 Qa1c3 Rg6e6 Qc3c5 Re6g6 Qc5c8+ Kg8g7 Qc8d8 Rg6e6
13/44 00:00 4.425 0 +0.03 Qd7d8 Re5e6 Kf4f5 Re6e5+ Kf5g4 Re5e6 Qd8d4 Kg7g8 Qd4c5 f6f5+ Qc5xf5 Kg8g7 Qf5b1 Re6g6+ Kg4f5 Rg6e6 Qb1b2+ Kg7g8
14/44 00:00 5.337 0 +0.03 Qd7d8 Re5e6 Kf4f5 Re6e5+ Kf5g4 Re5e6 Qd8d4 Kg7g8 Qd4c5 f6f5+ Qc5xf5 Kg8g7 Qf5b1 Re6g6+ Kg4f5 Rg6e6 Qb1b2+ Kg7g8
15/44 00:00 6.053 0 +0.03 Qd7d8 Re5e6 Kf4f5 Re6e5+ Kf5g4 Re5e6 Qd8d4 Kg7g8 Qd4c5 f6f5+ Qc5xf5 Kg8g7 Qf5b1 Re6g6+ Kg4f5 Rg6e6 Qb1b2+ Kg7g8
16/44 00:00 8.656 0 +0.03 Qd7d8 Re5e6 Kf4f5 Re6e5+ Kf5g4 Re5e6 Qd8d4 Kg7g8 Qd4c5 f6f5+ Qc5xf5 Kg8g7 Qf5b1 Re6g6+ Kg4f5 Rg6e6 Qb1b2+ Kg7g8 Qb2g2+ Re6g6
17/44 00:00 12.713 0 +0.03 Qd7d8 Re5e6 Kf4f5 Re6e5+ Kf5g4 Re5e6 Qd8d4 Kg7g8 Qd4c5 f6f5+ Qc5xf5 Kg8g7 Qf5b1 Re6g6+ Kg4f5 Rg6e6 Qb1b2+ Kg7g8 Qb2d4 Re6g6 Qd4h4 Kg8g7 Kf5f4 Rg6e6 Qh4h3 Kg7g8 Qh3g4+ Re6g6 Qg4c8+ Kg8g7 Qc8c3+ Kg7g8 Qc3e5 Rg6e6 Qe5g5+ Re6g6 Qg5d8+ Kg8g7 Kf4e4 Rg6e6+ Ke4f3 Re6g6 Qd8c8 Rg6e6 Qc8a8 Re6g6 Qa8b8 Rg6e6 Qb8g3+ Re6g6 Qg3e5+ Kg7g8 Qe5b8+ Kg8g7 Qb8c8 Rg6e6
18/56 00:00 20.090 0 +0.03 Qd7d8 Re5e6 Kf4f5 Re6e5+ Kf5g4 Re5e6 Qd8d4 Kg7g8 Qd4c5 f6f5+ Qc5xf5 Kg8g7 Qf5b1 Re6g6+ Kg4f5 Rg6e6 Qb1b2+ Kg7g8 Qb2d4 Re6g6 Qd4d8+ Kg8g7 Qd8d4+ Kg7g8 Qd4d8+
19/56 00:00 30.947 2.063.000 +0.03 Qd7d8 Re5e6 Kf4f5 Re6e5+ Kf5g4 Re5e6 Qd8d4 Kg7g8 Qd4c5 f6f5+ Qc5xf5 Kg8g7 Qf5b1 Re6g6+ Kg4f5 Rg6e6 Qb1b2+ Kg7g8 Qb2d4 Re6g6 Qd4h4 Kg8g7 Kf5f4 Rg6e6 Qh4h3 Kg7g8 Qh3g4+ Re6g6 Qg4c8+ Kg8g7 Qc8c3+ Kg7g8 Qc3e5 Rg6e6 Qe5g5+ Re6g6 Qg5d8+ Kg8g7 Kf4e4 Rg6e6+ Ke4f3 Re6g6 Qd8c8 Rg6e6 Qc8a8 Re6g6 Qa8b8 Rg6e6 Qb8g3+ Re6g6 Qg3e5+ Kg7g8 Qe5b8+ Kg8g7 Qb8c8 Rg6e6
20/56 00:00 49.264 3.284.000 +0.03 Qd7d8 Re5e6 Kf4f5 Re6e5+ Kf5g4 Re5e6 Qd8d4 Kg7g8 Qd4c5 f6f5+ Qc5xf5 Kg8g7 Qf5b1 Re6g6+ Kg4f5 Rg6e6 Qb1b2+ Kg7g8 Qb2d4 Re6g6 Qd4h4 Kg8g7 Kf5f4 Rg6e6 Qh4h3 Kg7g8 Qh3g4+ Re6g6 Qg4c8+ Kg8g7 Qc8c3+ Kg7g8 Qc3e5 Rg6e6 Qe5g5+ Re6g6 Qg5d8+ Kg8g7 Kf4e4 Rg6e6+ Ke4f3 Re6g6 Qd8c8 Rg6e6 Qc8a8 Re6g6 Qa8b8 Rg6e6 Qb8g3+ Re6g6 Qg3e5+ Kg7g8 Qe5b8+ Kg8g7 Qb8c8 Rg6e6
21/56 00:00 75.344 2.216.000 +0.03 Qd7d8 Re5e6 Kf4f5 Re6e5+ Kf5g4 Re5e6 Qd8d4 Kg7g8 Qd4c5 f6f5+ Qc5xf5 Kg8g7 Qf5b1 Re6g6+ Kg4f5 Rg6e6 Qb1b2+ Kg7g8 Qb2d4 Re6g6 Qd4h4 Kg8g7 Kf5f4 Rg6e6 Qh4h3 Kg7g8 Qh3g4+ Re6g6 Qg4c8+ Kg8g7 Qc8c3+ Kg7g8 Qc3e5 Rg6e6 Qe5g5+ Re6g6 Qg5d8+ Kg8g7 Kf4e4 Rg6e6+ Ke4f3 Re6g6 Qd8c8 Rg6e6 Qc8a8 Re6g6 Qa8b8 Rg6e6 Qb8g3+ Re6g6 Qg3e5+ Kg7g8 Qe5b8+ Kg8g7 Qb8c8 Rg6e6
22/56 00:00 119.531 905.000 +0.03 Qd7d8 Re5e6 Kf4f5 Re6e5+ Kf5g4 Re5e6 Qd8d4 Kg7g8 Qd4c5 f6f5+ Qc5xf5 Kg8g7 Qf5b1 Re6g6+ Kg4f5 Rg6e6 Qb1b2+ Kg7g8 Qb2d4 Re6g6 Qd4h4 Kg8g7 Kf5f4 Rg6e6 Qh4h3 Kg7g8 Qh3g4+ Re6g6 Qg4c8+ Kg8g7 Qc8c3+ Kg7g8 Qc3e5 Rg6e6 Qe5g5+ Re6g6 Qg5d8+ Kg8g7 Kf4e4 Rg6e6+ Ke4f3 Re6g6 Qd8c8 Rg6e6 Qc8a8 Re6g6 Qa8b8 Rg6e6 Qb8g3+ Re6g6 Qg3e5+ Kg7g8 Qe5b8+ Kg8g7 Qb8c8 Rg6e6
23/56 00:00 196.193 1.249.000 +0.03 Qd7d8 Re5e6 Kf4f5 Re6e5+ Kf5g4 Re5e6 Qd8d4 Kg7g8 Qd4c5 f6f5+ Qc5xf5 Kg8g7 Qf5b1 Re6g6+ Kg4f5 Rg6e6 Qb1b2+ Kg7g8 Qb2d4 Re6g6 Qd4h4 Kg8g7 Kf5f4 Rg6e6 Qh4h3 Kg7g8 Qh3g4+ Re6g6 Qg4c8+ Kg8g7 Qc8c3+ Kg7g8 Qc3e5 Rg6e6 Qe5g5+ Re6g6 Qg5d8+ Kg8g7 Kf4e4 Rg6e6+ Ke4f3 Re6g6 Qd8c8 Rg6e6 Qc8a8 Re6g6 Qa8b8 Rg6e6 Qb8g3+ Re6g6 Qg3e5+ Kg7g8 Qe5b8+ Kg8g7 Qb8c8 Rg6e6
