interesting position

Discussion of anything and everything relating to chess playing software and machines.

Moderator: Ras

jdart
Posts: 4433
Joined: Fri Mar 10, 2006 5:23 am
Location: http://www.arasanchess.org

interesting position

Post by jdart »

How long to see Rf2 is winning:

8/8/1p1p2p1/p3p1P1/PrP1Np1k/2K2P1r/2B5/5R2 w - -

(from an online game: SugarAI-Arasan, FICS 2023).

Stockfish 15 as usual is fast on this, other engines not so much.
User avatar
Dariusz
Posts: 379
Joined: Sat Jun 13, 2015 10:08 am
Location: Poland
Full name: Dariusz Domagała

Re: interesting position

Post by Dariusz »

16 seconds, Koivisto 8.16, MacBook Pro M1.

0:17/32-74: 1.Rf2, 107,6M nodes (5,9M nps), 437,4K tbhits, 1GB hash, 7 threads
0:00: 0.00/1 1.Bd1
0:00: +0.28/2 1.Rf2 Rh1
0:00: +0.84/3 1.Nxd6 Kxg5 2.Rg1+
0:00: +0.84/4 1.Nxd6 Kxg5 2.Rg1+ Kh4
0:00: +0.74/5 1.Nxd6 Rg3 2.Bb3 Rxg5 3.Ne4
0:00: +1.74/6 1.Nxd6 Kg3 2.Bxg6
0:00: +1.65/7 1.Nxd6 Kg3 2.Ne4+ Kh4 3.Nd2 Kxg5 4.Rg1+ Kf6
0:00: +1.64/8 1.Nxd6 Kg3 2.Ne4+ Kh2 3.Nd2 Rg3 4.Rf2+ Kh3 5.Ne4
0:00: +1.83/9 1.Nxd6 Rh2 2.Bxg6 Rxa4 3.Bc2 Ra3+ 4.Kb2
0:00: +0.71/10 1.Nxd6 Kxg5 2.Rg1+ Rg3 3.Ne4+ Kh4 4.Nxg3 fxg3 5.Rh1+ Kg5 6.Be4 Rxa4
0:00: +0.85/11 1.Rf2 Rh1 2.Rd2 Rh3 3.Bd1 Rb1 4.Rxd6 Rc1+ 5.Kd2
0:00: +0.09/12 1.Rf2 Kh5 2.Nxd6 Kxg5 3.Rf1 Kf6 4.Ne4+ Kg7 5.Nd2 g5 6.Re1 g4 7.Rxe5 gxf3 8.Bf5
0:00: +0.77/13 1.Rf2 Kh5 2.Nf6+ Kxg5 3.Nd5 e4 4.Bxe4 Rxa4 5.Nxb6 Ra1 6.Rd2
0:00: +0.92/14 1.Rf2 Kh5 2.Nf6+ Kh4 3.Nd5 Kg3 4.Rd2 Kxf3 5.Rd3+ Kg4 6.Rxh3 Kxh3 7.Nxb4 axb4+ 8.Kxb4 f3 9.Bxg6
0:00: +0.76/15 1.Rf2 Kh5 2.Nf6+ Kh4 3.Nd5 Kg3 4.Rd2 Kxf3 5.Rd3+ Kg4 6.Rxh3 Kxh3 7.Nxb4 axb4+ 8.Kxb4 f3 9.Bxg6 Kg4 10.Be4 f2 11.Bg2
0:00: +0.24/16 1.Rf2 Kh5 2.Nf6+ Kh4 3.Nd5 Kg3 4.Rd2 Kxf3 5.Rd3+ Kg4 6.Rxh3 Kxh3 7.Nxb4 axb4+ 8.Kxb4 f3 9.Bxg6 Kg4 10.Be4 f2 11.Bg2 Kxg5 12.Kc3 Kg4 13.Kd2 Kg3 14.Bf1
0:00: +0.76/17 1.Rf2 Kh5 2.Nf6+ Kh4 3.Nd5 Kg3 4.Rd2 Kxf3 5.Rd3+ Kg4 6.Rxh3 Kxh3 7.Nxb4 axb4+ 8.Kxb4 f3 9.Bxg6 Kg4 10.Be4
0:00: +0.61/18 1.Rf2 Kh5 2.Nf6+ Kh4 3.Nd5 Kg3 4.Rd2 Kxf3 5.Nxb4 axb4+ 6.Kxb4 e4 7.Rxd6 e3 8.Bd3 Kf2 9.Rxg6 f3 10.Rf6 e2 11.Bxe2 Kxe2 12.Re6+ Kd3 13.Rxb6
0:00: +1.24/19 1.Rf2 Kh5 2.Nf6+ Kh4 3.Nd5 Kg3 4.Rd2 Kxf3 5.Rd3+ Kg4 6.Rxh3 Kxh3 7.Nxb4 axb4+ 8.Kxb4 f3 9.Bxg6 Kh4 10.Be4 f2 11.Bg2 e4 12.Kc3
0:00: +1.17/20 1.Rf2 Kh5 2.Nf6+ Kh4 3.Nd5 Kg3 4.Rd2 Kxf3 5.Rd3+ Kg4 6.Rxh3 Kxh3 7.Nxb4 axb4+ 8.Kxb4 f3 9.Bxg6 Kg4 10.Be4 f2 11.Bg2 Kxg5 12.Kc3 Kg4 13.Bf1 Kg3 14.Kd2 Kf3 15.Kd3
0:00: +0.83/21 1.Rf2 Kh5 2.Nf6+ Kh4 3.Nd5 Kg3 4.Rd2 Kxf3 5.Rd3+ Kg4 6.Rxh3 Kxh3 7.Nxb4 axb4+ 8.Kxb4 f3 9.Bxg6 Kg4 10.Be4 f2 11.Bg2 Kxg5 12.Kc3 Kf4 13.Kd2 Kg3 14.Bf1 Kf3
0:00: +0.83/22 1.Rf2 Kh5 2.Nf6+ Kh4 3.Nd5 Kg3 4.Rd2 Kxf3 5.Rd3+ Kg4 6.Rxh3 Kxh3 7.Nxb4 axb4+ 8.Kxb4 f3 9.Bxg6 Kg4 10.Be4 f2 11.Bg2 Kxg5 12.Kc3 Kf4 13.Kd2 Kg3 14.Bf1 Kf3
0:00: +1.52/23 1.Rf2 Kh5 2.Nf6+ Kh4 3.Nd5 Kg3 4.Rd2 Kxf3 5.Rd3+ Kg4 6.Rxh3 Kxh3 7.Nxb4 axb4+ 8.Kxb4 f3 9.Bxg6 Kg4 10.Be4 f2 11.Bg2 Kxg5 12.Kc3 Kf4 13.Kd2 Kg3 14.Bf1 Kf3 15.Kd3 e4+ 16.Kd4 e3 17.Kd3
0:01: +1.56/24 1.Rf2 Kh5 2.Nf6+ Kxg5 3.Nd5 Kh4 4.Nxb4 axb4+ 5.Kxb4 Kg3 6.Rf1 Kg2 7.Rd1 Kxf3 8.Bxg6 Ke2 9.Rxd6 f3 10.Re6 f2 11.Rxe5+ Kd2 12.Rf5 Ke1 13.Kb5 f1=Q 14.Rxf1+ Kxf1 15.Be8 Re3 16.Bf7 Rb3+ 17.Kc6
0:01: +1.31/25 1.Rf2 Kh5 2.Nf6+ Kxg5 3.Nd5 Kh4 4.Nxb4 axb4+ 5.Kxb4 Kg3 6.Rd2 Kxf3 7.Rd3+ Kg4 8.Rxd6 f3 9.Rf6 Kg3 10.Rxb6 f2 11.Rf6 Rh1 12.Rxg6+ Kf4 13.Rf6+ Ke3 14.a5 f1=Q 15.Rxf1 Rxf1 16.a6 e4 17.a7
0:02: +1.56/26 1.Rf2 Kh5 2.Nf6+ Kxg5 3.Nd5 Kh4 4.Nxb4 axb4+ 5.Kxb4 Kg3 6.Rd2 Kxf3 7.Rd3+ Kg4 8.Rxd6 f3 9.Rxb6 f2 10.Rxg6+ Kf4 11.Rf6+ Ke3 12.Be4 Rh6 13.Rf3+ Kxe4 14.Rxf2 Kd3 15.Rf1 e4 16.Rd1+ Kc2 17.Re1 Re6 18.a5 e3 19.a6 Re7 20.a7 Rb7+ 21.Kc5
0:02: +1.40/27 1.Rf2 Kh5 2.Nf6+ Kxg5 3.Nd5 Kh4 4.Nxb4 axb4+ 5.Kxb4 Kg3 6.Rd2 Kxf3 7.Rd3+ Kg4 8.Rxd6 f3 9.Rxb6 f2 10.Rxg6+ Kf4 11.Rf6+ Ke3 12.Be4 Rh6 13.Rf3+ Kxe4 14.Rxf2 Rh1 15.Rb2 Kd3 16.c5 Rh8 17.Rg2 e4 18.c6 e3 19.Rg1 e2
0:04: +1.58/28 1.Rf2 Kh5 2.Nf6+ Kxg5 3.Nd5 Kh4 4.Nxb4 axb4+ 5.Kxb4 Kg3 6.Rf1 Kg2 7.Rd1 Kxf3 8.Rd3+ Kg4 9.Rxd6 f3 10.Rxb6 f2 11.Rxg6+ Kf4 12.Rf6+ Ke3 13.Be4 Rh6 14.Rf3+ Kxe4 15.Rxf2 Kd3 16.Rf1 e4 17.Rd1+ Kc2 18.Re1 Re6 19.a5 e3
0:05: +1.39/29 1.Rf2 Kh5 2.Nf6+ Kxg5 3.Nd5 Kh4 4.Nxb4 axb4+ 5.Kxb4 Kg3 6.Rf1 Kg2 7.Rd1 Kxf3 8.Rd3+ Kg4 9.Rxd6 f3 10.Rf6 Kg3 11.Bxg6 Rh6 12.Kc3 Kf2 13.c5 e4 14.c6 e3 15.c7 e2 16.c8=Q e1=Q+ 17.Kb3 Rh4 18.Qc2+ Kg1 19.Rxf3 Qb4+ 20.Ka2 Qxa4+ 21.Qxa4 Rxa4+ 22.Kb1 Kg2 23.Rf6 Kg3 24.Rxb6
0:11: +1.58/30 1.Rf2 Kh5 2.Nf6+ Kxg5 3.Nd5 Kh4 4.Nxb4 axb4+ 5.Kxb4 Kg3 6.Rd2 Kxf3 7.Rd3+ Kg4 8.Rxd6 f3 9.Rf6 Kg3 10.Rxb6 f2 11.Rf6 Rh1 12.Rxg6+ Kf4 13.Rf6+ Ke3 14.c5 Rh4+ 15.Kc3 e4 16.Bb3 Rh1 17.Bc4 Rc1+ 18.Kb4 Kd4 19.Be2 e3 20.c6 Ke5
0:16: +1.95/31 1.Rf2 Kh5 2.Nf6+ Kxg5 3.Nd5 Kh4 4.Nxb4 axb4+ 5.Kxb4 Kg3 6.Rd2 Kxf3 7.Rd3+ Kg4 8.Rxd6 f3 9.Rf6 Kg3 10.Rxb6 f2 11.Rf6 g5 12.a5 Rh1 13.Bd3 Rd1 14.Kc3 e4 15.Be2 Ra1 16.Kd4 Ra2 17.Ke3 Rxa5 18.Rf7 Ra1
Regards, Darius
https://chessengeria.eu
Vinvin
Posts: 5329
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 9:40 am
Full name: Vincent Lejeune

