The grand unified rating list 2013-12-22

Discussion of computer chess matches and engine tournaments.

Moderator: Ras

Vinvin
Posts: 5312
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 9:40 am
Full name: Vincent Lejeune

The grand unified rating list 2013-12-22

Post by Vinvin »

Note on time control :
This list is made of mixed conditions (40/20, ponder=off on slow CPU ; 5+3, ponder=on on fast CPU ; 40/40, ponder=off on slow CPU ; ...)
Recent tests shows that Houdini performs well on this time control but on longer TC, SF and Komodo overtake Houdini. See details here : http://www.talkchess.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=50591 )

Games used for this list :
Old projects : rapid from WBEC, SWCR, Chess War, Mega FREEWARE
Active projects :
- CEGT 5+3 (ponder=on)
- CEGT 40/20 ponder=on
- CEGT 40/20 ponder=off
- CCRL 40/40 (ponder=off)
- CountryChess

Generated with Bayeselo and Ordo 0.7.

- If there's no "n-CPU" info, it's 1 CPU.
- If there's no "n-bit" info, it's 32 bit.

Code: Select all

Total games         1'576'969
White wins            579'893
Draws                 560'609
Black wins            436'467
No result                  0
Unique head to head     0.00%
Reference rating      2810.0 (set to "Spike 1.2")
Bayeselo : http://home.scarlet.be/vincentlejeune/r ... 131222.txt

Ordo 0.7 : http://home.scarlet.be/vincentlejeune/r ... 131222.txt
Vinvin
Posts: 5312
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 9:40 am
Full name: Vincent Lejeune

Re: The grand unified rating list 2013-12-22

Post by Vinvin »

Top 50 with 1 CPUs :

Code: Select all

Rank Name                                      Elo      +/-     Games  
  11 Houdini 4 64-bit                       3279.06    15.94     1195  
  14 Stockfish DD 64-bit                    3266.87    14.07     1524  
  18 Houdini 3.0 64-bit                     3257.91     7.34     6186  
  20 Komodo TCEC 64-bit                     3254.69    15.75     1239  
  24 Houdini 3.0 Tactical 64-bit            3250.81    17.82      955  
  27 Komodo 6 64-bit                        3246.90    10.25     3026  
  37 Houdini 3.0                            3223.91    19.60      838  
  42 Houdini 2.0 64-bit                     3220.08     7.67     5990  
  43 Komodo CCT 64-bit                      3219.60     9.12     3743  
  44 Komodo 5.1 64-bit                      3218.06    10.76     2633  
  45 Stockfish 4 64-bit                     3217.31     9.89     3072  
  46 Houdini 1.5 64-bit                     3216.60     7.36     6457  
  55 Komodo 5 64-bit                        3205.02     7.23     5917  
  62 Strelka 5.5 64-bit                     3199.58    10.72     2456  
  68 Critter 1.6a 64-bit                    3195.51    12.07     1947  
  69 Critter 1.6 64-bit                     3194.10     8.35     4442  
  72 DeepSaros 4.1.3c 64-bit                3191.77    79.34       42  
  73 Rybka 4 64-bit Exp. 42                 3190.58    16.77     1450  
  76 Houdini 2.0                            3187.87    13.06     2011  
  77 Komodo 4 64-bit                        3186.44     6.61     7501  
  78 Rybka 4.1 64-bit Exp. 79TD v.1         3186.33    19.17     1200  
  81 Houdini 1.5                            3185.39     8.39     4822  
  82 Stockfish 3.0 64-bit                   3183.56     9.19     3531  
  85 Critter 1.4 64-bit                     3182.10     8.00     5156  
  86 Fire 3.0 64-bit                        3180.50    82.22       42  
  87 IvanHoe 999946f 64-bit                 3180.42    16.05     1480  
  88 Equinox 1.90 64-bit                    3178.11    12.51     1798  
  90 Critter 1.2 64-bit                     3177.69     8.50     4537  
  91 IvanHoe B46fB 64-bit                   3177.63    16.57     1400  
  92 Strelka 5.5                            3176.74    15.98     1200  
  93 Komodo 3 64-bit                        3176.52     8.02     5174  
 100 Bouquet 1.8 64-bit                     3172.37    18.47      798  
 101 Stockfish 2.1.1 64-bit PHQ             3171.81    15.68     1530  
 102 Strelka 5.1                            3171.11    16.21     1154  
 103 Rybka 4.1 64-bit                       3170.03     5.49    10233  
 104 Stockfish 3.0                          3168.49    17.50     1000  
 105 Houdini 1.03a 64-bit                   3166.66    20.74     1000  
 106 Stockfish 2.3.1 64-bit                 3166.48    11.09     2330  
 107 Rybka 4 Exp.61 64-bit                  3165.96    10.74     2999  
 108 Gull 2.2 64-bit                        3164.14    10.01     2965  
 109 Fire 2.2 xTreme 64-bit                 3163.33    14.33     1840  
 110 Gull 2.3 64-bit                        3163.31    21.85      578  
 111 Stockfish 2.2.2 64-bit                 3163.04     9.93     3119  
 112 IvanHoe B47cB 64-bit                   3162.93    14.14     1800  
 113 Critter 1.4                            3162.67    10.63     2706  
 117 Equinox 1.70 64-bit                    3160.91    14.46     1339  
 118 Critter 1.6                            3160.69    15.59     1215  
 119 Rybka 4 64-bit                         3160.34     9.50     3939  
 120 Fire 1.5 xTreme 64-bit                 3158.45    16.37     1400  
 122 RobboLito 0.21Q 64-bit                 3157.78    15.56     1140 
ouachita
Posts: 454
Joined: Tue Jan 15, 2013 4:33 pm
Location: Ritz-Carlton, NYC
Full name: Bobby Johnson

