NNUE engines will probably start to cluster in their own cluster. New dendrogram.

[Laskos]

Some are showing some relatedness, here SV_22.07_2141 and Gekkehenker_27.06 net. They all are not that related to SF or Lc0 (and any other of these 2 types), even those trained on SF games and using SF search. Here only "nightnurse" is not trained on SF games and all are using SF binary for search.
In fact, they seem a bit more related to Lc0 than to SF, but just a bit.

Code: Select all

sim version 3

  Key:

  1) Lc0 96x8 (time: 100 ms  scale: 1.0)
  2) Lc0 SV_3010 (time: 100 ms  scale: 1.0)
  3) Lc0 T40 (time: 100 ms  scale: 1.0)
  4) Lc0 T70 (time: 100 ms  scale: 1.0)
  5) SF_FiNN02 (time: 100 ms  scale: 1)
  6) SF_NNUE_GK (time: 100 ms  scale: 1)
  7) SF_NNUE_nightnurse (time: 100 ms  scale: 1)
  8) SF_NNUE_SV_2441 (time: 100 ms  scale: 1)
  9) Stockfish 10 (time: 100 ms  scale: 1)
 10) Stockfish 11 (time: 100 ms  scale: 1)
 11) Stockfish 6 (time: 100 ms  scale: 1)
 12) Stockfish 8 (time: 100 ms  scale: 1)
 13) Stockfish dev (time: 100 ms  scale: 1)
 14) Stockfish dev Bis (time: 100 ms  scale: 1)
 15) Andscacs (time: 100 ms  scale: 1)
 16) Komodo 14 (time: 100 ms  scale: 1)
 17) Ethereal (time: 100 ms  scale: 1)

         1     2     3     4     5     6     7     8     9    10    11    12    13    14    15    16    17
  1.  ----- 63.60 64.23 67.24 46.61 53.10 51.52 53.24 50.62 50.30 47.90 49.45 50.57 50.42 47.98 49.50 49.73
  2.  63.60 ----- 74.82 70.39 46.82 53.96 51.30 55.22 51.30 51.23 48.35 50.07 51.76 51.92 48.46 49.84 49.00
  3.  64.23 74.82 ----- 70.25 46.08 53.28 51.01 53.87 50.23 50.10 47.41 49.22 50.44 50.45 48.06 49.15 48.14
  4.  67.24 70.39 70.25 ----- 47.63 55.83 52.67 56.71 52.62 52.61 49.78 51.07 52.62 52.18 49.73 50.44 50.30
  5.  46.61 46.82 46.08 47.63 ----- 50.76 48.09 50.46 47.71 48.15 45.04 47.51 47.84 48.07 45.74 46.16 45.39
  6.  53.10 53.96 53.28 55.83 50.76 ----- 54.60 60.96 55.12 55.38 51.52 54.33 55.80 55.24 52.05 52.11 51.76
  7.  51.52 51.30 51.01 52.67 48.09 54.60 ----- 55.07 50.79 50.53 47.80 50.33 50.39 50.34 48.82 48.97 48.64
  8.  53.24 55.22 53.87 56.71 50.46 60.96 55.07 ----- 52.65 53.02 49.65 52.02 53.03 52.61 49.87 50.51 50.12
  9.  50.62 51.30 50.23 52.62 47.71 55.12 50.79 52.65 ----- 64.79 56.43 61.67 63.57 63.51 56.05 55.83 56.25
 10.  50.30 51.23 50.10 52.61 48.15 55.38 50.53 53.02 64.79 ----- 55.52 60.31 66.04 65.53 55.55 55.90 54.95
 11.  47.90 48.35 47.41 49.78 45.04 51.52 47.80 49.65 56.43 55.52 ----- 60.96 54.79 54.86 56.02 54.90 54.05
 12.  49.45 50.07 49.22 51.07 47.51 54.33 50.33 52.02 61.67 60.31 60.96 ----- 59.03 58.62 58.55 56.19 55.45
 13.  50.57 51.76 50.44 52.62 47.84 55.80 50.39 53.03 63.57 66.04 54.79 59.03 ----- 66.06 54.88 54.60 53.96
 14.  50.42 51.92 50.45 52.18 48.07 55.24 50.34 52.61 63.51 65.53 54.86 58.62 66.06 ----- 54.22 54.90 54.47
 15.  47.98 48.46 48.06 49.73 45.74 52.05 48.82 49.87 56.05 55.55 56.02 58.55 54.88 54.22 ----- 53.91 53.44
 16.  49.50 49.84 49.15 50.44 46.16 52.11 48.97 50.51 55.83 55.90 54.90 56.19 54.60 54.90 53.91 ----- 53.86
 17.  49.73 49.00 48.14 50.30 45.39 51.76 48.64 50.12 56.25 54.95 54.05 55.45 53.96 54.47 53.44 53.86 -----

[dkappe]

I’m disappointed you didn’t include night nurse, lizardfish and toga III in your analysis, as none of those were trained from stockfish evals.

Edit: sorry. Oversight.