Re: interesting position

Post by Vinvin »

+2 after 17 seconds, SF 16 threads 5950x :

Code: Select all

FEN: 8/8/1p1p2p1/p3p1P1/PrP1Np1k/2K2P1r/2B5/5R2 w - - 0 1

Stockfish_22120921_x64_avx2:
Found 513 tablebases
NNUE evaluation using nn-ad9b42354671.nnue enabled
...
 29/60	00:04	 78.644k	17.334k	+1,63	1.Rf2 Rh1 2.Rd2 Rh3 3.Rd3 Kh5 4.Nd2 Rg3 5.Rxd6 Rxg5 6.Rd7 Kh6 7.Re7 Rg1 8.Rxe5 Ra1 9.Re4 Ra2 10.Rd4 Ra3+ 11.Bb3 g5 12.Kb2 Raxa4 13.Rd5 Kh5 14.Ne4 Kh4 15.Rxg5 Rxc4 16.Bxc4 Rxc4 17.Rg6 Kh3 18.Rxb6 a4 19.Rf6 Kg2 20.Rxf4 Rb4+ 21.Ka2 Rd4 22.Rf7 Rd3 23.Ng5 Kh2 24.Rh7+ Kg3
 30/64	00:05	 94.982k	17.326k	+1,67	1.Rf2 Kh5 2.Nf6+ Kxg5 3.Nd5 Kh4 4.Nxb4 axb4+ 5.Kxb4 Kg3 6.Rd2 Kxf3 7.Rd3+ Kg4 8.Rxd6 f3 9.Rf6 Kg3 10.Be4 f2 11.Kc3 Rh5 12.Kd3 Rf5 13.Rxg6+ Kf4 14.Bg2 e4+ 15.Kd2 Rc5 16.Bf1 Ra5 17.Rf6+ Ke5 18.Rxf2 Rxa4 19.Rf8 Ra1 20.Kc3 Rc1+ 21.Kb2 Rd1 22.Kc2 Ra1 23.Re8+ Kd4
 31/63-	00:05	 97.411k	17.268k	+1,55	1.Rf2 Kh5
 31/63+	00:05	 99.805k	17.223k	+1,64	1.Rf2
 31/63+	00:06	 110.137k	17.171k	+1,76	1.Rf2
 31/63	00:07	 127.649k	17.241k	+1,67	1.Rf2 Rh1 2.Rd2 Rh3 3.Rd3 Kh5 4.Nd2 Rg3 5.Rxd6 Rxg5 6.Rd8 Kh6 7.Rd5 Rg1 8.Rxe5 Ra1 9.Re4 Ra3+ 10.Bb3 g5 11.Kb2 Raxa4 12.Re5 Kh5 13.Ne4 Kh4 14.Rxg5 Rxc4 15.Bxc4 Rxc4 16.Rg6 Kh3 17.Rxb6 a4 18.Rh6+ Kg2 19.Rg6+ Kh3 20.Ka3 Rd4 21.Ka2 Rc4 22.Rf6 Kh2 23.Rxf4
 32/48+	00:08	 146.352k	17.446k	+1,77	1.Rf2
 32/51	00:09	 163.473k	17.532k	+1,83	1.Rf2 Rh1 2.Rd2 Rh3 3.Rd3 Kh5 4.Nd2 Rg3 5.Rxd6 Rxg5 6.Rd7 Kh6 7.Re7 Rg1 8.Rxe5 Ra1 9.Re4 Ra3+ 10.Bb3 g5 11.Kb2 Raxa4 12.Re5 g4 13.fxg4 Kg6 14.Rh5 Kg7 15.Rf5
 33/58	00:11	 200.950k	18.066k	+1,84	1.Rf2 Rh1 2.Rd2 Rh3 3.Rd3 Kh5 4.Nd2 Rg3 5.Rxd6 Rxg5 6.Rd8 Kh6 7.Rd5 Rg1 8.Rxe5 Ra1 9.Re4 Ra3+ 10.Bb3 g5 11.Kb2 Raxa4 12.Re5 Kh5 13.Ne4 Rxc4 14.Rxg5+ Kh4 15.Bxc4 Rxc4 16.Rg6 Kh3 17.Rxb6 Rc8 18.Rf6 Rb8+ 19.Ka2 Kg2 20.Rxf4 Rd8 21.Kb2 Rb8+ 22.Ka3 Rd8 23.Ng5 Rd5 24.Re4 Kg3 25.Rg4+ Kf2
 34/63+	00:12	 237.900k	18.550k	+1,93	1.Rf2
 34/63	00:13	 247.472k	18.667k	+1,91	1.Rf2 Kh5 2.Nf6+ Kxg5 3.Nd5 Kh4 4.Nxb4 axb4+ 5.Kxb4 Kg3 6.Rd2 Kxf3 7.Rd3+ Kg4 8.Rxd6 f3 9.Rf6 Kg3 10.Be4 f2 11.Kc3 Rh5 12.Kd3 Rf5 13.Rxg6+ Kf4 14.Bg2 e4+ 15.Kd2 Rc5 16.Bf1 Ra5 17.Rf6+ Ke5 18.Rxf2 Rxa4 19.Rf8 Ra1 20.Kc3 Rc1+ 21.Kb2 Rd1 22.Re8+ Kf4 23.Kc2 Re1 24.Rd8 Kf3 25.Rd1 Re3 26.Bh3 Kf4 27.Bd7 Ra3 28.Rd6 e3 29.Re6 Kf3
 35/55-	00:13	 250.368k	18.707k	+1,79	1.Rf2 Kh5
 35/61+	00:14	 274.972k	19.045k	+1,90	1.Rf2
 35/64+	00:17	 356.073k	19.798k	+2,05	1.Rf2
 35/78	00:20	 414.729k	20.132k	+2,12	1.Rf2 Rh1 2.Rd2 Rh3 3.Rd3 Kh5 4.Nd2 Rg3 5.Rxd6 Rxg5 6.Rd7 Kh6 7.Re7 Rg1 8.Rxe5 Ra1 9.Re4 Kg5 10.Re6 Ra3+ 11.Kd4 Rb2 12.Ne4+ Kh4 13.Rxg6 Kh3 14.Bd1 Ra1 15.Kc3 Rb4 16.Nf2+ Kh2 17.Bc2 Ra3+ 18.Kd4 Rb2 19.Ng4+ Kh1 20.Be4 Rxa4 21.Ne5 Rbb4 22.Bd5 Ra2 23.Ke4 b5 24.Nd3 Rba4 25.Nc5
 36/52	00:22	 469.091k	20.397k	+2,11	1.Rf2 Rh1 2.Rd2 Rh3 3.Rd3 Kh5 4.Nd2 Rh1 5.Rxd6 Ra1 6.Re6 Kxg5 7.Rxg6+ Kh4 8.Ne4 Ra3+ 9.Kd2 Kh3 10.Nf2+ Kh2 11.Ng4+ Kh1 12.Nxe5 Ra2 13.Kc3 Ra3+ 14.Kd4 Ra2 15.Bd3 Raxa4 16.Be4 b5 17.Bc6 Rb3 18.Ke4 Ra1 19.cxb5 a4 20.Kxf4 a3 21.Kf5 a2 22.f4+ Kh2 23.Rg2+ Kh3 24.Bd5 Ra3
 37/63+	00:27	 577.685k	20.861k	+2,22	1.Rf2
 37/63	00:28	 593.537k	20.877k	+2,18	1.Rf2 Rh1 2.Rd2 Rh3 3.Rd3 Kh5 4.Nd2 Rg3 5.Rxd6 Rxg5 6.Rd7 Kh6 7.Re7 Rg1 8.Rxe5 Ra1 9.Re4 Ra2 10.Rd4 Ra3+ 11.Bb3 Rbxa4 12.Kb2 b5 13.Rxf4 bxc4 14.Nxc4 Rxb3+ 15.Kxb3 Ra1 16.Rh4+ Kg7 17.Kb2 Rg1 18.Kc2 a4 19.Kd3 Kf6 20.Rd4 Rd1+ 21.Nd2 Ra1 22.Ne4+ Ke5 23.Nc3 g5 24.Rg4 a3 25.Ra4 g4 26.fxg4 Kf6 27.Ne4+ Ke6 28.Ke2
 38/72+	00:34	 723.502k	21.167k	+2,31	1.Rf2
 38/78	00:35	 748.774k	21.193k	+2,26	1.Rf2 Kh5 2.Nf6+ Kxg5 3.Nd5 Kh4 4.Nxb4 axb4+ 5.Kxb4 Kg3 6.Rd2 Kxf3 7.Rd3+ Kg4 8.Rxd6 f3 9.Rf6 Kg3 10.Be4 f2 11.Kc3 Rh5 12.Kc2 Rf5 13.Rxg6+ Kf4 14.Bg2 e4 15.Kd2 Rc5 16.Bf1 Ra5 17.Rf6+ Ke5 18.Rxf2 Rxa4 19.Rf8 Ra1 20.Kc3 Rc1+ 21.Kb2 Re1 22.Bd3 Re3 23.Re8+ Kd6 24.Bxe4 Kc5 25.Rc8+ Kb4 26.Bd5 Re2+ 27.Kc1 Kc3 28.Kd1 Rb2 29.Be6 Rd2+ 30.Ke1 Rd6 31.Bd5 Kd3 32.Rb8 Rg6 33.Rf8 Kd4 34.Rf4+ Kc5 35.Rf5 Rh6 36.Kd2 Rh2+ 37.Ke3
 39/72+	00:39	 841.576k	21.564k	+2,40	1.Rf2