24/56 00:00 315.505 1.467.000 +0.03 Qd7d8 Re5e6 Kf4f5 Re6e5+ Kf5g4 Re5e6 Qd8d4 Kg7g8 Qd4c5 f6f5+ Qc5xf5 Kg8g7 Qf5b1 Re6g6+ Kg4f5 Rg6e6 Qb1b2+ Kg7g8 Qb2d4 Re6g6 Qd4h4 Kg8g7 Kf5f4 Rg6e6 Qh4h3 Kg7g8 Qh3g4+ Re6g6 Qg4f5 Rg6e6 Qf5b1 Re6g6 Qb1b8+ Kg8g7 Qb8e5+ Kg7g8 Kf4f5 Rg6e6 Qe5b8+ Kg8g7 Qb8c8 Re6f6+ Kf5e5 Rf6e6+ Qc8xe6 f7xe6
25/56 00:00 499.816 1.694.000 +0.03 Qd7d8 Re5e6 Kf4f5 Re6e5+ Kf5g4 Re5e6 Qd8d4 Kg7g8 Qd4c5 f6f5+ Qc5xf5 Kg8g7 Qf5b1 Re6g6+ Kg4f5 Rg6e6 Qb1b2+ Kg7g8 Qb2d4 Re6g6 Qd4h4 Kg8g7 Kf5f4 Rg6e6 Qh4h3 Kg7g8 Qh3g4+ Re6g6 Qg4c8+ Kg8g7 Qc8c3+ Kg7g8 Qc3e5 Rg6e6 Qe5g5+ Re6g6 Qg5d8+ Kg8g7 Kf4e4 Rg6e6+ Ke4f3 Re6g6 Qd8c8 Rg6e6 Qc8a8 Re6g6 Qa8b8 Rg6e6 Qb8g3+ Re6g6 Qg3e5+
26/56 00:00 735.008 1.788.000 +0.03 Qd7d8 Re5e6 Kf4f5 Re6e5+ Kf5g4 Re5e6 Qd8d4 Kg7g8 Qd4c5 f6f5+ Qc5xf5 Kg8g7 Qf5b1 Re6g6+ Kg4f5 Rg6e6 Qb1b2+ Kg7g8 Qb2d4 Re6g6 Qd4h4 Kg8g7 Kf5f4 Rg6e6 Qh4h3 Kg7g8 Qh3g4+ Re6g6 Qg4c8+ Kg8g7 Qc8c3+ Kg7g8 Qc3e5 Rg6e6 Qe5g5+ Re6g6 Qg5d8+ Kg8g7 Kf4e4 Rg6e6+ Ke4f3 Re6g6 Qd8c8 Rg6e6 Qc8a8 Re6g6 Qa8b8 Rg6e6 Qb8g3+ Re6g6 Qg3e5+
27/56 00:00 1.126.072 1.979.000 +0.03 Qd7d8 Re5e6 Kf4f5 Re6e5+ Kf5g4 Re5e6 Qd8d4 Kg7g8 Qd4c5 f6f5+ Qc5xf5 Kg8g7 Qf5b1 Re6g6+ Kg4f5 Rg6e6 Qb1b2+ Kg7g8 Qb2d4 Re6g6 Qd4h4 Kg8g7 Kf5f4 Rg6e6 Qh4h3 Kg7g8 Qh3g4+ Re6g6 Qg4f5 Rg6e6
28/56 00:01 1.740.487 2.186.000 +0.03 Qd7d8 Re5e6 Kf4f5 Re6e5+ Kf5g4 Re5e6 Qd8d4 Kg7g8 Qd4c5 f6f5+ Qc5xf5 Kg8g7 Qf5b1 Re6g6+ Kg4f5 Rg6e6 Qb1b2+ Kg7g8 Qb2d4 Re6g6 Qd4h4 Kg8g7 Kf5f4 Rg6e6 Qh4h3 Kg7g8 Qh3g4+ Re6g6 Qg4f5 Rg6e6 Qf5g5+ Re6g6 Qg5d8+ Kg8g7 Kf4e4 Rg6e6+ Ke4f3 Re6g6 Qd8c8 Rg6e6 Qc8a8 Re6g6 Qa8b8 Rg6e6 Qb8g3+ Re6g6 Qg3e5+
29/56 00:01 2.585.961 2.268.000 +0.03 Qd7d8 Re5e6 Kf4f5 Re6e5+ Kf5g4 Re5e6 Qd8d4 Kg7g8 Qd4c5 f6f5+ Qc5xf5 Kg8g7 Qf5b1 Re6g6+ Kg4f5 Rg6e6 Qb1b2+ Kg7g8 Qb2d4 Re6g6 Qd4h4 Kg8g7 Kf5f4 Rg6e6 Qh4h3 Kg7g8 Qh3g4+ Re6g6 Qg4f5 Rg6e6 Qf5g5+ Re6g6 Qg5d8+ Kg8g7 Kf4e4 Rg6e6+ Ke4f3 Re6g6 Qd8c8 Rg6e6 Qc8a8 Re6g6 Qa8b8 Rg6e6 Qb8g3+ Re6g6 Qg3e5+
30/56 00:01 4.007.262 2.388.000 +0.03 Qd7d8 Re5e6 Kf4f5 Re6e5+ Kf5g4 Re5e6 Qd8d4 Kg7g8 Qd4c5 f6f5+ Qc5xf5 Kg8g7 Qf5b1 Re6g6+ Kg4f5 Rg6e6 Qb1b2+ Kg7g8 Qb2d4 Re6g6 Qd4h4 Kg8g7 Kf5f4 Rg6e6 Qh4h3 Kg7g8 Qh3g4+ Re6g6 Qg4f5 Rg6e6 Qf5g5+ Re6g6 Qg5d8+ Kg8g7 Qd8d4+ Kg7g8 Qd4d8+ Kg8g7
31/56 00:02 6.132.250 2.413.000 +0.03 Qd7d8 Re5e6 Kf4f5 Re6e5+ Kf5g4 Re5e6 Qd8d4 Kg7g8 Qd4c5 f6f5+ Qc5xf5 Kg8g7 Qf5b1 Re6g6+ Kg4f5 Rg6e6 Qb1b2+ Kg7g8 Qb2d4 Re6g6 Qd4h4 Kg8g7 Kf5f4 Rg6e6 Qh4h3 Kg7g8 Qh3g4+ Re6g6 Qg4f5 Rg6e6 Qf5g5+ Re6g6 Qg5d8+ Kg8g7 Kf4e4 Rg6e6+ Ke4f5 Re6g6 Qd8d4+ Kg7g8 Qd4h4
32/56 00:04 11.169.471 2.611.000 +0.03 Qd7d8 Re5e6 Kf4f5 Re6e5+ Kf5g4 Re5e6 Qd8d4 Kg7g8 Qd4c5 f6f5+ Qc5xf5 Kg8g7 Qf5b1 Re6g6+ Kg4f5 Rg6e6 Qb1b2+ Kg7g8 Qb2d4 Re6g6 Qd4h4 Kg8g7 Kf5f4 Rg6e6 Qh4h3 Kg7g8 Qh3g4+ Re6g6 Qg4f5 Rg6e6 Qf5g5+ Re6g6 Qg5d8+ Kg8g7 Kf4e4 Rg6e6+ Ke4f5 Re6g6 Qd8d4+ Kg7g8 Qd4h4
33/56 00:06 17.646.171 2.668.000 +0.03 Qd7d8 Re5e6 Kf4f5 Re6e5+ Kf5g4 Re5e6 Qd8d4 Kg7g8 Qd4c5 f6f5+ Qc5xf5 Kg8g7 Qf5b1 Re6g6+ Kg4f5 Rg6e6 Qb1b2+ Kg7g8 Qb2d4 Re6g6 Qd4h4 Kg8g7 Kf5f4 Rg6e6 Qh4h3 Kg7g8 Qh3g4+ Re6g6 Qg4f5 Rg6e6 Qf5g5+ Re6g6 Qg5d8+ Kg8g7 Kf4e4 Rg6e6+ Ke4f3 Re6g6 Qd8c8 Rg6e6 Qc8a8 Re6g6 Qa8b8 Rg6e6 Qb8g3+ Re6g6 Qg3e5+ Kg7g8 Qe5b8+ Kg8g7 Qb8c8 Rg6e6
