Discussion of computer chess matches and engine tournaments.
Moderator: Ras
Vinvin
Posts: 5312Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 9:40 amFull name: Vincent Lejeune
Post by Vinvin Mon Sep 16, 2013 1:52 pm
Sometimes rating programs give a different order than simple "points" ordering (Equinox with 75% is 6th here because it played engines on the bottom of the list)
Code: Select all
Rank Name Elo + - games score oppo. draws
1 Bouquet 1.8 352 229 193 6 83% 174 33%
2 Gull 2.2 320 207 186 6 75% 176 50%
3 Stockfish 4 283 206 189 6 67% 196 33%
4 Komodo 1063 243 189 176 6 67% 159 67%
5 Houdini 3 226 187 175 6 67% 144 67%
6 Equinox 2b 210 237 209 6 75% 52 17%
7 Exchess 7.15b 194 217 209 6 58% 134 17%
8 Junior 13.3 192 201 196 6 58% 125 50%
9 Critter 1.6a 190 193 189 6 67% 35 67%
10 Shredder 12 180 211 197 6 67% 81 33%
11 Rybka 4.1 174 189 177 6 67% 94 67%
12 Spike 1.4 157 221 218 6 58% 77 17%
13 Naum 4.2 132 184 172 7 64% 67 43%
14 Hiarcs 14 117 177 173 7 57% 68 57%
15 Tornado 4.88 96 197 191 6 58% 46 50%
16 Spark 1 58 196 189 6 58% 17 50%
17 Toga II 280513 42 181 181 7 50% 34 43%
18 Jonny 6 39 181 182 7 50% 25 43%
19 The Baron 3.35a 23 183 186 7 50% 16 43%
20 Hannibal 220813 19 203 202 7 50% 16 14%
21 Onno 1.27 15 188 192 7 50% -8 43%
22 Sjeng WC2008 -44 201 201 7 50% -43 14%
23 Gaviota 0.87a8 -52 193 194 7 50% -58 43%
24 Minkochess 1.3 -82 185 184 7 50% -85 43%
25 Scorpio 2.76 -97 185 191 7 43% -54 29%
26 Crafty 23.6 -103 218 227 7 43% -54 0%
27 Hamsters 0.71 -130 185 184 7 50% -127 43%
28 Delphil 3 -165 192 203 7 43% -149 29%
29 Octochess 5178 -166 210 236 7 36% -79 14%
30 Arminius 100813 -212 202 231 7 29% -82 0%
31 Alfil 13.1 -250 184 195 7 36% -169 43%
32 Arasan 16 -298 207 221 7 36% -205 14%
33 Redqueen 1.14 -313 214 244 7 29% -174 0%
34 Nebula 2 -315 187 212 7 29% -200 29%
35 Firefly 2.6 -457 209 271 7 14% -226 0%
36 Bugchess2 1.9 -581 222 341 7 0% -218 0%
Vinvin
Posts: 5312Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 9:40 amFull name: Vincent Lejeune
Post by Vinvin Tue Sep 17, 2013 9:31 am
Code: Select all
Rank Name Elo + - games score oppo. draws
1 Bouquet 1.8 371 232 195 6 83% 186 33%
2 Gull 2.2 340 208 188 6 75% 190 50%
3 Stockfish 4 306 202 180 7 71% 193 29%
4 Komodo 1063 282 184 168 7 71% 169 57%
5 Houdini 3 237 190 177 6 67% 152 67%
6 Equinox 2b 219 240 212 6 75% 59 17%
7 Junior 13.3 218 196 185 7 64% 123 43%
8 Spike 1.4 194 214 202 7 64% 82 14%
9 Critter 1.6a 190 177 173 7 64% 58 71%
10 Rybka 4.1 177 173 164 7 64% 103 71%
11 Exchess 7.15b 166 200 202 7 50% 154 14%
12 Shredder 12 161 194 191 7 57% 109 29%
13 Naum 4.2 123 185 172 7 64% 58 43%
14 Hiarcs 14 115 179 174 7 57% 65 57%
15 Tornado 4.88 79 184 186 7 50% 71 43%
16 Spark 1 43 183 184 7 50% 42 43%
17 Toga II 280513 43 182 183 7 50% 36 43%
18 Jonny 6 39 182 184 7 50% 26 43%
19 Hannibal 220813 18 208 206 7 50% 19 14%
20 Onno 1.27 18 189 193 7 50% -3 43%
21 The Baron 3.35a 14 184 186 7 50% 8 43%
22 Sjeng WC2008 -41 203 202 7 50% -38 14%
23 Gaviota 0.87a8 -56 194 194 7 50% -60 43%
24 Minkochess 1.3 -84 185 184 7 50% -87 43%
25 Scorpio 2.76 -104 185 192 7 43% -59 29%