 39/74	00:49	 1.095.151k	22.240k	+2,49	1.Rf2 Rh1 2.Rd2 Rh3 3.Rd3 Kh5 4.Nd2 Rg3 5.Rxd6 Rxg5 6.Rd7 Kh6 7.Re7 Rg1 8.Rxe5 Ra1 9.Re4 Ra2 10.Rd4 Ra3+ 11.Bb3 Rbxa4 12.Kb2 b5 13.Rxf4 bxc4 14.Nxc4 Rxb3+ 15.Kxb3 Ra1 16.Rh4+ Kg7 17.Kb2 Rd1 18.Kc2 Rf1 19.Nd2 Ra1 20.Kd3 a4 21.Rc4 g5 22.Rc5 Kh6 23.Ra5 a3 24.Ke3 a2 25.Kf2 Kh5 26.Ra4 Kh6 27.Ra6+ Kh5
 40/86+	01:00	 1.369.404k	22.705k	+2,61	1.Rf2
 40/86	01:02	 1.431.573k	22.762k	+2,63	1.Rf2 Kh5 2.Nf6+ Kxg5 3.Nd5 e4 4.Bxe4 Rxa4 5.Rb2 b5 6.Rxb5 Ra3+ 7.Kd4 Rh2 8.Nc3+ Kf6 9.Bd3 g5 10.Ne4+ Ke7 11.Rb7+ Kf8 12.Nxg5 Rd2 13.Ne6+ Ke8 14.Nxf4 Kd8 15.Ke3 Rc2 16.Ke4 Rd2 17.Ra7 Kc8 18.Ra6 Kd7 19.Bf1 Ra1 20.Bh3+ Kc7 21.Nd5+ Kb7 22.Rxd6 Re1+ 23.Kf5 Rb2 24.Rd7+ Kb8 25.Ne7 Rb6 26.c5 Rbe6 27.Nd5 Rc6
 41/84	01:12	 1.682.299k	23.047k	+2,53	1.Rf2 Kh5 2.Nf6+ Kxg5 3.Nd5 Kh4 4.Nxb4 axb4+ 5.Kxb4 Kg3 6.Rf1 Kg2 7.Rd1 Kxf3 8.Rd3+ Kg4 9.Rxd6 f3 10.Rf6 Kg3 11.Be4 f2 12.Kc3 Rh5 13.Kd3 Rf5 14.Rxg6+ Kf4 15.Bg2 e4+ 16.Kd2 Rc5 17.Bf1 Ra5 18.Rf6+ Ke5 19.Rxf2 Rxa4 20.Rf8 Ra1 21.Kc3 Rc1+ 22.Kb2 Re1 23.Bd3 Re3 24.Re8+ Kd6 25.Bxe4 Kc5 26.Rc8+ Kb4 27.Bd5 Re2+ 28.Kc1 Kc3 29.Kd1 Rb2 30.Rd8 Rd2+ 31.Ke1 Rb2 32.Bf7 Kb4 33.Rc8 Ra2 34.Be6 Ra5 35.Kd2 Rg5 36.Bd7 Rg2+ 37.Kd3 Rg3+ 38.Kd4 Rg1 39.Bb5
 42/87	01:17	 1.795.168k	23.157k	+2,44	1.Rf2 Rh1 2.Rd2 Rh3 3.Rd3 Kh5 4.Nd2 Rg3 5.Rxd6 Rxg5 6.Rd7 Kh6 7.Re7 Rg1 8.Rxe5 Ra1 9.Re4 Ra2 10.Rd4 Kg5 11.Rd6 Ra3+ 12.Kd4 Rb2 13.Ne4+ Kh4 14.Rxg6 Kh3 15.Bd3 Kh2 16.Rg4 Rxa4 17.Rh4+ Kg2 18.Rxf4 Ra3 19.Rf8 Rbb3 20.Rg8+ Kh2 21.Nf2 Ra2 22.Ng4+ Kh3 23.Ne3 a4 24.Bc2
 43/45+	01:19	 1.843.242k	23.194k	+2,65	1.Rf2
 43/73	01:22	 1.926.846k	23.230k	+2,56	1.Rf2 Rh1 2.Rd2 Rh3 3.Rd3 Kh5 4.Nd2 Rg3 5.Rxd6 Rxg5 6.Rd7 Kh6 7.Re7 Rg1 8.Rxe5 Ra1 9.Re4 Ra2 10.Rd4 Ra3+ 11.Bb3 g5 12.Kb2 Raxa4 13.Rd5 Kh5 14.Ne4 Rxc4 15.Rxg5+ Kh4 16.Bxc4 Rxc4 17.Rg6 Kh3 18.Rxb6 a4 19.Ka3 Kh2 20.Rb2+ Kg1 21.Rb4 Rc8 22.Ng5 Rf8 23.Kxa4 Kg2 24.Rb5 Re8 25.Kb4 Rc8 26.Ra5 Rc7 27.Rc5 Rb7+ 28.Kc4 Ra7 29.Kb5 Rb7+ 30.Kc6
 44/70+	01:34	 2.218.694k	23.462k	+2,75	1.Rf2
 44/83	01:48	 2.559.285k	23.627k	+2,81	1.Rf2 Rh1 2.Rd2 Rh3 3.Rd3 Kh5 4.Nd2 Rg3 5.Rxd6 Rxg5 6.Rd7 Kh6 7.Re7 Rg1 8.Rxe5 Ra1 9.Re4 Ra2 10.Rd4 Ra3+ 11.Bb3 Rbxa4 12.Kb2 b5 13.Rxf4 bxc4 14.Nxc4 Rxb3+ 15.Kxb3 Ra1 16.Rh4+ Kg7 17.Kb2 Rd1 18.Kc2 Rd5 19.Nd2 Kf7 20.Ra4 Kf6 21.Kd1 Re5 22.Ne4+ Ke6 23.Kd2 Kd7 24.Rc4 Rb5 25.Ke3 Re5 26.Kf4 Rf5+ 27.Kg4 Rb5 28.Kg3 Re5 29.Nc3 Kd6 30.Kg4 Kd7 31.f4 Rf5 32.Ne2 Kd6 33.Ra4 Rb5
 45/77	02:05	 3.003.320k	23.846k	+2,84	1.Rf2 Rh1 2.Rd2 Rh3 3.Rd3 Kh5 4.Nd2 Rg3 5.Rxd6 Rxg5 6.Rd7 Kh6 7.Re7 Rh5 8.Re6 Rh1 9.Rxe5 Ra1 10.Re4 Ra3+ 11.Bb3 g5 12.Kb2 Raxa4 13.Re5 Kg6 14.Ne4 Kh6 15.Nxg5 Ra1 16.Kxa1 Rxb3 17.Ka2 Rc3 18.Rb5 Kg6 19.Kb2 Rxc4 20.Nh3 Kf6 21.Rxb6+ Ke5 22.Rb5+ Kd4 23.Rxa5 Ke3 24.Ng5 Rc6 25.Kb3 Kf2 26.Kb4 Kg2 27.Kb5 Rc1 28.Ra3 Kg3 29.Kb4 Rc7 30.Rc3 Rg7 31.Ne4+ Kg2
 46/76	02:34	 3.714.498k	24.016k	+2,99	1.Rf2 Rh1 2.Rd2 Rh3 3.Rd3 Kh5 4.Nd2 Rg3 5.Rxd6 Rxg5 6.Rd7 Kh6 7.Re7 Rh5 8.Re6 Rh1 9.Rxe5 Ra1 10.Re4 Ra2 11.Rd4 Ra3+ 12.Bb3 Rbxa4 13.Kb2 b5 14.Rxf4 bxc4 15.Nxc4 Rxb3+ 16.Kxb3 Ra1 17.Rh4+ Kg7 18.Kb2 Re1 19.Re4 Rd1 20.Kc2 Rd5 21.Nd2 g5 22.Rc4 Rb5 23.Kd3 Rb4 24.Rc7+ Kg6 25.Ne4 Rb3+ 26.Ke2 Kf5 27.Rg7 Kf4 28.Rf7+ Ke5 29.Nxg5 Rb2+ 30.Ke3 Rb3+ 31.Kf2
 47/67	02:43	 3.938.106k	24.082k	+3,01	1.Rf2 Rh1 2.Rd2 Rh3 3.Rd3 Kh5 4.Nd2 Rg3 5.Rxd6 Rxg5 6.Rd7 Kh6 7.Re7 Rg1 8.Rxe5 Kg7 9.Re4 g5 10.Re5 Rg3 11.Rf5 Kg8 12.Ne4 Rxf3+ 13.Kd4 g4 14.Nf6+ Kg7 15.Nxg4 Rh3 16.Rxf4 Rb2 17.Be4 Ra2 18.Nf6 Rxa4 19.Ke5 Rh8 20.Rg4+ Kf8 21.Nd7+ Ke8 22.Nxb6 Ra1 23.Kd6 Rh6+ 24.Kc5 Ke7 25.Kb5 Kf6 26.c5 Ke7 27.Bd5 Rc1 28.Re4+ Kd8
 48/82	03:39	 5.349.251k	24.414k	+3,09	1.Rf2 Rh1 2.Rd2 Rh3 3.Rd3 Kh5 4.Nd2 Rh1 5.Rxd6 Rc1 6.Re6 Kxg5 7.Rxg6+ Kh5 8.Rg7 Re1 9.Rh7+ Kg5 10.Ne4+ Kg6 11.Nf2+ Kg5 12.Rg7+ Kf6 13.Rg6+ Ke7 14.Ng4 e4 15.fxe4 Rg1 16.Ne5 Rg3+ 17.Kd4 Rb2 18.Bd3 Rb3 19.Rh6 f3 20.Rh7+ Ke6 21.Rh2 Ra3 22.Rb2 Ke7 23.Rf2 Rxa4 24.Nxf3 Rg8 25.Nh4 Ke6 26.Nf5 Rd8+ 27.Ke3 Ra1 28.Nd4+ Kd7 29.Rf7+ Ke8 30.Ra7 Rd7 31.Ra8+ Ke7 32.Ra6 a4 33.Nf5+ Kf7 34.c5 Rxd3+ 35.Kxd3 bxc5 36.Kc4 a3