34/56 00:09 25.586.210 2.696.000 +0.03 Qd7d8 Re5e6 Kf4f5 Re6e5+ Kf5g4 Re5e6 Qd8d4 Kg7g8 Qd4c5 f6f5+ Qc5xf5 Kg8g7 Qf5b1 Re6g6+ Kg4f5 Rg6e6 Qb1b2+ Kg7g8 Qb2d4 Re6g6 Qd4h4 Kg8g7 Kf5f4 Rg6e6 Qh4h3 Kg7g8 Qh3g4+ Re6g6 Qg4f5 Rg6e6 Qf5g5+ Re6g6 Qg5d8+ Kg8g7 Kf4e4 Rg6e6+ Ke4f3 Re6g6 Qd8d4+ Kg7g8 Qd4d8+ Kg8g7 Qd8d4+
35/56 00:13 35.214.984 2.689.000 +0.03 Qd7d8 Re5e6 Kf4f5 Re6e5+ Kf5g4 Re5e6 Qd8d4 Kg7g8 Qd4c5 f6f5+ Qc5xf5 Kg8g7 Qf5b1 Re6g6+ Kg4f5 Rg6e6 Qb1b2+ Kg7g8 Qb2d4 Re6g6 Qd4h4 Kg8g7 Kf5f4 Rg6e6 Qh4h3 Kg7g8 Qh3g4+ Re6g6 Qg4f5 Rg6e6 Qf5g5+ Re6g6 Qg5d8+ Kg8g7 Kf4e4 Rg6e6+ Ke4f3 Re6g6 Qd8c8 Rg6e6 Qc8a8 Re6g6 Qa8b8 Rg6e6 Qb8g3+ Re6g6 Qg3e5+ Kg7g8 Qe5b8+ Kg8g7 Qb8c8 Rg6e6
36/56 00:18 49.174.831 2.707.000 +0.03 Qd7d8 Re5e6 Kf4f5 Re6e5+ Kf5g4 Re5e6 Qd8d4 Kg7g8 Qd4c5 f6f5+ Qc5xf5 Kg8g7 Qf5b1 Re6g6+ Kg4f5 Rg6e6 Qb1b2+ Kg7g8 Qb2d4 Re6g6 Qd4h4 Kg8g7 Kf5f4 Rg6e6 Qh4h3 Kg7g8 Qh3g4+ Re6g6 Qg4f5 Rg6e6 Qf5g5+ Re6g6 Qg5d8+ Kg8g7 Kf4e4 Rg6e6+ Ke4f3 Re6g6 Qd8c8 Rg6e6 Qc8c3+ Kg7g8 Qc3c8+ Kg8g7 Qc8c3+
37/56 00:28 77.376.824 2.765.000 +0.03 Qd7d8 Re5e6 Kf4f5 Re6e5+ Kf5g4 Re5e6 Qd8d4 Kg7g8 Qd4c5 f6f5+ Qc5xf5 Kg8g7 Qf5b1 Re6g6+ Kg4f5 Rg6e6 Qb1b2+ Kg7g8 Qb2d4 Re6g6 Qd4h4 Kg8g7 Kf5f4 Rg6e6 Qh4h3 Kg7g8 Qh3g4+ Re6g6 Qg4f5 Rg6e6 Qf5g5+ Re6g6 Qg5d8+ Kg8g7 Kf4e4 Rg6e6+ Ke4f3 Re6g6 Qd8c8 Rg6e6 Qc8a8 Re6g6 Qa8a1+ Kg7g8 Qa1a8+ Kg8g7 Qa8a1+
38/56 00:36 97.861.832 2.706.000 +0.03 Qd7d8 Re5e6 Kf4f5 Re6e5+ Kf5g4 Re5e6 Qd8d4 Kg7g8 Qd4c5 f6f5+ Qc5xf5 Kg8g7 Qf5b1 Re6g6+ Kg4f5 Rg6e6 Qb1b2+ Kg7g8 Qb2d4 Re6g6 Qd4h4 Kg8g7 Kf5f4 Rg6e6 Qh4h3 Kg7g8 Qh3g4+ Re6g6 Qg4f5 Rg6e6 Qf5g5+ Re6g6 Qg5d8+ Kg8g7 Kf4e4 Rg6e6+ Ke4f3 Re6g6 Qd8c8 Rg6e6 Qc8a8 Re6g6 Qa8b8 Rg6e6 Qb8g3+ Re6g6 Qg3e5+ Kg7g8 Qe5b8+ Kg8g7 Qb8c8 Rg6e6
39/56 00:53 142.023.410 2.689.000 +0.03 Qd7d8 Re5e6 Kf4f5 Re6e5+ Kf5g4 Re5e6 Qd8d4 Kg7g8 Qd4c5 f6f5+ Qc5xf5 Kg8g7 Qf5b1 Re6g6+ Kg4f5 Rg6e6 Qb1b2+ Kg7g8 Qb2d4 Re6g6 Qd4h4 Kg8g7 Kf5f4 Rg6e6 Qh4h3 Kg7g8 Qh3g4+ Re6g6 Qg4f5 Rg6e6 Qf5g5+ Re6g6 Qg5d8+ Kg8g7 Kf4e4 Rg6e6+ Ke4f3 Re6g6 Qd8c8 Rg6e6 Qc8a8 Re6g6 Qa8b8 Rg6e6 Qb8g3+ Re6g6 Qg3e5+ Kg7g8 Qe5b8+ Kg8g7 Qb8c8 Rg6e6
40/56 01:08 182.501.343 2.677.000 +0.03 Qd7d8 Re5e6 Kf4f5 Re6e5+ Kf5g4 Re5e6 Qd8d4 Kg7g8 Qd4c5 f6f5+ Qc5xf5 Kg8g7 Qf5b1 Re6g6+ Kg4f5 Rg6e6 Qb1b2+ Kg7g8 Qb2d4 Re6g6 Qd4h4 Kg8g7 Kf5f4 Rg6e6 Qh4h3 Kg7g8 Qh3g4+ Re6g6 Qg4f5 Rg6e6 Qf5g5+ Re6g6 Qg5d8+ Kg8g7 Kf4e4 Rg6e6+ Ke4f3 Re6g6 Qd8c8 Rg6e6 Qc8a8 Re6g6 Qa8b8 Rg6e6 Qb8g3+ Re6g6 Qg3e5+ Kg7g8 Qe5b8+ Kg8g7 Qb8c8 Rg6e6
41/56 01:35 253.955.843 2.675.000 +0.03 Qd7d8 Re5e6 Kf4f5 Re6e5+ Kf5g4 Re5e6 Qd8d4 Kg7g8 Qd4c5 f6f5+ Qc5xf5 Kg8g7 Qf5b1 Re6g6+ Kg4f5 Rg6e6 Qb1b2+ Kg7g8 Qb2d4 Re6g6 Qd4h4 Kg8g7 Kf5f4 Rg6e6 Qh4h3 Kg7g8 Qh3g4+ Re6g6 Qg4f5 Rg6e6 Qf5g5+ Re6g6 Qg5d8+ Kg8g7 Kf4e4 Rg6e6+ Ke4f3 Re6g6 Qd8c8 Rg6e6 Qc8a8 Re6g6 Qa8b8 Rg6e6 Qb8g3+ Re6g6 Qg3e5+ Kg7g8 Qe5b8+ Kg8g7 Qb8c8 Rg6e6
42/61 02:08 339.296.545 2.652.000 +0.03 Qd7d8 Re5e6 Kf4f5 Re6e5+ Kf5g4 Re5e6 Qd8d4 Kg7g8 Qd4c5 f6f5+ Qc5xf5 Kg8g7 Qf5b1 Re6g6+ Kg4f5 Rg6e6 Qb1b2+ Kg7g8 Qb2d4 Re6g6 Qd4h4 Kg8g7 Kf5f4 Rg6e6 Qh4h3 Kg7g8 Qh3g4+ Re6g6 Qg4f5 Rg6e6 Qf5g5+ Re6g6 Qg5d8+ Kg8g7 Kf4e4 Rg6e6+ Ke4f3 Re6g6 Qd8c8 Rg6e6 Qc8a8 Re6g6 Qa8b8 Rg6e6 Qb8g3+ Re6g6 Qg3e5+ Kg7g8 Qe5b8+ Kg8g7 Qb8c8 Rg6e6
zullil
Posts: 6442
Joined: Tue Jan 09, 2007 12:31 am
Location: PA USA
Full name: Louis Zulli

