lithander wrote: ↑Wed Apr 28, 2021 2:32 am
That are some pretty high draw rates, aren't they? Do you still know if the draws are caused by three-fold-repetitions? I guess your engine isn't alone in not handling that properly. I really need to handle that better because while MMC won't repeat a position if it thinks it's winning it isn't actively preventing the opponent from repeating positions.
Of the 46 draws 6 were clear wins for Bricabrac. Games like this one.
[pgn][Event "TSCP.at"]
[Site "DESKTOP-HFVHK2B"]
[Date "2021.04.26"]
[Round "31"]
[White "Bricabrac"]
[Black "MinimalChessEngine"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[BlackElo "2200"]
[ECO "C45"]
[Opening "Scotch"]
[Time "22:40:30"]
[Variation "Steinitz, 5.Nc3"]
[WhiteElo "2200"]
[TimeControl "5+0"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "67"]
[WhiteType "human"]
[BlackType "human"]
1. e4 e5 2. Nf3 Nc6 3. d4 exd4 4. Nxd4 Qh4 {(Qd8-h4 Nb1-c3 Bf8-b4 Qd1-d3
Ng8-f6 Nd4-b5) -0.13/6} 5. Nc3 {(b1c3 f8b4 d1d3 b4c3 b2c3 c6e5 d3e2 g8f6
d4f5) +0.14/9} Bb4 {(Bf8-b4 Bc1-e3 Qh4xe4 Nd4-b5 Bb4xc3+ b2xc3) -0.08/6} 6.
Qd3 {(d1d3 b4c3 b2c3 c6e5 d3e2 g8f6 d4f5 h4e4 f5g7) +0.14/9} Nf6 {(Ng8-f6
Nd4xc6 d7xc6 e4-e5 Nf6-g4 g2-g3) 0.00/6} 7. Nxc6 {(d4c6 d7c6 e4e5 f6g4 g2g3
h4h5 f2f4 b4c3 d3c3) 0.00/9} dxc6 {(d7xc6 e4-e5 Nf6-g4 Qd3-e2 O-O Bc1-f4)
+0.10/6} 8. e5 {(e4e5 f6g4 d3e2 h8f8 c1f4 c8e6 a1d1 b4c3 b2c3) -0.26/9} Ng4
{(Nf6-g4 Qd3-e2 Qh4-e7 Bc1-f4 Qe7-c5 Ra1-d1) +0.31/6 1} 9. Qe2 {(d3e2 b4c5
c3e4 c5d4 g2g3 h4d8 f2f4 h8f8 f1g2) -0.38/9} Bc5 {(Bb4-c5 Nc3-e4 Ng4xe5
Ne4xc5 Qh4-b4+ Bc1-d2) +0.66/6} 10. Ne4 {(c3e4 c5d4 g2g3 h4d8 f2f4 c8f5
c2c3 f5e4 e2e4) -0.46/9} Bd4 {(Bc5-d4 c2-c3 Bd4xe5 Bc1-g5 Qh4-h5 O-O-O)
+0.27/6} 11. h3 {(h2h3 g4e5 c2c3 d4b6 e4g5 f7f6 g2g3 h4h6 g5e6) -0.22/9}
Nxe5 {(Ng4xe5 Bc1-g5 Bd4xf2+ Ke1-d2 Ne5-c4+ Qe2xc4) -0.41/6} 12. Bg5 {(c1g5
d4f2 e1d2 c8g4 g5h4 g4e2 h4f2 e2f3 g2f3) +0.98/9} Bxf2+ {(Bd4xf2+ Ke1-d2
Bc8-g4 Bg5xh4 Bg4xe2 Bh4xf2) -1.02/6} 13. Kd2 {(e1d2 c8g4 g5h4 g4e2 h4f2
e2f1 h1f1 f7f5 f2d4 a8d8) +0.89/10} Bg4 {(Bc8-g4 Bg5xh4 Bg4xe2 Bh4xf2
Be2-b5 Kd2-c1) -1.32/6} 14. Bxh4 {(g5h4 g4e2 e4f2 e2f1 h1f1 e5c4 d2c1 c4e3
f1e1) +1.04/9} Bxe2 {(Bg4xe2 Bh4xf2 Be2xf1 Rh1xf1 O-O Ra1-d1 Rf8-e8)
-1.29/7} 15. Bxf2 {(h4f2 e2b5 d2c1 a8d8 f1b5 c6b5 f2g3 e5g6 g3c7) +1.51/9}
Bxf1 {(Be2xf1 Rh1xf1 O-O-O+ Kd2-c3 a7-a5 Ra1-d1 Rh8-e8) -1.29/7 1} 16.