 49/89	03:55	 5.743.005k	24.405k	+2,98	1.Rf2 Rh1 2.Rd2 Rh3 3.Rd3 Kh5 4.Nd2 Rh1 5.Rxd6 Rc1 6.Re6 Kxg5 7.Rxg6+ Kh5 8.Rg7 Re1 9.Rh7+ Kg5 10.Ne4+ Kf5 11.Nf2+ Kg5 12.Rg7+ Kf6 13.Rg6+ Ke7 14.Ng4 e4 15.fxe4 Rg1 16.Ne5 Rg3+ 17.Kd4 Rb2 18.Bd3 Rb3 19.Rh6 f3 20.Rh7+ Ke6 21.Rh2 Ra3 22.Rb2 Ke7 23.Rf2 Rxa4 24.Nxf3 Rg8 25.Nh4 Rd8+ 26.Ke3 Ke6 27.Nf5 Ra1 28.Nd4+ Kd7 29.Rf7+ Ke8 30.Ra7 Rd7 31.Ra6 Re1+ 32.Ne2 Kd8 33.Rxb6 Ra7 34.Rh6 a4 35.Kd2 a3 36.Nc3 Rg1 37.Rh8+ Kc7 38.Nb5+ Kb6 39.Rh6+ Ka5 40.Nxa7 a2 41.c5
 50/59+	04:12	 6.179.325k	24.467k	+3,24	1.Rf2
 50/88	05:54	 8.744.215k	24.633k	+3,39	1.Rf2 Rh1 2.Rd2 Rh3 3.Rd3 Kh5 4.Nd2 Rg3 5.Rxd6 Rxg5 6.Rd7 Kh6 7.Re7 Rg3 8.Rxe5 Kg7 9.Re7+ Kf6 10.Ra7 Ke5 11.c5 bxc5 12.Rxa5 Kd5 13.Ra8 Rg1 14.Rd8+ Ke6 15.Ne4 Ke7 16.Rc8 Rd4 17.a5 Rd8 18.Rxc5 Rb8 19.Re5+ Kf7 20.Nc5 Rf1 21.Be4 Rc1+ 22.Kd3 Kg7 23.a6 Rd8+ 24.Ke2 Kh6 25.Ne6 Re8 26.Rc5 Ra1 27.Rc6 Ra8 28.Nc7 Ra7 29.Rxg6+ Kh5 30.Nd5 Ra2+ 31.Kf1 Ra1+ 32.Kg2
 51/89	07:59	 11.938.851k	24.904k	+3,52	1.Rf2 Rh1 2.Rd2 Rh3 3.Rd3 Kh5 4.Nd2 Kxg5 5.Rxd6 Rh2 6.Rxg6+ Kh5 7.Rc6 Rh1 8.Rc8 Ra1 9.Re8 Re1 10.Rh8+ Kg5 11.Ne4+ Kg6 12.Nf2+ Kg5 13.Rg8+ Kf6 14.Rg6+ Ke7 15.Ng4 e4 16.fxe4 Rg1 17.Ne5 Rg3+ 18.Kd4 Rb2 19.Bd3 Rb3 20.Rh6 f3 21.Rh7+ Ke6 22.Rh2 Ra3 23.Rb2 Ke7 24.Rf2 Rxa4 25.Nxf3 Rh3 26.Ng1 Rh6 27.Ne2 Ra1 28.e5 Rd1 29.Nf4 Kd8 30.Nd5 a4 31.Rf8+ Kd7 32.Rf7+ Ke8 33.Ra7 Rh4+ 34.Kc3 Rh3 35.Nf4 Re3 36.e6 Rf3 37.Kc2 Re1 38.Nd5 Rxe6 39.Nc7+ Ke7 40.Nxe6+ Kxe6 41.Kc3 Kd6
 52/101	09:22	 14.088.300k	25.036k	+3,74	1.Rf2 Rh1 2.Rd2 Rh3 3.Rd3 Kh5 4.Nd2 Rg3 5.Rxd6 Rxg5 6.Rd7 Kh6 7.Re7 Rg3 8.Rxe5 Kg7 9.Re7+ Kf6 10.Ra7 Ke6 11.c5 bxc5 12.Rxa5 Kd5 13.Ra8 g5 14.Rd8+ Ke6 15.Rc8 Ke7 16.Rxc5 Rb8 17.Bf5 Rd8 18.Bg4 Rg1 19.Rxg5 Ra1 20.a5 Rc1+ 21.Kb2 Rd1 22.Nc4 Rb8+ 23.Kc3 Kf6 24.Rf5+ Kg6 25.Rc5 Rc1+ 26.Kd4 Rd8+ 27.Ke4 Kf6 28.a6 Re1+ 29.Kxf4 Rd4+ 30.Kg3
 53/71	10:17	 15.543.929k	25.170k	+3,79	1.Rf2 Rh1 2.Rd2 Rh3 3.Rd3 Kh5 4.Nd2 Rg3 5.Rxd6 Rxg5 6.Rd7 Kh6 7.Re7 Rg1 8.Rxe5 Ra1 9.Re4 Ra2 10.Rd4 Ra3+ 11.Bb3 Rbxa4 12.Kb2 b5 13.Rxf4 bxc4 14.Nxc4 Rxb3+ 15.Kxb3 Ra1 16.Rh4+ Kg5 17.Rg4+ Kf6 18.Kc2 Ra4 19.Kc3 Ra2 20.Kd3 Ra1 21.Rf4+ Ke7 22.Rd4 Rd1+ 23.Nd2 Ra1 24.Rd5 Ke6 25.Rc5 a4 26.Rg5 Kf7 27.Ra5 a3 28.Nc4 a2 29.Ne3 g5 30.Ke4 Kg6 31.Nc2 Rb1 32.Ra6+ Kh5 33.Rxa2 Rb8
 54/80	15:00	 22.669.608k	25.175k	+4,00	1.Rf2 Rh1 2.Rd2 Rh3 3.Rd3 Kh5 4.Nd2 Rg3 5.Rxd6 Rxg5 6.Rd7 Kh6 7.Re7 Rh5 8.Re6 Kg7 9.Rxg6+ Kf7 10.Rc6 Rh2 11.c5 bxc5 12.Rxc5 Re2 13.Bd3 Re1 14.Rxa5 Rb8 15.Rb5 Rd8 16.Nc4 Kf6 17.Bc2 Rc8 18.Kb3 Rc1 19.Rb4 Kg5 20.a5 Kh4 21.Be4 Ra1 22.Rb5 Kg3 23.Nxe5 Kg2 24.Kb2 Rcc1 25.Nc4 Re1 26.Na3 Rad1 27.a6 Rd8 28.Nc4 Re2+ 29.Kb3 Rxe4
 55/90	20:31	 30.681.412k	24.914k	+4,04	1.Rf2 Rh1 2.Rd2 Rh3 3.Rd3 Kh5 4.Nd2 Rh1 5.Rxd6 Ra1 6.Re6 Kxg5 7.Rxg6+ Kh5 8.Rg2 Ra3+ 9.Bb3 Ra1 10.Re2 Kh4 11.Rxe5 Kg3 12.Re4 Rh1 13.Bc2 Rh7 14.Re6 Rc7 15.Re2 Rc6 16.Bf5 Rxa4 17.Bd7 Raxc4+ 18.Nxc4 Rc7 19.Bb5 Kxf3 20.Kd3 Kg4 21.Nd2 Ra7 22.Rg2+ Kf5 23.Rg8 f3 24.Nxf3 a4 25.Nd4+ Kf6 26.Rf8+ Kg6 27.Bc6 a3 28.Ra8 Re7 29.Rxa3 Kf6 30.Ra2
 56/84	25:49	 38.512.004k	24.854k	+4,36	1.Rf2 Rh1 2.Rd2 Rh3 3.Rd3 Kh5 4.Nd2 Rh1 5.Rxd6 Ra1 6.Re6 Kxg5 7.Rxg6+ Kh4 8.Ne4 Ra3+ 9.Kd2 Kh3 10.Nf2+ Kh2 11.Ng4+ Kh1 12.Nxe5 Ra2 13.Kc3 Ra3+ 14.Kd4 Ra2 15.Be4 Raxa4 16.Bc6 Ra1 17.Nd3 Rb3 18.Nxf4 Rd1+ 19.Ke5 Re1+ 20.Kf5 Ree3 21.Ne6 Kh2 22.f4 Rg3 23.Ng5 Kg1 24.Rh6 Kf1 25.Ke5 Ke2 26.Ne4 Rh3 27.Rxh3 Rxh3 28.f5 Ke3 29.Nd6 Rh5 30.Bb5 Kf3 31.Bd7 Kg4
 57/92	31:25	 46.641.078k	24.743k	+4,40	1.Rf2 Rh1 2.Rd2 Rh3 3.Rd3 Kh5 4.Nd2 Rg3 5.Rxd6 Rxg5 6.Rd7 Kh6 7.Re7 Rh5 8.Re6 Rg5 9.Ne4 Rg2 10.Rxe5 Rg1 11.Nd2 Kg7 12.Re4 g5 13.Re5 Rg3 14.Rf5 Kg8 15.Ne4 Rxf3+ 16.Kd4 g4 17.Nf6+ Kg7 18.Nxg4 Rh3 19.Rxf4 Rh1 20.Ne5 Rb2 21.Rf7+ Kg8 22.Rf2 Kg7 23.Kc3 Ra2 24.Rg2+ Kf8 25.Nd7+ Ke7 26.Nxb6 Rh4 27.Nd5+ Kd6 28.Kb3 Ra1 29.Rg6+ Kc5 30.Nc3 Rf1 31.Ne4+ Kd4 32.Rd6+ Ke3 33.Rd5 Rh2 34.Nd6 Rc1 35.Nf5+ Kf4 36.Nd4 Kg4 37.Kb2 Rb1+ 38.Kxb1
Jouni
Posts: 3893
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 8:15 pm
Full name: Jouni Uski