Re: What engine can evaluate this draw ending correctly w/o

Post by zullil »

pichy wrote:How many Engines can evaluate this position as a draw without using tablebase
Why do you consider it "acceptable" for an engine to use fortress-recognition code to call this a draw, but "unacceptable" for an engine to reach the same conclusion using a database? Your antipathy to databases seems strange to me.
zullil
Posts: 6442
Joined: Tue Jan 09, 2007 12:31 am
Location: PA USA
Full name: Louis Zulli

Re: What engine can evaluate this draw ending correctly w/o

Post by zullil »

Stockfish-2.2.2:

Code: Select all

Searching: 8/3Q1pk1/5p2/4r3/5K2/8/8/8 w - - 0 1
infinite: 1 ponder: 0 time: 0 increment: 0 moves to go: 0
 1   +4.44   00:02      61  Qd6 
 2   +4.36   00:02     528  Qg4+ Rg5 Qd7 
 3   +0.00   00:02    1032  Qg4+ Rg5 Qd7 Rg6 
 4   +0.00   00:02    1609  Qg4+ Rg5 Qd7 Rg6 Qd4 
 5   +0.00   00:02    2181  Qg4+ Rg5 Qd7 Rg6 Qd4 Kf8 
 6   +0.00   00:02    3293  Qg4+ Rg5 Qd7 Rg6 Qd4 Kg8 Kf5 Kf8 
 7   +0.00   00:02    6243  Qd2 Re6 Qg2+ Kf8 Qa8+ Kg7 Kf5 Re5+ Kf4 Re6 
 8   +0.00   00:02    7256  Qd2 Re6 Qg2+ Kf8 Qa8+ Kg7 Kf5 Re5+ Kf4 Re6 
 9   +0.00   00:02    8856  Qd2 Re6 Qg2+ Kf8 Qa8+ Kg7 Kf5 Re5+ Kf4 Re6 
10   +0.00   00:02   20006  Qg4+ Kf8 Qd7 Re6 Qd1 f5 Kxf5 Rg6 Qd4 Re6 Qd1 
11   +0.00   00:02   28448  Qg4+ Kf8 Qd7 Re6 Qd1 f5 Kxf5 Rg6 Qd4 Re6 Qd1 
12   +0.00   00:02   38791  Qg4+ Kf8 Qd7 Re6 Qd1 f5 Kxf5 Rg6 Qd4 Re6 Qd1 
13   +0.00   00:02   53201  Qg4+ Kf8 Qd7 Re6 Qd1 f5 Kxf5 Rg6 Qd4 Re6 Qd1 
14   +0.00   00:02   70647  Qg4+ Kf8 Qd7 Re6 Qd1 f5 Kxf5 Rg6 Qd4 Re6 Qd1 
15   +0.00   00:02   88877  Qg4+ Kf8 Qd7 Re6 Qd1 f5 Kxf5 Rg6 Qd4 Re6 Qd1 
16   +0.00   00:02  113076  Qg4+ Kf8 Qd7 Re6 Qd1 f5 Kxf5 Rg6 Qd4 Re6 Qd1 
17   +0.00   00:02  127761  Qg4+ Kf8 Qd7 Re6 Qd1 f5 Kxf5 Rg6 Qd4 Re6 Qd1 
18   +0.00   00:02  157811  Qg4+ Kf8 Qd7 Re6 Qd1 f5 Kxf5 Rg6 Qd4 Re6 Qd1 
19   +0.00   00:02  161925  Qg4+ Kf8 Qd7 Re6 Qd1 f5 Kxf5 Rg6 Qd4 Re6 Qd1 
20   +0.00   00:02  196245  Qg4+ Kf8 Qd7 Re6 Qd1 f5 Kxf5 Rg6 Qd4 Re6 Qd1 
21   +0.00   00:02  241066  Qg4+ Kf8 Qd7 Re6 Qd1 f5 Kxf5 Rg6 Qd4 Re6 Qd1 
22   +0.00   00:02  297928  Qg4+ Kf8 Qd7 Re6 Qd1 f5 Kxf5 Rg6 Qd4 Re6 Qd1 
23   +0.00   00:02  364792  Qg4+ Kf8 Qd7 Re6 Qd1 f5 Kxf5 Rg6 Qd4 Re6 Qd1 
24   +0.00   00:02  437525  Qg4+ Kf8 Qd7 Re6 Qd1 f5 Kxf5 Rg6 Qd4 Re6 Qd1 
25   +0.00   00:02  533563  Qg4+ Kf8 Qd7 Re6 Qd1 f5 Kxf5 Rg6 Qd4 Re6 Qd1 
26   +0.00   00:02  643812  Qg4+ Kf8 Qd7 Re6 Qd1 f5 Kxf5 Rg6 Qd4 Re6 Qd1 
27   +0.00   00:02  751904  Qg4+ Kf8 Qd7 Re6 Qd1 f5 Kxf5 Rg6 Qd4 Re6 Qd1 
28   +0.00   00:02  867023  Qg4+ Kf8 Qd7 Re6 Qd1 f5 Kxf5 Rg6 Qd4 Re6 Qd1 
29   +0.00   00:02   1013K  Qg4+ Kf8 Qd7 Re6 Qd1 f5 Kxf5 Rg6 Qd4 Re6 Qd1 
30   +0.00   00:02   1196K  Qg4+ Kf8 Qd7 Re6 Qd1 f5 Kxf5 Rg6 Qd4 Re6 Qd1 
31   +0.00   00:02   1392K  Qg4+ Kf8 Qd7 Re6 Qd1 f5 Kxf5 Rg6 Qd4 Re6 Qd1 
32   +0.00   00:02   1590K  Qg4+ Kf8 Qd7 Re6 Qd1 f5 Kxf5 Rg6 Qd4 Re6 Qd1 
33   +0.00   00:02   1814K  Qg4+ Kf8 Qd7 Re6 Qd1 f5 Kxf5 Rg6 Qd4 Re6 Qd1 
34   +0.00   00:02   2094K  Qg4+ Kf8 Qd7 Re6 Qd1 f5 Kxf5 Rg6 Qd4 Re6 Qd1 
35   +0.00   00:02   2409K  Qg4+ Kf8 Qd7 Re6 Qd1 f5 Kxf5 Rg6 Qd4 Re6 Qd1 
36   +0.00   00:02   2752K  Qg4+ Kf8 Qd7 Re6 Qd1 f5 Kxf5 Rg6 Qd4 Re6 Qd1 
37   +0.00   00:02   3070K  Qg4+ Kf8 Qd7 Re6 Qd1 f5 Kxf5 Rg6 Qd4 Re6 Qd1 
38   +0.00   00:03   3557K  Qg4+ Kf8 Qd7 Re6 Qd1 f5 Kxf5 Rg6 Qd4 Re6 Qd1 
39   +0.00   00:03   4113K  Qg4+ Kf8 Qd7 Re6 Qd1 f5 Kxf5 Rg6 Qd4 Re6 Qd1 
40   +0.00   00:03   4641K  Qg4+ Kf8 Qd7 Re6 Qd1 f5 Kxf5 Rg6 Qd4 Re6 Qd1 
41   +0.00   00:03   5196K  Qg4+ Kf8 Qd7 Re6 Qd1 f5 Kxf5 Rg6 Qd4 Re6 Qd1 
42   +0.00   00:03   5851K  Qg4+ Kf8 Qd7 Re6 Qd1 f5 Kxf5 Rg6 Qd4 Re6 Qd1 
43   +0.00   00:03   7004K  Qg4+ Kf8 Qd7 Re6 Qd1 f5 Kxf5 Rg6 Qd4 Re6 Qd1 
44   +0.00   00:04   7854K  Qg4+ Kf8 Qd7 Re6 Qd1 f5 Kxf5 Rg6 Qd4 Re6 Qd1 
45   +0.00   00:04   9688K  Qg4+ Kf8 Qd7 Re6 Qd1 f5 Kxf5 Rg6 Qd4 Re6 Qd1 
46   +0.00   00:04  10635K  Qg4+ Kf8 Qd7 Re6 Qd1 f5 Kxf5 Rg6 Qd4 Re6 Qd1 
47   +0.00   00:05  11704K  Qg4+ Kf8 Qd7 Re6 Qd1 f5 Kxf5 Rg6 Qd4 Re6 Qd1 
48   +0.00   00:05  13186K  Qg4+ Kf8 Qd7 Re6 Qd1 f5 Kxf5 Rg6 Qd4 Re6 Qd1 
49   +0.00   00:05  15003K  Qg4+ Kf8 Qd7 Re6 Qd1 f5 Kxf5 Rg6 Qd4 Re6 Qd1 
50   +0.00   00:06  16453K  Qg4+ Kf8 Qd7 Re6 Qd1 f5 Kxf5 Rg6 Qd4 Re6 Qd1 
51   +0.00   00:22 131479K  Qd2 Re6 Qd8 Re5 Qd1 Rg5 Ke3 Rg6 Kd4 f5 Qc2 Kf8 Qf2 
                            Kg8 Qxf5 Re6 Kd3 Rd6+ Ke3 Re6+ Kd2 Rd6+ Ke2 Re6+ Kd1 
                            Kg7 Qg5+ Kf8 Qc5+ Kg7 Kc2 Kg8 Qd4 Rc6+ Kb3 Rg6 Kb4 
                            Re6 Qf2 Kf8 Qd4 Rh6 Ka3 Ra6+ Kb2 Kg8 Qc5 Re6 Qf2 Kf8 
                            Kb3 Kg8 Qf4 Rg6 Qb8+ Kg7 Qe5+ Kg8 Qe8+ Kg7 Qe5+ 
52   +0.00   00:23 137557K  Qd2 Re6 Qd8 Re5 Qd1 Rg5 Ke3 Rg6 Kd4 f5 Qc2 Kf8 Qf2 
                            Kg8 Qxf5 Re6 Kd3 Rd6+ Ke3 Re6+ Kd2 Rd6+ Ke2 Re6+ Kd1 
                            Kg7 Qg5+ Kf8 Qc5+ Kg7 Kc2 Kg8 Qd4 Rc6+ Kb3 Rg6 Kb4 
                            Re6 Qf2 Kf8 Qd4 Rh6 Ka3 Ra6+ Kb2 Kg8 Qc5 Re6 Qf2 Kf8 
                            Kb3 Kg8 Qf4 Rg6 Qb8+ Kg7 Qe5+ Kg8 Qe8+ Kg7 Qe5+ 
53   +0.00   00:24 142267K  Qd2 Re6 Qd8 Re5 Qd1 Rg5 Ke3 Rg6 Kd4 f5 Qc2 Kf8 Qf2 
                            Kg8 Qxf5 Re6 Kd3 Rd6+ Ke3 Re6+ Kd2 Rd6+ Ke2 Re6+ Kd1 
                            Kg7 Qg5+ Kf8 Qc5+ Kg7 Kc2 Kg8 Qd4 Rc6+ Kb3 Rg6 Kb4 