Rhxf1 {(h1f1 a8d8 d2c1 h7h6 f2g3 d8d5 e4c3 d5c5 f1f5) +1.70/9} O-O {(O-O
Bf2-d4 Ra8-e8 Rf1-f5 Ne5-c4+ Kd2-d3 g7-g6) -1.51/7 1} 17. Rae1 {(a1e1 e5g6
f2c5 f8e8 d2c1 b7b6 c5d4 a8d8 c2c3) +1.44/9} Rfd8+ {(Rf8-d8+ Kd2-c3 b7-b5
Bf2-c5 a7-a5 Rf1-f5 b5-b4+) -1.54/7 1} 18. Kc1 {(d2c1 e5g6 f2g3 a8c8 c1b1
h7h6 c2c3 a7a6 f1f5 d8d3) +1.62/10} Nc4 {(Ne5-c4 b2-b3 Nc4-d6 Ne4xd6 c7xd6
Bf2-d4) -1.51/6} 19. b3 {(b2b3 c4b6 c2c4 a8c8 e4c5 d8e8 c5b7 e8e1 f1e1)
+2.21/9} Nd6 {(Nc4-d6 Ne4xd6 c7xd6 Re1-e7 b7-b6 Bf2-e3 f7-f6) -1.72/7} 20.
Nxd6 {(e4d6 d8d6 e1e7 d6g6 g2g4 g6h6 f2c5 b7b6 c5a3 f7f6) +2.38/10} cxd6
{(c7xd6 Re1-e7 b7-b6 Bf2-g3 f7-f6 Re7-e6 Kg8-f7) -2.12/7} 21. Re7 {(e1e7
b7b6 f2g3 f7f6 e7e6 g8f7 f1e1 a8c8 g3d6) +2.19/9} b6 {(b7-b6 Bf2-g3 f7-f6
Re7-e6 Kg8-f7 Rf1-e1 Rd8-e8) -2.24/7} 22. Bg3 {(f2g3 f7f6 e7b7 d8b8 b7b8
a8b8 g3d6 b8c8 c1d2 g8f7) +2.41/10} f6 {(f7-f6 Rf1-e1 a7-a5 Re7-b7 Ra8-b8
Rb7xb8 Rd8xb8) -2.31/7} 23. Rb7 {(e7b7 d8b8 b7d7 b8d8 d7d6 d8d6 g3d6 a8d8
f1d1) +2.50/9} Rdb8 {(Rd8-b8 Rb7-e7 Rb8-e8 Re7-c7 d6-d5 Rc7xc6 Re8-e2)
-2.21/7 1} 24. Rc7 {(b7c7 b8c8 c7b7 c8b8 b7b8 a8b8 g3d6 b8c8 c1d2 g8f7)
+2.41/10} Rc8 {(Rb8-c8 Rc7-b7 Rc8-e8 Bg3xd6 Re8-e2 Rb7-c7 Re2xg2) -2.25/7}
25. Bxd6 {(g3d6 c8c7 d6c7 a8c8 c7f4 g8f7 c1d2 f7e6 f1g1 h7h5) +2.44/10}
Rxc7 {(Rc8xc7 Bd6xc7 Ra8-c8 Bc7-f4 Kg8-f7 Kc1-d2 Kf7-e6 Kd2-e3) -2.25/8}
26. Bxc7 {(d6c7 a8c8 c7f4 g8f7 c1d2 h7h5 h3h4 c8d8 d2c3 f7e6) +2.45/10} Rc8
{(Ra8-c8 Bc7-f4 Kg8-f7 Kc1-d2 h7-h5 Kd2-e3 h5-h4) -2.16/7} 27. Bf4 {(c7f4
g8f7 c1d2 f7e6 d2c3 g7g5 f4e3 h7h5 e3d4 f6f5) +2.45/10} Rd8 {(Rc8-d8 Rf1-d1
Rd8xd1+ Kc1xd1 Kg8-f7 Kd1-e2 Kf7-e6) -2.18/7} 28. Kb2 {(c1b2 g8f7 b2c3 h7h5
h3h4 f7e6 f1g1 d8d5 c3c4 d5c5) +2.56/10} Kf7 {(Kg8-f7 Kb2-c3 h7-h5 h3-h4
Kf7-e6 Rf1-c1 c6-c5) -2.23/7} 29. Kc3 {(b2c3 f7e6 f4e3 h7h5 h3h4 d8g8 f1e1
e6d5 e1g1) +2.59/9} h5 {(h7-h5 h3-h4 c6-c5 Rf1-e1 Rd8-d4 g2-g3 Kf7-g6)
-2.24/7} 30. Be3 {(f4e3 d8e8 c3d3 e8d8 d3c4 h5h4 f1f4 b6b5 c4c5 g7g5)