Re: interesting position

Post by Jouni »

Stockfish has a problem in this position, maybe pruning? Nxd6 wins also and even faster!

Analysis by Crystal 5 KWK bmi2:

...
1.Nxd6 Kxg5 2.Rg1+ Kf6 3.Rxg6+ Ke7 4.Be4 Rh1 5.Nc8+ Ke8 6.Nxb6 Rc1+ 7.Kd2 Ra1 8.Rg8+ Kf7 9.Bd5+ Ke7 10.c5 Rd4+ 11.Kc2 Rdd1 12.Rg7+ Ke8 13.Bc6+ Kf8 14.Rg2 e4 15.Bxe4 Rac1+ 16.Kb2 Rxc5 17.Rc2 Rg5 18.Nc4 Ke7 19.Rd2 Rh1 20.Rd5 Rxd5 21.Bxd5 Rh5 22.Be4 Rc5 23.Kb3 Kf6 24.Kc3 Ke6 25.Kd4 Rc7 26.Bd5+ Kf5 27.Ne5 Rc1 28.Nc4 Ra1 29.Be4+ Kg5
+- (5.17) Depth: 40/80 00:06:06 1993mN, tb=4709916
Jouni
User avatar
Eelco de Groot
Posts: 4717
Joined: Sun Mar 12, 2006 2:40 am
Full name:   Eelco de Groot

Re: interesting position

Post by Eelco de Groot »

Taking the new Rebel bolide for a testrun, the behaviour was very different from Rebel 16 (first version of 16). Both had different winning moves, playing this move right from the start. Because of different moves they also show very different times to depth. Rebel 16 is still not at depth 32 and we are 15 minutes into the search. Rebel 16.1 would have passed that long ago even with a different move I think. I can not really compare that from this because of the different move choice. But I would not have expected this difference if the NNUE had not changed besides the change with pondering and the new time control algorithm. Mysteries :)

Code: Select all

8/8/1p1p2p1/p3p1P1/PrP1Np1k/2K2P1r/2B5/5R2 w - -

Engine: Rebel-16.1 (512 MB)
gemaakt door Ed Schroder and Chris Whittington (C) 2

19/40  0:01   +1.48++  1.Tf2 (699.710) 683 

19/33  0:01   +1.63    1.Tf2 Kh5 2.Pf6+ Kxg5 3.Pd5 e4 
                       4.Lxe4 Txa4 5.Tb2 b5 6.Txb5 Ta3+ 
                       7.Kd4 Th2 8.Pc3+ Kh4 9.Lxg6 Kg3 
                       10.Pe4+ Kxf3 11.Pxd6 Td2+ 12.Kc5 (774.823) 703 

20/38  0:01   +0.99++  1.Tf2 (1.122.492) 769 

20/37  0:01   +1.56    1.Tf2 Kh5 2.Pf6+ Kh4 3.Pd5 Kg3 4.Td2 Kxf3 
                       5.Td3+ Kg4 6.Txh3 Kxh3 7.Pxb4 axb4+ 
                       8.Kxb4 Kg4 9.Lxg6 f3 10.Le4 f2 
                       11.Ld3 Kxg5 12.Kc3 Kf4 (1.146.866) 773 

21/46  0:01   +0.92++  1.Tf2 (1.396.164) 801 

21/44  0:01   +0.97    1.Tf2 Kh5 2.Pxd6 Kxg5 3.Tf1 Kf6 
                       4.Pe4+ Ke7 5.Lb3 Kf8 6.Tf2 Th1 7.Pf6 Tc1+ 
                       8.Kb2 Tcxc4 9.Pd5 Txb3+ 10.Kxb3 Td4 
                       11.Pc3 Kf7 12.Kc2 Ke6 13.Th2 e4 
                       14.Pxe4 (1.530.793) 811 

22/40  0:02   +1.13++  1.Tf2 (1.729.322) 824 

22/37  0:02   +1.29++  1.Tf2 (1.800.256) 830 

22/32  0:02   +1.53++  1.Tf2 (1.874.819) 836 

22/38  0:02   +1.35++  1.Tf2 (2.282.030) 859 

22/39  0:03   +1.50    1.Tf2 Kh5 2.Kd3 Kh4 3.Pxd6 Th1 4.Te2 Tc1 
                       5.Txe5 Kg3 6.Kd2 Tg1 7.Te6 Kxf3 
                       8.Lxg6 Txa4 9.Lh5+ Kg3 10.g6 Ta2+ 
                       11.Kd3 (2.827.460) 877 

23/45  0:04   +0.59    1.Tf2 Kh5 2.Pf6+ Kh4 3.Pd5 Kg3 4.Td2 Kxf3 
                       5.Td3+ Kg4 6.Txh3 Kxh3 7.Pxb4 axb4+ 
                       8.Kxb4 Kg4 9.Lxg6 f3 10.Le4 f2 
                       11.Lg2 Kxg5 12.Kc3 Kf4 13.Kd2 Kg3 
                       14.Lf1 (3.843.422) 899 

24/40  0:04   +0.75++  1.Tf2 (3.960.600) 901 

24/40  0:04   +0.91++  1.Tf2 (4.005.296) 902 

24/43  0:04   +1.15++  1.Tf2 (4.044.757) 904 

24/44  0:04   +1.51++  1.Tf2 (4.150.084) 906 

24/44  0:04   +2.05++  1.Tf2 (4.522.473) 910 

24/50  0:05   +2.27    1.Tf2 Kh5 2.Pf6+ Kxg5 3.Pd5 e4 
                       4.Lxe4 Txa4 5.Tb2 b5 6.Txb5 Ta3+ 
                       7.Kb2 Taxf3 8.Lxf3 Txf3 9.Txa5 Kh4 
                       10.Ta6 g5 11.Txd6 g4 12.c5 g3 13.Tg6 Tf2+ 
                       14.Kc3 (5.282.462) 916 

25/41  0:06   +2.27++  1.Tf2 Kh5 (5.934.326) 921 

25/54  0:06   +2.51++  1.Tf2 (6.436.064) 926 

25/43  0:07   +2.41++  1.Tf2 Th1 (7.215.214) 928 

25/52  0:08   +2.74    1.Tf2 Kh5 2.Pf6+ Kxg5 3.Pd5 e4 
                       4.Lxe4 Txa4 5.Tb2 b5 6.Txb5 Ta3+ 
                       7.Kb2 Taxf3 8.Lxf3 Txf3 9.Txa5 Tg3 
                       10.Kc2 f3 11.Kd3 f2+ 12.Ke2 Tf3 
                       13.Kf1 Kg4 14.Ta6 (7.614.387) 931 

26/50  0:08   +2.74++  1.Tf2 Th1 (7.980.803) 933 

26/36  0:09   +2.38++  1.Tf2 Th1 (8.437.468) 937 

26/55  0:09   +2.73    1.Tf2 Kh5 2.Pf6+ Kh4 3.Pd5 Kg3 4.Td2 Kxf3 
                       5.Td3+ Kg4 6.Txh3 Kxh3 7.Pxb4 axb4+ 
                       8.Kxb4 Kg4 9.Lxg6 f3 10.Le4 f2 
                       11.Lg2 Kxg5 12.Kc3 e4 13.Kd2 Kf4 
                       14.Ke2 (9.264.959) 938 