                            Re6 Qf2 Kf8 Qd4 Rh6 Ka3 Ra6+ Kb2 Kg8 Qc5 Re6 Qf2 Kf8 
                            Kb3 Kg8 Qf4 Rg6 Qb8+ Kg7 Qe5+ Kg8 Qe8+ Kg7 Qe5+ 
54   +0.00   00:25 148239K  Qd2 Re6 Qd8 Re5 Qd1 Rg5 Ke3 Rg6 Kd4 f5 Qc2 Kf8 Qf2 
                            Kg8 Qxf5 Re6 Kd3 Rd6+ Ke3 Re6+ Kd2 Rd6+ Ke2 Re6+ Kd1 
                            Kg7 Qg5+ Kf8 Qc5+ Kg7 Kc2 Kg8 Qd4 Rc6+ Kb3 Rg6 Kb4 
                            Re6 Qf2 Kf8 Qd4 Rh6 Ka3 Ra6+ Kb2 Kg8 Qc5 Re6 Qf2 Kf8 
                            Kb3 Kg8 Qf4 Rg6 Qb8+ Kg7 Qe5+ Kg8 Qe8+ Kg7 Qe5+ 
55   +0.00   00:26 154061K  Qd2 Re6 Qd8 Re5 Qd1 Rg5 Ke3 Rg6 Kd4 f5 Qc2 Kf8 Qf2 
                            Kg8 Qxf5 Re6 Kd3 Rd6+ Ke3 Re6+ Kd2 Rd6+ Ke2 Re6+ Kd1 
                            Kg7 Qg5+ Kf8 Qc5+ Kg7 Kc2 Kg8 Qd4 Rc6+ Kb3 Rg6 Kb4 
                            Re6 Qf2 Kf8 Qd4 Rh6 Ka3 Ra6+ Kb2 Kg8 Qc5 Re6 Qf2 Kf8 
                            Kb3 Kg8 Qf4 Rg6 Qb8+ Kg7 Qe5+ Kg8 Qe8+ Kg7 Qe5+ 
56   +0.00   00:28 161839K  Qd2 Re6 Qd8 Re5 Qd1 Rg5 Ke3 Rg6 Kd4 f5 Qc2 Kf8 Qf2 
                            Kg8 Qxf5 Re6 Kd3 Rd6+ Ke3 Re6+ Kd2 Rd6+ Ke2 Re6+ Kd1 
                            Kg7 Qg5+ Kf8 Qc5+ Kg7 Kc2 Kg8 Qd4 Rc6+ Kb3 Rg6 Kb4 
                            Re6 Qf2 Kf8 Qd4 Rh6 Ka3 Ra6+ Kb2 Kg8 Qc5 Re6 Qf2 Kf8 
                            Kb3 Kg8 Qf4 Rg6 Qb8+ Kg7 Qe5+ Kg8 Qe8+ Kg7 Qe5+ 
57   +0.00   00:30 169546K  Qd2 Re6 Qd8 Re5 Qd1 Rg5 Ke3 Rg6 Kd4 f5 Qc2 Kf8 Qf2 
                            Kg8 Qxf5 Re6 Kd3 Rd6+ Ke3 Re6+ Kd2 Rd6+ Ke2 Re6+ Kd1 
                            Kg7 Qg5+ Kf8 Qc5+ Kg7 Kc2 Kg8 Qd4 Rc6+ Kb3 Rg6 Kb4 
                            Re6 Qf2 Kf8 Qd4 Rh6 Ka3 Ra6+ Kb2 Kg8 Qc5 Re6 Qf2 Kf8 
                            Kb3 Kg8 Qf4 Rg6 Qb8+ Kg7 Qe5+ Kg8 Qe8+ Kg7 Qe5+ 
58   +0.00   03:30   2032M  Qd2 Re6 Qc2 Kg8 Qg2+ Kf8 Qh3 Kg7 Qh4 Re5 Kf3 Rf5+ 
                            Ke4 Ra5 Qh3 Re5+ Kd4 Re6 Qg4+ Kf8 Qf5 Rd6+ Ke3 Re6+ 
                            Kd3 Kg8 Kc4 Kg7 Kb3 Kf8 Ka4 Kg7 Kb3 
59   +0.00   03:34   2046M  Qd2 Re6 Qc2 Kg8 Qg2+ Kf8 Qh3 Kg7 Qh4 Re5 Kf3 Rf5+ 
                            Ke4 Ra5 Qh3 Re5+ Kd4 Re6 Qg4+ Kf8 Qf5 Rd6+ Ke3 Re6+ 
                            Kd3 Kg8 Kc4 Kg7 Kb3 Kf8 Ka4 Kg7 Kb3 
60   +0.00   03:34   2050M  Qd2 Re6 Qc2 Kg8 Qg2+ Kf8 Qh3 Kg7 Qh4 Re5 Kf3 Rf5+ 
                            Ke4 Ra5 Qh3 Re5+ Kd4 Re6 Qg4+ Kf8 Qf5 Rd6+ Ke3 Re6+ 
                            Kd3 Kg8 Kc4 Kg7 Kb3 Kf8 Ka4 Kg7 Kb3 
61   +0.00   03:37   2063M  Qd2 Re6 Qc2 Kg8 Qg2+ Kf8 Qh3 Kg7 Qh4 Re5 Kf3 Rf5+ 
                            Ke4 Ra5 Qh3 Re5+ Kd4 Re6 Qg4+ Kf8 Qf5 Rd6+ Ke3 Re6+ 
                            Kd3 Kg8 Kc4 Kg7 Kb3 Kf8 Ka4 Kg7 Kb3 
62   +0.00   03:39   2072M  Qd2 Re6 Qc2 Kg8 Qg2+ Kf8 Qh3 Kg7 Qh4 Re5 Kf3 Rf5+ 
                            Ke4 Ra5 Qh3 Re5+ Kd4 Re6 Qg4+ Kf8 Qf5 Rd6+ Ke3 Re6+ 
                            Kd3 Kg8 Kc4 Kg7 Kb3 Kf8 Ka4 Kg7 Kb3 
63   +0.00   03:42   2083M  Qd2 Re6 Qc2 Kg8 Qg2+ Kf8 Qh3 Kg7 Qh4 Re5 Kf3 Rf5+ 
                            Ke4 Ra5 Qh3 Re5+ Kd4 Re6 Qg4+ Kf8 Qf5 Rd6+ Ke3 Re6+ 
                            Kd3 Kg8 Kc4 Kg7 Kb3 Kf8 Ka4 Kg7 Kb3 
64   +0.00   03:45   2095M  Qd2 Re6 Qc2 Kg8 Qg2+ Kf8 Qh3 Kg7 Qh4 Re5 Kf3 Rf5+ 
                            Ke4 Ra5 Qh3 Re5+ Kd4 Re6 Qg4+ Kf8 Qf5 Rd6+ Ke3 Re6+ 
                            Kd3 Kg8 Kc4 Kg7 Kb3 Kf8 Ka4 Kg7 Kb3 
65   +0.00   03:48   2110M  Qd2 Re6 Qc2 Kg8 Qg2+ Kf8 Qh3 Kg7 Qh4 Re5 Kf3 Rf5+ 
                            Ke4 Ra5 Qh3 Re5+ Kd4 Re6 Qg4+ Kf8 Qf5 Rd6+ Ke3 Re6+ 
                            Kd3 Kg8 Kc4 Kg7 Kb3 Kf8 Ka4 Kg7 Kb3 
66   +0.00   03:52   2130M  Qd2 Re6 Qc2 Kg8 Qg2+ Kf8 Qh3 Kg7 Qh4 Re5 Kf3 Rf5+ 
                            Ke4 Ra5 Qh3 Re5+ Kd4 Re6 Qg4+ Kf8 Qf5 Rd6+ Ke3 Re6+ 
                            Kd3 Kg8 Kc4 Kg7 Kb3 Kf8 Ka4 Kg7 Kb3 
67   +0.00   03:57   2153M  Qd2 Re6 Qc2 Kg8 Qg2+ Kf8 Qh3 Kg7 Qh4 Re5 Kf3 Rf5+ 
                            Ke4 Ra5 Qh3 Re5+ Kd4 Re6 Qg4+ Kf8 Qf5 Rd6+ Ke3 Re6+ 
                            Kd3 Kg8 Kc4 Kg7 Kb3 Kf8 Ka4 Kg7 Kb3 
68   +0.00   04:05   2190M  Qd2 Re6 Qc2 Kg8 Qg2+ Kf8 Qh3 Kg7 Qh4 Re5 Kf3 Rf5+ 
                            Ke4 Ra5 Qh3 Re5+ Kd4 Re6 Qg4+ Kf8 Qf5 Rd6+ Ke3 Re6+ 
                            Kd3 Kg8 Kc4 Kg7 Kb3 Kf8 Ka4 Kg7 Kb3 
69   +0.00   07:47   3852M  Qg4+ Rg5 Qc8 Rg6 Qa8 f5 Qd8 Re6 Qd4+ Kf8 Qh8+ Ke7 
                            Qb2 Rg6 Qf2 Re6 Qc5+ Ke8 Qa3 Rg6 Qa8+ Ke7 Qh8 Re6 
70   +0.00   07:53   3880M  Qg4+ Rg5 Qc8 Rg6 Qa8 f5 Qd8 Re6 Qd4+ Kf8 Qh8+ Ke7 
                            Qb2 Rg6 Qf2 Re6 Qc5+ Ke8 Qa3 Rg6 Qa8+ Ke7 Qa3+ Ke8 
71   +0.00   09:16   4528M  Qg4+ Rg5 Qc8 Rg6 Qa8 f5 Qd8 Re6 Qd4+ Kg8 Qg1+ Kf8 
                            Qa7 Kg8 Qa8+ Kg7 Qa1+ Kg8 Qg1+ 
72   +0.00   09:28   4601M  Qg4+ Rg5 Qc8 Rg6 Qa8 f5 Qd8 Re6 Qd4+ Kg8 Qg1+ Kf8 
                            Qa7 Kg8 Qa8+ Kg7 Qa1+ Kg8 Qg1+ 
73   +0.00   09:36   4639M  Qg4+ Rg5 Qc8 Rg6 Qa8 f5 Qd8 Re6 Qd4+ Kg8 Qg1+ Kf8 
                            Qa7 Kg8 Qa8+ Kg7 Qa1+ Kg8 Qg1+ 
74   +0.00   09:45   4685M  Qg4+ Rg5 Qc8 Rg6 Qa8 f5 Qd8 Re6 Qd4+ Kg8 Qg1+ Kf8 
                            Qa7 Kg8 Qa8+ Kg7 Qa1+ Kg8 Qg1+ 
75   +0.00   22:14   6160M  Qg4+ Rg5 Qf3 Rg6 Qa8 Rg4+ Kxg4 Kh7 Qe4+ Kg7 Kf5 Kh8 
                            Kxf6 
Nodes: 6160682214
Nodes/second: 4617330
Best move: Qg4+
Ponder move: Rg5
BubbaTough
Posts: 1154
Joined: Fri Jun 23, 2006 5:18 am