26 Crafty 23.6 -110 220 227 7 43% -57 0%
27 Hamsters 0.71 -136 185 184 7 50% -134 43%
28 Delphil 3 -173 193 204 7 43% -155 29%
29 Octochess 5178 -178 210 236 7 36% -89 14%
30 Arminius 100813 -216 203 233 7 29% -82 0%
31 Alfil 13.1 -258 184 195 7 36% -176 43%
32 Arasan 16 -303 208 222 7 36% -208 14%
33 Redqueen 1.14 -319 216 245 7 29% -173 0%
34 Nebula 2 -323 187 212 7 29% -207 29%
35 Firefly 2.6 -463 210 272 7 14% -231 0%
36 Bugchess2 1.9 -590 222 343 7 0% -224 0%
Vinvin
Posts: 5312Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 9:40 amFull name: Vincent Lejeune
Post by Vinvin Tue Sep 17, 2013 3:44 pm
With all games from stage 1 (the 18 firsts go to stage 2) :
Code: Select all
Rank Name Elo + - games score oppo. draws
1 Bouquet 1.8 347 202 177 7 79% 189 43%
2 Gull 2.2 320 186 172 7 71% 198 57%
3 Stockfish 4 298 202 180 7 71% 187 29%
4 Komodo 1063 282 185 168 7 71% 169 57%
5 Houdini 3 259 174 165 7 64% 178 71%
6 Equinox 2b 245 210 194 7 71% 98 29%
7 Junior 13.3 216 195 185 7 64% 122 43%
8 Critter 1.6a 197 177 174 7 64% 64 71%
9 Spike 1.4 193 215 203 7 64% 82 14%
10 Rybka 4.1 184 174 165 7 64% 109 71%
11 Shredder 12 165 194 191 7 57% 112 29%
12 Exchess 7.15b 161 200 201 7 50% 150 14%
13 Naum 4.2 123 185 173 7 64% 57 43%
14 Hiarcs 14 120 180 175 7 57% 70 57%
15 Tornado 4.88 79 184 186 7 50% 70 43%
16 Toga II 280513 44 183 183 7 50% 38 43%
17 Spark 1 43 183 184 7 50% 41 43%
18 Jonny 6 38 182 184 7 50% 26 43%
19 Hannibal 220813 18 208 205 7 50% 18 14%
20 The Baron 3.35a 16 185 187 7 50% 11 43%
21 Onno 1.27 14 189 193 7 50% -7 43%
22 Sjeng WC2008 -41 204 203 7 50% -36 14%
23 Gaviota 0.87a8 -58 193 194 7 50% -63 43%
24 Minkochess 1.3 -84 186 185 7 50% -84 43%
25 Scorpio 2.76 -103 186 192 7 43% -58 29%
26 Crafty 23.6 -112 219 228 7 43% -60 0%
27 Hamsters 0.71 -137 185 184 7 50% -134 43%
28 Delphil 3 -173 193 204 7 43% -156 29%
29 Octochess 5178 -178 210 236 7 36% -89 14%
30 Arminius 100813 -216 203 233 7 29% -82 0%
31 Alfil 13.1 -258 184 195 7 36% -176 43%
32 Arasan 16 -304 209 222 7 36% -205 14%
33 Redqueen 1.14 -319 216 245 7 29% -174 0%
34 Nebula 2 -323 187 212 7 29% -207 29%
35 Firefly 2.6 -464 210 272 7 14% -233 0%
36 Bugchess2 1.9 -591 222 343 7 0% -223 0%
Laskos
Posts: 10948Joined: Wed Jul 26, 2006 10:21 pmFull name: Kai Laskos
Post by Laskos Tue Sep 17, 2013 4:55 pm
Vinvin wrote: With all games from stage 1 (the 18 firsts go to stage 2) :
Code: Select all
Rank Name Elo + - games score oppo. draws
1 Bouquet 1.8 347 202 177 7 79% 189 43%
2 Gull 2.2 320 186 172 7 71% 198 57%
3 Stockfish 4 298 202 180 7 71% 187 29%
4 Komodo 1063 282 185 168 7 71% 169 57%
5 Houdini 3 259 174 165 7 64% 178 71%
6 Equinox 2b 245 210 194 7 71% 98 29%
7 Junior 13.3 216 195 185 7 64% 122 43%
8 Critter 1.6a 197 177 174 7 64% 64 71%
9 Spike 1.4 193 215 203 7 64% 82 14%
10 Rybka 4.1 184 174 165 7 64% 109 71%
11 Shredder 12 165 194 191 7 57% 112 29%
12 Exchess 7.15b 161 200 201 7 50% 150 14%
13 Naum 4.2 123 185 173 7 64% 57 43%
14 Hiarcs 14 120 180 175 7 57% 70 57%
15 Tornado 4.88 79 184 186 7 50% 70 43%
16 Toga II 280513 44 183 183 7 50% 38 43%
17 Spark 1 43 183 184 7 50% 41 43%