27/41  0:10   +2.73++  1.Tf2 Th1 (10.239.287) 940 

27/38  0:11   +2.37++  1.Tf2 Th1 (10.733.901) 943 

27/40  0:11   +1.59    1.Tf2 Kh5 2.Pf6+ Kh4 3.Pd5 Kg3 4.Td2 Kxf3 
                       5.Td3+ Kg4 6.Txh3 Kxh3 7.Pxb4 axb4+ 
                       8.Kxb4 Kg4 9.Lxg6 f3 10.Le4 f2 
                       11.Lg2 Kxg5 12.Kc3 Kf4 13.Kd2 e4 
                       14.Ke2 (10.956.795) 943 

28/49  0:13   +1.75++  1.Tf2 Th1 (12.950.161) 938 

28/45  0:13   +1.91++  1.Tf2 (13.022.446) 939 

28/49  0:13   +2.15++  1.Tf2 (13.096.943) 939 

28/47  0:14   +2.25    1.Tf2 Kh5 2.Pf6+ Kh4 3.Pd5 Kg3 4.Td2 Kxf3 
                       5.Td3+ Kg4 6.Txh3 Kxh3 7.Pxb4 axb4+ 
                       8.Kxb4 f3 9.Lxg6 Kg4 10.Le4 f2 
                       11.Lg2 Kxg5 12.Kc3 e4 13.Kd2 Kf4 
                       14.Ke2 (13.455.309) 941 

29/51  0:14   +2.41++  1.Tf2 Th1 (13.784.603) 941 

29/52  0:14   +2.57++  1.Tf2 (14.074.661) 941 

29/45  0:15   +2.45++  1.Tf2 Th1 (14.515.793) 943 

29/52  0:15   +2.36++  1.Tf2 Th1 (14.778.771) 944 

29/49  0:15   +2.30    1.Tf2 Kh5 2.Pf6+ Kh4 3.Pd5 Kg3 4.Td2 Kxf3 
                       5.Td3+ Kg4 6.Txh3 Kxh3 7.Pxb4 axb4+ 
                       8.Kxb4 f3 9.Lxg6 Kg4 10.Le4 f2 
                       11.Lg2 Kxg5 12.Kc3 e4 13.Kd2 Kf4 
                       14.Ke2 (14.832.784) 945 

30/42  0:17   +1.94++  1.Tf2 Th1 (16.731.441) 946 

30/64  0:18   +2.48++  1.Tf2 (17.179.813) 946 

30/61  0:24   +3.11    1.Tf2 Kh5 2.Pf6+ Kxg5 3.Pd5 e4 
                       4.Lxe4 Txa4 5.Tb2 b5 6.Txb5 Ta3+ 
                       7.Kb2 Taxf3 8.Lxf3 Txf3 9.Txa5 Kf5 
                       10.Pc3+ Ke6 11.Kc2 Te3 12.Pd5 Tf3 
                       13.Pc7+ Kf6 14.Td5 (22.679.908) 942 

31/64  0:34   +2.47++  1.Tf2 Th1 (32.333.122) 945 

31/55  0:35   +2.37    1.Tf2 Kh5 2.Pf6+ Kxg5 3.Pd5 Kh4 
                       4.Pxb4 axb4+ 5.Kxb4 Kg3 6.Td2 Kxf3 
                       7.Td3+ Kg4 8.Txd6 f3 9.Txg6+ Kf4 
                       10.Txb6 f2 11.Tf6+ Ke3 12.Le4 Th6 
                       13.Tf5 Kxe4 14.Txf2 (33.418.096) 946 

32/64  0:38   +2.53++  1.Tf2 Th1 (36.043.337) 945 

32/57  0:45   +2.45++  1.Tf2 Th1 (43.187.486) 942 

32/51  0:47   +2.08    1.Tf2 Kh5 2.Pf6+ Kxg5 3.Pd5 Kh4 
                       4.Pxb4 axb4+ 5.Kxb4 Kg3 6.Td2 Kxf3 
                       7.Td3+ Kg4 8.Txd6 f3 9.Txg6+ Kf4 
                       10.Txb6 f2 11.Tf6+ Ke3 12.Le4 Th6 
                       13.Tf5 Kxe4 14.Txf2 (44.814.863) 942 

33/51  0:51   +2.24++  1.Tf2 Th1 (48.519.315) 939 

33/59  0:52   +2.40++  1.Tf2 (49.381.805) 940 

33/53  0:54   +2.08    1.Tf2 Kh5 2.Pf6+ Kxg5 3.Pd5 Kh4 
                       4.Pxb4 axb4+ 5.Kxb4 Kg3 6.Td2 Kxf3 
                       7.Td3+ Kg4 8.Txd6 f3 9.Txg6+ Kf4 
                       10.Txb6 f2 11.Tf6+ Ke3 12.Le4 Th6 
                       13.Tf5 Kxe4 14.Txf2 (51.307.059) 940 

34/58  0:55   +2.24++  1.Tf2 Th1 (52.460.534) 939 

34/48  0:57   +2.40++  1.Tf2 (53.600.838) 937 

34/64  1:05   +2.64++  1.Tf2 (61.851.022) 939 

34/68  1:11   +3.00++  1.Tf2 (67.298.988) 940 

34/66  2:21   +3.54++  1.Tf2 (130.463.561) 921 

34/71  3:16   +3.61    1.Tf2 Kh5 2.Pf6+ Kxg5 3.Pd5 Kh4 
                       4.Pxb4 axb4+ 5.Kxb4 Kg3 6.Td2 Kxf3 
                       7.Td3+ Kg4 8.Txd6 f3 9.Tf6 Kg3 
                       10.Txg6+ Kf4 11.Txb6 f2 12.Tf6+ Ke3 
                       13.Le4 Th6 14.Tf5 (181.176.227) 922 

35/56  3:25   +3.61++  1.Tf2 Tg3 (189.771.598) 923 

35/65  4:14   +3.73    1.Tf2 Kh5 2.Pf6+ Kxg5 3.Pd5 Kh4 
                       4.Pxb4 axb4+ 5.Kxb4 Kg3 6.Td2 Kxf3 
                       7.Td3+ Kg4 8.Txd6 f3 9.Tf6 Kg3 
                       10.Txg6+ Kf4 11.Txb6 f2 12.Tf6+ Ke3 
                       13.Le4 Th6 14.Tf5 (234.419.535) 922
Rebel 16 chooses Nxd6 but with less of a rise in eval I think to suggest it wins faster than Rf2. More than 18 minutes to reach depth 32.

Code: Select all

8/8/1p1p2p1/p3p1P1/PrP1Np1k/2K2P1r/2B5/5R2 w - -

Engine: Rebel 16 (512 MB)
gemaakt door Ed Schroder and Chris Whittington (C) 2

19/34  0:01   +0.49++  1.Pxd6 (1.546.805) 1036 

19/22  0:01   +0.73++  1.Pxd6 (1.556.214) 1037 

19/37  0:01   +1.09++  1.Pxd6 (1.648.652) 1035 

19/37  0:01   +1.63++  1.Pxd6 (1.905.140) 1030 

19/30  0:01   +1.43    1.Pxd6 Kxg5 2.Pe4+ Kh4 3.Ld1 Tb1 
                       4.Pd2 Tb4 5.Te1 g5 6.Txe5 Th1 7.Lb3 g4 
                       8.Te7 Tc1+ 9.Kb2 Tg1 10.fxg4 Txg4 
                       11.Th7+ Kg3 (1.945.657) 1031 

20/37  0:02   +1.59++  1.Pxd6 Th2 2.Pf7 (2.134.292) 1030 

20/35  0:02   +1.75++  1.Pxd6 (2.374.606) 1033 

20/36  0:02   +1.27--  1.Pxd6 Kxg5 (2.611.972) 1032 

20/31  0:02   +1.63++  1.Pxd6 Th2 2.Pf7 (2.632.884) 1032 

20/43  0:03   +1.34    1.Pxd6 Kxg5 2.Pe4+ Kh4 3.Ld1 Tg3 
                       4.Th1+ Th3 5.Te1 Tg3 6.Pd2 Tg5 7.Lc2 Kh3 
                       8.Te2 Kh4 9.Th2+ Kg3 10.Th7 Th5 
                       11.Te7 Kf2 12.Lxg6 Th1 13.Lc2 Te1 
                       14.Pe4+ (3.096.627) 1026 

21/40  0:03   +1.18--  1.Pxd6 Kg3 (3.578.198) 1025 

21/30  0:03   +1.02--  1.Pxd6 Kg3 (3.702.978) 1026 

21/32  0:03   +0.78--  1.Pxd6 Kg3 (3.843.415) 1025 

21/33  0:04   +0.42--  1.Pxd6 Kg3 (4.188.868) 1024 

21/34  0:04   +0.70++  1.Pxd6 Kxg5 (4.423.826) 1024 

21/35  0:04   +1.51++  1.Pxd6 (4.569.557) 1024 

21/39  0:06   +1.47    1.Pxd6 Kg3 2.Lxg6 Kg2 3.Lf5 Tg3 
                       4.Td1 Txg5 5.Td2+ Kxf3 6.Le4+ Kg4 
                       7.Tg2+ Kh4 8.Pf5+ Txf5 9.Lxf5 Txa4 
                       10.Tg6 Ta3+ 11.Kb2 (6.399.252) 1022 

22/38  0:06   +1.31--  1.Pxd6 Kg3 (6.760.880) 1022 

22/37  0:06   +1.15--  1.Pxd6 Kg3 (6.996.506) 1020 

22/42  0:07   +1.31++  1.Pxd6 Kxg5 (7.323.557) 1020 

22/50  0:08   +1.42    1.Pxd6 Kxg5 2.Pe4+ Kh4 3.Ld1 Tg3 
                       4.Th1+ Th3 5.Te1 Tg3 6.Pd2 Tg5 7.Lc2 Kh3 
                       8.Te2 Kh4 9.Th2+ Kg3 10.Th7 Th5 
                       11.Te7 Kf2 12.Te8 Th1 13.Txe5 Tc1 
                       14.Te6 (8.315.506) 1019 