Re: What engine can evaluate this draw ending correctly w/o

Post by BubbaTough »

Hannibal also considers this a draw.

-Sam
pichy
Posts: 2564
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 3:04 am

Re: What engine can evaluate this draw ending correctly w/o

Post by pichy »

BubbaTough wrote:Hannibal also considers this a draw.

-Sam
Yes, Hannibal evaluation of +0.04 is considered a draw

FEN: 8/3Q1pk1/5p2/4r3/8/5K2/8/8 w - - 0 1

Hannibal1.1x32:
8 00:00 3.089 40.116 +0.03 Qd7d1 Re5g5 Qd1b1 Rg5e5 Qb1c1 Re5g5 Qc1d1 Rg5e5
9 00:00 4.272 49.103 +0.03 Qd7d1 Re5g5 Qd1b1 Rg5e5 Qb1c1 Re5g5 Qc1d1 Rg5e5 Qd1b1
10 00:00 5.953 64.010 +0.03 Qd7d1 Re5g5 Qd1b1 Rg5e5 Qb1c1 Re5g5 Qc1d1 Rg5e5 Qd1b1 Re5g5
11 00:00 8.949 90.393 +0.03 Qd7d1 Re5g5 Qd1b1 Rg5e5 Qb1c1 Re5g5 Qc1d1 Rg5e5 Qd1b1 Re5g5 Qb1c1
12 00:00 13.498 128.552 +0.03 Qd7d1 Re5g5 Qd1b1 Rg5e5 Qb1c1 Re5g5 Qc1d1 Rg5e5 Qd1b1 Re5g5 Qb1c1 Rg5e5
13 00:00 19.818 162.442 +0.03 Qd7d1 Re5g5 Qd1b1 Rg5e5 Qb1c1 Re5g5 Qc1d1 Rg5e5 Qd1b1 Re5g5 Qb1c1 Rg5e5 Qc1f4
14 00:00 28.080 208.000 +0.03 Qd7d1 Re5g5 Qd1b1 Rg5e5 Qb1c1 Re5g5 Qc1d1 Rg5e5 Qd1b1 Re5g5 Qb1c1 Rg5e5 Qc1f4 Re5g5
15 00:00 40.557 253.481 +0.03 Qd7d1 Re5g5 Qd1b1 Rg5e5 Qb1c1 Re5g5 Qc1d1 Rg5e5 Qd1b1 Re5g5 Qb1c1 Rg5e5 Qc1f4 Re5g5 Qf4b8
16 00:00 59.152 323.234 +0.03 Qd7d1 Re5g5 Qd1b1 Rg5e5 Qb1c1 Re5g5 Qc1d1 Rg5e5 Qd1b1 Re5g5 Qb1c1 Rg5e5 Qc1f4 Re5g5 Qf4b8 Rg5e5
17 00:00 87.907 414.655 +0.03 Qd7d1 Re5g5 Qd1b1 Rg5e5 Qb1c1 Re5g5 Qc1d1 Rg5e5 Qd1b1 Re5g5 Qb1c1 Rg5e5 Qc1f4 Re5g5 Qf4b8 Rg5e5 Qb8b3
18 00:00 133.491 509.507 +0.03 Qd7d1 Re5g5 Qd1b1 Rg5e5 Qb1c1 Re5g5 Qc1d1 Rg5e5 Qd1b1 Re5g5 Qb1c1 Rg5e5 Qc1f4 Re5g5 Qf4b8 Rg5e5 Qb8b3 Re5g5
19 00:00 185.487 600.281 +0.03 Qd7d1 Re5g5 Qd1b1 Rg5e5 Qb1c1 Re5g5 Qc1d1 Rg5e5 Qd1b1 Re5g5 Qb1c1 Rg5e5 Qc1f4 Re5g5 Qf4b8 Rg5e5 Kf3f4 Re5g5 Qb8b1
20 00:00 278.324 713.651 +0.03 Qd7d1 Re5g5 Qd1b1 Rg5e5 Qb1c1 Re5g5 Qc1d1 Rg5e5 Qd1b1 Re5g5 Qb1c1 Rg5e5 Qc1f4 Re5g5 Qf4b8 Rg5e5 Kf3f4 Re5g5 Qb8b3 Rg5e5
21 00:00 395.880 804.634 +0.03 Qd7d1 Re5g5 Qd1b1 Rg5e5 Qb1c1 Re5g5 Qc1d1 Rg5e5 Qd1b1 Re5g5 Qb1c1 Rg5e5 Kf3f4 Re5g5 Qc1b1 Rg5e5 Qb1d1 Re5g5 Qd1a1 Rg5e5 Qa1b1
22 00:01 1.016.951 1.060.428 +0.04 Qd7h3 Re5g5 Qh3h2 Rg5e5 Kf3f4 Re5g5 Qh2h3 Rg5e5 Qh3g2+ Re5g5 Qg2h2 Rg5e5 Qh2g3+ Kg7f8 Qg3g2 Re5g5 Qg2h3 Kf8g7 Qh3c3 Rg5g6 Qc3b4 Kg7g8 Qb4e4 f6f5 Qe4xf5
23 00:01 1.332.667 1.143.920 +0.04 Qd7h3 Re5g5 Qh3h2 Rg5e5 Kf3f4 Re5g5 Qh2h3 Rg5e5 Qh3g2+ Re5g5 Qg2h2 Rg5e5 Qh2g3+ Kg7f8 Qg3g2 Re5g5 Qg2h3 Kf8g7 Qh3e3 Kg7f8 Qe3b6 Rg5g6 Qb6d8+ Kf8g7 Qd8e7 Kg7g8
24 00:01 1.725.367 1.204.024 +0.04 Qd7h3 Re5g5 Qh3h2 Rg5e5 Kf3f4 Re5g5 Qh2h3 Rg5e5 Qh3g2+ Re5g5 Qg2h2 Rg5e5 Qh2h3 Re5g5 Qh3c3 Rg5g6 Qc3d4 Rg6g5 Qd4e3 Kg7f8 Qe3b6 Rg5g6 Qb6d8+ Kf8g7 Qd8e7 Kg7g8
25 00:02 2.562.645 1.331.244 +0.04 Qd7h3 Re5g5 Qh3h2 Rg5e5 Kf3f4 Re5g5 Qh2h3 Rg5e5 Qh3g2+ Re5g5 Qg2h2 Rg5e5 Qh2h3 Re5g5 Qh3c3 Rg5g6 Qc3c1 Rg6g5 Qc1e3 Kg7f8 Qe3b6 Rg5g6 Qb6a6 Rg6g5 Qa6xf6 Rg5g6
26 00:02 3.305.752 1.390.139 +0.04 Qd7h3 Re5g5 Qh3h2 Rg5e5 Kf3f4 Re5g5 Qh2h3 Rg5e5 Qh3g2+ Re5g5 Qg2h2 Rg5e5 Qh2h3 Re5g5 Qh3c3 Rg5g6 Qc3c4 Rg6g5 Qc4c2 Rg5h5 Qc2c3 Rh5h4+ Kf4f5 Rh4h5+ Kf5e4 Rh5e5+ Ke4f4 Re5e6 Qc3g3+ Kg7f8 Kf4f5 Re6e5+ Kf5xf6 Re5e6+ Kf6f5