Re: The grand unified rating list 2013-12-22

Post by ouachita »

please don't post this stuff, my competitors might see it
SIM, PhD, MBA, PE
Vinvin
Posts: 5312
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 9:40 am
Full name: Vincent Lejeune

Re: The grand unified rating list 2013-12-22

Post by Vinvin »

ouachita wrote:please don't post this stuff, my competitors might see it
:D
What are you planning ? :-)
ouachita
Posts: 454
Joined: Tue Jan 15, 2013 4:33 pm
Location: Ritz-Carlton, NYC
Full name: Bobby Johnson

Re: The grand unified rating list 2013-12-22

Post by ouachita »

Vinvin wrote::D What are you planning ? :-)
Ha, a rapid assault of the GM title
SIM, PhD, MBA, PE
User avatar
Ajedrecista
Posts: 2179
Joined: Wed Jul 13, 2011 9:04 pm
Location: Madrid, Spain.

Grand unified rating list 2013-12-22: possible duplicates.

Post by Ajedrecista »

Hello Vincent:
Vinvin wrote:Note on time control :
This list is made of mixed conditions (40/20, ponder=off on slow CPU ; 5+3, ponder=on on fast CPU ; 40/40, ponder=off on slow CPU ; ...)
Recent tests shows that Houdini performs well on this time control but on longer TC, SF and Komodo overtake Houdini. See details here : http://www.talkchess.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=50591 )

Games used for this list :
Old projects : rapid from WBEC, SWCR, Chess War, Mega FREEWARE
Active projects :
- CEGT 5+3 (ponder=on)
- CEGT 40/20 ponder=on
- CEGT 40/20 ponder=off
- CCRL 40/40 (ponder=off)
- CountryChess

Generated with Bayeselo and Ordo 0.7.

- If there's no "n-CPU" info, it's 1 CPU.
- If there's no "n-bit" info, it's 32 bit.

Code: Select all

Total games         1'576'969
White wins            579'893
Draws                 560'609
Black wins            436'467
No result                  0
Unique head to head     0.00%
Reference rating      2810.0 (set to "Spike 1.2")
Bayeselo : http://home.scarlet.be/vincentlejeune/r ... 131222.txt

Ordo 0.7 : http://home.scarlet.be/vincentlejeune/r ... 131222.txt
Great lists as usual. Let me post some possible duplicates in Ordo list (the same engines will be found at BayesElo list):