+2.52/10} Re8 {(Rd8-e8 Kc3-d3 Re8-d8+ Kd3-e4 h5-h4 Rf1-f4 Rd8-e8+) -2.22/7}
31. Kd3 {(c3d3 e8d8 d3c4 d8e8 f1f3 f7e6 e3d4 e8g8 f3e3 e6f5) +2.51/10} Rd8+
{(Re8-d8+ Kd3-c3 Rd8-e8 Rf1-e1 h5-h4 Kc3-d3 c6-c5) -2.21/7} 32. Kc3 {(d3c3
d8e8 c3d3 e8d8 d3c4 h5h4 f1f4 b6b5 c4c5 g7g5) +2.52/10} Re8 {(c6-c5 h3-h4
Rd8-e8 Kc3-d3 Re8-d8+ Kd3-e4 Kf7-e6) -2.27/7} 33. Kd3 {(c3d3 e8d8 d3c4 d8e8
f1f3 f7e6 e3d4 e8g8 f3e3 e6f5) +2.51/10} Rd8+ {(c6-c5 h3-h4 Kf7-e6 a2-a4
Re8-d8+ Kd3-e4 a7-a5) -2.27/7} 34. Kc3 {(d3c3 d8e8 c3d3 e8d8 d3c4 h5h4 f1f4
b6b5 c4c5 g7g5) +2.52/10 3-fold repetition} 1/2-1/2
[/pgn]
And in ten Bricabrac had a substantial advantage. Like this one.
[pgn][Event "TSCP.at"]
[Site "DESKTOP-HFVHK2B"]
[Date "2021.04.27"]
[Round "46"]
[White "MinimalChessEngine"]
[Black "Bricabrac"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[BlackElo "2000"]
[ECO "C92"]
[Opening "Spanish"]
[Time "01:18:05"]
[Variation "Closed, Zaitsev, 10.d4"]
[WhiteElo "2200"]
[TimeControl "5+0"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "58"]
[WhiteType "human"]
[BlackType "program"]
1. e4 e5 2. Nf3 Nc6 3. Bb5 a6 4. Ba4 Nf6 5. O-O Be7 6. Re1 d6 7. c3 b5 8.
Bb3 O-O 9. h3 Bb7 {(c8b7 d2d4 a8c8 b1d2 e5d4 c3d4 h7h6 d4d5 c6e5) +0.05/9}
10. d4 {(d2-d4 e5xd4 c3xd4 d6-d5 e4xd5 Nf6xd5) -0.02/6} Rc8 {(a8c8 f3g5
h7h6 b3f7 f8f7 g5f7 g8f7 a2a3) +0.07/8} 11. Nbd2 {(Nb1-d2 e5xd4 c3xd4
Rf8-e8 d4-d5 Nc6-e5) -0.02/6} b4 {(b5b4 a1b1 h7h6 d2c4 e5d4 c3d4 d6d5 e4d5
f6d5) +0.11/9} 12. d5 {(d4-d5 b4xc3 b2xc3 Nc6-a5 Bc1-b2 Na5xb3) +0.35/6}
bxc3 {(b4c3 d2c4 c3b2 c1b2 c6a7 c4a5 b7a8 a2a4 c7c6) -0.07/9} 13. bxc3
{(b2xc3 Nc6-a5 Bc1-b2 Na5xb3 a2xb3 c7-c6 c3-c4) +0.20/7 1} Na5 {(c6a5 b3c2
c7c6 c3c4 d8c7 c2d3 c6d5 c4d5 c8d8) +0.09/9} 14. Bb2 {(Bc1-b2 Na5xb3 a2xb3
Rf8-e8 Nd2-c4 c7-c6 d5xc6) +0.15/7 1} Nxb3 {(a5b3 d1b3 c8b8 b3c2 c7c6 c3c4
c6d5 c4d5 b8c8) +0.30/9} 15. axb3 {(a2xb3 c7-c6 d5xc6 Rc8xc6 Qd1-c2 Rc6-c8
Ra1-d1) +0.25/7} c6 {(c7c6 d5c6 c8c6 d2c4 c6c8 d1c2 b7e4 e1e4 f6e4)