27 00:03 4.396.311 1.433.423 +0.04 Qd7h3 Re5g5 Qh3h2 Rg5e5 Kf3f4 Re5g5 Qh2h3 Rg5e5 Qh3c3 Kg7g6 Qc3c2+ Kg6g7 Qc2b1 Re5g5 Qb1d1 Kg7g6 Qd1c2+ Kg6g7 Qc2c3 Rg5g6 Qc3c1 Rg6g5 Qc1e3 Kg7f8 Qe3b6 Rg5g6 Qb6b8+ Kf8g7 Kf4e3 f6f5 Qb8e5+ Kg7f8 Qe5xf5
28 00:04 6.123.404 1.491.694 +0.04 Qd7h3 Re5g5 Qh3h2 Rg5e5 Kf3f4 Re5g5 Qh2h3 Rg5e5 Qh3c3 Kg7g6 Qc3c2+ Kg6g7 Qc2b1 Re5g5 Qb1d1 Kg7g6 Qd1c2+ Kg6g7 Qc2c3 Rg5g6 Qc3b2 Rg6g5 Qb2b4 Rg5e5 Kf4g4 Re5e6 Qb4c3 Kg7g6 Qc3c2+ f6f5+ Kg4f4 Kg6f6 Qc2xf5+ Kf6g7
29 00:06 9.280.066 1.575.295 +0.04 Qd7h3 Re5g5 Qh3h2 Rg5e5 Kf3f4 Re5g5 Qh2h3 Rg5e5 Qh3c3 Kg7g6 Qc3c2+ Kg6g7 Qc2b1 Re5g5 Qb1d1 Kg7g6 Qd1c2+ Kg6g7 Qc2c3 Rg5g6 Qc3c4 Rg6g5 Qc4e2 Rg5e5 Qe2g4+ Re5g5 Qg4h4 Rg5g6 Kf4e3 Kg7g8 Qh4e4 f6f5 Qe4xf5
30 00:08 13.151.565 1.609.541 +0.04 Qd7h3 Re5g5 Qh3h2 Rg5e5 Kf3f4 Re5g5 Qh2h3 Rg5e5 Qh3c3 Kg7g6 Qc3c2+ Kg6g7 Qc2b1 Re5g5 Qb1d1 Kg7g6 Qd1c2+ Kg6g7 Qc2c3 Rg5g6 Qc3c4 Rg6g5 Qc4c6 Rg5e5 Qc6a8 Re5g5 Kf4e4 Rg5g6 Ke4e3 f6f5 Ke3f4 Kg7f6 Qa8c6+ Kf6g7 Qc6c3+ Kg7f8 Kf4xf5
31 00:12 19.117.103 1.587.535 +0.04 Qd7h3 Re5g5 Qh3h2 Rg5e5 Kf3f4 Re5g5 Qh2h3 Rg5e5 Qh3g2+ Re5g5 Qg2h2 Rg5e5 Qh2h3 Re5g5 Qh3c3 Rg5g6 Qc3c4 Rg6g5 Qc4c7 Rg5e5 Kf4f3 Re5g5 Kf3e4 Rg5e5+ Ke4f4 Re5g5 Kf4e3 Rg5e5+ Ke3d4 Re5g5 Qc7a7 Rg5g6 Kd4d5 Kg7f8
32 00:17 28.093.948 1.598.517 +0.04 Qd7h3 Re5g5 Qh3h2 Rg5e5 Kf3f4 Re5g5 Qh2h3 Rg5e5 Qh3g2+ Re5g5 Qg2h2 Rg5e5 Qh2h3 Re5g5 Qh3c3 Rg5g6 Qc3c4 Rg6g5 Qc4c7 Rg5e5 Kf4f3 Re5g5 Kf3e4 Rg5e5+ Ke4d4 Re5g5 Qc7c3 Rg5e5 Qc3a3 Re5g5 Qa3h3 Rg5g6 Qh3d3 f6f5 Qd3xf5
33 00:27 44.159.653 1.629.567 +0.04 Qd7h3 Re5g5 Qh3h2 Rg5e5 Kf3f4 Re5g5 Qh2h3 Rg5e5 Qh3c3 Kg7g6 Qc3c2+ Kg6g7 Qc2b1 Re5g5 Qb1d1 Kg7g6 Qd1c2+ Kg6g7 Qc2c3 Rg5g6 Qc3c4 Rg6g5 Qc4c7 Rg5e5 Kf4f3 Re5g5 Kf3e4 Rg5e5+ Ke4d4 Re5g5 Qc7a7 Rg5g6 Qa7a8 f6f5 Qa8d8 Rg6e6 Qd8g5+ Re6g6 Qg5xf5
34 00:44 72.263.291 1.622.763 +0.04 Qd7h3 Re5g5 Qh3h2 Rg5e5 Kf3f4 Re5g5 Qh2h3 Rg5e5 Qh3c3 Kg7g6 Qc3c2+ Kg6g7 Qc2b1 Re5g5 Qb1d1 Kg7g6 Qd1c2+ Kg6g7 Qc2c3 Rg5g6 Qc3c4 Rg6g5 Qc4c7 Rg5e5 Kf4f3 Re5g5 Kf3e4 Rg5e5+ Ke4d4 Re5g5 Kd4d3 Rg5g6 Qc7c4 Kg7f8 Qc4c1 f6f5 Qc1c5+ Kf8e8 Qc5xf5
35 01:29 142.021.193 1.600.689 +0.04 Qd7h3 Re5g5 Qh3h2 Rg5e5 Kf3f4 Re5g5 Qh2h3 Rg5e5 Qh3c3 Kg7g6 Qc3c2+ Kg6g7 Qc2b1 Re5g5 Qb1d1 Kg7g6 Qd1c2+ Kg6g7 Qc2c3 Rg5g6 Qc3c4 Rg6g5 Qc4c7 Rg5e5 Kf4f3 Re5g5 Kf3e4 Rg5e5+ Ke4f4 Re5g5 Kf4e3 Rg5e5+ Ke3d4 Re5g5 Qc7d7 Rg5g6 Kd4d5 f6f5 Qd7xf5
36 02:15 216.262.804 1.595.105 +0.04 Qd7h3 Re5g5 Qh3h2 Rg5e5 Kf3f4 Re5g5 Qh2h3 Rg5e5 Qh3g2+ Re5g5 Qg2h2 Rg5e5 Qh2h3 Re5g5 Qh3c3 Rg5g6 Qc3c4 Rg6g5 Qc4c7 Rg5e5 Kf4f3 Re5g5 Kf3e4 Rg5e5+ Ke4f4 Re5g5 Qc7c2 Rg5h5 Qc2b1 Rh5g5 Kf4e3 Rg5e5+ Ke3d3 Re5g5 Qb1b6 Rg5g6 Kd3c3 f6f5 Qb6d4+ Kg7f8 Qd4c5+ Kf8g7 Qc5xf5
37 03:24 325.795.631 1.600.764 +0.04 Qd7h3 Re5g5 Qh3h2 Rg5e5 Kf3f4 Re5g5 Qh2h3 Rg5e5 Qh3b3 Kg7g6 Qb3b1+ Kg6g7 Qb1a1 Re5g5 Qa1c3 Rg5g6 Qc3c4 Rg6g5 Qc4c7 Rg5e5 Kf4f3 Re5g5 Kf3e4 Rg5e5+ Ke4f4 Re5g5 Kf4e3 Rg5e5+ Ke3d4 Re5g5 Qc7c3 Rg5e5 Qc3g3+ Re5g5 Qg3d6 Rg5e5 Kd4c3 Re5e6 Qd6g3+ Kg7f8 Qg3f4 f6f5 Qf4xf5
pichy
Posts: 2564
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 3:04 am