Code: Select all

3383 Bearded 06.29                            : 2166.5     285.0     560   50.9%
3422 Bearded 06.29.02                         : 2153.3     289.5     607   47.7%
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
4543 Braincrack                               : 1409.0      36.5      74   49.3%
4565 Braincrack Alpha                         : 1372.2      28.0      53   52.8%
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3034 CyberPagno 2.1                           : 2266.5     320.5     678   47.3%
3301 CyberPagno 2.10                          : 2190.4      21.0      62   33.9%
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 758 Dirty 20Apr2013 64-bit                   : 2873.5     275.0     550   50.0%
 776 Dirty Apr2013 64-bit                     : 2867.1     596.0    1121   53.2%
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1022 ExChess 6.71b 64-bit                     : 2777.3     104.5     218   47.9%
1046 ExChess v6.71b 64-bit                    : 2767.5     352.5     700   50.4%
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 867 ExChess v7.11b 64-bit                    : 2836.7     534.0    1050   50.9%
 899 ExChess 7.11b 64-bit                     : 2827.7     163.0     324   50.3%
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3163 FireFly 2.5.7b4 64-bit                   : 2227.9       6.0      11   54.5%
3269 FireFly 2.57b4 64-bit                    : 2197.2      41.5      54   76.9%
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3186 FireFly 2.5.7b7 64-bit                   : 2221.5       5.5      10   55.0%
3343 FireFly 2.57b7 64-bit                    : 2176.9      45.0      62   72.6%
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 516 Fruit 2.3.4n 64-bit                      : 2958.1      67.0      92   72.8%
 611 Fruit 2.34n 64-bit                       : 2923.3      46.5      92   50.5%
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 661 Fruit 090705                             : 2906.0    1007.5    2303   43.7%
1514 Fruit X-0705                             : 2641.5      44.5      60   74.2%
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2320 Ges 1.36                                 : 2459.0      15.0      22   68.2%
2958 GES 1.36                                 : 2289.8     199.0     397   50.1%
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1576 Jonny 2.82-2.83                          : 2623.1    1401.5    3010   46.6%
1683 Jonny 2.82                               : 2596.2       5.0      11   45.5%
2068 Jonny 2.83                               : 2515.0       4.0      11   36.4%
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1673 LittleThought 1.05.2 64-bit 2C           : 2599.2      61.0     126   48.4%
Should it be '2CPU' instead of '2C'?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
4662 Marquis 0.1.5                            : 1160.5      16.5      57   28.9%
4672 Marquis 1.5                              : 1103.7       8.0      53   15.1%
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2682 NOW 0.3abeta                             : 2364.6      13.5      22   61.4%
3160 NOW 0.3a beta                            : 2229.2       6.0      10   60.0%
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
4623 Nanook 1.6                               : 1270.5      62.0     317   19.6%
4624 Nanook 0.16                              : 1268.4      19.0      42   45.2%
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 893 NirvanaChess 1.3 64-bit                  : 2828.6     203.5     378   53.8%
 914 Nirvana Chess 1.3 64-bit                 : 2820.1     363.5     700   51.9%
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3659 Plywood 1.7.3x                           : 2065.1       6.0      22   27.3%
3828 Plywood 1.7.3                            : 1992.6     283.5     560   50.6%
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1869 Quark 2.70                               : 2557.4     134.5     213   63.1%
1891 Quark 2.70 Alpha                         : 2553.0     135.0     276   48.9%
In general, I did not take care of a or b letters (and similar things like b and b1) at the end of the name this time. I search the duplicates manually again, so there could be false positives while other true positives are not listed.

The doubt of Marquis (0.1.5 & 1.5 versions):

Marquis chess engine history
Release 1.5
Nov 18 2006 :

Marquis chess engine 0.1.5

- improved book and move search algorithm
- new feature "san"

Estimated Elo: 1950
Nanook could be affected in the same way than Marquis.

------------------------

As a side note, I made the effort of count the number of different chess engine names using Fortran, Notepad++ and a manual check (I know, a too strange method). I did this with the only reason of count the number of engines by their fisrt character in their name. The list should be something similar to:

Code: Select all

730 different engine names.
Beginning character and number of engines with this first character in their name:

3  1
a 57
b 48
c 70
d 39
e 30
f 25
g 37
h 19
i 14
j 17
k 27
l 30
m 44
n 29
o  9
p 45
q  7
r 31
s 62
t 38
u  6
v  6
w 14
x  4
y  5
z 16
It is needless to say that this list may contain a bunch of errors. I had doubts with some of the names, but this list might be a good approximation. The letter C (or c) is the winner, probably due to the word chess.

Regards from Spain.

Ajedrecista.
Vinvin
Posts: 5312
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 9:40 am
Full name: Vincent Lejeune

Re: Grand unified rating list 2013-12-22: possible duplicate

Post by Vinvin »

Ajedrecista wrote:Hello Vincent:...

It is needless to say that this list may contain a bunch of errors. I had doubts with some of the names, but this list might be a good approximation. The letter C (or c) is the winner, probably due to the word chess.

Regards from Spain.

Ajedrecista.
Thanks a lot, Jesús !
At least the half of this list is easily "mergeable" !
I'll do next list in about 1 month, when we'll have >300 games with 4 CPUs for SF DD and Komodo TCEC.