-0.01/9} 16. dxc6 {(d5xc6 Rc8xc6 Nd2-c4 Rc6-c8 Qd1-c2 Rf8-e8 Ra1-d1)
+0.29/7 1} Rxc6 {(c8c6 d2f1 c6c5 f1g3 d6d5 b3b4 c5b5 f3e5 f6e4) -0.11/9}
17. Qc2 {(Qd1-c2 Qd8-a8 Ra1-d1 Rc6-c8 b3-b4 Rf8-e8) +0.25/6} Rc8 {(c6c8
a1d1 h7h6 d2c4 d8c7 c2d3 c8d8 d3c2 f8e8) +0.05/9} 18. Nc4 {(Nd2-c4 h7-h6
Ra1-b1 Qd8-c7 Rb1-d1 Rf8-e8) +0.18/6} Bxe4 {(b7e4 c2e2 e4b7 a1d1 b7d5 c4d2
a6a5 c3c4 d5c6) +1.08/9} 19. Rxe4 {(Re1xe4 Nf6xe4 Qc2xe4 d6-d5 Qe4xe5
d5xc4) -0.69/6} Nxe4 {(f6e4 c2e4 d6d5 e4e5 d5c4 b3c4 c8c4 e5e2 c4f4)
+1.30/9} 20. Qxe4 {(Qc2xe4 d6-d5 Qe4xe5 Be7-f6 Qe5-f4 d5xc4) -0.87/6} d5
{(d6d5 e4e2 d5c4 b3c4 e7f6 f3e5 d8e7 f2f4 c8e8) +0.98/9} 21. Qe2 {(Qe4-e2
e5-e4 Nc4-e3 e4xf3 Qe2xf3 Rc8-b8) -0.88/6} dxc4 {(d5c4 b3c4 e7d6 a1a6 d8c7
f3g5 d6e7 g5f3 e7f6) +1.39/9} 22. bxc4 {(b3xc4 Qd8-c7 Nf3xe5 Be7-d6 f2-f4
Bd6xe5) -1.12/6} Re8 {(f8e8 a1a6 e7f6 a6a7 c8c7 a7a5 c7c4 a5e5 f6e5)
+1.43/9} 23. Rxa6 {(Ra1xa6 Be7-c5 Nf3-d2 Rc8-a8 Ra6-c6 Ra8-a2) -1.19/6} Qc7
{(d8c7 a6a1 e7f6 f3d2 g7g6 d2e4 f6g7 c4c5 c8d8) +1.57/9} 24. Ra1 {(Ra6-a1
Be7-f6 Nf3-d2 h7-h6 Ra1-d1 Rc8-d8) -1.42/6} Bf6 {(e7f6 f3d2 h7h6 d2e4 f6e7
e2h5 e7f8 a1d1 c7c4) +1.61/9} 25. Nd2 {(Nf3-d2 h7-h6 Ra1-e1 Bf6-g5 Nd2-f3
Bg5-f6 Nf3-d2) -1.36/7 1} Bg5 {(f6g5 d2e4 g5e7 e4d2 e7g5 a1e1 g5f4 g2g3
f4d2) +1.56/9} 26. Ne4 {(Nd2-e4 Bg5-e7 Ra1-a4 h7-h6 Qe2-f3 Qc7-b6 Qf3-e2)
-1.22/7 1} Be7 {(g5e7 a1a4 h7h6 e4g3 g7g6 g3e4 f7f5 e4g3 e7f6) +1.58/9} 27.
Nd2 {(Ne4-d2 Be7-g5 Nd2-e4 Bg5-f4 c4-c5 h7-h6) -1.31/6} Bg5 {(e7g5 d2e4
g5e7 e4d2 e7g5 a1e1 g5f4 g2g3 f4d2) +1.56/9} 28. Ne4 {(Ra1-e1 Bg5-f4 Bb2-c1
Bf4xd2 Bc1xd2 Qc7xc4) -1.74/6} Be7 {(g5e7 a1a4 h7h6 e4g3 g7g6 g3e4 f7f5
e4g3 e7f6) +1.58/9} 29. Nd2 {(Ra1-a4 Re8-d8 Kg1-h2 f7-f5 Ne4-g3 f5-f4)
-1.33/6} Bg5 {(e7g5 d2e4 g5e7 e4d2 e7g5 a1e1 g5f4 g2g3 f4d2) +1.56/9 3-fold
repetition} 1/2-1/2
[/pgn]
So if 11 half points are adjusted the score would be 38-27-35 +38.
I did not see any draws where MCE allowed a 3FR when it should not have.