Re: What engine can evaluate this draw ending correctly w/o

Post by pichy »

zullil wrote:
pichy wrote:How many Engines can evaluate this position as a draw without using tablebase
Why do you consider it "acceptable" for an engine to use fortress-recognition code to call this a draw, but "unacceptable" for an engine to reach the same conclusion using a database? Your antipathy to databases seems strange to me.
Very simple when you use an engine with tablebase, you are not allowing the engine to calculate by itself

PS: With this Fortress position a tablebase will still consider this position as a draw, but the object is to let the engine do its own calculation :wink:
User avatar
michiguel
Posts: 6401
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 8:30 pm
Location: Chicago, Illinois, USA

Re: What engine can evaluate this draw ending correctly w/o

Post by michiguel »

pichy wrote:
zullil wrote:
pichy wrote:How many Engines can evaluate this position as a draw without using tablebase
Why do you consider it "acceptable" for an engine to use fortress-recognition code to call this a draw, but "unacceptable" for an engine to reach the same conclusion using a database? Your antipathy to databases seems strange to me.
Very simple when you use an engine with tablebase, you are not allowing the engine to calculate by itself

PS: With this Fortress position a tablebase will still consider this position as a draw, but the object is to let the engine do its own calculation :wink:
Not even when Gaviota uses Gaviota TBs? :-)

Miguel
rbarreira
Posts: 900
Joined: Tue Apr 27, 2010 3:48 pm

Re: What engine can evaluate this draw ending correctly w/o

Post by rbarreira »

pichy wrote:
zullil wrote:
pichy wrote:How many Engines can evaluate this position as a draw without using tablebase
Why do you consider it "acceptable" for an engine to use fortress-recognition code to call this a draw, but "unacceptable" for an engine to reach the same conclusion using a database? Your antipathy to databases seems strange to me.
Very simple when you use an engine with tablebase, you are not allowing the engine to calculate by itself

PS: With this Fortress position a tablebase will still consider this position as a draw, but the object is to let the engine do its own calculation :wink:
But humans do not learn everything by themselves either. They recognize patterns on a database stored on his/her brain, many of those patterns come from books, teachers etc...
zullil
Posts: 6442
Joined: Tue Jan 09, 2007 12:31 am
Location: PA USA
Full name: Louis Zulli

Re: What engine can evaluate this draw ending correctly w/o

Post by zullil »

rbarreira wrote:
pichy wrote:
zullil wrote:
pichy wrote:How many Engines can evaluate this position as a draw without using tablebase
Why do you consider it "acceptable" for an engine to use fortress-recognition code to call this a draw, but "unacceptable" for an engine to reach the same conclusion using a database? Your antipathy to databases seems strange to me.
Very simple when you use an engine with tablebase, you are not allowing the engine to calculate by itself

PS: With this Fortress position a tablebase will still consider this position as a draw, but the object is to let the engine do its own calculation :wink:
But humans do not learn everything by themselves either. They recognize patterns on a database stored on his/her brain, many of those patterns come from books, teachers etc...
Yes. And I'm not sure why writing code so that an engine can recognize this pattern as a "fortress draw" is in any way better that referring to a database of positions. What "calculation" would an engine be doing here, if it were denied tablebase access.