23/38  0:09   +1.34    1.Pxd6 Kxg5 2.Pe4+ Kh4 3.Ld1 Tg3 
                       4.Th1+ Th3 5.Te1 Tg3 6.Pd2 Tg5 7.Lc2 Kh3 
                       8.Te2 Kh4 9.Th2+ Kg3 10.Th7 Th5 
                       11.Te7 Kg2 12.Te8 Kg3 13.Lxg6 Th1 
                       14.Lc2 (9.714.718) 1017 

24/42  0:10   +1.50++  1.Pxd6 Th2 2.Tg1 (11.076.049) 1012 

24/46  0:11   +1.66++  1.Pxd6 (12.002.097) 1011 

24/45  0:15   +1.25    1.Pxd6 Kxg5 2.Pe4+ Kh4 3.Ld1 Tb1 
                       4.Pd2 Ta1 5.Kb2 Th2 6.Kxa1 Txd2 
                       7.Tg1 g5 8.Kb1 Td4 9.Kc1 Txc4+ 
                       10.Kd2 Tb4 11.Ke1 Tb1 12.Kf2 Tb2+ 
                       13.Le2 Kh5 14.Th1+ (15.890.890) 1004 

25/46  0:17   +1.41++  1.Pxd6 Kg3 (17.977.620) 1001 

25/40  0:18   +1.41    1.Pxd6 Kxg5 2.Pe4+ Kh4 3.Ld1 Tb1 
                       4.Pd2 Ta1 5.Kb2 Th2 6.Kxa1 Txd2 
                       7.Tg1 g5 8.Kb1 Td4 9.Kc1 Txc4+ 
                       10.Kd2 Tb4 11.Ke1 Tb1 12.Kf2 Tb2+ 
                       13.Le2 Kh5 14.Th1+ (18.392.466) 1000 

26/52  0:19   +1.57++  1.Pxd6 Th2 2.Pf7 (19.472.848) 999 

26/43  0:22   +1.25--  1.Pxd6 Kxg5 2.Tf2 Kf6 (22.741.293) 1000 

26/33  0:23   +1.49++  1.Pxd6 Kg3 (23.574.895) 1000 

26/50  0:28   +1.81    1.Pxd6 Kxg5 2.Pe4+ Kh4 3.Ld1 Tb1 
                       4.Pd2 Ta1 5.Kb2 Th2 6.Kxa1 Txd2 
                       7.Tg1 g5 8.Kb1 Td4 9.Kc1 Txc4+ 
                       10.Kd2 Tb4 11.Ke1 Tb1 12.Kf2 Tb2+ 
                       13.Le2 Kh5 14.Th1+ (28.697.423) 996 

27/52  0:38   +1.65--  1.Pxd6 Kxg5 (38.271.483) 992 

27/38  0:38   +1.81++  1.Pxd6 Kg3 (38.662.550) 992 

27/49  0:46   +1.49--  1.Pxd6 Kxg5 (45.624.159) 989 

27/46  0:48   +1.59    1.Pxd6 Kxg5 2.Pe4+ Kh4 3.Ld1 Tb1 
                       4.Pd2 Ta1 5.Kb2 Th2 6.Kxa1 Txd2 
                       7.Tg1 g5 8.Kb1 Td4 9.Kc1 Txc4+ 
                       10.Kd2 Tb4 11.Ke1 Tb1 12.Kf2 Tb2+ 
                       13.Le2 Kh5 14.Th1+ (47.690.904) 986 

28/52  1:03   +1.43--  1.Pxd6 Kxg5 2.Kd3 Kh4 (62.431.111) 983 

28/50  1:10   +1.59++  1.Pxd6 Th2 2.Ta1 (68.884.902) 980 

28/55  1:29   +1.27--  1.Pxd6 Kxg5 2.Kd3 Tg3 (87.482.330) 979 

28/45  1:30   +1.55++  1.Pxd6 Th2 2.Ta1 (88.554.578) 979 

28/51  1:45   +1.26    1.Pxd6 Kxg5 2.Pe4+ Kh4 3.Ld1 Tb1 
                       4.Pd2 Ta1 5.Kb2 Th2 6.Kxa1 Txd2 
                       7.Tg1 g5 8.Kb1 Td4 9.Kc1 Txc4+ 
                       10.Kd2 Tb4 11.Ke1 Tb1 12.Kf2 Tb2+ 
                       13.Le2 Kh5 14.Th1+ (103.203.533) 977 

29/58  2:19   +1.42++  1.Pxd6 Tg3 2.Pf7 (136.003.682) 973 

29/53  2:22   +1.58++  1.Pxd6 (138.149.807) 972 

29/54  2:39   +1.75    1.Pxd6 Kxg5 2.Pe4+ Kh4 3.Ld1 Tb1 
                       4.Pd2 Ta1 5.Kb2 Th2 6.Kxa1 Txd2 
                       7.Tg1 g5 8.Kb1 Td4 9.Kc1 Txc4+ 
                       10.Kd2 Tb4 11.Tg4+ Kh5 12.Tg2 Kh4 
                       13.Ke1 b5 14.Kf2 (155.065.148) 972 

30/62  3:38   +1.59--  1.Pxd6 Kxg5 (213.082.953) 977 

30/52  5:50   +1.75++  1.Pxd6 Th2 2.Tg1 Th3 (341.867.966) 974 

30/52  5:57   +1.43--  1.Pxd6 Kxg5 2.Tg1+ (348.735.494) 974 

30/45  6:57   +1.71++  1.Pxd6 Th2 2.Ta1 (406.757.724) 973 

30/60  8:07   +1.31    1.Pxd6 Kxg5 2.Pe4+ Kh4 3.Ld1 Tb1 
                       4.Pd2 Ta1 5.Kb2 Th2 6.Kxa1 Txd2 
                       7.Tg1 g5 8.Kb1 Td4 9.Kc1 Txc4+ 
                       10.Kd2 Tb4 11.Ke1 Tb1 12.Tg4+ Kh5 
                       13.Tg2 e4 14.Th2+ (474.750.963) 974 

31/61  13:49  +1.15--  1.Pxd6 Kxg5 2.Tg1+ (802.070.315) 966 

31/60  17:04  +1.31++  1.Pxd6 Kg3 (990.121.942) 966 

31/51  17:09  +1.38    1.Pxd6 Kxg5 2.Pe4+ Kh4 3.Ld1 Tb1 
                       4.Pd2 Ta1 5.Kb2 Th2 6.Kxa1 Txd2 
                       7.Tg1 g5 8.Kb1 Td4 9.Kc1 Txc4+ 
                       10.Kd2 Tb4 11.Ke1 Tb1 12.Tg4+ Kh5 
                       13.Tg2 e4 14.Th2+ (994.806.872) 965 

32/58  17:29  +1.54++  1.Pxd6 Th2 2.Tg1 Th3 (1.013.832.957) 965 

32/51  17:49  +1.22--  1.Pxd6 Kxg5 2.Tg1+ (1.032.261.368) 965 

32/62  17:59  +1.46++  1.Pxd6 Kg3 (1.042.203.868) 965 

32/55  18:34  +1.73    1.Pxd6 Kxg5 2.Pe4+ Kh4 3.Ld1 Tb1 
                       4.Pd2 Ta1 5.Kb2 Th2 6.Kxa1 Txd2 
                       7.Tg1 g5 8.Kb1 Td4 9.Kc1 Txc4+ 
                       10.Kd2 Tb4 11.Ke1 Tb1 12.Tg4+ Kh5 
                       13.Tg2 e4 14.Th2+ (1.075.166.750) 965 
Debugging is twice as hard as writing the code in the first
place. Therefore, if you write the code as cleverly as possible, you
are, by definition, not smart enough to debug it.
-- Brian W. Kernighan
Vinvin
Posts: 5329
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 9:40 am
Full name: Vincent Lejeune

Re: interesting position

Post by Vinvin »

Jouni wrote: Mon Jan 02, 2023 9:03 am Stockfish has a problem in this position, maybe pruning? Nxd6 wins also and even faster!