18 Jonny 6 38 182 184 7 50% 26 43%
19 Hannibal 220813 18 208 205 7 50% 18 14%
20 The Baron 3.35a 16 185 187 7 50% 11 43%
21 Onno 1.27 14 189 193 7 50% -7 43%
22 Sjeng WC2008 -41 204 203 7 50% -36 14%
23 Gaviota 0.87a8 -58 193 194 7 50% -63 43%
24 Minkochess 1.3 -84 186 185 7 50% -84 43%
25 Scorpio 2.76 -103 186 192 7 43% -58 29%
26 Crafty 23.6 -112 219 228 7 43% -60 0%
27 Hamsters 0.71 -137 185 184 7 50% -134 43%
28 Delphil 3 -173 193 204 7 43% -156 29%
29 Octochess 5178 -178 210 236 7 36% -89 14%
30 Arminius 100813 -216 203 233 7 29% -82 0%
31 Alfil 13.1 -258 184 195 7 36% -176 43%
32 Arasan 16 -304 209 222 7 36% -205 14%
33 Redqueen 1.14 -319 216 245 7 29% -174 0%
34 Nebula 2 -323 187 212 7 29% -207 29%
35 Firefly 2.6 -464 210 272 7 14% -233 0%
36 Bugchess2 1.9 -591 222 343 7 0% -223 0%
Now the single round-robin with 18 engines, 17 games each engine. The first 10 qualify.
Lyudmil Tsvetkov
Posts: 6052Joined: Tue Jun 12, 2012 12:41 pm
Post by Lyudmil Tsvetkov Tue Sep 17, 2013 6:44 pm
Laskos wrote: Vinvin wrote: With all games from stage 1 (the 18 firsts go to stage 2) :
Code: Select all
Rank Name Elo + - games score oppo. draws
1 Bouquet 1.8 347 202 177 7 79% 189 43%
2 Gull 2.2 320 186 172 7 71% 198 57%
3 Stockfish 4 298 202 180 7 71% 187 29%
4 Komodo 1063 282 185 168 7 71% 169 57%
5 Houdini 3 259 174 165 7 64% 178 71%
6 Equinox 2b 245 210 194 7 71% 98 29%
7 Junior 13.3 216 195 185 7 64% 122 43%
8 Critter 1.6a 197 177 174 7 64% 64 71%
9 Spike 1.4 193 215 203 7 64% 82 14%
10 Rybka 4.1 184 174 165 7 64% 109 71%
11 Shredder 12 165 194 191 7 57% 112 29%
12 Exchess 7.15b 161 200 201 7 50% 150 14%
13 Naum 4.2 123 185 173 7 64% 57 43%
14 Hiarcs 14 120 180 175 7 57% 70 57%
15 Tornado 4.88 79 184 186 7 50% 70 43%
16 Toga II 280513 44 183 183 7 50% 38 43%
17 Spark 1 43 183 184 7 50% 41 43%
18 Jonny 6 38 182 184 7 50% 26 43%
19 Hannibal 220813 18 208 205 7 50% 18 14%
20 The Baron 3.35a 16 185 187 7 50% 11 43%
21 Onno 1.27 14 189 193 7 50% -7 43%
22 Sjeng WC2008 -41 204 203 7 50% -36 14%
23 Gaviota 0.87a8 -58 193 194 7 50% -63 43%
24 Minkochess 1.3 -84 186 185 7 50% -84 43%
25 Scorpio 2.76 -103 186 192 7 43% -58 29%
26 Crafty 23.6 -112 219 228 7 43% -60 0%
27 Hamsters 0.71 -137 185 184 7 50% -134 43%
28 Delphil 3 -173 193 204 7 43% -156 29%
29 Octochess 5178 -178 210 236 7 36% -89 14%
30 Arminius 100813 -216 203 233 7 29% -82 0%
31 Alfil 13.1 -258 184 195 7 36% -176 43%
32 Arasan 16 -304 209 222 7 36% -205 14%
33 Redqueen 1.14 -319 216 245 7 29% -174 0%
34 Nebula 2 -323 187 212 7 29% -207 29%
35 Firefly 2.6 -464 210 272 7 14% -233 0%
36 Bugchess2 1.9 -591 222 343 7 0% -223 0%
Now the single round-robin with 18 engines, 17 games each engine. The first 10 qualify.
That will already be statistically more relevant.
Laskos
Posts: 10948Joined: Wed Jul 26, 2006 10:21 pmFull name: Kai Laskos
Post by Laskos Tue Sep 17, 2013 9:48 pm
Lyudmil Tsvetkov wrote:
Yes, and Stage 3 and 4 will have even more games per engine, until the Superfinal with 2 engines in 48 games. Also, to reach the Superfinal, three, if not six engines have real chances. It will be tough.