Analysis by Crystal 5 KWK bmi2:

...
1.Nxd6 Kxg5 2.Rg1+ Kf6 3.Rxg6+ Ke7 4.Be4 Rh1 5.Nc8+ Ke8 6.Nxb6 Rc1+ 7.Kd2 Ra1 8.Rg8+ Kf7 9.Bd5+ Ke7 10.c5 Rd4+ 11.Kc2 Rdd1 12.Rg7+ Ke8 13.Bc6+ Kf8 14.Rg2 e4 15.Bxe4 Rac1+ 16.Kb2 Rxc5 17.Rc2 Rg5 18.Nc4 Ke7 19.Rd2 Rh1 20.Rd5 Rxd5 21.Bxd5 Rh5 22.Be4 Rc5 23.Kb3 Kf6 24.Kc3 Ke6 25.Kd4 Rc7 26.Bd5+ Kf5 27.Ne5 Rc1 28.Nc4 Ra1 29.Be4+ Kg5
+- (5.17) Depth: 40/80 00:06:06 1993mN, tb=4709916
3 best moves after 5 minutes :

Code: Select all

Stockfish_22120921_x64_avx2:
...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
 44/64	04:46	 7.105.110k	24.841k	+0,10	1.Nf6 Rh2 2.Ne4 Rxc2+ 3.Kxc2 Rxc4+ 4.Kd3 Rd4+ 5.Ke2 Kh3 6.Kf2 Kh2 7.Nc3 Rd2+ 8.Ne2 d5 9.Rc1 e4 10.fxe4 dxe4 11.Ke1 Ra2 12.Nxf4 Kg3 13.Nd5 Rxa4 14.Ke2 Rd4 15.Nc7 Kg4 16.Ke3 Ra4 17.Ne6 b5 18.Rb1 Kf5 19.Nd4+ Kxg5 20.Rg1+ Kf6 21.Nxb5 Rb4 22.Nd4 a4 23.Ra1 Kg5 24.Ra3 Kh4 25.Kxe4 g5 26.Kd3 Kg4 27.Ke3 Rb2 28.Ke4 Kh5 29.Kf5
 44/80	04:46	 7.105.110k	24.841k	+4,01	1.Nxd6 Kg3 2.Bxg6 Kg2 3.Bd3 Rxa4 4.Kb2 Rb4+ 5.Kc2 Ra4 6.Rd1 Kxf3 7.g6 Rg3 8.Nf5 Rg2+ 9.Kb1 Rxg6 10.Nh4+ Ke3 11.Bxg6 Rxc4 12.Re1+ Kf2 13.Rxe5 Rc3 14.Bh5 Re3 15.Rb5 Rc3 16.Rf5 Ke3 17.Kb2 Rc6 18.Re5+ Kd4 19.Nf3+ Kd3 20.Ne1+ Kd4 21.Re8 Rc5 22.Bf3 Rb5+ 23.Kc2 Rc5+ 24.Kd2 Rc7 25.Nd3 Kc4 26.Re4+ Kb5 27.Nxf4 Rf7 28.Ke3 Rh7 29.Be2+ Kc6 30.Kd2 a4 31.Re6+ Kc5 32.Nd3+ Kd5
 44/79	04:46	 7.105.110k	24.841k	+4,10	1.Rf2 Kh5 2.Nxd6 Kxg5 3.Rg2+ Kf6 4.Rxg6+ Ke7 5.Be4 Rh1 6.Nc8+ Ke8 7.Nxb6 Rc1+ 8.Kd2 Ra1 9.Rg8+ Kf7 10.Bd5+ Ke7 11.c5 Rd4+ 12.Kc2 Rdd1 13.Rg7+ Kf6 14.Rg2 e4 15.Bxe4 Rac1+ 16.Kb2 Rxc5 17.Rc2 Re5 18.Rc6+ Ke7 19.Kc2 Rd4 20.Rc4 Rd8 21.Rc7+ Kd6 22.Rc6+ Ke7 23.Nc4 Rg5 24.Kc3 Rd7 25.Rg6 Rxg6 26.Bxg6 Kf6 27.Be4 Rc7 28.Kd4 Ke6 29.Nb6 Rc1 30.Nc4 Ra1 31.Bc6 Ke7 32.Kd5 Rc1 33.Kc5 Rc3 34.Be4 Ke6 35.Kd4 Rc1 36.Bd5+ Kf6 37.Bc6
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
 44/64	05:16	 7.858.538k	24.819k	+0,10	1.Nf6 Rh2 2.Ne4 Rxc2+ 3.Kxc2 Rxc4+ 4.Kd3 Rd4+ 5.Ke2 Kh3 6.Kf2 Kh2 7.Nc3 Rd2+ 8.Ne2 d5 9.Rc1 e4 10.fxe4 dxe4 11.Ke1 Ra2 12.Nxf4 Kg3 13.Nd5 Rxa4 14.Ke2 Rd4 15.Nc7 Kg4 16.Ke3 Ra4 17.Ne6 b5 18.Rb1 Kf5 19.Nd4+ Kxg5 20.Rg1+ Kf6 21.Nxb5 Rb4 22.Nd4 a4 23.Ra1 Kg5 24.Ra3 Kh4 25.Kxe4 g5 26.Kd3 Kg4 27.Ke3 Rb2 28.Ke4 Kh5 29.Kf5
 44/80	05:16	 7.858.538k	24.819k	+4,01	1.Nxd6 Kg3 2.Bxg6 Kg2 3.Bd3 Rxa4 4.Kb2 Rb4+ 5.Kc2 Ra4 6.Rd1 Kxf3 7.g6 Rg3 8.Nf5 Rg2+ 9.Kb1 Rxg6 10.Nh4+ Ke3 11.Bxg6 Rxc4 12.Re1+ Kf2 13.Rxe5 Rc3 14.Bh5 Re3 15.Rb5 Rc3 16.Rf5 Ke3 17.Kb2 Rc6 18.Re5+ Kd4 19.Nf3+ Kd3 20.Ne1+ Kd4 21.Re8 Rc5 22.Bf3 Rb5+ 23.Kc2 Rc5+ 24.Kd2 Rc7 25.Nd3 Kc4 26.Re4+ Kb5 27.Nxf4 Rf7 28.Ke3 Rh7 29.Be2+ Kc6 30.Kd2 a4 31.Re6+ Kc5 32.Nd3+ Kd5
 45/83	05:16	 7.858.538k	24.819k	+4,19	1.Rf2 Kh5 2.Nxd6 Kxg5 3.Rg2+ Kf6 4.Rxg6+ Ke7 5.Be4 Rh1 6.Nc8+ Ke8 7.Nxb6 Rc1+ 8.Kd2 Ra1 9.Rg8+ Kf7 10.Bd5+ Ke7 11.c5 Rd4+ 12.Kc2 Rdd1 13.Rg7+ Kf6 14.Rg2 e4 15.Bxe4 Rac1+ 16.Kb2 Rxc5 17.Rc2 Re5 18.Rc6+ Kg5 19.Nc4 Re8 20.Rc5+ Kh4 21.Rxa5 Rb8+ 22.Rb5 Rc8 23.Ne5 Kg3 24.a5 Rd2+ 25.Kb3 Rd1 26.Nc4 Ra1 27.Rb6 Kf2 28.Kb4 Rc7 29.a6 Re7 30.Na3 Ra2 31.Kb3 Ra1 32.Rb5 Ra7 33.Ra5 Kg3 34.Kb2 Re1
Jouni
Posts: 3893
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 8:15 pm
Full name: Jouni Uski

Re: interesting position

Post by Jouni »

A lesson: ALWAYS check 3-4 best moves before any conclusion!
Jouni
peter
Posts: 3580
Joined: Sat Feb 16, 2008 7:38 am
Full name: Peter Martan

Re: interesting position

Post by peter »

Jouni wrote: Mon Jan 02, 2023 10:32 pm A lesson: ALWAYS check 3-4 best moves before any conclusion!
And always better together with some Forward- Backward of the near to each other moves and lines too as for trusting in their numeric evals at least compared to each other.

Good found, Jouni, here's SF dev. after some in and out of the two main lines and MultiPV=3 (hope you don't find it unfair here like you did in the other one thread, didn't you? :))

About 5 minutes with 30 threads of 16x3.5GHz and 32G hash, after return from latest Backward (Forwward from Nxd6 first and Rf2 then secondly) started with full hash again then, here at depth 45:

8/8/1p1p2p1/p3p1P1/PrP1Np1k/2K2P1r/2B5/5R2 w - - 0 1

Analysis by Stockfish dev-20230101-be9bc420:

Code: Select all

1. +- (4.32): 1.Nxd6 Rh2 2.Ne4 Kh3 3.Rf2 Rh1 4.Re2 Ra1 5.Nd2 Ra3+ 6.Bb3 Ra1 7.Rxe5 Kh4 8.Re6 Kxg5 9.Bc2 Ra3+ 10.Kd4 Rb2 11.Ne4+ Kh4 12.Rxg6 Kh3 13.Bd3 Kh2 14.Rg4 Rxa4 15.Rxf4 Rg2 16.Rh4+ Kg1 17.Nc3 Rb4 18.f4 Rg8 19.Be4 b5 20.Nxb5 Rc8 21.Rh1+ Kf2 22.Nd6 Rf8 23.Ra1 Rxf4 24.Rxa5 Rb6 25.Ra2+ Kg1 

2. +- (3.67): 1.Rf2 Rh1 2.Rd2 Rh3 3.Rd3 Kh5 4.Nd2 Rg3 5.Rxd6 Rxg5 6.Rd7 Kh6 7.Re7 Rg3 8.Rxe5 Kg7 9.Re7+ Kf6 10.Rc7 Ke6 11.c5 bxc5 12.Rxc5 Rb6 13.Bb3+ Ke7 14.Rxa5 Rd6 15.Re5+ Kd7 16.Bd5 Kc7 17.a5 g5 18.Be6 Rg1 19.Nb3 Rc6+ 20.Kb4 Kd6 21.Re4 Rc2 22.Bf5 Ra2 23.Re6+ Kd5 24.Re8 Rf1 25.Bd3 Rg1 26.Bc4+ Kd6 27.Re6+ Kc7 28.a6 g4 29.Nd4 Rb1+ 30.Kc5 Ra5+ 31.Bb5 Rc1+ 32.Kb4 Ra2 33.fxg4 

3. = (0.03): 1.Nf6 Rh2 2.Ne4 Rxc2+ 3.Kxc2 Rxc4+ 4.Kd3 Rd4+ 5.Ke2 Kh3 6.Kf2 Kh2 7.Nc3 Rd2+ 8.Ne2 d5 9.Rc1 e4 10.fxe4 dxe4 11.Ke1 Rb2 12.Nxf4 Kg3 13.Nd5 b5 14.axb5 Rxb5 15.Ne3 Kf4 16.Kd2 Rb3 17.Nc4 a4 18.Ra1 e3+ 19.Ke2 Rb4 20.Rf1+ Kxg5 21.Ne5 Rb3 22.Nc6 Rb2+ 23.Kxe3 
Peter.